Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

Right because when one is trying to understand a U.S. political movement the best source of information is clearly a British M.A publication. Shouldn't this be in the CT forum?
The UCSF cite above notes:
The research was funded by grants from the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health (CA113710 and CA087472).

Fallin presented the paper at the annual UCSF CTCRE “It’s About a Billion Lives” symposium at the UCSF Parnassus campus on Friday, Feb. 8. The symposium webcast can be found at http://lecture.ucsf.edu/special-events/billion-lives/.

Yes that liberal bastion UCSF is in cahoots with the NIH and NCI to smear the TEA Party. :rolleyes:
 
Which the tobacco companies are also doing their best to deny is any danger to anyone, and getting the organizations that they fund to help push their denial.

Trying to be shocked... Trying... Failed to be shocked.
 
Absolutely. Here's some more dots that just got connected, too.....
That's a lot of dots. It's frustrating that the right leaners in the forum who consider themselves to be skeptics cry "CT" whenever threads like this come up. There is so much evidence that this group of ideologues hide their donations and support multiple efforts to discredit valid science. The Merchants of Doubt do just as much damage discrediting all science when they promote the 'global warming isn't human caused' or 'second hand smoke isn't harmful' fake science. They're promoting the belief that science isn't reliable and science is just manipulated by everyone, when they are the main perpetrators of the manipulation.
 
Last edited:
If that Rolling Stone article is going with the strongest evidence, I gotta say it's pretty tepid.

The Tobacco Control study cites a 1995 memo by another tobacco strategist, calling for the industry to "quarterback behind the scenes, third-party efforts" that would support its agenda.

Oooh, a 1995 memo! So they were planning this all along, and it only took them, what, 14 years to find a third-party effort to quarterback?

In 2002, Citizens for a Sound Economy (CSE), which had received funding from the tobacco industry since the late Eighties, set up a website for the "US Tea Party." The tobacco-funded organization later split to become Americans for Prosperity and Freedom Works – two groups still closely associated with the Tea Party as we now know it. According to the study's authors, both groups "continue to advocate on behalf of the tobacco industry's anti-tax, anti-regulation agenda."

And it only took them 7 years to get the Tea Party going?

Sorry folks, but this is classic confirmation bias.
 
If that Rolling Stone article is going with the strongest evidence, I gotta say it's pretty tepid.



Oooh, a 1995 memo! So they were planning this all along, and it only took them, what, 14 years to find a third-party effort to quarterback?



And it only took them 7 years to get the Tea Party going?

Sorry folks, but this is classic confirmation bias.
Way to cherry pick, Brainster. :rolleyes:
 
If that Rolling Stone article is going with the strongest evidence, I gotta say it's pretty tepid.

Why don't you read the whole paper and find out?

And it only took them 7 years to get the Tea Party going?

Yes, it's almost like they weren't able to get the "tea partiers" riled up and angry about the overreaching government and massive spending that was taking place under a white Republican president, but were easily able to do so barely a month after a black Democratic president was inaugurated.

Weird, huh?
 
If that Rolling Stone article is going with the strongest evidence, I gotta say it's pretty tepid.

Oooh, a 1995 memo! So they were planning this all along, and it only took them, what, 14 years to find a third-party effort to quarterback?

And it only took them 7 years to get the Tea Party going?

Sorry folks, but this is classic confirmation bias.
Yep. And I'm not even sure what the point is for this "ad corporatem" smear. Are there people in the world who would say, "You know, Michelle Bachman makes a lot of sense, but if the tobacco companies are pulling her strings I might have to rethink my support"?

Yes, it's almost like they weren't able to get the "tea partiers" riled up and angry about the overreaching government and massive spending that was taking place under a white Republican president, but were easily able to do so barely a month after a black Democratic president was inaugurated.

Weird, huh?
I'll bet getting Obama elected was a false-flag operation, and part of their evil plan from the very beginning. Tobarrako Tobamaco. It's like he was hand-picked. Get it?
 
Yep. And I'm not even sure what the point is for this "ad corporatem" smear. Are there people in the world who would say, "You know, Michelle Bachman makes a lot of sense, but if the tobacco companies are pulling her strings I might have to rethink my support"?

No, they'd probably just keep living in denial. Maybe even call it a "smear" or something.

I'll bet getting Obama elected was a false-flag operation, and part of their evil plan from the very beginning. Tobarrako Tobamaco. It's like he was hand-picked. Get it?

This is what your argument has been reduced to, has it?
 
This is what your argument has been reduced to, has it?
It rises to the level of the evidence you've presented to support your claim that "Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies".

Frankly, this seems like the progressive side of the same coin that the conservatives were flipping in the last election -- "those polls are rigged; come election day, you'll see how the REAL PEOPLE REALLY FEEL".

If it makes you feel better to think the Tea Party wasn't a grassroots movement, then feel better. It looks like a grassroots movement to me, and one which has probably passed the peak of its influence. I hope they continue to sabotage the Republican party with extreme candidates who can win primaries but can't win a general election. It's unfortunate that they can pepper the House of Representatives with a few of those candidates too, but that's part of the price of freedom.
 
My biggest problem with the OP is framing this as science.

While I believe that the Tea Party movement is more beholden to corporate interests than most alleged "grass roots" movements, the idea that this is a reproducible methodology is a farce.

Methods We used the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, the Wayback Machine, Google, LexisNexis, the Center for Media and Democracy and the Center for Responsive Politics (opensecrets.org) to examine the tobacco companies’ connections to the Tea Party.
The whole point of reporting a methodology is that anyone else can come along and reproduce it and expect to get the same results. This is certainly not so in this case. It matters greatly who the "we" are that looked at these documents since that's the only "method" reported.

And even ignoring political bias, the method as described guarantees confirmation bias (the only thing they looked for was evidence of connections, so that is the only thing they could find, and therefore the only conclusion that is possible to draw; there is no falsifiable hypothesis being tested).
 
Sorry folks, but this is classic confirmation bias.

Yep. The "methods" described is pretty much the very definition of confirmation bias.

ETA: That is, if you only look for evidence of x, it's impossible to find anything other than evidence for x, and you know it's impossible even before you start to reach any other conclusion except x.

If they'd similarly, for example, done a "study" that only examined news reports of Tea Party activity and only looked for evidence that it's a grass roots movement, then they would only have found that evidence and could only conclude that it's, therefore, a grass roots movement. But neither the actual "study" nor my hypothetical one is actually science, but simply an exercise in confirmation bias.
 
Last edited:
It rises to the level of the evidence you've presented to support your claim that "Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies".

How would you know, since you refuse to read the paper?

If it makes you feel better to think the Tea Party wasn't a grassroots movement, then feel better..

From Steep: the Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party:

Most accounts trace the origins of the Tea Party to CNBC on-air editor Rick Santelli's rant on the floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange on February 19, 2009. Commenting on the Homeowners Affordability and Stability Plan, which was designed to provide relief to mortgage holders and signed into law by President Obama on February 17, Santelli accused Obama of "promoting bad behavior" by proposing to "subsidize the losers' mortgages." Turning to the traders on the floor, Santelli shouted, "This is America! How many of you people want to pay for your neighbor's mortgage that has an extra bathroom and can't pay their bills? Raise their [sic] hand!" Met with cheers, Santelli continued, "President Obama, are you listening?" He concluded, "It's time for another tea party. What we are doing will make Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin roll over in their graves."

Though some have questioned whether Santelli's rant was staged and even coordinated with right-wing groups, none dispute its role in providing a spark that helped to mobilize antitax and antigovernment organizations and protesters during the spring of 2009. In the days immediately following Santelli's outburst, FreedomWorks, a conservative Washington-based advocacy group led by former Republican House Majority Leader Dick Armey, put Rick Santelli's picture on its website and asked "Are you with Rick? We are." After contacting supporters around the country to ask if they were willing to organize a Tea Party, FreedomWorks staffers announced the launch of a twenty-five-city nationwide Tea Party tour "where taxpayers angry that their hard-earned money is being usurped by the government for irresponsible bailouts, can show President Obama and congressional Democrats that their push towards outright socialism will not stand." In the weeks following, locally based protests opposing taxes and government spending sprang up in Cincinnati, Ohio, Green Bay, Wisconsin, and Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, among other cities and towns across the country.

[...]

Spurred on by Fox News coverage and assisted by FreedomWorks and Americans for Prosperity (another DC-based conservative advocacy group founded by oil tycoon and billionaire David Kock), these "TEA [Taxed Enough Already] Party" rallies drew anywhere from a handful to thousands of participants.

From Boiling Mad: Inside Tea Party America:

The new street protesters had a powerful ally in Fox News, which had been searching out popular opposition to the stimulus bill. When Mary Rakovich protested in Fort Myers, Fox producers quickly got her to a local affiliate so she could be interviewed by satellite by Neil Cavuto in New York, even though her protest had, by her own count, consisted of herself, her husband, and one other person.

Sean Hannity replayed footage of Santelli's rant a few hours after it happened. The next day, Glenn Beck promoted the idea of tax revolts. And in the next several weeks, Fox would promote Tax Day Tea Parties - scheduled for April 15 - in news programs and commercial spots. The network's anchors directed viewers to an online list of Tea Parties nationwide. Hannity attended one in Atlanta. And Fox offered its own virtual Tax Day Tea Party for people who could not attend.

[...]

FreedomWorks had been waiting for just this moment.

Since its founding in 1984, it had been trying to grow a grassroots movement that would make it more than just the well-connected Washington advocacy group it was, one that would produce a groundswell behind economic theories that rested lonely in academia.

[...]

In 2007, [Dick Armey] and the group's president, Matt Kibbe, wrote an op-ed article proposing the Boston Tea Party as a model of grassroots pressure on an overbearing central government. The men who dressed as Mohawks to dump the tea in Boston Harbor in 1773 had not simply shown up, they argued; Samuel Adams had tilled the ground for years, recruiting activists to his Sons of Liberty in the bars, shipyards, and shops of Boston, and enlisting wealthy businessmen like John Hancock in his cause. Presaging Tea Party tactics in the summer of 2009, they described how Adams packed town hall meetings with his supporters to drown out Tory voices and used each new British policy or tax as "an excuse to rally new recruits to the cause of American independence."

"Adams was the first American to recognize that 'it does not require a majority to prevail, but rather, an irate, tireless minority keen to set brush fires in people's minds'," the wrote. But the op-ed lamented that conservative groups had "failed to effectively organize a cadre of vocal citizens willing and able to defend the principles of limited government."

[...]

FreedomWorks, in turn, gave people with inchoate anger something to do about it - organize. While many groups on the right moved to seize the Tea Party energy as it grew in the early months of 2009, it was FreedomWorks that moved first and most aggressively. And very quickly, the FreedomWorks ideology became the Tea Party ideology.

So no, the tea party movement is not a grassroots movement. It might have become one, had the disorganized dissatisfaction that arose after Obama's election been allowed to actually grow into a movement on its own. Or it might not have, and the undirected sentiment of "I'm angry at Obama and the stimulus bill I don't know what to do" would have just faded away rather than becoming any kind of movement at all.

But the instant Santelli's rant hit the airwaves, groups like AFP and FreedomWorks were there to start organizing and directing things the way those two organizations wanted, and enticing people to join up with the Fox-News-promoted "tea parties" that they themselves created, creating the astroturf group called the "tea party movement".
 
Last edited:
How would you know, since you refuse to read the paper?
I've read the evidence you presented in this thread. I can't recall the name of one tobacco company you've identified as a creator of the Tea Party movement. You're free to paraphrase the entire paper to lay out the chain of evidence which substantiates the claim. From what you've said, some political advocacy groups provided financial and other assistance to a grassroots movement which advocated some of the same things they had previously advocated. Not much there about tobacco's involvement.

From Steep: the Precipitous Rise of the Tea Party:

From Boiling Mad: Inside Tea Party America:

So no, the tea party movement is not a grassroots movement. It might have become one, had the disorganized dissatisfaction that arose after Obama's election been allowed to actually grow into a movement on its own. Or it might not have, and the undirected sentiment of "I'm angry at Obama and the stimulus bill I don't know what to do" would have just faded away rather than becoming any kind of movement at all.

But the instant Santelli's rant hit the airwaves, groups like AFP and FreedomWorks were there to start organizing and directing things the way those two organizations wanted, and enticing people to join up with the Fox-News-promoted "tea parties" that they themselves created, creating the astroturf group called the "tea party movement".
Okay, AFP and FreedomWorks got involved early. The most they could have done is channel the grassroots energy, and they don't seem to have channelled it in directions which were particularly aligned with the goals of tobacco companies. Your sources don't show that this wasn't a grassroots movement, only that it might have been less organized without the involvement of political advocacy groups (not tobacco companies).

It doesn't seem to me like there's any "there" there.

To me, "astroturf" is an attempt to portray more popular support than actually exists, rather than organizing and encouraging the support which actually exists. Astroturf doesn't win elections.
 
That's a lot of dots.

But again, looking for dots to connect is just an exercise in confirmation bias and is not science. If you looked, for example, for evidence that the Tea Party movement is a grass roots movement, you could find lots of it too. People with absolutely no connection to tobacco companies writing letters to editors, arguing a position in a coffee shop, organizing or attending a rally, for examples. And if that's all you looked for, that's all you'd find. So?

IMO, the Tea Party ideology should stand or fall (that is, fall) on its own merits and not owing to any connection it has with corporations.

Similarly, ideologies that I like should also stand or fall on their own merits, and the fact that corporations (such as the ACLU, MoveOn, ANSWER, etc.) are connected to these movements is irrelevant.
 
So no, the tea party movement is not a grassroots movement. It might have become one, had the disorganized dissatisfaction that arose after Obama's election been allowed to actually grow into a movement on its own.

It sounds like your argument that the Tea Party movement is not a grassroots movement depends on the premise that it's not a movement at all.

You seem to acknowledge that how it started doesn't really matter to the question. (It could have started as a corporate conspiracy, but whether or not it's a grassroots movement doesn't depend on that, right?)
 
It sounds like your argument that the Tea Party movement is not a grassroots movement depends on the premise that it's not a movement at all.

You seem to acknowledge that how it started doesn't really matter to the question. (It could have started as a corporate conspiracy, but whether or not it's a grassroots movement doesn't depend on that, right?)

No, my argument is that the "tea party movement" is indeed a movement, but it's not a grassroots movement because its organization, internal networking, rally planning, and ideology were all determined in a top-down fashion by large, pre-existing Washington, DC-based conservative political advocacy groups right from the very beginning, despite efforts to pretend that it was the result of spontaneous self-organizing individual protesters who are politically independent.

In other words, the "tea party movement" fits exactly with the definition of astroturfing: "political, advertising or public relations campaigns that are designed to mask the sponsors of the message to give the appearance of coming from a disinterested, grassroots participant. Astroturfing is intended to give the statements the credibility of an independent entity by withholding information about the source's financial connection."
 
No, my argument is that the "tea party movement" is indeed a movement, but it's not a grassroots movement because its organization, internal networking, rally planning, and ideology were all determined in a top-down fashion by large, pre-existing Washington, DC-based conservative political advocacy groups right from the very beginning, despite efforts to pretend that it was the result of spontaneous self-organizing individual protesters who are politically independent.

So you now contradict your statement that it could have become a grassroots movement.

You're now saying it doesn't matter what happened subsequently since its inception is what made it not a grassroots movement.

Seriously, you're claiming the Tea Party ideology was handed down? No yahoo sitting in a bar already held that ideology?

In fact, the history of that ideology in our country goes way back. There's a great example of it in the drunken rantings of Huck Finn's Pap. Surely you aren't claiming that this ideology didn't already exist?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom