One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Yet again, there's little in your post beyond assertion without evidence, so there's not much to which I can respond. One point I can correct is that I did not assert that UNSC 242 specified borders -I said that it reinforced those specified in UNGAR 181. What 242 did do was call for the "withdrawal of Israel armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict" and emphasized the "inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war". One doesn't really need to get into a debate on semantics to understand the intention this Resolution.
Of course, this only matters if you consider international law to be binding. By your use of the phrase "tired" and "worn out" I assume you're one of those people who don't accept that Israel is subject to the law.
Of course -and this is an elementary point- Israel would be subject to all manner of fresh Resolutions, were it not for the unilateral US veto protecting it`s asset (just as Iraq would not have violated any Resolutions if it, or a close friend, had the veto). I won't even bother to mention the consistant (and virtually unanimous) stance taken by the UN General Assembly or Israel's violations of the Charter (to which the Security Council is subject) since it presumably doesn't interest you.

The rest of your post, which -for example- can make laughable statements like "Israel has invested substantial resources in making the water available to the Palestinian-Arabs" (despite the evidence I cited which demonstrates the reverse), isn't really worth a response. If you're impervious to facts, logic, and reason there's nothing else I can say to you.

I hope others might notice that you treat the idea of actually discussing this issue with Palestinians as laughable too. I wish this was just another example of your flippant juvenile drivel but obviously it is not. It`s the keystone in the arch that supports your monumental racist bigotry.
 
zenith-nadir said:



I wish the IDF didn't have to blow up houses Zero. I wish the IDF didn't have to protect Israel from the north, south, east and west. I wish the world never heard of the PLO, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Hizbollah, Al Aksa Martyrs Brigade, Fatah and Tanzim. I wish alot of things.

But guess what?...they exsist, there are groups who are not fighting Israeli 'oppression', they are only interested in killing as many jews as possible and destroying Israel....and these groups blow up arab and jewish Israelis, they don't distinguish between the two...and they have to be stopped so that an Arab Israeli who wants to own a restaurant or a jewish family from America eating pizza on holiday in Jerusalem doesn't have to pay for it with their lives.
\

They don't have to blow them up, they could just leave the areas they are blowing the houses up in.
 
Mycroft said:


In a sense, the suicide-bomber is a victim too of the terror networks that recruit him, indoctrinate him, train him, arm him and smuggle him to his target. The individual bomber is just a tool, the real responsibility lay with the terrorists that use him.

Moral Relativism at it's worst.
 
a_unique_person said:
They don't have to blow them up, they could just leave the areas they are blowing the houses up in.



Ever heard of the Oslo Accords? Forget that for a sec. Ever heard of the concept of time?

You forget about time. There was a time when Israel did not blow up houses of suicide bombers. That "time" was pre-2001. Freaky huh? Only 3 years ago Israel started blowing up Palestinian suicide bombers homes when all other methods failed. Yet suicide bombings have been happening since the mid 90's.

There was also a time when Arafat signed the Oslo accords with Israel. The principles agreed were, in essence, the withdrawal of Israeli forces from the Gaza Strip and the West Bank and the Palestinian right to self-government within those areas through the creation of the Palestinian Authority.

The Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (also called Oslo 2), was signed in September 1995 which gave the Palestinians self-rule in Bethlehem, Hebron, Jenin, Nablus, Qalqilya, Ramallah, Tulkarm, and some 450 villages.

Guess what a_unique_person,.... the suicide bombers kept coming out of Jenin, Nablus, Qalqilya, Ramallah and Tulkarm after Arafat controlled those areas....so Israel CAME BACK TO STOP THE BOMBERS.



I just don't get you, Demon, davefoc, the fool....you guys constantly try start time after the act that caused Israel to respond.
 
Originally posted by a_unique_person

Moral Relativism at it's worst.

Explain how that’s moral relativism.

Hey, you never answered my question about Ausie lingo. Is the word unique used as a euphamism in the same way we in the States use the word special?
 
Mycroft said:
Explain how that’s moral relativism.Hey, you never answered my question about Ausie lingo. Is the word unique used as a euphamism in the same way we in the States use the word special?



I am waiting to hear a_unique_person admit that he lives on land stolen from the aboriginies. That he is in fact 'occupying' stolen aboriginal lands...;)

And if the aboriginal population of Australia decided to start blowing up buses and restaurants in Sydney and Melbourne would a_unique_person say they are justified?

After all that is the 'template' he put's the Israeli-Palestinian issue in endlessly.
 
Originally posted by demon
Yet again, there's little in your post beyond assertion without evidence, so there's not much to which I can respond. One point I can correct is that I did not assert that UNSC 242 specified borders -I said that it reinforced those specified in UNGAR 181. What 242 did do was call for the "withdrawal of Israel armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict" and emphasized the "inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war". One doesn't really need to get into a debate on semantics to understand the intention this Resolution.

In politics, semantics is everything.

For example, did you know that the PLO rejected resolution 242? Their reasoning was that it didn’t deal with Palestinian-Arabs as a people with national rights. This makes perfect sense, of course, as before 1967 they weren’t a people; the term Palestinian didn’t come into common usage until after 1967, prior to that they self-identified as Jordanians, or Egyptians or simply Arabs. Nope, the PLO didn’t accept Resolution 242 until 1988, and only after pressure from the United States which set it as a precondition to recognizing them.

But what about the resolution itself? What does it mean?

Well, let’s take a look at some statements from some of the diplomats of the time:

"To seek withdrawal without secure and recognized boundaries ... would be just as fruitless as to seek secure and recognized boundaries without withdrawal. Historically, there have never been secure or recognized boundaries in the area. Neither the armistice lines of 1949 nor the cease-fire lines of 1967 have answered that description... such boundaries have yet to be agreed upon. An agreement on that point is an absolute essential to a just and lasting peace just as withdrawal is... "

Arthur Goldberg, U.S. ambassador to the U.N

“The purposes are perfectly clear, the principle is stated in the preamble, the necessity for withdrawal is stated in the operative section. And then the essential phrase which is not sufficiently recognized is that withdrawal should take place to secure and recognized boundaries, and these words were very carefully chosen: they have to be secure and they have to be recognized. They will not be secure unless they are recognized. And that is why one has to work for agreement. This is essential. I would defend absolutely what we did. It was not for us to lay down exactly where the border should be. I know the 1967 border very well. It is not a satisfactory border, it is where troops had to stop in 1947, just where they happened to be that night, that is not a permanent boundary . . . "

Lord Caradon Britain’s representative to the U.N


"Until the states concerned in the dispute make peace in accordance with Resolution 242, the Security Council decided, Israel could remain in the territories it held after the Six Day War as occupying power. The legality and legitimacy of its presence as occupying power is thus certified by the Security Council"

Eugene V. Rostow U.S. Undersecretary of State.


So who cares what Eugene Rostow, Lord Caradon, and Arthur Goldberg think? Well, if you want to invoke UNSCR 242, you should. They’re the guys who wrote it.

Resolution 242 doesn’t call for Israel to withdraw from all the territories occupied in 1967. It presumes that a withdrawal will be a part of a negotiated peace between all parties involved, but it also presumes that the negotiated peace will include secure and defensible boundaries that are not the armistice lines of 1949.
 
originally posted by Mycroft
Killing a terrorist is characterized as assassination or revenge.

Even for you this is a bit rich.

Israel has a state policy of assassinating suspects.

Do you understand the difference between a suspect and the guilty?

It's a simple question.
 
Mycroft, in your own mind, you can tell us where/when the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Didn’t you hear? The Jooz want it all! They put it down in this book that was smuggled out of one of their secret meetings a hundred years ago. It talks all about how all us goyim are cattle and they’re going to control the world to ensure their supply of the bones of Christian babies to make their matsa!!

Another question answered by Mycroft.

QED.
 
zenith-nadir said:




I am waiting to hear a_unique_person admit that he lives on land stolen from the aboriginies. That he is in fact 'occupying' stolen aboriginal lands...;)

And if the aboriginal population of Australia decided to start blowing up buses and restaurants in Sydney and Melbourne would a_unique_person say they are justified?

After all that is the 'template' he put's the Israeli-Palestinian issue in endlessly.

Are you proposing that Palestinians should have the same land rights as indigenous australians? Are you proposing Australian land rights legislation as a solution in the middle east? Because if you are you have just changed sides in this discussion. If you are, you are proposing something that The current Israeli government would never accept. ..welcome aboard ZN. Its always refreshing to get up in the morning to find you have already dismantled your own argument and changed camps...It saves me a lot of time (at least 2 minutes)

Have you ever wondered why Australian Aboriginals are not blowing up things and palestinians are???? when it dawns on you, let me know.
 
The Fool said:
Have you ever wondered why Australian Aboriginals are not blowing up things and palestinians are???? when it dawns on you, let me know.


That one is easy...Because Australian Aboriginals do not belong to militant groups who idolize martyrdom and suicide.
 
zenith-nadir said:



That one is easy...Because Australian Aboriginals do not belong to militant groups who idolize martyrdom and suicide.
as I said, when it dawns on you let me know..

are you adding my other question to your list of unanswerable questions?

In case you have forgotten the question...Are you proposing Australian land rights legislation as a solution to palestinian land right issues?
 
"That one is easy...Because Australian Aboriginals do not belong to militant groups who idolize martyrdom and suicide."

Keep digging ZN :D
 
Why doesn't MADD use suicide bombing? They are against drunk driving, but the letters MAD also stand for "Mutually Assured Destruction."
 
Originally posted by The Fool
Have you ever wondered why Australian Aboriginals are not blowing up things and palestinians are???? when it dawns on you, let me know.

Because your ancestors spent almost two centuries killing them almost to the point of extinction, and as recently as the 1950s was busy stealing their babies so they could be raised by white folk and thus destroying whatever sense of cultural identity they had left. No, I don’t wonder that they are not blowing things up, I wonder that there are any left alive.

Personally, I hope for a more humane solution in the Middle East.
 
Allow me to point out the irony...

Lets take a few pages out of Australian Aborigial history.

The Aboriginal population was decimated by British colonisation which began in 1788. The founding of the modern Australian nation led to the disruption of the Aboriginal traditional way of life -- to death, disease and dispossession and outright murder reduced the Aboriginal population by an estimated 90% during the 19th Century and early 20th Century. A wave of massacres and resistance followed the frontier. The last massacre was at Coniston in the Northern Territory in 1928.

European settlers gradually made their way into the interior of Australia, appropriating water and land for their own exclusive use.

Land and property rights fueled an important civil rights movement in the 1970s. Aborigines spoke out for equal rights, and specifically for land rights for property that had been forcibly taken by British settlers. The Aboriginal Land Rights Act, passed in 1976, became instrumental in territories with tribal associations. The 1990s witnessed further rights milestones, including government legislation that returned a great degree of autonomy, and increased wages and welfare benefits to aboriginal people.





And Aborigines gained all those "equal rights" and "land rights for property" without resorting to TERRORISM, SUICIDE BOMBING AND THE GLORIFICATION OF MARTYRDOM....unlike "others"

Crazy huh?.....
 
Mycroft said:


Because your ancestors spent almost two centuries killing them almost to the point of extinction, and as recently as the 1950s was busy stealing their babies so they could be raised by white folk and thus destroying whatever sense of cultural identity they had left. No, I don’t wonder that they are not blowing things up, I wonder that there are any left alive.

Personally, I hope for a more humane solution in the Middle East.
lol...my ancestors did that did they?

I truly fail to see the relevance of this, is it any more or less relevant than American treatment of thier native people...Oh hang on...I get it. Israel Isn't a colonial oppressor as long as you can point to another colonial oppressor and say they did it too?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom