Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Here is an interesting point of view:

No matter how clever gene editors get, the chances that they could beat evolution at its own game and come up with the right combination of infectiousness, lethality and viability to spread a disease through the human race are vanishingly small. To do so in secret would be even harder.
 
I was going to ask for this post to be moved to the 'Origins of Covid' thread if you ignored my suggestion and put it here but, having now read it, I'm going to ask for it to be moved to the Covid Conspiracy thread instead. I don't know why I expected better, but I did.
PartSkeptic's wall of non-informative text was an evasion, upon being asked to provide evidence for his original unhinged claim about Fauci. Clearly a conspiracy theory.
PartSkeptic said:
Look at how Fauci was shown to have funded Wuhan and manufactured Covid, then lied to Congress and yet get lots of money and government perks.
 
Here's some fun. I haven't looked much into this recently because nothing new has happened.

BUT, this skeptic-minded guy debated with Yuri Deigin about the lab leak, and he bet 100,000 dollars that he could persuade two judges that the zoonotic origin is most likely.

He seems to give some succinct answers to the constellation of Lab Leak Truther Factoids that make up the various inconsistent and incoherent arguments.

He calls it a conspiracy in search of a theory.

Anyway, maybe you might want to watch or at least bookmark it if you hear any more of the Gish Gallops that pop up periodically.



The decision. Most likely zoonotic. I am not surprised. There is a huge effort to continue to muddy the waters by doing making such a video. The money most likely was already designated as going to the zoonotic argument who would simply decline to accept it. This is how propaganda works.

The reason. The (one) judge says both sides agreed that the outbreak occurred around the Wuhan food market. This is not what John Campbell says using the Publication issed by the US committee.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKwunTJ1b40&ab_channel=PeterMiller


Seems like I am forced :( to analyze the facts to date to rebut the current conspiracy theorists (:D those pushing the zoonotic origin).
I have not watched any of this 3 part hours long "debate". Have downloaded all the text and will skim that.
 
PartSkeptic's wall of non-informative text was an evasion, upon being asked to provide evidence for his original unhinged claim about Fauci. Clearly a conspiracy theory.
​


I pointed to a video that was fairly clear and based on a US committee paper. Here is the link in case you were too lazy to look it up.

https://www.help.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/report_an_analysis_of_the_origins_of_covid-19_102722.pdf

Did you even watch the video or read the report?

What points have subsequently proven to be wrong?

Why must I do all the work so you can just make snarky remarks because you are a supporter of the US coverup of this dreadful outbreak?

Did you watch Jeffery Sachs make quite clear that his committee supporting his first investigation did not declare their conflicts of interests and were actually blindsiding him? Did you? What points do you disagree with and why?

So much for the much-vaunted (now more an more discredited) scientific community. :eek:
 
Here is an interesting point of view:

No matter how clever gene editors get, the chances that they could beat evolution at its own game and come up with the right combination of infectiousness, lethality and viability to spread a disease through the human race are vanishingly small. To do so in secret would be even harder.


Wrong. It was just simple deduction. And then they got the tools to do it.

Imagine if they really let loose a complex virus and aerosolized ebola. :eek:
 
The facts are indisputable but no doubt I will have a lot of members telling me that it is not so.

So rather than waste my time listing the events and what is now known of the coverup I have listed the results of my searches.

There is still a lot of misinformation trying to say that the zoonotic theory is still plausible. It is not. Fauci is a liar and a perjurer and evil.

Take the file name and google it. You will get the source. The bold video by John Campbell was the most compelling.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EaJt5jC5gbY&ab_channel=Dr.JohnCampbell

One (or maybe more) of the videos by Jeffrey Sachs tells how the scientists he chose to assist in the first inquiries were all implicated in the coverup and did not disclose their interests in the matter. They all lied to him. Science it not the problem but modern scientists are.

Some key facts:
Fauci wrote a series of emails telling scientists that the lab leak theory was to be considered a conspiracy theory and hastily wrote a paper about the origins being zoonotic. Before that almost all scientists considered the lab leak the most plausible.
Now we know that 3 scientists at the lab were the first victims.
There is no intermediate host animal and no intermediate mutations.
Fauci led a gain of function research to manufacture the virus and they succeeded.
Fauci did not notify the relevant oversight agencies and it seems he had gotten rid of all documentation and notes.

<Snip>

Yo keep foisting John Campbell, an educator not a medical practitioner, on us despite a) he's not anywhere near being an expert and b) his assertions are all easily debunked lies.

Have you anything other than this charlatan and grifter?
 
Yo keep foisting John Campbell, an educator not a medical practitioner, on us despite a) he's not anywhere near being an expert and b) his assertions are all easily debunked lies.

Have you anything other than this charlatan and grifter?

For a sense of what PartSkeptic has or has not got, you can peruse his usual approach to scientific questions as documented in PartSkeptic's Thread for Matters of Interest Part III.

His recent contributions to this thread began with a post that was moved here from that thread. One of his earlier contributions to the "Origins of Covid" threads, telling us how God will protect His creation by allowing a "massive die-off" caused by some combination of a pandemic and cell phone towers, became the first post in PartSkeptic’s Thread for Predictions and Other Matters of Interest. That thread is located within the "Conspiracies and Conspiracy Theories" subforum, but its most recent continuation lives within the "Forum Community" subforum.
 
Last edited:
The decision. Most likely zoonotic. I am not surprised. There is a huge effort to continue to muddy the waters by doing making such a video. The money most likely was already designated as going to the zoonotic argument who would simply decline to accept it. This is how propaganda works.

The reason. The (one) judge says both sides agreed that the outbreak occurred around the Wuhan food market. This is not what John Campbell says using the Publication issed by the US committee.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKwunTJ1b40&ab_channel=PeterMiller


Seems like I am forced :( to analyze the facts to date to rebut the current conspiracy theorists (:D those pushing the zoonotic origin).
I have not watched any of this 3 part hours long "debate". Have downloaded all the text and will skim that.

This is a silly objection. The debate itself was organized by a lab leak proponent, Rootclaim. Here is how they responded to the debate itself...

And the winner of Rootclaim’s COVID-19 origins debate and the $100,000 prize is…

Unfortunately, not us :). We would like to explain this result, but first, we would like to congratulate our opponent and Rootclaim’s first challenger, Peter Miller. Miller showcased an impressive understanding of the details during the debate, which was hard to match.

While Peter’s victory was well earned within the parameters of the debate, we believe it was also due to our failure to structure an effective debate.

...

First, we’d like to clarify, that the judges did an amazing job, putting immense effort, thought, and talent into their decisions:

Will Van Treuren is a microbiologist and immunologist with a PhD from Stanford.

...

Eric Stansifer is an applied mathematician with a PhD in the Earth sciences from MIT. He has previously done research in a mathematical virology research group, doing simulations of MS2 capsid assembly.

Link

In other words, Rootclaim itself, while arguing for the lab leak, and having had no problems with the judges and how they made their decision, agree that they lost the debate fair and square as opposed to the frankly idiotic insistence that the debate must have been rigged as you, Part Skeptic, resort to out of cope.
 
In response to this quotation...

"No matter how clever gene editors get, the chances that they could beat evolution at its own game and come up with the right combination of infectiousness, lethality and viability to spread a disease through the human race are vanishingly small. To do so in secret would be even harder."

Part Skeptic (I am assuming it is a very small part), wrote...

Wrong. It was just simple deduction. And then they got the tools to do it.

Imagine if they really let loose a complex virus and aerosolized ebola. :eek:

But as part of Part Skeptic's Gish Gallop, we find a familiar name...

The facts are indisputable but no doubt I will have a lot of members telling me that it is not so.
...
= Viral The Origin of Covid 19 Matt Ridley EP 310.mp4


The author of these very lines, is indeed, Matt Ridley (from 2018!)

"No matter how clever gene editors get, the chances that they could beat evolution at its own game and come up with the right combination of infectiousness, lethality and viability to spread a disease through the human race are vanishingly small. To do so in secret would be even harder."

Link

I mean, Matt Ridley is pretty astute of course. He knows climate change is no biggie, and was partial to the idea that HIV did not cause AIDS. In fact, it looks like these ideas are being reintroduced by other lab leak people like that idiot Bret Weinstein. But maybe I am just poisoning the well now, so I'll stop.
 
Coincidentally this was recommended by YouTube to me this morning.

Watch Democrats Sit in Silence While Jim Jordan EXPOSES Fauci's LIES
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RRnCV1dYKY&ab_channel=TuyềnƠi

Seems like a slam-dunk to me.
Jim Jordan, isn't he the Trump sycophant who is trying to shut down anyone who shows this kind of disinformation to be the BS it is? Why yes, yes he is.

The longer this goes on, the worse it gets for Fauci.
Fauci is enjoying a well earned retirement. I see no reason that should change.
 
Coincidentally this was recommended by YouTube to me this morning.

Watch Democrats Sit in Silence While Jim Jordan EXPOSES Fauci's LIES
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0RRnCV1dYKY&ab_channel=TuyềnƠi

Seems like a slam-dunk to me.

The longer this goes on, the worse it gets for Fauci.

Why not acknowledge the points I made about the Rootclaim debate?

Also, maybe it will be worth your time to actually watch the debate. It might clear up some of your confusion, and you might be able to become a little more Skeptic.
 
I pointed to a video that was fairly clear and based on a US committee paper.
Full stop. I don't click youtube links unless the poster summarizes the salient points, and provides a time stamp to those salient points. That's my practice even when the source isn't a known nut job.
 
Let's wander over to Lab Leak Twitter and...whoah...

If Drs. Daszak, Baric, and Fauci are convicted and sentenced to death in US Military Tribunals, then what method of execution should they face?

Followed by a poll suggesting the following...

Lethal injection
Firing squad
Hanging
Gas chamber

Who would write such a thing?

Oh, Andrew Huff

I still haven't found out what amazing secrets he was privvy to and the way in which the Covid lab leak was blown open by his tell-all memoir.
 
Here's a (long) summary of of a 15 hour debate on the lab leak hypothesis and origins of covid that I found particularly enlightening on the details.

I think the video was posted upthread, but if you don't have the time to watch it the summary and discussion at the link is pretty good, and the piece has been read and agreed to be accurate by both parties in the debate.
 
Here's a (long) summary of of a 15 hour debate on the lab leak hypothesis and origins of covid that I found particularly enlightening on the details.

I think the video was posted upthread, but if you don't have the time to watch it the summary and discussion at the link is pretty good, and the piece has been read and agreed to be accurate by both parties in the debate.

Thanks for the link. Just scanned it so far but love the analytical/probablistic thinking. Need to spend more time to digest it.
 
Here's a (long) summary of of a 15 hour debate on the lab leak hypothesis and origins of covid that I found particularly enlightening on the details.

I think the video was posted upthread, but if you don't have the time to watch it the summary and discussion at the link is pretty good, and the piece has been read and agreed to be accurate by both parties in the debate.

Haven't watched it yet, (I intend to watch it tomorrow or shortly thereafter), but already the part I bolded from the above post has my confidence in the article on high suspicion alert.
 
Haven't watched it yet, (I intend to watch it tomorrow or shortly thereafter), but already the part I bolded from the above post has my confidence in the article on high suspicion alert.

Can you explain? It seems to me that the fact that the summary of events is seen as accurate by both parties is a good sign that it's actually accurate. You think that both sides agreeing that he's portrayed them fairly is a sign that he hasn't?

This doesn't mean that they agree with the writer's conclusions/opinions about the debate.
 
Last edited:
Can you explain? It seems to me that the fact that the summary of events is seen as accurate by both parties is a good sign that it's actually accurate. You think that both sides agreeing that he's portrayed them fairly is a sign that he hasn't?

I read that as SG saying “if they don’t end up agreeing with me they are wrong”.
 
I read that as SG saying “if they don’t end up agreeing with me they are wrong”.

I assumed that SG doubts that the debate was in good faith, which would be fair under certain circumstances. For example, if I saw Bret Weinstein saying he was going to debate his wife on lab leak, and that Bret Weinstein's brother was going to be a neutral judge, I would call foul on that. BUT...

It is pretty clear that Rootclaim (Saar Wilf) is being honest about favouring lab leak, and that he and Peter Miller were satisfied with the impartiality of the judges. The fact that Yuri Deigin was also involved on the side of the lab leak proponent also makes it pretty clear to me that this is not part of some "zoonati" plot. I also think that Scott Alexander of Astral Codex Ten is a pretty trustworthy source. In other words, I don't see any evidence of the debate being rigged as Part Skeptic ruled it to be without any evidence.

Some people just have knee-jerk opposition to anything that doesn't favour their pre-conceived conclusions. It's also one of the dangers of going down the conspiracy theory rabbit hole. When confronted with reasons or evidence that destroys or at least damages a position you might hold, to simply see this is as evidence for of a larger conspiracy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom