Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Can you explain? It seems to me that the fact that the summary of events is seen as accurate by both parties is a good sign that it's actually accurate. You think that both sides agreeing that he's portrayed them fairly is a sign that he hasn't?

This doesn't mean that they agree with the writer's conclusions/opinions about the debate.

Who are "both parties"? Who are "both sides"? That is the main issue as I see it. And just what did they agree on? That the answer hasn't been confirmed either way?
 
It's too long so I will tackle it a bit at a time beginning with stuff already discussed in this thread. So far it looks like a re-hash with nothing new added.

1)Worobey claims the cases cluster around the wet market. He conveniently left out the actual earliest cases.
2)One vendor infected by one person coming from the WIV could show a similar pattern. The market is a super-spreader location given the traffic in and out daily.
3)There is no concentrated housing around the WIV where an outbreak would show up.
4)No source species was identified. A minute amount of COVID RNA was found in a stall that had housed and sold raccoon dogs. But nothing similar to COVID 19 has ever been found circulating in raccoon dogs.
5)Cases also clustered around the subway line leading to and from the WIV.​
 
Last edited:
It's too long so I will tackle it a bit at a time beginning with stuff already discussed in this thread. So far it looks like a re-hash with nothing new added.

1)Worobey claims the cases cluster around the wet market. He conveniently left out the actual earliest cases.
2)One vendor infected by one person coming from the WIV could show a similar pattern. The market is a super-spreader location given the traffic in and out daily.
3)There is no concentrated housing around the WIV where an outbreak would show up.
4)No source species was identified. A minute amount of COVID RNA was found in a stall that had housed and sold raccoon dogs. But nothing similar to COVID 19 has ever been found circulating in raccoon dogs.
5)Cases also clustered around the subway line leading to and from the WIV.​

Peter Miller debunks each of those points. The one point that remains true is that raccoon dogs have not been found to have a precursor virus of SARS-CoV-2 but as has been pointed out repeatedly, the search for it was late and hasn’t been continued.

The supposed coincidence of a coronavirus being found in a city with a coronavirus lab is on a par with the outbreak occurring in a wet martlet containing susceptible animals, with the greatest concentration of cases and environmental samples centering around the very stalls in which they were kept.

Other evidence against the lab is the way in which the virus can be expected to replicate leaving the improbable scenario that you suggest, apparently in all seriousness, that an infected lab worker made a bee-line for the wet market to set off a chain of infections. Your own scenario therefore discredits or contradicts the theory about the “early cases” which as Miller points out did not pan out.
 
Who are "both parties"? Who are "both sides"? That is the main issue as I see it. And just what did they agree on? That the answer hasn't been confirmed either way?

Saar Wilf who offered to bet $100,000 on the outcome of a debate, determined by two judges, and Peter Miller, who is just a guy who took him up on the offer. As to what they agreed on, it's just that they read that summary of the debate written by Scott Alexander and agreed that he accurately represented what was said. They don't agree about the correct judgement of the questions raised, for instance Saar still thinks that lab leak is 95% likely to be true, whereas Peter Miller is convinced of the opposite.

The "both sides agreed that the summary is accurate" comment was only meant to suggest that the summary was an accurate portrayal of what was said in the debate, not about any conclusions that should be drawn.
 
Peter Miller debunks each of those points. The one point that remains true is that raccoon dogs have not been found to have a precursor virus of SARS-CoV-2 but as has been pointed out repeatedly, the search for it was late and hasn’t been continued.
Oh BS. Had it actually occurred there would be a genetic trail circulating in the raccoon dog population somewhere in China. You think it came and went out in the blink of an eye, just like that.

Are you aware we can still find Neanderthal DNA in the human population after millions of years? How naive to think absolutely no trace of a related virus to COVID has been found. This is why it's difficult to carry on this discussion with people in the thread repeating 'facts' they actually know very little about.


And the second point you raised in your first paragraph, what points were debunked? All the 'points' were debunked in this thread.

Nothing new to see here folks, move along.


How about we shorten this waste of time and someone tell us what is actually new in that article?
 
Saar Wilf who offered to bet $100,000 on the outcome of a debate, determined by two judges, and Peter Miller, who is just a guy who took him up on the offer. As to what they agreed on, it's just that they read that summary of the debate written by Scott Alexander and agreed that he accurately represented what was said. They don't agree about the correct judgement of the questions raised, for instance Saar still thinks that lab leak is 95% likely to be true, whereas Peter Miller is convinced of the opposite.

The "both sides agreed that the summary is accurate" comment was only meant to suggest that the summary was an accurate portrayal of what was said in the debate, not about any conclusions that should be drawn.
That makes sense!

I'm still convinced the evidence supports the lab origin of the virus and there are a whole slew of people who don't want to consider that might be true.
 
Oh BS. Had it actually occurred there would be a genetic trail circulating in the raccoon dog population somewhere in China. You think it came and went out in the blink of an eye, just like that.

Are you aware we can still find Neanderthal DNA in the human population after millions of years? How naive to think absolutely no trace of a related virus to COVID has been found. This is why it's difficult to carry on this discussion with people in the thread repeating 'facts' they actually know very little about.

And the second point you raised in your first paragraph, what points were debunked? All the 'points' were debunked in this thread.

Nothing new to see here folks, move along.


How about we shorten this waste of time and someone tell us what is actually new in that article?

You know, the origins of Covid debate never gets boring for me because every time we have these discussions, I will see a new and more hilariously bad argument.

Today, for example, I am asked if I am aware "we can still find Neanderthal DNA in the human population after millions of years".

Yes, I am, and I have read David Reich's excellent book Who We Are and How We Got Here, in which he points out that almost all human populations (with notable exceptions) have up to about 2% of their inheritance from Neaderthals. Also, populations have varying amounts of Denisovan ancestry. The book also explains how ancient DNA was able to be sequenced from bones. It's fascinating, and if you haven't read it, then I recommend it.

Now, your example is about the human genome and its DNA. This is relevant to the ability to find coronavirus RNA in raccoon dogs, how?

Oh yes, it isn't relevant whatsoever. It's just a pointless attempt at a rhetorical curveball. Unlike Covid, your analogy won't catch on.
 
Oh BS. Had it actually occurred there would be a genetic trail circulating in the raccoon dog population somewhere in China. You think it came and went out in the blink of an eye, just like that.

Are you aware we can still find Neanderthal DNA in the human population after millions of years? How naive to think absolutely no trace of a related virus to COVID has been found. This is why it's difficult to carry on this discussion with people in the thread repeating 'facts' they actually know very little about.


And the second point you raised in your first paragraph, what points were debunked? All the 'points' were debunked in this thread.

Nothing new to see here folks, move along.


How about we shorten this waste of time and someone tell us what is actually new in that article?

What is the relevance of Neanderthal DNA?

You can certainly have outbreaks of infections in a community that then completely disappears having run its course. So the precursor to NCoV-19 may no longer be in the racoon dog population infected (if they still exist, since the captive population was likely eliminated).

The single piece of evidence in favour of a laboratory origin is the coincidence that NCoV-19 appeared in the same city where China's largest coronavirus research laboratory was, but sometimes coincidences are exactly that. Other than that, the laboratory leak case has no positive evidence, it just is a litany of this might have happened with no evidence any of the hypothesised events e.g. insertion of an atypical Furin cleavage site at an atypical site in a laboratory that didn't do that type of experiment actually happened.
 
Sorry, have to make a correction: Neanderthals did not live millions of years ago. They lived as recently as tens of thousands of years ago and up to half a million years. Just thought SG might like to be made aware of that.
 
What is the relevance of Neanderthal DNA?

You can certainly have outbreaks of infections in a community that then completely disappears having run its course. So the precursor to NCoV-19 may no longer be in the racoon dog population infected (if they still exist, since the captive population was likely eliminated).

The single piece of evidence in favour of a laboratory origin is the coincidence that NCoV-19 appeared in the same city where China's largest coronavirus research laboratory was, but sometimes coincidences are exactly that. Other than that, the laboratory leak case has no positive evidence, it just is a litany of this might have happened with no evidence any of the hypothesised events e.g. insertion of an atypical Furin cleavage site at an atypical site in a laboratory that didn't do that type of experiment actually happened.

Yes, sometimes coincidences are exactly that - other times they're circumstantial evidence. AIUI there is no hard evidence for either route from cave to wet market, in which case circumstantial evidence is all that is available. The fact of the coronavirus research lab being in the same city as the outbreak start, together with the clear direct link from caves to lab is quite some coincidence, isn't it? was there a clear direct link from caves to market?

The more circumstantial evidence that has to be handwaved away as coincidence to arrive at a specific conclusion, the less likely the conclusion is correct.
 
The reason China has several coronavirus labs is because it was always the most likely country for a novel coronavirus to emerge in though, wasn't it? And such a virus was always most likely to get a foothold in a large city. So I'm not sure one emerging in a Chinese city which had a lab is as unlikely a coincidence as it might at first appear.
 
The reason China has several coronavirus labs is because it was always the most likely country for a novel coronavirus to emerge in though, wasn't it? And such a virus was always most likely to get a foothold in a large city. So I'm not sure one emerging in a Chinese city which had a lab is as unlikely a coincidence as it might at first appear.

How many cities in China? How many labs? Particularly labs that take samples from the caves at the centre of the controversy?
 
The reason China has several coronavirus labs is because it was always the most likely country for a novel coronavirus to emerge in though, wasn't it? And such a virus was always most likely to get a foothold in a large city. So I'm not sure one emerging in a Chinese city which had a lab is as unlikely a coincidence as it might at first appear.

There's a bit on that point in the piece I linked earlier:

I think - not because Saar really explained it, but just reading between the lines - Saar thought the un-ignorable big picture evidence was the origin in a city with a coronavirus gain-of-function lab, and the twelve-nucleotide insertion in the furin cleavage site.

To some degree, Peter just ate the loss on those questions. No matter how you slice it, it really is a weird coincidence that the epidemic started so close to Asia’s biggest coronavirus laboratory. Peter tried to deflect this - he pointed out there were other BSL-3 and BSL-4 laboratories in Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, etc. But this was a rare question where he unambiguously came out looking worse - the other cities’ labs had much less coronavirus-specific research. Wuhan really was unique (aside from the other big coronavirus lab in North Carolina).

Peter did better when he tried to control the damage: there are a couple hundred million people in the South Asian areas where people eat weird animals exposed to virus-infected bats, Wuhan has a population of about 12 million, so maybe 1.5% of all potential zoonotic pandemics should start in Wuhan. Peter tried to argue that Wuhan was a local trade center, so maybe we should up that to 5 - 10%. 5 - 10% coincidences aren’t that rare. Even 1.5% coincidences happen sometimes.
 
How many cities in China? How many labs? Particularly labs that take samples from the caves at the centre of the controversy?

I have no idea. It just doesn't strike me as as unlikely a coincidence as it would have done if the pandemic had begun in a city with such a lab in any other country.

Maybe I've just spent too much time arguing with people who, given a choice between accepting that unlikely coincidences do occur and believing in the paranormal, choose the latter without hesitation.
 
The reason China has several coronavirus labs is because it was always the most likely country for a novel coronavirus to emerge in though, wasn't it? And such a virus was always most likely to get a foothold in a large city. So I'm not sure one emerging in a Chinese city which had a lab is as unlikely a coincidence as it might at first appear.

It wasn't just in Wuhan, it was in Wuhan within a few miles of the WIV where they were doing research on SARS coronaviruses in a level 2 biosafety lab.

There has been no trail found how said viruses got to the seafood market and no source species. The connection to raccoon dogs sold at the market was as tenuous as you can get.

There were no contemporary outbreaks of any unusual pneumonia clusters across China at the time of the cases appearing in Wuhan.

Emails between Fauci and his colleagues discussed it looking like a lab leak then within days they stopped such communication and suddenly without evidence claimed it wasn't a lab leak.

The head of the WHO upon return of the investigative team said their report prematurely ruled out the lab without ever having sufficiently investigated a lab origin.

On the WHO team was Peter Daszak who steered the team away from the lab. Daszak happened to be involved with the research on emerging coronaviruses and had a motive to slant the report. Other scientists on the team complained he should not have been on the team at all. Daszak was also responsible for getting scientists to sign a paper supporting a natural spillover which he had hidden the fact he wrote the letter. Several signatories withdrew their names when they found this out.

Daszak wanted to find or create a potentially pandemic emerging coronavirus in order to develop a vaccine for it before the virus spread. He worked closely with Dr Shi from the WIV.

Shi claimed there were no live cultures and no live bats at the WIV. This turned out to be false.

The wet market was initially determined to be a superspreader site, not the site of origin. The cases spread among people in the market. Despite China initially closing the market and destroying the animals sold there, RNA was recovered and a trace amount was found in one stall that had sold raccoon dogs. It was never determined the RNA recovered was from any animals sold in that stall.

The earlier cases which were left out of the study of the virus initially spreading had no connection to the market and the Chinese government withheld demographic information about those earliest cases which could have shed light on the viruses origin. The idea the virus spreading silently in the community explained those cases has at least one big problem. If those cases were not connected to the market, how many other cases were left out of mapping the spread? Another big problem is why did the Chinese refuse to disclose important information about those cases?


We've been through all this in this thread ad nauseum. Yet people still insist this or that cherrypicked bit of evidence doesn't support a lab origin. But if you add all the evidence up, if you look at it as a whole, if you consider no source of circulating pathogenic coronavirus has been found to this day, it adds up to a lab origin.
 
You know, the origins of Covid debate never gets boring for me because every time we have these discussions, I will see a new and more hilariously bad argument.

Today, for example, I am asked if I am aware "we can still find Neanderthal DNA in the human population after millions of years".


Giving Skeptic Ginger the benefit of the doubt here, she might have been pointing out to us that more than 15 years elapsed between the first isolation of Neanderthal DNA and the discovery of Neanderthal DNA in modern humans.

So maybe she's saying it could well take us more than a decade to discover the origins of COVID-19.

But as Planigale points out, the virus may already have disappeared from its original host population. So we might never learn the true origin of this disease.

What is the relevance of Neanderthal DNA?

You can certainly have outbreaks of infections in a community that then completely disappears having run its course. So the precursor to NCoV-19 may no longer be in the racoon dog population infected (if they still exist, since the captive population was likely eliminated).
 
I have no idea. It just doesn't strike me as as unlikely a coincidence as it would have done if the pandemic had begun in a city with such a lab in any other country.

Maybe I've just spent too much time arguing with people who, given a choice between accepting that unlikely coincidences do occur and believing in the paranormal, choose the latter without hesitation.

I'd agree that would be enough to colour anyone's perception.
 
Giving Skeptic Ginger the benefit of the doubt here, she might have been pointing out to us that more than 15 years elapsed between the first isolation of Neanderthal DNA and the discovery of Neanderthal DNA in modern humans.

So maybe she's saying it could well take us more than a decade to discover the origins of COVID-19.

But as Planigale points out, the virus may already have disappeared from its original host population. So we might never learn the true origin of this disease.

What I was pointing out is the fact traces or COVID RNA don't just arise and disappear without a trace. Any animals destined for that market but that hadn't been destroyed in the initial closing down of the market would have had evidence of circulating related, if not exact traces of the pathogen.

It is an absurd excuse-making trying to rationalize why no traces of circulating related coronaviruses have been found in any source species.
They destroyed all the animals from the market.
They haven't tested enough animals.
Look, all the parts of the virus have been found in caves in China and Laos.
​
These are all BS arguments. There is no trail where there should be a trail leading from a source species to the market. How is it this virus evolved ready to infect humans right out of the box yet no precursor virus circulated in any other market in China? It's absurd.

In the meantime the trail of the virus to the WIV can indeed be seen.
 
What I was pointing out is the fact traces or COVID RNA don't just arise and disappear without a trace. Any animals destined for that market but that hadn't been destroyed in the initial closing down of the market would have had evidence of circulating related, if not exact traces of the pathogen.

It is an absurd excuse-making trying to rationalize why no traces of circulating related coronaviruses have been found in any source species.
They destroyed all the animals from the market.
They haven't tested enough animals.
Look, all the parts of the virus have been found in caves in China and Laos.
​
These are all BS arguments. There is no trail where there should be a trail leading from a source species to the market. How is it this virus evolved ready to infect humans right out of the box yet no precursor virus circulated in any other market in China? It's absurd.

In the meantime the trail of the virus to the WIV can indeed be seen.

1) For most zoonotic outbreaks there is no clear trail. Look at mpox. No clear trail from source to human pandemic. Look at HIV no clear trail from primate to human. Look at TB no clear trail into the human populations e.g. South America. What traces are you suggesting should exist? Antibodies?

2) The virus was no more ready to infect humans than many other mammalian species like mink, deer etc.

3) How do we know no precursor virus circulated? No one was looking., if the precursor virus didn't cause deaths in humans no one would have looked for it.

Again you just claim that absence of evidence is evidence in itself. That is only true if you would have expected evidence to exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom