Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

I smoke, so I'm generally against restrictions. However, that's not enough to get me to join the Tea Party.

Aren't there Tea Party politicians in federal office now? That might be a place to see if tobacco money is having an effect. I'm not skilled enough to find out if the Tea Party guys also got political contributions from big tobacco, but isn't that info out there? (If not this election cycle -- with the hidden PAC money -- previous cycles?)
 
I smoke, so I'm generally against restrictions. However, that's not enough to get me to join the Tea Party.

Aren't there Tea Party politicians in federal office now? That might be a place to see if tobacco money is having an effect. I'm not skilled enough to find out if the Tea Party guys also got political contributions from big tobacco, but isn't that info out there? (If not this election cycle -- with the hidden PAC money -- previous cycles?)

Serious thing here;

Please stop, I'd hate to see you get lung cancer or emphysema.

I've seen both first hand and they are terrible.

I know it's a hard one to break, but you can do it.
 
Serious thing here;

Please stop, I'd hate to see you get lung cancer or emphysema.

I've seen both first hand and they are terrible.

I know it's a hard one to break, but you can do it.

Thank you for the kind thoughts.
 
(BenBurch): "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "C'mon. Cite =___?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Cite=___?"
(BenBurch): "If you need a cite (BTW, Heartland not Heritage - all you GOPers look alike to me) then you really haven't been paying attention, or you forgot how to Google. Plus it makes me happy to not answer your questions."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Pride in ignorance and paranoia, huh? It's Heartland Institute and Heritage Foundation. C'mon. You made the assertion. Defend it, if it's so easy to do. Cite=___?"
(BenBurch):dl:

C'mon. Is it really so hard? Cite = ___?
 
Last edited:
I too would like to see a cite for laughing dog. Peer reviewed by other laughing dogs if possible.
 
I smoke, so I'm generally against restrictions. However, that's not enough to get me to join the Tea Party.

Aren't there Tea Party politicians in federal office now? That might be a place to see if tobacco money is having an effect. I'm not skilled enough to find out if the Tea Party guys also got political contributions from big tobacco, but isn't that info out there? (If not this election cycle -- with the hidden PAC money -- previous cycles?)

You can find an interactive map of direct tobacco industry campaign contributions (during the last election cycle, I think) here.
 
Last edited:
Ben's dodging, and you approve?

I don't care. I never understood the point of asking for a citation. If someone has one, they can post it in support of their point. If they don't, why bother beating them up over it? Just assume it's a personal opinion unless a cite is included. Otherwise, the request itself seems like a rhetorical dodge.

I know it's part of the culture here, but I think I'd hold off on such requests unless I honestly felt the other party had one.
 
I don't care. I never understood the point of asking for a citation. If someone has one, they can post it in support of their point. If they don't, why bother beating them up over it? Just assume it's a personal opinion unless a cite is included. Otherwise, the request itself seems like a rhetorical dodge.

I know it's part of the culture here, but I think I'd hold off on such requests unless I honestly felt the other party had one.
That's a fair point, but I had a point, also. "To" asserts an intention. I see this often in newspapers, as in "X (policy) was established to ___" (fill in the blank), where the reporter takes some politician or textbook author at his/her word. Reporters could quit and make $ millions at poker if they could really read minds. As with the passive voice, this formula widens the path for personal bias to enter unacknowledged. I complain to newspapers about "to" all the time.
 
(BenBurch): "Koch's dad founded Heritage Foundation to defend tobacco."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "'To' is a statement of intention. Intentions are mental events. Either you (Ben) read minds of dead people or there's some text or recording somewhere in which the elder Koch makes this clear. Do you have any support for this assertion of intention?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "C'mon. Cite =___?"
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Cite=___?"
(BenBurch): "If you need a cite (BTW, Heartland not Heritage - all you GOPers look alike to me) then you really haven't been paying attention, or you forgot how to Google. Plus it makes me happy to not answer your questions."
(Malcolm Kirkpatrick): "Pride in ignorance and paranoia, huh? It's Heartland Institute and Heritage Foundation. C'mon. You made the assertion. Defend it, if it's so easy to do. Cite=___?"
(BenBurch):dl:

C'mon. Is it really so hard? Cite = ___?
Allow me, it's a tangled web and Ben may have some mixed memories, but there are connections that are a lot closer than 6 degrees.

The Heritage Foundation
Early years
Edwin Feulner
The Heritage Foundation was founded in 1973 by Paul Weyrich, Edwin Feulner and Joseph Coors.[5] Growing out of discontent with Richard Nixon's embrace of the "liberal consensus" and the nonpolemical, cautious nature of existing think tanks,[6] Weyrich and Feulner sought to create an organization that would supply policymakers with concise, timely position papers. With $200,000 from Coors, the Analysis and Research Association was created in 1970. New supporters and board members joined, including petroleum executive Edward Noble and Richard Mellon Scaife. Eventually, the organization split into a public interest law center and a separate public policy foundation, the latter of which was incorporated as The Heritage Foundation on February 16, 1973. ...

...In 2007, Heritage reported an operating revenue of $75.0 million. As of February 2011, Heritage reported 710,000 supporters.[44] Heritage Foundation is also a part of the Koch Foundation Associate Program.[45]

SourceWatch
2006 Budget
In the 2006 calendar year the Heritage Foundation spent over $40.5 million on its operations. That year the foundation raised over $25 million from individual contributors and $13.1 million from foundations..... tobacco company Altria Group (Philip Morris),...

...Historical funding
Between 1985 and 2003, Media Transparency reports that the following contributors provided $57,497,537 (unadjusted for inflation) to the Heritage Foundation: ...
Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation

Legacy Tobacco Documents Library
I don't know what's all in there but there are 19 pages listing documents that include 'Heritage Foundation' and 'tobacco'.

I don't want to spend too much time on this so I'll let other interested parties wade through the stuff.

The bottom line, the Kochs, the Heritage Foundation, the John Birch Society, and the Tobacco companies all crossed paths many times and kept the same company in the the last half century.
 
Because they defended by telling people that cigarettes do not and cannot cause cancer.

When we now know they had absolute knowledge that they were telling a lie.

They convinced many people to use their product with fatal consequences with a known lie.

And made a fortune!

If that is not mustache-twirling evil, then it doesn't exist.

This may have been true at one time, but cigarette smokers have this thing called informed consent so I'm against taking away their cigarettes. They imbibe cigarettes so they have no one to blame but themselves when develop any of the hundreds of health conditions associated with long term smoking.

My issue comes when it effects second hand smokers.
 
... The bottom line, the Kochs, the Heritage Foundation, the John Birch Society, and the Tobacco companies all crossed paths many times and kept the same company in the the last half century.
Thanks for the work. It doesn't say much about the elder Koch's intention. A common path does not have to imply a common destination.
Where's the expressed intention "to" defend tobacco?

Those of us who believe that regulators systematically understate the costs of regulation and overstate the benefits will examine the abstract case for regulation in general and specific product regulation in particular with more care than will those people who are more predisposed to accept the case for regulation.

Koch Industries has no significant tobacco-related holdings. Not every religion needs a God. Every religion needs a devil. Koch Industries has replaced Haliburton as the devil for socialist conspiracy loons. You don't have to buy into that.
 
Thanks for the work. It doesn't say much about the elder Koch's intention. A common path does not have to imply a common destination.
Where's the expressed intention "to" defend tobacco?

Those of us who believe that regulators systematically understate the costs of regulation and overstate the benefits will examine the abstract case for regulation in general and specific product regulation in particular with more care than will those people who are more predisposed to accept the case for regulation.

Koch Industries has no significant tobacco-related holdings. Not every religion needs a God. Every religion needs a devil. Koch Industries has replaced Haliburton as the devil for socialist conspiracy loons. You don't have to buy into that.
I don't know if there is or isn't a direct tie from Koch to tobacco, thus I said Ben may be mixing memories. But there is definitely and ideological tie due to their mutual goal of preventing/repealing government enacted tobacco control laws. ([related sidetrack] Though I've never seen anything saying they opposed government subsidies of tobacco farmers. :rolleyes: [/sidetrack])

Guess you'd have to understand how the pieces all fit together.

Like I noted, the elder Koch was a co-founder of the John Birch Society.

The sentiment of Koch, which his sons have adopted, is extreme Ayn Randian Libertarianism. So any government regulation was seen as the road to socialism and ruin.
The organization identifies with Christian principles, seeks to limit governmental powers, and opposes wealth redistribution, and economic interventionism. It not only opposes the practices it terms collectivism, totalitarianism, and communism, but socialism and fascism as well, which it asserts is infiltrating US governmental administration....

The Heritage Foundation is a milder version of the JBS ideologies but only slightly. Many of the same contributors tied to the JBS and Koch Industries, like the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation are also tied to funding the Heritage Foundation as the Kochs are.
...Harry was one of the original charter members of the far right-wing John Birch Society, along with another Birch Society board member, Fred Koch, the father of Koch Industries billionaire brothers and owners, Charles and David Koch.[2]...

..."The overall objective of the Bradley Foundation, however, is to return the U.S. -- and the world -- to the days before governments began to regulate Big Business, before corporations were forced to make concessions to an organized labor force. In other words, laissez-faire capitalism: capitalism with the gloves off.
"To further this objective, Bradley supports the organizations and individuals that promote the deregulation of business, the rollback of virtually all social welfare programs, and the privatization of government services. As a result, the list of Bradley grant recipients reads like a Who's Who of the U.S. Right ... Heritage Foundation ... Madison Center for Educational Affairs ... American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, literary home for such racist authors as Charles Murray (The Bell Curve) and Dinesh D'Souza (The End of Racism), former conservative officeholders Jeane J. Kirkpatrick, Jack Kemp and William J. Bennett, and arch-conservative jurists Robert H. Bork and Antonin Scalia...[4]

The reason there are 19 pages of document bibliography tying the Heritage Foundation with tobacco companies is because these people's extreme Libertarian ideology is vehemently opposed to anti-smoking laws. Tobacco companies have also given millions to the Heritage Foundation, naturally.
 
I don't know if there is or isn't a direct tie from Koch to tobacco, thus I said Ben may be mixing memories. But there is definitely and ideological tie due to their mutual goal of preventing/repealing government enacted tobacco control laws.
...
The sentiment of Koch, which his sons have adopted, is extreme Ayn Randian Libertarianism. So any government regulation was seen as the road to socialism and ruin.
That was my point. Koch's support for free markets generally hardly implies a concern for the tobacco industry in particular. We agree.
The reason there are 19 pages of document bibliography tying the Heritage Foundation with tobacco companies is because these people's extreme Libertarian ideology is vehemently opposed to anti-smoking laws.
Alcohol prohibition didn't work very well. How's the War on Drugs going?
... Tobacco companies have also given millions to the Heritage Foundation, naturally.
Naturally. That says nothing about the elder Koch's motives for supportig Heartland or Heritage.
 
More connected dots:

Tea Party Blood Ties: The reemergence of the John Birch Society in 2012 Definitely a liberal blog, but contains a lot of facts, nonetheless.

The Heritage Foundation and Grover Norquist Ties
The Heritage Foundation bills itself as a Conservative think tank when in truth they are lobbyist and responsible for hiring the people who spread the lies against the Democrat majority and President Obama both on the blog-o-sphere and the air waves. It, along with Grover Norquist, was responsible in helping elect President George W. Bush. They sponsor Rush Limbaugh and work in unison with Grover Norquist refusal to raise taxes. Grover Norquist is a frequent guest as are Tea Party members Ron and Rand Paul on CNN

Phillip Morris Tobacco along with the Choctaw Indian Tribe and Time Warner who owns CNN are large contributors.
The comments about CNN's politics are disturbing to say the least.

I should also point out that these people go to great lengths to cloak their influence in fake front groups. The Heritage Foundation is under no circumstance unbiased.

Here's a link to the UCSF (did the study) comments on the research.
..“Nonprofit organizations associated with the Tea Party movement have longstanding ties to tobacco companies, and continue to advocate on behalf of the tobacco industry’s anti-tax, anti-regulation agenda,” ....

...From previously secret tobacco industry documents available at the UCSF Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, IRS filings and other publicly available documents, the study authors traced a decades-long chain of personal, corporate and financial relationships between tobacco companies, tobacco industry lobbying and public relations firms and nonprofit organizations associated with the Tea Party.

The research uncovered the tobacco industry’s ongoing opposition to health care reform, dating back to a major campaign waged against President Bill Clinton’s proposed 75-cent cigarette tax to help finance it. ...

...In 2002, before the mainstream media widely discussed Tea party politics, Citizens for a Sound Economy (CSE), a nonprofit funded in part by cigarette companies since 1987 to support a pro-tobacco political agenda, started its US Tea Party project. ...

In 2004, CSE split into the Tea Party organizations Americans for Prosperity (AFP) and Freedom Works. Those two groups, say the authors, have since waged campaigns to turn public opinion against tobacco taxes, smoke-free laws and health care reform in general....

This is the key to the connections I've tried to show with my posts:
“If you look at CSE, AFP and Freedom Works, you will see a number of the same key players, strategies and messages going back to the 1980s,” said lead author Amanda Fallin, PhD, RN, also a CTCRE fellow. “The records indicate that the Tea Party has been shaped by the tobacco industry, and is not a spontaneous grassroots movement at all.”
This is also true for a number of science denial campaigns tied to the same people by the historians who wrote "Merchants of Doubt" that I posted about earlier.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom