Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Hu was the principle investigator ON THAT PAPER. You denied he was involved at all. I posted evidence he was very much involved.


Yes HIV backbone as I wrote. Are you ever embarrassed by these confirmation biased mistakes? You would do yourself a favor to read the beginning of the thread. It was discussed there.

Evolutionary Arms Race between Virus and Host Drives Genetic Diversity in Bat Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome-Related Coronavirus Spike Genes
Shi is an author on this paper. She worked directly with Baric on these chimeras though this paper is from Sept 2020 and by that time Shi was no longer working with Baric.

Arguing what is and isn't GoF is moot and a sidetrack, just like fussing over whether Hu was one of 3 patient zeros. SARS CoV2 has gained the function of being significantly more infectious. Changes in the RBS is one key difference. Where that came from can be addressed without the sidetrack of what is and isn't GoF research. [... Which has been addressed so I'm not ceding the argument, it's time to move on.]

For SARS-CoV, we used the pseudotyped virus carrying the S protein of strain BJ01 with HIV backbone,

Since a pseudotyped virus is non-functional this can never be gain of function research; this is the specific reason pseudotyped viruses are used. i previously referenced a review addressing this.

Current status on the development of pseudoviruses for enveloped viruses
Emerging and reemerging infectious diseases have a strong negative impact on public health. However, because many of these pathogens must be handled in biosafety level, 3 or 4 containment laboratories, research and development of antivirals or vaccines against these diseases are often impeded. Alternative approaches to address this issue have been vigorously pursued, particularly the use of pseudoviruses in place of wild‐type viruses. As pseudoviruses have been deprived of certain gene sequences of the virulent virus, they can be handled in biosafety level 2 laboratories. Importantly, the envelopes of these viral particles may have similar conformational structures to those of the wild‐type viruses, making it feasible to conduct mechanistic investigation on viral entry and to evaluate potential neutralizing antibodies. However, a variety of challenging issues remain, including the production of a sufficient pseudovirus yield and the inability to produce an appropriate pseudotype of certain viruses. This review discusses current progress in the development of pseudoviruses and dissects the factors that contribute to low viral yields
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7169153/
 

Interesting but blatantly biased. Just listen to the language he uses.

He claims there is lots of evidence for "one" hypothesis and "none" for the hypothesis now shifting to popular preference. It wasn't hard to guess where he was going with that.

He leaves out the evidence for a lab leak except where he counters it when he does mention it. It's the opposite when he fails to note the criticisms of the spillover hypothesis except for a few times and with those he counters the criticisms.

Fauci et al changing their minds only weeks after their discussions about the lab leak was supposedly because finding the furin cleavage site changed their minds. Quammen does note all the places the FCS is found in bats and in the pangolin and he notes it would have to have been a recombination event to account for finding it in a SARS-like CoV. That's fine but it still leaves out gaps such as proximity to the cave horseshoe bats are found.

He calls the lab leak hypothesis "not plausible" and "lurid". He wasn't quoting anyone. He called serial passages "far-fetched" when it is a well documented lab technique.

Quammen notes that people start out with their preferred biases then stick with those. Later he goes on to describe all his previous work reporting on spillovers. He makes a brief mention of lab accidents but never once says that he might be biased toward spillover hypothesis.

He wrote the book, "Spillover: Animal Infections and the Next Human Pandemic (2012)". We discussed that here already.

He describes evidence for the spillover to be based on published science and evidence of the lab leak to be based on news accounts and non-science reporting. The guy himself is a science reporter for heaven's sake. From Wiki:
During his graduate studies at Oxford, he studied literature, concentrating on the works of William Faulkner.
He didn't get a graduate degree:
Yale University (B.A., 1970)
University of Oxford (B.Litt., English, 1973)[1]
He did graduate work but I can't find where he ever got a graduate degree.

I'm not saying the guy is unqualified to report on science events/research. Obviously he's well qualified. I point out his background because he disses his peers that support the lab leak hypothesis without noting he has no claim to being a scientist either.

He claims the 2 lineages are evidence of two spillover events without addressing the genetic scientist, Quay, who said with only 3 nucleotides different it looks to him that the B lineage came from the A lineage. Given how fast the virus evolves it should have at least been mentioned.

Quammen notes the WIV is 7 miles from the seafood market as if that is evidence COVID couldn't have started at the WIV. That's ludicrous unless he thinks it's some walled off isolated research center.

He describes Worobey as a hero, investigating the HIV origin when people were saying it came from poliovirus vaccine research and proving that was not the source. The polio vaccine hypothesis was never taken seriously by the medical community. It was always considered a far-fetched CT with no supporting evidence. (This is not meant to disrespect Worobey's HIV study.)

Noting Worobey's study of cases connected to the market, Quammen doesn't put 2 & 2 together that there were 1/3 of the cases left out of Worobey's case mapping.

Quammen never once mentions the market was evidence of a super spreader event. And when he brings up the release of the surface sampling at the market he fails to mention there was not enough virus in the stall sample where raccoon dog DNA was found to suggest the dog was the source rather than contamination by an infected human being more likely.

He does note re being adapted to humans at first contact that the virus was well adapted to other animals as well. The begs the question then why haven't dozens of species been infected before humans were?

He notes how long it took to find the origin of lots of viruses including SARS but fails to mention the intermediate species have in many cases been found within weeks to months.

He notes the work by Shi published on SARS CoVs in 2018 with no genomes close to COVID. He concludes had Shi found a virus with the FCS she would have published it therefore she didn't find it. Evidence of absence ...

He didn't mention Daszak noting in an interview in Dec 2019 how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab and that they were working on finding a universal vaccine before a spillover event occurred. That is a critical piece of evidence.

Quammen noted the proposal for funds for the above research was denied without mentioning Shi had other sources for funds.

In the end Quammen spends a few minutes telling us about all the CTs, including Jon Stewart's piece on the Colbert Show.

Things not mentioned in addition to leaving out the Daszak interview:

Live bats were kept at the lab. Shi claimed that wasn't true but the evidence said it was and she was caught in a lie.

He didn't mention Daszak manipulating the letter to the Lancet being slanted to say the lab leak hypothesis was a CT. And there was no mention of the WHO team investigating the WIV also being manipulated by Daszak, including Tedros from the WHO criticizing the report as dismissing the lab leak hypothesis without any investigation. For a year researchers who suggested the lab source were ostracized so they were reluctant do it.

Quammen does say in the end there was no proof of either hypothesis. That doesn't change how biases this podcast is.

I've left stuff out that is evidence for the lableak because Quammen doesn't address a lot of things. People should listen to the podcast but with a ear for the biased language Quammen uses.
 
Last edited:
Re the cables as a source for the 3 ill workers, good grief had anyone spent as much time as they did trying to find a gotcha they might have found the actual source.

Yes, OMG SG thought an embassy cable to the State Dept was the source when it turns out there was an unnamed person from a foreign country that was the source.

I can't find the source that said who gave the info to the state department but I'll keep looking. In the meantime:
Not a bombshell; Fact Check
Sometimes it’s specified that all worked on gain-of-function research, or all in the same lab, but other times not. Sometimes they are sick in November 2019; in other versions, it’s October. The illnesses are variously described as respiratory illnesses or consistent with COVID-19, but sometimes include details that could be more diagnostic of COVID-19, such as patients losing their senses of smell and having ground-glass opacities in their lungs. Some versions say the workers were hospitalized or visited a hospital for their symptoms, while others do not. And some add other unsubstantiated details, such as a relative of a worker dying or there being body bags outside of the WIV and the workers having gone missing.

The provenance of all these claims is unclear, but a couple of former Trump officials consistently pop up as providing information to journalists, including David Asher, a former State Department adviser, and John Ratcliffe, the former director of National Intelligence.

Although Asher has sometimes referred to foreign sources, neither he nor others have explained exactly what these sources — who may or may not be credible — have said. Nor has any evidence of the rumors been provided.
This bit of evidence or not evidence hardly makes the case one way or the other and I've said that repeatedly.
 
Last edited:
Re the cables as a source for the 3 ill workers, good grief had anyone spent as much time as they did trying to find a gotcha they might have found the actual source.

It is unlikely that anyone would have found the source given that your own link that you have quoted from says:

The provenance of all these claims is unclear, but a couple of former Trump officials consistently pop up as providing information to journalists, including David Asher, a former State Department adviser, and John Ratcliffe, the former director of National Intelligence.​

Precisely! This is precisely what I have been telling you over and over again.

The reason why I have apparently been spending so much energy (actually a very frustrating time) repeating the very same information that you have belatedly accepted, is because YOU were the one who insisted the provenance was known.

Not only did you insist it was known but YOU expended a lot of energy insisting that this was established fact and that you had posted links stating that the information was in a cable. You insisted to me that you had linked to these cables as well. And you insisted you had done so multiple times.

Then there is this bit...

a couple of former Trump officials consistently pop up as providing information to journalists, including David Asher, a former State Department adviser, and John Ratcliffe, the former director of National Intelligence.​

This is what I have been telling you!

And it was YOU who tried to play gotcha when I posted links to examples of David Asher doing exactly this, such as a link to the Daily Mail.

The attempted gotcha of yours was the idea that my linking to the Daily Mail was some kind of hilarious hypocrisy given that I had criticized you for relying on low-quality sources for much of your information. You completely misunderstood the point which was that this was an example of David Asher spreading information about sick WIV workers through the very same low quality sources of information that you rely on for your lab leak information.

Again, I have no idea if there were or were not sick WIV workers, but there is almost nothing that we have heard about it that has a reliable chain of information. If anything, we have intelligence services saying they put no stock in the information.

So, shall we let this one go now?
 
Tl;dr though I did skim it to see if you addressed anything else.

Why are you wasting so much effort on the 3 ill workers? Seriously, it's trivial given it's not proven.

I let it go pages ago.
 
Tl;dr though I did skim it to see if you addressed anything else.

Why are you wasting so much effort on the 3 ill workers? Seriously, it's trivial given it's not proven.

I let it go pages ago.

No, you did not.

You pop up every now and again to imply that everyone else who asks about your sources are the ones with the problem.
 
He describes evidence for the spillover to be based on published science and evidence of the lab leak to be based on news accounts and non-science reporting. The guy himself is a science reporter for heaven's sake. From Wiki: He didn't get a graduate degree: He did graduate work but I can't find where he ever got a graduate degree.
I'm not saying the guy is unqualified to report on science events/research. Obviously he's well qualified. I point out his background because he disses his peers that support the lab leak hypothesis without noting he has no claim to being a scientist either]

An Oxford B.Lltt degree is a post graduate degree, it is either a year study post MA (which in Oxford is an undergraduate degree!) or award for a failed DPhil. Yes Oxford is odd, people get an MA then do a bachelors degree e.g. BCL as a post graduate degree. MA and B.Litt can be in any subject including STEM.
 
Last edited:
He does note re being adapted to humans at first contact that the virus was well adapted to other animals as well. The begs the question then why haven't dozens of species been infected before humans were?

He notes how long it took to find the origin of lots of viruses including SARS but fails to mention the intermediate species have in many cases been found within weeks to months.

Do you have any evidence for the claim that 'in many cases intermediate species have been found within weeks or months'?
 
An Oxford B.Lltt degree is a post graduate degree, it is either a year study post MA (which in Oxford is an undergraduate degree!) or award for a failed DPhil. Yes Oxford is odd, people get an MA then do a bachelors degree e.g. BCL as a post graduate degree. MA and B.Litt can be in any subject including STEM.
Yale is in the US and Wiki says it was a BA degree.

During his graduate studies at Oxford, he studied literature, concentrating on the works of William Faulkner. After the completion of his education and the publication of his first novel, he relocated to Bozeman, Montana, where he currently lives with his wife, Betsy Gaines Quammen.[4]
If he had done research or gotten a degree in any STEM field I'm sure his bio would have said so.

It's moot anyway, I've not questioned his qualifications, I question his blindness to his own biases while discounting valid sources of evidence calling them news accounts and non-science reporting.

His degree or degrees were in literature, not in science. I was merely pointing out he discounted anything that was actually evidence of a lab leak because the sources weren't scientists. And he ignored sources of actual evidence like the corroborating evidence there were live bats at the WIV, and the missing data Worobey ignored, and Daszak's own words they were manipulating coronaviruses in the lab, and Daszak's efforts to slant the WHO investigation, and calling serial passages "far-fetched" when it is a well documented lab technique and so on and so on. I'm not going over this **** again.

I replied to the podcast Puppycow linked to. You got something new, post it.

Quammen also has a poor understanding that HIV coming from polio vaccine research was always an absurd CT. It was never taken seriously in the medical community.

Quammen was convinced up front COVID was a spillover because he's been looking at spillover events for years. And that's all he looked at re COVID origins, just like the prosecutor that hones in on one suspect early on overlooking evidence of other suspects.

Smart guy, heavily biased POV.
 
Yale is in the US and Wiki says it was a BA degree.
Yes, he did complete a BA at Yale University. Completing a BA at Yale University does not make someone ineligible for graduate study at some other university.

According to Encyclopedia.com, with my highlighting:
Education: Yale University, B.A., 1970; Merton College, Oxford University, B.Litt., 1973 .​
 
Yes, he did complete a BA at Yale University. Completing a BA at Yale University does not make someone ineligible for graduate study at some other university.
:rolleyes:

Who said it did? What a bizarre statement.


I was responding to the person who wrote this:
An Oxford B.Lltt degree is a post graduate degree, it is either a year study post MA (which in Oxford is an undergraduate degree!) or award for a failed DPhil. Yes Oxford is odd, people get an MA then do a bachelors degree e.g. BCL as a post graduate degree. MA and B.Litt can be in any subject including STEM.
Yale is in the US and Wiki says it was a BA degree.


ETA: I would assume the person who wrote that thought it was important to point out that Quammen's undergraduate degree was from Yale rather than Oxford, and was a BA rather than Oxford's MA. Lest somebody misinterpret Skeptic Ginger's remark as denial of the fact that Quammen's graduate degree is a B.Litt from Oxford, I pointed out that it is possible for someone to earn an undergraduate degree from one university and a graduate degree from another. (It might seem silly to remark upon something so obvious, but this is a thread in which it has been necessary to remark upon many things that are even more obvious, such as the fact that a cable sent in 2018 cannot be evidence for something that allegedly happened in 2019.)
 
Last edited:
Quammen also has a poor understanding that HIV coming from polio vaccine research was always an absurd CT. It was never taken seriously in the medical community.

This is ironic.

At the time, almost the same kinds of claims were made about the OPV theory as they are today about lab leak of Covid.

If you said, for example, that the claims were fringe and few in the medical and scientific establishment took it seriously, and that only non-scientific publications were writing about it, no doubt you would get people arguing that, well actually none other than evolutionary biologist, W D Hamilton took it seriously, and that it had been supressed by the scientific and medical journals. Or that only investigative sources were doing the job that scientific publications should, such as Rolling Stone. Or that it was debated at the Royal Society. Or that it was investigated and supported by UN and BBC investigator Edward Hooper, Or that luminaries no less esteemed as Matt Ridley argued that there was a case.

It all sounds very familiar. Letters to the editor, complaints of collusion by the scientific establishment. Claims that the virus was another goof by those crazy scientists making vaccines. No doubt a side-order of derision for Anthony Fauci in some places, and of course Matt Ridley buying into both.

The lab leak is really just as fringe as the OPV-HIV theory. There are few differences. The idea here is that it came from the same region that they did shady science and that all the scientists have shut up shop apart from a few brave renegades and some editors at news and investigative journalistic outlets.

The other is that Michael Worobey has seemed to take both seriously enough to actually investiagate and do peer-reviewed research that effectively discredits both.
 
This is ironic.

At the time, almost the same kinds of claims were made about the OPV theory as they are today about lab leak of Covid.

If you said, for example, that the claims were fringe and few in the medical and scientific establishment took it seriously, and that only non-scientific publications were writing about it, no doubt you would get people arguing that, well actually none other than evolutionary biologist, W D Hamilton took it seriously, and that it had been supressed by the scientific and medical journals. Or that only investigative sources were doing the job that scientific publications should, such as Rolling Stone. Or that it was debated at the Royal Society. Or that it was investigated and supported by UN and BBC investigator Edward Hooper, Or that luminaries no less esteemed as Matt Ridley argued that there was a case.

It all sounds very familiar. Letters to the editor, complaints of collusion by the scientific establishment. Claims that the virus was another goof by those crazy scientists making vaccines. No doubt a side-order of derision for Anthony Fauci in some places, and of course Matt Ridley buying into both.

The lab leak is really just as fringe as the OPV-HIV theory. There are few differences. The idea here is that it came from the same region that they did shady science and that all the scientists have shut up shop apart from a few brave renegades and some editors at news and investigative journalistic outlets.

The other is that Michael Worobey has seemed to take both seriously enough to actually investiagate and do peer-reviewed research that effectively discredits both.
Take a look at your citations and instead of seeing arguments of SG's you can't really counter, insert all the names of people and institutions pushing the spillover hypothesis. Anything look familiar?

Worobey rationalized his missing data. Check. What did he discredit? I missed that unless you are referring to some unsupported assertions. Check.

Letter to the editor? You mean the letter to the Lancet where even some of the original signatories withdrew their names, feeling duped? Or how about all the complaints to the WHO stating in no uncertain terms Daszak was not welcome on a second inspection if the WHO expected any credibility. And Tedros noted the WHO did not support the conclusion the lab origin was highly unlikely given the hypothesis was not examined at all.


It's not ironic that someone like me knew how stupid the polio vaccine CT was from the start anymore than someone in the JREF knew the Loose Change video was full of plot holes.

Wiki Oral polio vaccine AIDS hypothesis
Data analyses in molecular biology and phylogenetic studies contradict the OPV AIDS hypothesis; consequently, scientific consensus regards the hypothesis as disproven.[1][2][3][4] A 2004 Nature article has described the hypothesis as "refuted".[5]
...

In an August 1992 letter published in Science, Koprowski repudiated the OPV AIDS hypothesis, pointing to multiple errors of fact in its assertions.[31] In October 1992, Science ran a story titled "Panel Nixes Congo Vaccine as AIDS source", describing the findings of an independent panel which found each proposed step in the OPV-AIDS hypothesis "problematic". The story concluded:

...it can be stated with almost complete certainty that the large polio vaccine trial... was not the origin of AIDS.[32]
Notice there are no such problematic step after step findings re the COVID lab origin hypothesis.
I was involved in the HIV pandemic from the beginning, before people knew how it was spread and before they identified the viral cause. We started seeing patients with an unknown immunodeficiency disease in the Seattle hospital I worked in back in the early 80s. At no time did anyone in the healthcare community I was familiar with believe the polio vaccine nonsense. It didn't make sense then nor does it now.


And here you are going over the same **** again.
 
Last edited:
An Oxford B.Lltt degree is a post graduate degree, it is either a year study post MA (which in Oxford is an undergraduate degree!) or award for a failed DPhil. Yes Oxford is odd, people get an MA then do a bachelors degree e.g. BCL as a post graduate degree. MA and B.Litt can be in any subject including STEM.

I was merely making the point that the naming of Oxford degrees is odd. That a B.litt was not an undergraduate degree, but a post graduate degree, I was not claiming he had done undergraduate studies at Oxford.
 
Take a look at your citations and instead of seeing arguments of SG's you can't really counter, insert all the names of people and institutions pushing the spillover hypothesis. Anything look familiar?

Worobey rationalized his missing data. Check. What did he discredit? I missed that unless you are referring to some unsupported assertions. Check.

Letter to the editor? You mean the letter to the Lancet where even some of the original signatories withdrew their names, feeling duped? Or how about all the complaints to the WHO stating in no uncertain terms Daszak was not welcome on a second inspection if the WHO expected any credibility. And Tedros noted the WHO did not support the conclusion the lab origin was highly unlikely given the hypothesis was not examined at all.

The hypothesis was examined; by your constant reliance on secondary sources you are continually misled.

The joint international team made a series of recommendations for each area (see details in the report) and in doing so assessed the likelihood of different possible pathways for the introduction of the virus.
The joint international team examined four scenarios for introduction:
• direct zoonotic transmission to humans (spillover);
• introduction through an intermediate host followed by spillover;
• introduction through the (cold) food chain;
• introduction through a laboratory incident.For each of these possible pathways of emergence, the joint team conducted a qualitative risk assessment, considering the available scientific evidence and findings. It also stated the arguments against each possibility. The team assessed the relative likelihood of these pathways and prioritized further studies that would potentially increase knowledge and understanding globally.
The joint team’s assessment of likelihood of each possible pathway was as follows:
• direct zoonotic spillover is considered to be a possible-to-likely pathway;
• introduction through an intermediate host is considered to be a likely to very likely pathway;
• introduction through cold/ food chain products is considered a possible pathway;
• introduction through a laboratory incident was considered to be an extremely unlikely pathway.
https://www.who.int/publications/i/...bal-study-of-origins-of-sars-cov-2-china-part
 
Take a look at your citations and instead of seeing arguments of SG's you can't really counter, insert all the names of people and institutions pushing the spillover hypothesis. Anything look familiar?

Worobey rationalized his missing data. Check. What did he discredit? I missed that unless you are referring to some unsupported assertions. Check.

Letter to the editor? You mean the letter to the Lancet where even some of the original signatories withdrew their names, feeling duped? Or how about all the complaints to the WHO stating in no uncertain terms Daszak was not welcome on a second inspection if the WHO expected any credibility. And Tedros noted the WHO did not support the conclusion the lab origin was highly unlikely given the hypothesis was not examined at all.


It's not ironic that someone like me knew how stupid the polio vaccine CT was from the start anymore than someone in the JREF knew the Loose Change video was full of plot holes.

Wiki Oral polio vaccine AIDS hypothesisNotice there are no such problematic step after step findings re the COVID lab origin hypothesis.
I was involved in the HIV pandemic from the beginning, before people knew how it was spread and before they identified the viral cause. We started seeing patients with an unknown immunodeficiency disease in the Seattle hospital I worked in back in the early 80s. At no time did anyone in the healthcare community I was familiar with believe the polio vaccine nonsense. It didn't make sense then nor does it now.


And here you are going over the same **** again.

Lots of bluster, but the parallels with the HIV origin CT that you talk about, and the one about lab leak are pretty glaring.

The people who claimed OPV as a cause of course denied that they were pushing a CT. The fact that you so readily use the term suggests bad faith to me.

You may have been a nurse during the beginning of the AIDS pandemic, but there is no way from your vantage point that you could possibly have known that the OPV theory was just a CT.

Why a CT, anyway? Why is that a CT but lab leak not a CT?

You have essentially accused the authors of Proximal Origins, as well as Fauci, and the NIH,and Worobey, and Daszak and Zhengli Shi etc... of being part of a cover-up. You have argued that the Wuhan Military Games was a super-spreader event that infected athletes from the militaries of many countries before the official outbreak and assumed that various militaries and governments have not bothered to test their athlete soldiers. Why is this?

From what I can see, the OPV theory that was discredited many years after the outbreak, was not as much of a conspiracy theory as what you have pushed.

In other words, the comparison is completely fair.

This, for example, is a report on a conference in 2000.

“We trust that these results will put
to rest any remaining concerns of a
link between a Wistar-produced oral
polio vaccine and AIDS”, said
Clayton Buck, director of the Wistar
Institute. Hooper also presented new findings—“smoking guns”, he
said—to add further weight to his
hypothesis. First, he reported
“reliable eye-witness evidence that
kidneys were extracted from a large
number of chimpanzees” in central
Africa during the late 1950s. Second,
he claimed to have “reliable firsthand evidence” that these kidneys
were sent to laboratories in Belgium,
the USA, and to one vaccine-making
laboratory in Africa. This new evidence, Hooper argued, proved that “there is now a case [against OPV] to answer”. He also dismissed the SIV and HIV negative Wistar samples, which meant “nothing at all for the polio vaccine theory”. He noted that different batches of the particular OPV in question, named CHAT, were prepared in at least three countries, making a definitive exclusion of infection impossible by use of the Wistar samples alone. By contrast
with Basilico, Hooper concluded that
his OPV theory was “looking
considerably more impressive”.

Link

Hooper claimed "smoking guns" for his theories, and claimed that the evidence against "ignored" missing data.

In science, there is always missing data. Nobody has complete data.

In your theory, the Wuhan Military Games was a superspreader event.

And yet somehow between October and December, Covid cases must have suddenly diminished mysteriously in Wuhan until they somehow found their way back to a market opposite the Wuhan Center for Disease Control.

Do you not see how odd of a claim this is?

On the one hand you think that the lack of seropositivity implicates the lab, and the fact that there was a lab across the street from the market.

And yet you also think that there was a superspreader event in October in the Wuhan military Games (where is the stadium? Is it just acros the street from the WIV?)

And you also think the virus leaked out of the lab in September thus the taking down of the database?

This virus moves in mysterious ways to be sure.

ORRRRRR... maybe...

each proposed step in the [lab leak] hypothesis [is] "problematic"
 
The hypothesis was examined; by your constant reliance on secondary sources you are continually misled. ...
I was referring to Tedros' comments after the initial WHO report.

WHO Director-General's remarks at the Member State Briefing on the report of the international team studying the origins of SARS-CoV-2; 30 March 2021
The team also visited several laboratories in Wuhan and considered the possibility that the virus entered the human population as a result of a laboratory incident.

However, I do not believe that this assessment was extensive enough. Further data and studies will be needed to reach more robust conclusions.

Although the team has concluded that a laboratory leak is the least likely hypothesis, this requires further investigation,
potentially with additional missions involving specialist experts, which I am ready to deploy.

But you know that. Attacking me is all some people in this thread have.

As for news reports and secondary sources, those are flooding the media more and more, asserting the scientific evidence supports the spillover hypothesis. Yet what scientific evidence is that?

Not a lot, not any more since Worobey's flawed study, and certainly not enough to support the conclusions being asserted. "Peer reviewed, published" does not mean conclusive conclusions nor does it confer any special weight to the results. Many peer reviewed published studies contradict other peer reviewed published studies.


Technical Comment: Duplicate, Missing, and Biased Data in the Worobey et al. Study Undermine Their Main Result; Dec 2022
Abstract
A key finding from the COVID-19 origin study by Worobey et al. (published in Science on 26 July 2022) was that the group of early cases in Wuhan with a known epidemiologic link to the Huanan Seafood Wholesale market was statistically further away from that market than the cases without such link. It is shown here that this result of Worobey et al. is directly undermined by the study’s duplicate, missing, and biased data. Together with previous technical evidence against a market origin of SARS-CoV-2 lineage B cases (published as Science eLetter on 16 October 2022), this evidence further invalidates the market origin hypothesis.

Secondary sources indeed. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Technical Comment: Duplicate, Missing, and Biased Data in the Worobey et al. Study Undermine Their Main Result; Dec 2022
Abstract
A key finding from the COVID-19 origin study by Worobey et al. (published in Science on 26 July 2022) was that the group of early cases in Wuhan with a known epidemiologic link to the Huanan Seafood Wholesale market was statistically further away from that market than the cases without such link. It is shown here that this result of Worobey et al. is directly undermined by the study’s duplicate, missing, and biased data. Together with previous technical evidence against a market origin of SARS-CoV-2 lineage B cases (published as Science eLetter on 16 October 2022), this evidence further invalidates the market origin hypothesis.

Secondary sources indeed. :rolleyes:


That technical comment is available online but its full content appears to be otherwise unpublished. A stripped-down version of it appears to have been published by Science as one of the eLetters commenting upon Worobey et al's Science paper of 26 July 2022. As Science explains:
eLetters is a forum for ongoing peer review. eLetters are not edited, proofread, or indexed, but they are screened. eLetters should provide substantive and scholarly commentary on the article. Embedded figures cannot be submitted....​
The suggested citation for the full online version is
Lisewski, Andreas Martin, Technical Comment: Duplicate, Missing, and Biased Data in the Worobey et al. Study Undermine Their Main Result (November 11, 2022). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4275119 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4275119​
That full version consists of a 5-page technical comment followed by another 5 pages of Supplemental Information consisting of email correspondence, followed by 1 blank page.

On my reading of the technical comment and the emails within its Supplemental Information, the technical comment mostly concerns a mistake Worobey et al. made in their GitHub repository. The following email, from Michael Worobey to Andreas Martin Lisewski, acknowledges that mistake:
Dear Dr. Lisewski,

We recently became aware of a new preprint of yours that mentioned the issue of duplicate files on our GitHub repository for the Worobey et al 2022 paper. And we are sorry that we did not notice that you had apparently mentioned this issued [sic[ in earlier correspondence with us. We are eager to correct any error.

We see that there has indeed been a copy-paste error where by two files related to the n=35 Huanan-linked data set and the n-120 Huanan-unlinked data sets are identical. We are reviewing how the error occurred and will fix it shortly and make any small corrections it may require. However, it appears the [sic] at most that it will shift some P values in the supplementary materials by very small degrees. And we can assure you that your claim that we did not have data on the n=35 cases is incorrect — a quick glance at Figure 1A should reassure you that that is not true.

All the best, and thanks for bringing this to our attention,

Mike​
Those corrections were made on or before 8 May 2023, as can be seen by examining the online Supplementary Materials for Worobey et al.'s paper.

From other emails that are quoted within Lisewski's Supplemental Information, it looks as though Lisewski was unhappy that, after publishing Lisewski's first eLetter concerning this matter at the paper's web site, a Senior Editor at Science "decided against posting further communications from [Lisewski] on this paper." I see, however, that Science relented and published another version of his technical comment as a second eLetter on 10 April 2023.

It seems to me that Lisewski's technical comment concerns a minor mistake of negligible relevance to this thread. In particular, Lisewski's technical comment does not in any way provide new support for a lab-leak origin.

It also seems to me that the following remark, quoted from the abstract of Lisewski's full technical comment, is the sort of over-the-top claim you might expect from someone who was unhappy that his eLetter (published by Science on 16 October 2022) wasn't getting the attention he thought it deserved.
Together with previous technical evidence against a market origin of SARS-CoV-2 lineage B cases (published as Science Eletter on 16 October 2022), this evidence further invalidates the market origin hypothesis.​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom