Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

The "claims" are in the paper, as is the supporting evidence. Please tell me, in specific detail, what is wrong with those claims.

You don't expect someone with a made-up mind to go out and look for controverting evidence, do you?
 
The first question is rather disingenious, since you invented the whole thing.
Not at all. I quoted Kevin Lowe, and altered the text (as indicated) to demonstrate with parallel structure that it looks similar from the free marketeer's and the AGW skeptic's point of view.
Again, what facts did I invent?
The second question is purely dodging the entire issue, and denying basic physics. As such, denying basic physics and attempting a diversion is an attack on science and the scientific method, is scientific misconduct, and since the USA was founded on the Enlightenment Movement, an attack on the USA itself.
Not at all! Are you saying the physicist Freeman Dyson denies "basic physics"? Are you saying Ice Ages never occur? A thermometer buried under an inch of soil or suspended in shaded still air will cool and warm on cycles anging from 24 hours to hundreds of thousands of years (well, a thermometer proxy will vary on these long cycles). The Earth has been hotter than today with lower CO2 levels than today and cooler than today with higher CO2 levels than today. Other factors than CO2 contribute to the sun-induced surface warming of Earth. The issue is not whether CO2 makes any contribution at all but whether it dominates.
Inferring that communists are socialists is a very strange thing to do...
That sounds odd to my ear. It's like "inferring that dogs are mammals". Dogs are mammals. Not all mammals are dogs. Communists are socialists. Not all socialists are communists.
... and attempting to pass off the idea that social supports are eliminating private property is even nuttier.
Please rephrase this. I don't understand what you mean by "social supports".
And, of course, denying that there is private property is communism, not socialism. I guess you fell for that one.
Finally, your article forces a false conclusion, so you are absoutely calling for something.
Huh???
jj wrote: "'the excesses of capitalism' does not call for socialism, merely for moderation", so s/he's calling for something, if anyone is.
 
So, you haven't even read the paper, but you just know it's wrong somehow?
Perhaps you could quote the parts of the paper you've read which lead you to think it's right somehow.

Last I heard, the burden of proof was still on the person making the claim.
 
Perhaps you could quote the parts of the paper you've read which lead you to think it's right somehow.

I've quoted plenty of the paper already. Go buy it yourself if you want to read it.

Last I heard, the burden of proof was still on the person making the claim.

Which would be the paper's authors. What do you have to say about what they wrote?
 
Perhaps you could quote the parts of the paper you've read which lead you to think it's right somehow.

Last I heard, the burden of proof was still on the person making the claim.

"Your claim, your burden of proof" isn't a rule made up to allow people to snipe at internet posters from a position of safety.

Rather it is a rule that people making a positive claim have to present their evidence for it, and the people making the claim that the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies have done so. Just because you aren't able to access it because of a paywall doesn't mean it's not published and supported in the peer-reviewed literature - I imagine lots of things you don't know are published in the peer-reviewed literature behind paywalls and they're not false just because you can't access them.
 
I've quoted plenty of the paper already. Go buy it yourself if you want to read it.
I've read "Tea Party Patriots". The authors say they founded it. The fact that lots of people who were previously opposed to tobacco taxes joined up doesn't refute their account.

Which would be the paper's authors. What do you have to say about what they wrote?
All I've seen is what you've quoted. The case seems weaker than that presented by Meckler and Martin.

"Your claim, your burden of proof" isn't a rule made up to allow people to snipe at internet posters from a position of safety.

Rather it is a rule that people making a positive claim have to present their evidence for it, and the people making the claim that the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies have done so. Just because you aren't able to access it because of a paywall doesn't mean it's not published and supported in the peer-reviewed literature - I imagine lots of things you don't know are published in the peer-reviewed literature behind paywalls and they're not false just because you can't access them.
They aren't true just because they're "peer reviewed" either. Lots of people who were parts of other movements previously joined the Tea Party. To date, I haven't noticed any pro-tobacco lobbying from the Tea Party grousing that I've heard. That doesn't mean there hasn't been any, but it strongly argues that tobacco isn't the primary concern of most Tea Partiers, which I regard as a fatal flaw to the "peer reviewed" thesis, considering that they've had almost 4 years now to popularize the pro-tobacco stance you (they) claim is the Tea Party's raison d'etre.
 
Not at all. I quoted Kevin Lowe, and altered the text (as indicated) to demonstrate with parallel structure that it looks similar from the free marketeer's and the AGW skeptic's point of view.
Again, what facts did I invent?Not at all! Are you saying the physicist Freeman Dyson denies "basic physics"? Are you saying Ice Ages never occur? A thermometer buried under an inch of soil or suspended in shaded still air will cool and warm on cycles anging from 24 hours to hundreds of thousands of years (well, a thermometer proxy will vary on these long cycles). The Earth has been hotter than today with lower CO2 levels than today and cooler than today with higher CO2 levels than today. Other factors than CO2 contribute to the sun-induced surface warming of Earth. The issue is not whether CO2 makes any contribution at all but whether it dominates.That sounds odd to my ear. It's like "inferring that dogs are mammals". Dogs are mammals. Not all mammals are dogs. Communists are socialists. Not all socialists are communists.Please rephrase this. I don't understand what you mean by "social supports". Huh???
jj wrote: "'the excesses of capitalism' does not call for socialism, merely for moderation", so s/he's calling for something, if anyone is.

:facepalm:
 
They aren't true just because they're "peer reviewed" either. Lots of people who were parts of other movements previously joined the Tea Party. To date, I haven't noticed any pro-tobacco lobbying from the Tea Party grousing that I've heard. That doesn't mean there hasn't been any, but it strongly argues that tobacco isn't the primary concern of most Tea Partiers, which I regard as a fatal flaw to the "peer reviewed" thesis, considering that they've had almost 4 years now to popularize the pro-tobacco stance you (they) claim is the Tea Party's raison d'etre.

The argument that if the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies then being pro-tobacco would be the primary concern of Tea Partiers is not, as far as I can tell, in the published paper. It seems to be something you made up so you could knock it down.

I've noticed in the past a common pattern with self-described skeptics confronted with a scientific paper they can't read but don't like the conclusions of. They tend to confabulate some fairy story about how the conclusion could be wrong, and then decide that because they can confabulate such a story they are entitled to discard the conclusion of the paper.

In this case the confabulation is weaker than usual because the hypothesis that if the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies then being pro-tobacco would be the primary concern of Tea Partiers is remarkably silly.

The founders of the Tea Party, tobacco denial and global warming denial are anti-science by way of being anti-government. If the Tea Partiers were pro-science or pro-government when they were founded then there might be an apparent contradiction.
 
The argument that if the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies then being pro-tobacco would be the primary concern of Tea Partiers is not, as far as I can tell, in the published paper. It seems to be something you made up so you could knock it down.
I didn't say it was in the published paper. I say the tobacco companies are in the business of selling tobacco. If you wish to show that they are also in the business of founding and funding political parties which don't contribute to the bottom line of their business, by all means proceed.

I've noticed in the past a common pattern with self-described skeptics confronted with a scientific paper they can't read but don't like the conclusions of. They tend to confabulate some fairy story about how the conclusion could be wrong, and then decide that because they can confabulate such a story they are entitled to discard the conclusion of the paper.
I didn't confabulate a fairy story, I presented my own evidence in the form of a book by two people who say they've been part of the Tea Party movement from the very beginning. They don't have anything to say about tobacco; they do have a lot to say about lots of other topics.

Bill Gates has the Gates Foundation which doesn't promote Microsoft. It's possible that the tobacco companies support the Tea Party as an arm of their charity work too. Even if the "peer reviewed" paper made that case (and in the bits quoted, it doesn't seem to), that would still be a far cry from establishing that the movement was "created" by the tobacco companies, as you allege but can't prove.

I have no intention of paying to read the article. If you want to make a case, make it. If your case consists of claiming that "the proof is out there" then I guess there's nothing to discuss here.
 
I didn't say it was in the published paper. I say the tobacco companies are in the business of selling tobacco. If you wish to show that they are also in the business of founding and funding political parties which don't contribute to the bottom line of their business, by all means proceed.

The connection is simply that the tobacco industry and the CO2-emitting industries strongly dislike government regulation, and the Tea Partiers strongly dislike government regulation.

This is simple politics, not some complicated James Bond villain scheme.

I didn't confabulate a fairy story, I presented my own evidence in the form of a book by two people who say they've been part of the Tea Party movement from the very beginning. They don't have anything to say about tobacco; they do have a lot to say about lots of other topics.

Would a book by a global warming denier who was part of the movement from the beginning that didn't mention the movement being set up by PR companies working for fossil fuel companies count as evidence that didn't happen too? Lance Armstrong had a couple of autobiographical books from 2000 and 2003 that didn't mention him using performance enhancing drugs, as I recall, are they evidence he was clean? After all, he didn't talk about drugs but he did have a lot to say about lots of other topics - case closed!

Bill Gates has the Gates Foundation which doesn't promote Microsoft. It's possible that the tobacco companies support the Tea Party as an arm of their charity work too. Even if the "peer reviewed" paper made that case (and in the bits quoted, it doesn't seem to), that would still be a far cry from establishing that the movement was "created" by the tobacco companies, as you allege but can't prove.

The Tea Party is a charity now? I think I need to back away slowly.

I have no intention of paying to read the article. If you want to make a case, make it. If your case consists of claiming that "the proof is out there" then I guess there's nothing to discuss here.

So there's nothing to discuss with you. To quote the great Han Solo, "Boring conversation anyway". The world will go on whether or not you are informed about the contents of the paper.
 
National organisations funded by corporations, particularly Americans for Prosperity (AFP) and FreedomWorks, played an important role in structuring and supporting the Tea Party
What tobacco products does Americans for Prosperity manufacture?

What tobacco products does FreedomWorks manufacture?


As of 2012, AFP and FreedomWorks were supporting the tobacco companies’ political agenda by mobilising local Tea Party opposition to tobacco taxes and smoke-free laws.
Where was this opposition to tobacco taxes and smoke-free laws expressed?

Citizens for a Sound Economy (CSE)
What tobacco products does CSE manufacture?
 
Last edited:
What tobacco products does Americans for Prosperity manufacture?

What tobacco products does FreedomWorks manufacture?



Where was this opposition to tobacco taxes and smoke-free laws expressed?


What tobacco products does CSE manufacture?

The fact is simple, your obtuse misinterpretations and attempts to cause others to misinterpret the case made in the paper clearly exhibit a fundamentally misleading behavior to your postings.

Did you bother to read the paper, or like some others here, are you arguing against a straw-man version of it, not having bothered to actually read the evidence for and against what you are denying.

Evidence, please.
 
The fact is simple, your obtuse misinterpretations and attempts to cause others to misinterpret the case made in the paper clearly exhibit a fundamentally misleading behavior to your postings.

Did you bother to read the paper, or like some others here, are you arguing against a straw-man version of it, not having bothered to actually read the evidence for and against what you are denying.

Evidence, please.
The claim is "Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies".

The evidence offered to support this claim is "these entities which are not tobacco companies provided assistance to a demonstrably grass-roots movement".

Laughable.
 
Last edited:
I did a search for "Tea Party Platform" and found this:

The only reference I could find for tobacco was: https://teaparty-centrists.com/Platforms.html
(I added highlighting)
72) Welfare will be phased out as follows. Everyone currently on welfare and less than 17 years of age will lose benefits at age 18. Everyone who is 18 years old and on welfare will be given one year in order to graduate from high school, find a job and/or get a GED. All women over 18 without children and males over 18 lose benefits immediately. Anyone found to be using drugs, alcohol, or tobacco on routine screening will lose benefits immediately as will any woman who becomes pregnant while on welfare. Also, anyone refusing screening tests will lose their benefits.

I can't say that's an "official" platform, but it certainly makes one wonder just how much tobacco use is promoted by the movement. Perhaps they were created in part by tobacco interests and have drifted off the reservation?
 
I've read "Tea Party Patriots". The authors say they founded it.

Really? You've made up your mind to completely reject the conclusions and cited sources in this peer-reviewed paper because it contradicts the self-aggrandizing manifesto written by two of the three founders of one of the many tea party groups that were dancing to the tune of a big Republican political advocacy group that was one of the ones had essentially started and directed the formation of the current "tea party movement"?

At least read a real book on the subject.
 
Last edited:
I remember when the Tea Party was recruiting in my area, they had little tables set up in the parking lots with pictures of Obama sporting a Hitler mustache.

Now, it's possible that if I'd taken the time to have a conversation instead of simply capturing a "here's some crazies" moment with my cell phone, I'd have heard "He's trying to TAKE OUR SMOKES!!!" Somehow, I doubt it.

As far as I'm concerned, the claim that the Tea Party originated as a smoker's rights movement is still properly filed in the "that which is claimed without evidence can be dismissed by default" bin.
 
Which it does.



EDIT: The Introduction to the paper lays out, with footnotes, the exact evidence summarized in the Abstract. Which you'd know if you read the paper.


There is more evidence that B. Hussein Obama is a Muslim.
 
As far as I'm concerned, the claim that the Tea Party originated as a smoker's rights movement is still properly filed in the "that which is claimed without evidence can be dismissed by default" bin.

So without having read the paper, you magically somehow know there's no evidence in it? Despite including voluminous citations and references to tobacco industry documents in the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, among its many other citations and references?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom