Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

I heard members of the Democrats say explicitly, a number of times, in the Morens hearing, that they have not seen evidence that any of the NIH grants, or Fauci or Morens or Daszak were involved in creating any viruses or working with any viruses that could have been the precursor of Covid-19.

Instead, despite no evidence, the idea that there is some murky cover-up about a lab leak is what many of the politicians in the GOP, as well as a few others, are trying to push.

It remains the fact that there is no credible evidence of a lab leak. All of the lab leak claims involve making up stuff written in crayon to cover over the gaps in knowledge.

A partisan viewpoint, by your own words. Viruses do not favor political parties. The origin being from the lab or scientists at the lab moving live viruses, needs nothing other than a 'chance'.
It is what it is.
Many still seem to avoid the simplest, most obvious answer- the top contender
being the premiere bat virus lab in the world being at ground zero, doing no-see-um experiments, or to anyone just looking at basic geography of the bats and the cuisine of the area NOT being bats..
Your statement here will age poorly (and already has -- in my opinion. )

All of this was known in the first few weeks.
 
A partisan viewpoint, by your own words. Viruses do not favor political parties. The origin being from the lab or scientists at the lab moving live viruses, needs nothing other than a 'chance'.
It is what it is.
Many still seem to avoid the simplest, most obvious answer- the top contender
being the premiere bat virus lab in the world being at ground zero, doing no-see-um experiments, or to anyone just looking at basic geography of the bats and the cuisine of the area NOT being bats..
Your statement here will age poorly (and already has -- in my opinion. )

All of this was known in the first few weeks.

Nobody credible is, or has ever been arguing that Covid was caused by eating bats.

One of the reasons why scientists wrote the Proximal Origins paper was because of the possibility that the virus somehow came about through manipulation. But they concluded that it was unlikely to have because the various parts of the virus were known in the wild and therefore it likely came about through recombination.
 
Nobody credible is, or has ever been arguing that Covid was caused by eating bats.

One of the reasons why scientists wrote the Proximal Origins paper was because of the possibility that the virus somehow came about through manipulation. But they concluded that it was unlikely to have because the various parts of the virus were known in the wild and therefore it likely came about through recombination.

"Somehow" was in early phase...just a week into the virus affecting the US. They (the writers of proximal) wrote it in a matter of a few days and spoke so confidently discounting the lab, which was so odd for a timeline of an outbreak where anything was possible at that point, especially the large level 2&3 and a new 4 viral biolab , top in the world for bat virus research, and just down the road n the city at ground zero.
And they were WRONG.
And so were you in your estimation of the statistical significance of it.

Time has already told the story. No natural origin was found. No animal. No vector in nature. It was the lab.
 
The 'Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic'?

https://oversight.house.gov/subcommittee/select-subcommittee-on-the-coronavirus-pandemic/

Appears to be an ad-hoc subcommittee of the House of Representatives, comprised of 9 Republicans, including Marjorie Taylor Greene, a certifiable lunatic, and 7 Democrats, none of whom I've heard of before.

I'm sure they'll get to the bottom of this.


That subcommittee is chaired by Representative Brad Wenstrup, DPM (Doctor of Podiatric Medicine).

It is fair to describe Dr Wenstrup as a conspiracy theorist, because he signed an amicus brief in support of Texas v Pennsylvania, a lawsuit drafted by lawyers associated with Donald Trump's campaign, brought by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, alleging that four states violated the US Constitution by actions that ran counter to the independent state legislature theory, which is a discredited legal theory that remains popular among Republicans. That lawsuit was the last gasp of Trump's legal efforts to overturn the 2016 election. It was opposed by the Texas Solicitor General, and the US Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

I apologize for having to mention the facts related in the paragraph above, but it is important to keep Dr Wenstrup's political biases in mind when reading the report I will cite in just a moment.

It looks to me like the "lab leak hypothesis is a scientifically unfounded conspiracy theory" narrative is unraveling.

The subcommittee is now requesting the declassification of certain documents that they've been able to examine and which they claim indicate a Chinese cover-up of a lab leak origin. Is there a dissenting minority report from the Democrat members? I haven't heard of any.


The subcommittee's most recent report is dated 1 May 2024. Its opening letter and executive summary give an impression that the report was written by Republicans without any moderating influence from Democrats. The opening letter also tells us Representative Wenstrup doesn't know the difference between "reign" and "rein".

That is why I took a moment to check up on Representative Wenstrup.

You were asking...

"Is there a dissenting minority report from the Democrat members? I haven't heard of any."

I heard members of the Democrats say explicitly, a number of times, in the Morens hearing, that they have not seen evidence that any of the NIH grants, or Fauci or Morens or Daszak were involved in creating any viruses or working with any viruses that could have been the precursor of Covid-19.

Instead, despite no evidence, the idea that there is some murky cover-up about a lab leak is what many of the politicians in the GOP, as well as a few others, are trying to push.


That does indeed appear to be the idea pushed by the subcommittee report of 1 May.

It remains the fact that there is no credible evidence of a lab leak. All of the lab leak claims involve making up stuff written in crayon to cover over the gaps in knowledge.

If you look again at page 1, you will see there was some claim about sick WIV workers apparently being known to Mike Pompeo's State Department. Years later we still have no more information except that Michael Shellenberger named three workers that he said he got from "insider sources". But why is THIS not declassifed? Where is the actual information? Why are these politicians not demanding that these sources be hauled before a hearing?

Well, my guess is for the same reason that we still have no information about a similarly sourced story by Michael Shellenber ("credible insiders") who told him all about the alien spacecraft and alien bodies that his credible sources found.

My guess, to be explicit, is that the information is complete BS!


With regard to the paragraph I highlighted, we do know that the US State Department issued a fact sheet on 15 January 2021 (less than a week before the end of Pompeo's tenure as Trump's Secretary of State) that averred the following:
The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses.


The fact sheet also said this:
The U.S. government does not know exactly where, when, or how the COVID-19 virus—known as SARS-CoV-2—was transmitted initially to humans. We have not determined whether the outbreak began through contact with infected animals or was the result of an accident at a laboratory in Wuhan, China.

The virus could have emerged naturally from human contact with infected animals, spreading in a pattern consistent with a natural epidemic. Alternatively, a laboratory accident could resemble a natural outbreak if the initial exposure included only a few individuals and was compounded by asymptomatic infection.


It seems to me the US government doesn't know a whole lot more now than it did then.

Time has already told the story. No natural origin was found. No animal. No vector in nature. It was the lab.


We are in a situation where there are two overly broad hypotheses, which we might refer to as X and Y. There are a few facts that could be construed as evidence for X, and a few facts that could be construed as evidence for Y, but there is as yet no open and shut case to be made for either X or Y.

At this time, it would be quite silly to pretend the absence of an open and shut case for X is definitive proof of Y.
 
Correction: see highlighted strikeout.

That subcommittee is chaired by Representative Brad Wenstrup, DPM (Doctor of Podiatric Medicine).

It is fair to describe Dr Wenstrup as a conspiracy theorist, because he signed an amicus brief in support of Texas v Pennsylvania, a lawsuit drafted by lawyers associated with Donald Trump's campaign, brought by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, alleging that four states violated the US Constitution by actions that ran counter to the independent state legislature theory, which is a discredited legal theory that remains popular among Republicans. That lawsuit was the last gasp of Trump's legal efforts to overturn the 2016 2020 election. It was opposed by the Texas Solicitor General, and the US Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
 
That subcommittee is chaired by Representative Brad Wenstrup, DPM (Doctor of Podiatric Medicine).

It is fair to describe Dr Wenstrup as a conspiracy theorist, because he signed an amicus brief in support of Texas v Pennsylvania, a lawsuit drafted by lawyers associated with Donald Trump's campaign, brought by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, alleging that four states violated the US Constitution by actions that ran counter to the independent state legislature theory, which is a discredited legal theory that remains popular among Republicans. That lawsuit was the last gasp of Trump's legal efforts to overturn the 2016 election. It was opposed by the Texas Solicitor General, and the US Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

I apologize for having to mention the facts related in the paragraph above, but it is important to keep Dr Wenstrup's political biases in mind when reading the report I will cite in just a moment.




The subcommittee's most recent report is dated 1 May 2024. Its opening letter and executive summary give an impression that the report was written by Republicans without any moderating influence from Democrats. The opening letter also tells us Representative Wenstrup doesn't know the difference between "reign" and "rein".

That is why I took a moment to check up on Representative Wenstrup.




That does indeed appear to be the idea pushed by the subcommittee report of 1 May.




With regard to the paragraph I highlighted, we do know that the US State Department issued a fact sheet on 15 January 2021 (less than a week before the end of Pompeo's tenure as Trump's Secretary of State) that averred the following:



The fact sheet also said this:



It seems to me the US government doesn't know a whole lot more now than it did then.




We are in a situation where there are two overly broad hypotheses, which we might refer to as X and Y. There are a few facts that could be construed as evidence for X, and a few facts that could be construed as evidence for Y, but there is as yet no open and shut case to be made for either X or Y.

At this time, it would be quite silly to pretend the absence of an open and shut case for X is definitive proof of Y.

Well said!

However, a priori it is very unlikely given the knowledge and technology available at the time that SARS-CoV-2 could have been created at WIV. Whilst on the other hand we have many, many zoonotic pandemics. HIV, Flu, SARS (nearly), plague, small pox, mpox, etc.
 
Well said!

However, a priori it is very unlikely given the knowledge and technology available at the time that SARS-CoV-2 could have been created at WIV. Whilst on the other hand we have many, many zoonotic pandemics. HIV, Flu, SARS (nearly), plague, small pox, mpox, etc.

That isn't the claim. It might be the reason, but there are a myriad of other ways that work at the lab leads to the escape of a virus that caused the virus to circulate in Wuhan, specifically. The other explanations actually need more proof, proof that was never found.
 
That isn't the claim. It might be the reason, but there are a myriad of other ways that work at the lab leads to the escape of a virus that caused the virus to circulate in Wuhan, specifically. The other explanations actually need more proof, proof that was never found.

No!

There are no ways that work at the laboratory can lead to SARS-CoV-2. It is impossible. The only real way a laboratory leak could have caused SARS-CoV-2 to have occurred in Wuhan is if SARS-CoV-2 was imported into the laboratory as a pre-existing virus from the wild. Even that is problematic and has no positive evidence to support it.
 
No!

There are no ways that work at the laboratory can lead to SARS-CoV-2. It is impossible. The only real way a laboratory leak could have caused SARS-CoV-2 to have occurred in Wuhan is if SARS-CoV-2 was imported into the laboratory as a pre-existing virus from the wild. Even that is problematic and has no positive evidence to support it.
To be clear, do you rule out the lab leak as the cause of the pandemic?
I have just checked back in.
 
No!

There are no ways that work at the laboratory can lead to SARS-CoV-2. It is impossible. The only real way a laboratory leak could have caused SARS-CoV-2 to have occurred in Wuhan is if SARS-CoV-2 was imported into the laboratory as a pre-existing virus from the wild. Even that is problematic and has no positive evidence to support it.

To be clear, do you rule out the lab leak as the cause of the pandemic?
I have just checked back in.


As has been said by multiple people, it is possible that the pandemic began with a lab leak.

As Planigale said above, the most plausible scenarios for a lab-leak origin of the pandemic involve escape from a laboratory of SARS-CoV-2 viruses that evolved in the wild but were brought into the laboratory inadvertently. For example, a lab worker whose job involved collecting bats or bat viruses might have become infected with SARS-CoV-2 as part of his/her job and then shopped at the wet market, causing the wet market to look like the origin of the pandemic. Another possibility is that bats or bat viruses were collected in the wild and brought into the lab as part of its research, but somehow escaped the lab; here again one of the more likely avenues of escape is through a lab worker becoming infected with SARS-CoV-2 while in the lab and then infecting others as he or she went about his/her daily life.

There is no solid evidence of any lab worker becoming infected with SARS-CoV-2 before the outbreak at the wet market. Some workers have of course come down with symptoms that were assumed to be caused by a common cold or flu-like virus, and it is conceivable that their symptoms were actually due to Covid-19. But there is no solid evidence for that.
 
As has been said by multiple people, it is possible that the pandemic began with a lab leak.

As Planigale said above, the most plausible scenarios for a lab-leak origin of the pandemic involve escape from a laboratory of SARS-CoV-2 viruses that evolved in the wild but were brought into the laboratory inadvertently. For example, a lab worker whose job involved collecting bats or bat viruses might have become infected with SARS-CoV-2 as part of his/her job and then shopped at the wet market, causing the wet market to look like the origin of the pandemic. Another possibility is that bats or bat viruses were collected in the wild and brought into the lab as part of its research, but somehow escaped the lab; here again one of the more likely avenues of escape is through a lab worker becoming infected with SARS-CoV-2 while in the lab and then infecting others as he or she went about his/her daily life.

There is no solid evidence of any lab worker becoming infected with SARS-CoV-2 before the outbreak at the wet market. Some workers have of course come down with symptoms that were assumed to be caused by a common cold or flu-like virus, and it is conceivable that their symptoms were actually due to Covid-19. But there is no solid evidence for that.

I agree.
 
... It was the lab.

Can you specify which of the three "out of the lab" scenarios just enumerated by W.D.C. you are convinced "it was"?
  1. A Wuhan lab worker got infected with SARS-Cov-2 virus while out on a field trip in the wild and inadvertantly spread it, e.g.at the wet market. (In this scenario, the lab was not actually working with the virus)
  2. A Wuhan lab stored and studied SARS-Cov-2 virus, which was sampled from some animal reservoir in the wild, and a lab worker got infected with that (natural origin) lab population virus and spread it in the city, e.g. at the wet market
  3. A lab in Wuhan had CREATED the Sars-Cov-2 virus with enhanced functionality or whatever (i.e. "weaponized") from a wild precursor virus, and through a lab accident (an infected worker...),or deliberately, it started spreading in Wuhan.

If you can't decide, do you at least have an opinion on which is the most likely, and which the least likely one? And what evidence or argument would you base that opinion on?
Or have I overlooked a fourth possibility?
 
A few days ago, the Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic released the transcript of Dr Fauci's closed-door testimony of 8 and 9 January, along with several press releases and memos that apply considerable political spin to that and other transcripts.

This excerpt, from page 117 of Fauci's second transcript, is relevant to this thread:

Q Just you sitting here today, do you think the possibility or the hypothesis that the coronavirus emerged from a laboratory accident is a conspiracy theory?

A Well, it's a possibility. I think people have made conspiracy aspects from it. And I think you have to separate the two when you keep an open mind, that it could be a lab leak or it could be a natural occurrence.

I've mentioned in this committee that I believe the evidence that I've seen weighs my opinion towards one, which is a natural occurrence, but I still leave an open mind.

So I think that in and of itself isn't inherently a conspiracy theory, but some people spin off things from that that are kind of crazy.

Q No, that's fair.

A Okay.


That short exchange was followed by a long and meandering discussion of Dr Daszak and others. That long and meandering discussion was followed by long and meandering discussions of various other issues.

Fauci gave public testimony before the subcommittee today, but the silliness of today's hearing belongs in a different subforum.
 
This is an episode of This Week in Virology which begins with a breakdown of the Alina Chan op-ed piece in the New York Times.

I would be interested to know what Capsid thinks of the episode, as they go into the science of viruses in some detail to explain why some of the diagrams in Alina Chan's piece are wrong.

They also explain how the op-ed does what I and others have been saying for a while, that a lab leak theory doesn't necessarily have to be a conspiracy theory, but dismissing evidence for the market origin essentially involves having to claim conspiracies and incompetence of scientists such as Worobey, the intelligence community in the US, and other government figures, and in other countries.

For example, the two lineages in the market, and the fact that even among those early cases of Covid who had no connection to the market lived closer to the market than those who did have a connection to it.

Again, the only way to explain it is some underhanded behaviour by virologists and the peer reviewers.



Here is one point that I think shows a deliberate distortion by Alina Chan:

Their research showed that the viruses most similar to SARS‑CoV‑2, the virus that caused the pandemic, circulate in bats that live roughly 1,000 miles away from Wuhan. Scientists from Dr. Shi’s team traveled repeatedly to Yunnan province to collect these viruses and had expanded their search to Southeast Asia. Bats in other parts of China have not been found to carry viruses that are as closely related to SARS-CoV-2.

This point came up because of RaTG13, which Chan and Ridley spent a lot of time hinting must have been the progenitor virus, and yet, RaTG13 is not as close to SARS-CoV2 than BANAL-52 which came from Laos. This part about "Bats in other parts of China have not been found to carry...." is misleading if viruses closer to SARS-CoV2 were found in Laos.
 


Here is one point that I think shows a deliberate distortion by Alina Chan:



This point came up because of RaTG13, which Chan and Ridley spent a lot of time hinting must have been the progenitor virus, and yet, RaTG13 is not as close to SARS-CoV2 than BANAL-52 which came from Laos. This part about "Bats in other parts of China have not been found to carry...." is misleading if viruses closer to SARS-CoV2 were found in Laos.


Wuhan Institute of Virology was the repository for bat viruses collected from _________?
Fill in the blank if you think it is just one area or one country.
🤔
 
Wuhan Institute of Virology was the repository for bat viruses collected from _________?
Fill in the blank if you think it is just one area or one country.
🤔

How many actual bat coronaviruses do you think they ever found?

China is the only country WIV searched for bat coronaviruses, and China being a large country, only a very small part of China.
 
It looks to me like the "lab leak hypothesis is a scientifically unfounded conspiracy theory" narrative is unraveling.

The subcommittee is now requesting the declassification of certain documents that they've been able to examine and which they claim indicate a Chinese cover-up of a lab leak origin. Is there a dissenting minority report from the Democrat members? I haven't heard of any.

Meanwhile the research effort to establish the natural origin of Covid-19 looks about as earnest, vigorous, and fruitful as O.J.'s search for the real killer.

A Republican led congressional subcommittee is not the best way to investigate a scientific issue in 2024.

Listen the recent episode of the TWIV podcast (This Week In Virology, linked to above by angrysoba) for a clear explanation about how they know it was not a lab leak, and what's wrong with the lab leak claims.
 
Last edited:
A Republican led congressional subcommittee is not the best way to investigate a scientific issue in 2024.

Listen the recent episode of the TWIV podcast (This Week In Virology, linked to above by angrysoba) for a clear explanation about how they know it was not a lab leak, and what's wrong with the lab leak claims.

I will just repeat something I have said a few times already. It's not conspiratorial per se to think that the virus began in a lab, and it is possible that some kind of lab incident did cause the pandemic. Because of this, I think it is too strong to state categorically that the pandemic began in nature.

That said, and again, to repeat, much of the arguments for a lab leak are either conspiracy theories, or unparsimonious, or both, with many of the conspiracy theories quickly relying on an ever-expanding cover-up across multiple entities in different countries, often relying on evidence that support different proposed routes for the pandemic to start, or even contradictory evidence. The lab leak theorists often appear to be agnostic or not even concerned how the virus leaked from a lab, or which lab it was supposed to have leaked from, whether any tampering of the virus occurred, whether the Chinese military were involved, whether it was simply caught in the wild and escaped as it was, or whether it was made more virulent, or more transmissable through serial passaging etc... the emails seem to be read as either confessions, or claims that they knew, but with the presumption that what they really thought was discussed outside of these Slack channels, emails etc...
 
I will just repeat something I have said a few times already. It's not conspiratorial per se to think that the virus began in a lab, and it is possible that some kind of lab incident did cause the pandemic. Because of this, I think it is too strong to state categorically that the pandemic began in nature.

That said, and again, to repeat, much of the arguments for a lab leak are either conspiracy theories, or unparsimonious, or both, with many of the conspiracy theories quickly relying on an ever-expanding cover-up across multiple entities in different countries, often relying on evidence that support different proposed routes for the pandemic to start, or even contradictory evidence. The lab leak theorists often appear to be agnostic or not even concerned how the virus leaked from a lab, or which lab it was supposed to have leaked from, whether any tampering of the virus occurred, whether the Chinese military were involved, whether it was simply caught in the wild and escaped as it was, or whether it was made more virulent, or more transmissable through serial passaging etc... the emails seem to be read as either confessions, or claims that they knew, but with the presumption that what they really thought was discussed outside of these Slack channels, emails etc...

I agree. It doesn't help the lab leak proponents when they argue for a conspiracy involving named scientists across many countries, we know there are extremists who believe that those involved are guilty of mass murder.

The simple case that an unknown virus infected a laboratory worker either through field work or handling material in a laboratory is possible but I feel not the most likely explanation. Any arguments that the virus was manipulated / synthesised in the laboratory is simply science fiction.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom