Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Take the file name and google it. You will get the source. The bold video by John Campbell was the most compelling.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EaJt5jC5gbY&ab_channel=Dr.JohnCampbell

John Campbell is a complete quack. He is about as much of a good source for information on Covid as Alex Jones.

Anyway, I was not sure about bothering to post this, but recently a survey of actual experts (not John bloody Campbell), asked virologists, epidemiologists and biosafety experts their opinions on whether the virus was zoonotic in origin or had escaped from a lab.

They largely had the opinion that it was zoonotic.

Link

Most experts believe that COVID-19 was very likely to
arise from a natural zoonosis, but experts also see at
least some chance of a research-related accident.

When asked how likely it is that COVID-19 originated from
natural zoonosis, experts gave an average likelihood of
77% (median=90%). In fact, four out of five experts stated
that a natural zoonotic origin was more than 50% likely.
However, consensus was not complete. Across all experts,
the average likelihood they gave for a research-related
accident origin was 21%. Overall, one out of five experts
reported a 50% or greater chance for an origin other than
natural zoonosis.

So why it is that some lay people can assert with such overwhelming confidence that Covid definitely escaped from a lab, I don't know.
 
The post belongs in the science subforum. Cherry picking a name or two as has been a common occurrence in this thread does not mean all the details in PartSkeptic's post are reflective of a CT.

There might be some disputable facts like that Fauci was involved in the accidental development of the virus with his own gain of function research. There is no evidence of that. Given his initial emails to his colleagues that just doesn't fit.

Fauci's quick switch to ruling out the lab origin along with the WHO chief telling the first investigative team that they ruled out the lab origin before any evidence was collected provides very strong suggestion it wasn't politically correct to go down the lab leak rabbit hole. And the evidence points squarely toward Peter Daszak as the initial source of the coverup and of being directly involved in the lab origin itself, followed by Dr Shi as the other person most directly involved.

I need a little time to go through PartSkeptic's post. Of course his facts need checking. But there was plenty of evidence of Fauci's quick reversal of his email at the beginning of the pandemic, corroborated by Tedros' (WHO) position that Daszak had manipulated the first team to investigate COVID's origin into declaring the lab leak was ruled out when in no way, shape or form had that been evidence supported.
 
Last edited:
I was going to ask for this post to be moved to the 'Origins of Covid' thread if you ignored my suggestion and put it here but, having now read it, I'm going to ask for it to be moved to the Covid Conspiracy thread instead. I don't know why I expected better, but I did.
Maybe because there is a lot of evidence COVID did originate in one of the labs at the WIV.
 
And the evidence points squarely toward Peter Daszak as the initial source of the coverup and of being directly involved in the lab origin itself, followed by Dr Shi as the other person most directly involved.

This is not true. Why would all the world's virologists decide to jump to Peter Daszak's tune?

There is another possibility, which you seem to rule out, that the virologists who looked into it came to the conclusion that it was a zoonotic origin through good-faith investigation, not because they are compromised or lying.
 
Maybe because there is a lot of evidence COVID did originate in one of the labs at the WIV.

My impression from following this thread (I'm not knowledgeable enough to contribute) is that a lab leak cannot be ruled out but a zoonotic one seems more likely, whilst deliberate engineering can be ruled out with a reasonable degree of certainty.

When PartSkeptic posted this in his dedicated thread:

Moving on to this topic, namely that Fauci funded the Wuhan lab research into gain of function, the lab made Covid and it escaped from the lab. (I know there are others which I will get to, but this one is easy.)

I will gather the evidence and present it to you.

I expected him to actually make the case, rather than post an unsupported Gish Gallop.
 
My impression from following this thread (I'm not knowledgeable enough to contribute) is that a lab leak cannot be ruled out but a zoonotic one seems more likely, whilst deliberate engineering can be ruled out with a reasonable degree of certainty.

My take is that, yes, a lab leak cannot be ruled out, but when trying to make a plausible coherent argument for it, it necessarily spirals into more and more implausible events occurring and bigger and bigger cover-ups that it just starts to sound like a CT.

It also seems to require, or at least nod towards, completely incompatible theories.

Much of the "evidence" centred on different labs. When trying to pin down a lab leak theorist on which lab it actually came out of, they don't seem to be that fussed. They will talk about the WIV BSL-4 lab as being the big coincidence, but then will get animated at research done at BSL-2, or even an unrelated lab run by the Wuhan CDC. If all else fails they will claim it was caught in the wild and brought back to Wuhan by accident.

In short, I don't think they really have a coherent theory so it comes across as similar to the 9/11 theories where any old rationale will do even if it doesn't fit together.

This is not to say that one of the theories cannot be correct. But I think zoonosis is more parsimonious given that it came from a wet market, which was the most likely nexus that even the Chinese government appeared to believe was the case by their actions. It is sometimes countered that the only reason why so many cases were found at the wet market was because that was where they were looking. Well, if that's the case, why do you think they thought that? It seems evidence on the surface that that is what they believed. Lab leakers may claim that this is merely the government story (in a similar way to how 9/11 Truthers talk about the government story), but in fact the Chinese government's official line on this is that the virus came from outside China.

Anyway, I am of course just rehashing the whole thing again, so I won't go any further into it right now.
 
My note is that those pushing the 'lab leak' are actually pushing it because they are pretending that the virus was human made.

There is no evidence that the virus has been manipulated in any way by any lab.

It also seems to be a cover for "all chinks are evil" and other racist clap trap.

Local authorities turning a blind eye to shoddy practices in a market is believable.

The lab leak stuff is just CT.

Even if it was true, so what?
 
The lab leak stuff is just CT.

Even if it was true, so what?


Clearly, there is no useful information that could come from knowledge that government-funded virus research could cause a pandemic. It would provide no input into future risk-benefit analyses of research proposals, or information on safety standards for laboratories.
 
My note is that those pushing the 'lab leak' are actually pushing it because they are pretending that the virus was human made.

There is no evidence that the virus has been manipulated in any way by any lab.

It also seems to be a cover for "all chinks are evil" and other racist clap trap.
Local authorities turning a blind eye to shoddy practices in a market is believable.

The lab leak stuff is just CT.

Even if it was true, so what?

The highlighted is not the argument for a lab leak.

I think I have been as critical as anyone about the lab leak, but I don't see this as a useful argument to counter it at all. It's equivalent to saying, "You think that because you are bad people!"

Besides, if you make that a premise of your argument against the lab leak, you would end up having to assent to a racist idea if, somehow, the virus did leak from a lab, which presumably, logically, is possible.

As for the final question, if it was true, so what? The so would be how to prevent such a thing happening again. At this point it would be even more serious given that most virologists have staked their reputations on the claim that it was most likely zoonotic. They would look a bit silly if they turned out to be wrong. And of course, if it was lab-origin, then it would indeed implicate a lot of people. Some form of justice would indeed be required.

If the converse is true, then the issues are one of how to prevent future spillovers. This requires managing the ecosystem, living with bats and other mammals, and cleaning up the wildlife trade.

Of course, these courses of action don't necessarily have to be mutually exclusive.
 
This is not true. Why would all the world's virologists decide to jump to Peter Daszak's tune?

There is another possibility, which you seem to rule out, that the virologists who looked into it came to the conclusion that it was a zoonotic origin through good-faith investigation, not because they are compromised or lying.

All the world's virologists? The virologists who looked into it? :rolleyes:

We've been through this before, no sense repeating the same stuff. All the world's virologists including all the virologists you claim looked into the origin of COVID do NOT support your POV even though you keep imagining they do.
 
My impression from following this thread (I'm not knowledgeable enough to contribute) is that a lab leak cannot be ruled out but a zoonotic one seems more likely, whilst deliberate engineering can be ruled out with a reasonable degree of certainty.
If the zoonotic origin were likely then the intermediate species and a trail would have been found long before now. Yet neither have been found.

When PartSkeptic posted this in his dedicated thread:

I expected him to actually make the case, rather than post an unsupported Gish Gallop.
Why is a list of evidence brushed off as a gish gallop?

I'll withhold my conclusion about PartSkeptic's list until I've had time to look at his list.
 
Last edited:
This is not true. Why would all the world's virologists decide to jump to Peter Daszak's tune?

There is another possibility, which you seem to rule out, that the virologists who looked into it came to the conclusion that it was a zoonotic origin through good-faith investigation, not because they are compromised or lying.

How many of these virologists were well-versed in gain-of-function no-see-um Baric/Shi technology applied to mammalian bat corona viruses and tested on humanized mice?

Because that is what they were confirmed to be doing in Wuhan. Confirmed. And in all the world, that is where a new corona virus, contagious to humans escaped. It isn't near where those bats lived.

For the 'experts' and officials and other scientists to discount the mere possibility, within days of getting a 'select' team together--- is idiocy. But that is what they did. And some, seeing the seniority, went along. And we now know much more about the motivations. Much more. And it all makes perfect sense where it was a bit puzzling as to why they would cover for China before.

But keep towing that 'spillover' line. It makes zero sense. It has zero evidence.
 
Last edited:
My note is that those pushing the 'lab leak' are actually pushing it because they are pretending that the virus was human made.
WTF?

There is no evidence that the virus has been manipulated in any way by any lab.
This is not true. This thread is full of very specific evidence how gain of function research manipulated existing coronaviruses to end up with COVID. The same cannot be said for a natural evolution of a coronavirus except to note the pieces are all there. But it leaves the problem that no evidence those pieces came together anywhere in the wild exists.

It also seems to be a cover for "all chinks are evil" and other racist clap trap.
"Chinks"? Is that Aussie for Chinese? I have no issue with the Chinese.

Local authorities turning a blind eye to shoddy practices in a market is believable.
Yes, undoubtably.

The lab leak stuff is just CT.
This is the opinion of people who have little knowledge about microbiology and infectious disease. If you think it's all CT stuff then how do you support that conclusion when the evidence of a 'spillover' event amounts to some holding the opinion spillovers are more common? That's it, that's the whole body of evidence. Lab leaks have been documented in this thread including some that resulted in outbreaks.

Even if it was true, so what?
Is this a serious question?
 
If the zoonotic origin were likely then the intermediate species and a trail would have been found long before now. Yet neither have been found.
Having followed the previous discussion on that point I still don't see how it follows, but as I say I'm not particularly knowledgeable in this area.

Why is a list of evidence brushed off as a gish gallop?

I'll withhold my conclusion about PartSkeptic's list until I've had time to look at his list.

I look forward to it.

Incidentally this was PartSkeptic's response to my suggestion that he put his Covid research post here:

No need to. This forum is not skeptical. It is about sowing the message of the elites who wish to control the masses.

It is an indication of the many false beliefs held by the members posting on this thread that they think that the origin of Covid was anything else but a lab leak.

I wonder. Does JayUtah get funding from Fauci? And pay some of you to support him? :rolleyes: (Note: I am not really serious but the world is so screwed up I am no longr shocked by the extent of the rot.)

I'll be interested to see how he responds to the lively - and informed - discussion here.
 
All the world's virologists? The virologists who looked into it? :rolleyes:

We've been through this before, no sense repeating the same stuff. All the world's virologists including all the virologists you claim looked into the origin of COVID do NOT support your POV even though you keep imagining they do.

How many of these virologists were well-versed in gain-of-function no-see-um Baric/Shi technology applied to mammalian bat corona viruses and tested on humanized mice?

Because that is what they were confirmed to be doing in Wuhan. Confirmed. And in all the world, that is where a new corona virus, contagious to humans escaped. It isn't near where those bats lived.

For the 'experts' and officials and other scientists to discount the mere possibility, within days of getting a 'select' team together--- is idiocy. But that is what they did. And some, seeing the seniority, went along. And we now know much more about the motivations. Much more. And it all makes perfect sense where it was a bit puzzling as to why they would cover for China before.

But keep towing that 'spillover' line. It makes zero sense. It has zero evidence.

I've already posted here that virologists and epidemiologists as well as biosafety experts who were surveyed here, favour the zoonosis by a clear majority.

You can dismiss them all as being stupid or corrupt if you like, but if you do I would say you are the ones with motivated reasoning. There was a time when you were open-minded on these topics but you both now assert with far too much confidence what you believe as though it had been proven.

Link

As for the claim that the "select" scientists were somehow browbeaten into believing in the zoonosis, you would have to explain why it is that they went back and forth. If you look at the reasoning that came out of the Slack channel leaks rather than focusing on specific wording that you find most incriminating, then you can see that this was not a case of being offered money, fame, power etc, but was entirely in keeping with the scientific method.

Link
 
My note is that those pushing the 'lab leak' are actually pushing it because they are pretending that the virus was human made.

There is no evidence that the virus has been manipulated in any way by any lab.

It also seems to be a cover for "all chinks are evil" and other racist clap trap.

Local authorities turning a blind eye to shoddy practices in a market is believable.

The lab leak stuff is just CT.

Even if it was true, so what?

When a smallpox or a flu virus has leaked....or when the original SARS virus leaked--from scientists who had them 'secured' to be studied....was it due to human manipulation of that virus? Were they altered? Maybe. Didnt need to be. Other viruses have infected researchers by developing on their own due to natural events expedited by lab conditions.

Can we think a bit less narrow about what a leak means? Or what it means to have come about due to the work at the lab? Or whether it is intentional? I happen to think now that it was a manipulation, but that would be actually a new type of leak.

Most leaks in history were NOT novel. But they do happen. And it isn't even a rare thing.
Oh, and guess what? The premiere, internationally recognized place with a lead scientist called 'bat woman' that held many of these types of infectious bat viruses- that had killed miners in the very same cave as the closest relative to this cov-2 virus- and had researchers trying to make them infectious to hmans to develop a vaccine in case it escaped- was in ...hhmmm wait, where was it?....wait for it. Thinking.
...thiiiinnnkkiingggg. Got it. It was-


...Wuhan!!

Amazing, isnt it?

Maybe there really are bots and paid shills on here. People really cannot be this dense after seeing what is presented.
 
Last edited:
If the zoonotic origin were likely then the intermediate species and a trail would have been found long before now. Yet neither have been found.

This is an unsupported assertion. You keep repeating this but there is no reason to think this must be the case.

Why is a list of evidence brushed off as a gish gallop?
I'll withhold my conclusion about PartSkeptic's list until I've had time to look at his list.

I think "list of evidence" is a dubious description of that infodump.

Napolitano, Jeffrey Sachs, John Campbell, Michael Shellenberger, Rand Paul... quack, quack, quack, quack, quack!
 
Last edited:
I think "list of evidence" is a dubious description of that infodump.

Napolitano, Jeffrey Sachs, John Campbell, Michael Shellenberger, Rand Paul... quack, quack, quack, quack, quack!
I must admit it was the reference to the John Campbell video as being "the most compelling" that made me consider the post an unworthy contribution to this serious thread, as I've checked out his stuff in the past and he's one of the worst sources of Covid disinformation on the net. But it's possible I dismissed the rest of it too cavalierly as also being the usual CT stuff, i.e. a few carefully cherry picked facts, their significance exaggerated out of all proportion, and then used to support unwarranted conclusions and wild speculation.
 
I must admit it was the reference to the John Campbell video as being "the most compelling" that made me consider the post an unworthy contribution to this serious thread, as I've checked out his stuff in the past and he's one of the worst sources of Covid disinformation on the net. But it's possible I dismissed the rest of it too cavalierly as also being the usual CT stuff, i.e. a few carefully cherry picked facts, their significance exaggerated out of all proportion, and then used to support unwarranted conclusions and wild speculation.

Yes, in my view it is a good heuristic that if someone is giddily brandishing a John Campbell video as evidence, then they might not be the best evaluator of evidence.

It was clear from fairly early on that John Campbell was tailoring his videos to the most credulous audience with his promotion of ivermectin, his insistence, initially that Covid vaccines had to be aspirated, then that they were useless or dangerous, and now he has moved onto claims that Covid vaccines create huge clots in the veins and arteries of those who received the mRNA vaccine. All of this is complete nonsense and just a rehash of garbage InfoWars-style documentary Died Suddenly, often using stock footage of autopsies taken from long before the pandemic as evidence of the dangers of the mRNA vaccines.
 
Here's some fun. I haven't looked much into this recently because nothing new has happened.

BUT, this skeptic-minded guy debated with Yuri Deigin about the lab leak, and he bet 100,000 dollars that he could persuade two judges that the zoonotic origin is most likely.

He seems to give some succinct answers to the constellation of Lab Leak Truther Factoids that make up the various inconsistent and incoherent arguments.

He calls it a conspiracy in search of a theory.

Anyway, maybe you might want to watch or at least bookmark it if you hear any more of the Gish Gallops that pop up periodically.

 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom