Interesting but blatantly biased.
Just listen to the language he uses.
He claims there is lots of evidence for "one" hypothesis and "none" for the hypothesis now shifting to popular preference. It wasn't hard to guess where he was going with that.
He leaves out the evidence for a lab leak except where he counters it when he does mention it. It's the opposite when he fails to note the criticisms of the spillover hypothesis except for a few times and with those he counters the criticisms.
Fauci et al changing their minds only weeks after their discussions about the lab leak was supposedly because finding the furin cleavage site changed their minds. Quammen does note all the places the FCS is found in bats and in the pangolin and he notes it would have to have been a recombination event to account for finding it in a SARS-like CoV. That's fine but
it still leaves out gaps such as proximity to the cave horseshoe bats are found.
He calls the lab leak hypothesis "not plausible" and "lurid". He wasn't quoting anyone.
He called serial passages "far-fetched" when it is a well documented lab technique.
Quammen notes that people start out with their preferred biases then stick with those. Later he goes on to describe all his previous work reporting on spillovers. He makes a brief mention of lab accidents but
never once says that he might be biased toward spillover hypothesis.
He wrote the book, "
Spillover: Animal Infections and the Next Human Pandemic (2012)". We discussed that here already.
He describes evidence for the spillover to be based on published science and evidence of the lab leak to be based on news accounts and non-science reporting. The guy himself is a science
reporter for heaven's sake. From
Wiki:
During his graduate studies at Oxford, he studied literature, concentrating on the works of William Faulkner.
He didn't get a graduate degree:
Yale University (B.A., 1970)
University of Oxford (B.Litt., English, 1973)[1]
He did graduate work but I can't find where he ever got a graduate degree.
I'm not saying the guy is unqualified to report on science events/research. Obviously he's well qualified. I point out his background because he disses his peers that support the lab leak hypothesis without noting he has no claim to being a scientist either.
He claims the 2 lineages are evidence of two spillover events without addressing the genetic scientist, Quay, who said with only 3 nucleotides different it looks to him that the B lineage came from the A lineage. Given how fast the virus evolves it should have at least been mentioned.
Quammen notes the WIV is 7 miles from the seafood market as if that is evidence COVID couldn't have started at the WIV. That's ludicrous unless he thinks it's some walled off isolated research center.
He describes Worobey as a hero, investigating the HIV origin when people were saying it came from poliovirus vaccine research and proving that was not the source. The polio vaccine hypothesis was never taken seriously by the medical community. It was always considered a far-fetched CT with no supporting evidence. (This is not meant to disrespect Worobey's HIV study.)
Noting Worobey's study of cases connected to the market, Quammen doesn't put 2 & 2 together that there were 1/3 of the cases left out of Worobey's case mapping.
Quammen never once mentions the market was evidence of a super spreader event. And when he brings up the release of the surface sampling at the market he fails to mention there was not enough virus in the stall sample where raccoon dog DNA was found to suggest the dog was the source rather than contamination by an infected human being more likely.
He does note re being adapted to humans at first contact that the virus was well adapted to other animals as well.
The begs the question then why haven't dozens of species been infected before humans were?
He notes how long it took to find the origin of lots of viruses including SARS but
fails to mention the intermediate species have in many cases been found within weeks to months.
He notes the work by Shi published on SARS CoVs in 2018 with no genomes close to COVID. He concludes had Shi found a virus with the FCS she would have published it therefore she didn't find it. Evidence of absence ...
He didn't mention Daszak noting in an interview in Dec 2019 how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab and that they were working on finding a universal vaccine before a spillover event occurred. That is a critical piece of evidence.
Quammen noted the proposal for funds for the above research was denied without mentioning Shi had other sources for funds.
In the end Quammen spends a few minutes telling us about all the CTs, including Jon Stewart's piece on the Colbert Show.
Things not mentioned in addition to leaving out the Daszak interview:
Live bats were kept at the lab. Shi claimed that wasn't true but the evidence said it was and she was caught in a lie.
He didn't mention Daszak manipulating the letter to the Lancet being slanted to say the lab leak hypothesis was a CT. And there was no mention of the WHO team investigating the WIV also being manipulated by Daszak, including Tedros from the WHO criticizing the report as dismissing the lab leak hypothesis without any investigation. For a year researchers who suggested the lab source were ostracized so they were reluctant do it.
Quammen does say in the end there was no proof of either hypothesis. That doesn't change how biases this podcast is.
I've left stuff out that is evidence for the lableak because Quammen doesn't address a lot of things.
People should listen to the podcast but with a ear for the biased language Quammen uses.