One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Mycroft

High Priest of Ed
Joined
Sep 10, 2003
Messages
20,501
Palestinian PM's family cement firm 'helping build Israeli wall'

Israel's Channel 10 TV also reported that the Al-Quds Cement Company - owned by Ahmed Qureia's family - has been providing the materials to help build a contentious West Bank barrier, allegations Palestinian officials have denied.
The TV report said Mr Qureia was providing the cement to build the concrete slabs right outside his house in Abu Dis, a town near Jerusalem divided by a 25-foot wall.

link
 
oh well.... can you think of any other ways to belittle the plight of these people mycroft? Maybe a story about the boom in the coffin industry?
 
Has anyone considered the money the 911 terrorists spent on hire cars and hotel rooms? The Pilot training schools made a bit out of it too.....anyone F*cking offended yet?

pathetic.
 
Re: Re: One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

a_unique_person said:
And where did ananova get the story? From Palestinians investigating the possible link. BTW, how is Sharon going with his fraud investigation? I bet nothing much happens, even with evidence on tape of him organising illegal funding.


Yes, Sharon is being investigated for over illegal financing in his 1999 election campaign. Israeli police are investigating a £1 million loan paid to Sharon's son during Sharon's 1999 leadership campaign. There, it's been said. All the cards are on the table about Sharon's "wicked", "horrible", "zionazi" crimes.



Now back to the topic at hand. The "wall" and Palestinian Authority "corruption".



The best quote I ever heard concerning the "wall" is this one;

"Terrorism is a deadly obstacle to peace. The fence is an obstacle to terrorism."

People who are against the wall will say that it is a "land grab". Well yes, parts of the wall do criss cross onto "disputed" lands. Land that is meant to be part of the future Palestinian state.

But the wall is not a political border, it is a defensive measure that Israel has had to build. It does not change the legal status of Palestinians or the legal status of the ground under the wall. The legal status of the ground under the wall is still to be negotiated.

So there goes the "land grab" argument out the window.



Now people who are against the wall will say that it is a "apartheid".

Israel is not racially segregating all jews from arabs inside Israel. That would be the definition of "apartheid". The only reason that Palestinians have in recent years been restricted from entering into Israel is because of their terrorist attacks against Israelis.

Arabs inside Isreal own businesses and property, in fact the Palestinians blew up the Maxim restaurant in Haifa, a city with a great reputation for Jewish and Arab cooperation. The Maxim restaurant was a well-known arab owned restaurant with arab and jewish employees!...yet even it was suicide bombed, by a palestinian lawyer!!!!....killing 20 arab and jewish Israelis and wounding over 40 seriously.

So there goes the "apartheid" argument out the window.


The security wall is being built because the Palestinian Authority refuses to stop the Hamas, Al Aksa Martyrs Brigade, Fatah, Tanzim and Islamic Jihad terror groups from launching attacks on Israelis from inside the West Bank. These attacks kill jewish AND arab Israelis. Period.


Now to the topic of Palestinian Authority corruption. The corruption of the Palestinian Authority is legendary.

It has been proven that Arafat has stolen nearly 2 billion from the Palestinians, it has also been proven that Arafat controlled monopolies in commodities with his cronies that ripped off the Palestinian people for gas, flour AND cement. The French government is investigating his wife who gets millions a year to live in Paris, the EU's anti-fraud unit and Belgian police are investigating claims that money earmarked for aid was paid to the Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades through Belgian and German affiliate organisations.

In response to September 11, President Bush signed Executive Order 13224, requiring all recipients of U.S. aid to guarantee that their organization does not support terrorism. Since the 1993 Oslo Accords, the United States has distributed $1.3 billion for Palestinian programs in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.

Palestinian organizations are refusing to accept U.S. foreign aid this year, (U.S. Agency for International Development 2004), rather than sign a pledge promising that the money will not be used to support terrorism.




As one can plainly see after all that, it is easy to believe that Ahmed Qureia's family's cement business may be profitting from cement for the security wall.
 
Has anyone considered the money the 911 terrorists spent on hire cars and hotel rooms? The Pilot training schools made a bit out of it too.....anyone F*cking offended yet?
Nope. :D
 
Re: Re: Re: One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

zenith-nadir said:
People who are against the wall will say that it is a "land grab". Well yes, parts of the wall do criss cross onto "disputed" lands. Land that is meant to be part of the future Palestinian state.

But the wall is not a political border, it is a defensive measure that Israel has had to build. It does not change the legal status of Palestinians or the legal status of the ground under the wall. The legal status of the ground under the wall is still to be negotiated.

I think the problem here is Israel's unwillingness to fight the good fight. If Israel wanted to avoid allegations of a "land grab," it should've built the wall on land that was clearly undisputed. This would avoid all arguments about expansionism as well as raise Israel's image in the international community. And if Israel has no desire to exploit the land behind the fence, then what's the big deal?

Really, this whole situation won't be resolved until one side admits that it will have to bear the brunt of the conflict. Think about it: right now, you have Palestinian terrorists sending suicide bombers on the one hand, and the IDF sending tanks and rockets on the other, with significant collateral damage. The ways things are now, it's very easy for each side to point their finger at the other. Both can make the other look bad, and with some justification: Israel is pretty damn trigger-happy.

But suppose Israel stopped retaliating in kind. Suppose it just "takes one for the team," builds the wall on its own land, and does its best to weather the storm. Then, public opinion would shift dramatically. Instead of a regional squabble in which both sides take things too far, you would have a clear aggressor and a clear victim. I'm guessing the rest of the world would polarize around Israel fairly quickly.

So, regardless of Israel's actual intentions, its unwillingness to avoid even the appearance of impropriety is prolonging the conflict. If Israel really has no designs for the land behind the fence, why would they do this?

Jeremy
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

toddjh said:
I think the problem here is Israel's unwillingness to fight the good fight. If Israel wanted to avoid allegations of a "land grab," it should've built the wall on land that was clearly undisputed. This would avoid all arguments about expansionism as well as raise Israel's image in the international community.


That would be in a perfect world.

The "wall" is to prevent terrorists from infiltrating into Israeli population centers. In order to attain that goal, the "wall" cannot simply be built on the "green line". That would not stop palestinians terrorists from infiltrating into Israel. The "wall" has to follow topographical considerations in order to stop infiltrations.

When it becomes necessary, and infiltrations can be stopped by the Palestinian Authority, the relevant parts of the wall can be moved to different locations or even torn down.


toddjh said:
Really, this whole situation won't be resolved until one side admits that it will have to bear the brunt of the conflict. Think about it: right now, you have Palestinian terrorists sending suicide bombers on the one hand, and the IDF sending tanks and rockets on the other, with significant collateral damage.

I disagree. The situation can be resolved once the terror groups no longer want the destruction of Israel. Just like Al Qaeda will no longer be a threat once they A) no longer want the destruction of America or B) are all dead.

On the topic of collateral damage you have palestinian terror groups deliberately hiding, operating, and launching attacks from within Palestinian civilian areas. They also disguise themselves as palestinian civilians, they do not wear uniforms.

If you want to lessen collateral damage then the Palestinian Authority should remove terror organizations from operating in civilian areas.




toddjh said:
But suppose Israel stopped retaliating in kind. Suppose it just "takes one for the team," builds the wall on its own land, and does its best to weather the storm. Then, public opinion would shift dramatically. Instead of a regional squabble in which both sides take things too far, you would have a clear aggressor and a clear victim. I'm guessing the rest of the world would polarize around Israel fairly quickly.


Israel has been taking "one for the team" since the 1960's. See the history of the PLO. :)


toddjh said:
So, regardless of Israel's actual intentions, its unwillingness to avoid even the appearance of impropriety is prolonging the conflict. If Israel really has no designs for the land behind the fence, why would they do this?


As I said before, the wall is based upon topographical considerations in order to stop infiltrations, not on setting a political border which will not stop infiltrations.


I wish they didn't have to build a wall, it is a huge expense and nothing but another excuse for the Palestinian Authority to blame Israel for not stopping Palestinian terrorism.

No terror = no IDF = no collateral damage.
 
Ah, ZN, there you are.


zenith-nadir, I`m calling you out for the fourth time now.

You said: "Show everyone on the Palestinian Ministry of Information Website where it says the Palestinian Charter is "effectively annulled" Demon. Failure to do so will mean only one thing. You are lying."

I supplied entirely different reasons for why I stated that the PC was "effectively annulled" as you and anyone else who read my post will know, if they agree with it or not.
Those reasons have nothing to do with anything appearing on or off of the PMI website.
You have accused me of being a liar on the basis of a straw man argument. Will you now show some character and retract your "you are lying" statement?

I`ve called you three times on this already, why won`t you address it? Are you letting your silence answer that which you are incapable of answering?
demon.
 
Originally posted by The Fool
oh well.... can you think of any other ways to belittle the plight of these people mycroft? Maybe a story about the boom in the coffin industry?

I don't see how it belittles them at all. There is Palestinian-Arab industry, and when things are built, they are involved. I don't see that this article does anything more than add a little depth to peoples understanding of the situation.
 
demon said:
Ah, ZN, there you are.


zenith-nadir, I`m calling you out for the fourth time now.

You said: "Show everyone on the Palestinian Ministry of Information Website where it says the Palestinian Charter is "effectively annulled" Demon. Failure to do so will mean only one thing. You are lying."

I supplied entirely different reasons for why I stated that the PC was "effectively annulled" as you and anyone else who read my post will know, if they agree with it or not.
Those reasons have nothing to do with anything appearing on or off of the PMI website.
You have accused me of being a liar on the basis of a straw man argument. Will you now show some character and retract your "you are lying" statement?

I`ve called you three times on this already, why won`t you address it? Are you letting your silence answer that which you are incapable of answering?
demon.



Ok. Let's go over this again very briefly because it is not the topic of the thread.

1) You claim the Palestinian Charter is "effectively annulled".

2) You cannot find any text on the Palestinian Authority's website that says "this palestinian charter is effectively annulled".

3) The Charter remains on the Palestinian Authority's website as originally written.

4) No new Palestinian Charter OR Palestinian Constitution has ever been published or seen by anyone on the planet earth.

5) Therefore the charter, as it appears on the official Palestinian Authority's website, is not "effectively annulled" until the Palestinian Authority puts that claim in writing.



The charter remains in effect.

If it was not in effect the Palestinian Authority would A) Remove it from their own website, B) Say it was "effectively annulled" on their own website, and on which date it was annulled, C) Publish a new Palestinian charter which reflects the official annulments for the world to see.

Therefore Demon, you can claim all you want that it has been "effectively annulled", in fact you can say the sky is pink if you so desire, but the evidence on the Palestinian Authority's own official website disproves your annulment theory.

You can't say something is true Demon when all the evidence points to the contrary. In layman's terms that is a lie. Sorry.

Perhaps you are giving the Palestinian Authority too much credit, they said they would have free and fair elections in 98, yet none have ever taken place, they said they would draft a Palestinian constitution in 96, yet that has never taken place, they said they would stop the terror groups in 11 different preace agreements, yet that has never taken place.........you may start to think about the fact Demon that maybe the Palestinian Authority has lied to you.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

zenith-nadir said:
In order to attain that goal, the "wall" cannot simply be built on the "green line". That would not stop palestinians terrorists from infiltrating into Israel. The "wall" has to follow topographical considerations in order to stop infiltrations.

So, adjust the topography to make it effective. We do it with roads all the time. No biggie, just a little more expensive.

I disagree. The situation can be resolved once the terror groups no longer want the destruction of Israel. Just like Al Qaeda will no longer be a threat once they A) no longer want the destruction of America or B) are all dead.

So, assuming that it will never be possible to stop Palestinian terrorists from wanting to destroy Israel, your only solution is to kill them all? Do you think that's practical? Do you think that will lead to greater acceptance of Israel by its neighbors, and eliminate future terrorism?

I think it will do just the opposite. It will continue the cycle of violence that has gone on for the last 40 years. Same old, same old. We need to change things, not keep them the same.

On the topic of collateral damage you have palestinian terror groups deliberately hiding, operating, and launching attacks from within Palestinian civilian areas. They also disguise themselves as palestinian civilians, they do not wear uniforms.

I am not defending Palestinian terrorists. Odds are I'd agree with most of the thing you'd say about them. That being the case, I'd appreciate it if we could limit the discussion to Israel's actions, since they actually have a central government capable of controlling things.

If you want to lessen collateral damage then the Palestinian Authority should remove terror organizations from operating in civilian areas.

SOMEONE is going to have to bit the bullet and just do what it takes. It's pretty clear that it's not going to be the PA. Thus, we're back to Israel's actions. The current "you bomb us, we bomb you" cycle is accomplishing nothing. Radical change is required. Israel could win the PR war hands-down if they'd just avoid the appearance of impropriety. It would be so easy. Why won't they do it?

It's not a question of whether or not they should have to. It's a question of practicality. What's more important: feeling smug, or stopping the cycle of killing that has lasted for decades?

Israel has been taking "one for the team" since the 1960's. See the history of the PLO. :)

In a sense, yes. But they've been doing it half-assed. They've managed to alienate just about everybody except the U.S. by responding to violence in kind. They need to decide whether they're going to be the good guys here, or just one half of a regional squabble.

Jeremy
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Originally posted by toddjh

So, adjust the topography to make it effective. We do it with roads all the time. No biggie, just a little more expensive.

If you look at a map, you will see that it follows the borders closely. Take a look:

http://www.mideastweb.org/thefence1.htm

Originally posted by toddjh
SOMEONE is going to have to bit the bullet and just do what it takes. It's pretty clear that it's not going to be the PA. Thus, we're back to Israel's actions. The current "you bomb us, we bomb you" cycle is accomplishing nothing. Radical change is required. Israel could win the PR war hands-down if they'd just avoid the appearance of impropriety. It would be so easy. Why won't they do it?

Here we have a solution that reacts to violence with non-violence, which attempts to end the cycle of reacting to violence with more violence. What could be better? Yet in the anti-Israel media campaign this non-violent solution is spun into a negative. Instead of a solution that doesn’t require that anyone die, it’s spun into a “land grab”, “apartheid” or “ghetoization”.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Mycroft said:
If you look at a map, you will see that it follows the borders closely.

Then why not just keep the wall inside the borders? If it's so close already, how hard can it be?

Here we have a solution that reacts to violence with non-violence, which attempts to end the cycle of reacting to violence with more violence. What could be better? Yet in the anti-Israel media campaign this non-violent solution is spun into a negative. Instead of a solution that doesn’t require that anyone die, it’s spun into a “land grab”, “apartheid” or “ghetoization”.

The "land grab" accusation is the only one I'm addressing, and I don't think it's true, it's just that I think Israel would do better to avoid the issue entirely and save themselves the PR trouble. As for the apartheid stuff, I think the accusations there are just dumb.

Jeremy
 
1)You claim the Palestinian Charter is "effectively annulled".

2) You cannot find any text on the Palestinian Authority's website that says "this palestinian charter is effectively annulled".

My claim didn`t rely on the PMI website and you know it. You are a piece of ◊◊◊◊ lying scum without the balls to accept when you are wrong.
I hope anyone who read my post, agreeing with it or not will realise what a disembling and disingenuous wanker you are.
 
Originally posted by toddjh

Then why not just keep the wall inside the borders? If it's so close already, how hard can it be?

That’s a great question for an engineer. It’s a government project so it’s natural to assume that the end result is a result of costs, geography, engineering needs and politics.

Originally posted by toddjh
The "land grab" accusation is the only one I'm addressing, and I don't think it's true, it's just that I think Israel would do better to avoid the issue entirely and save themselves the PR trouble. As for the apartheid stuff, I think the accusations there are just dumb.

Jeremy

If it were just the one issue, I’d agree. Right or wrong, fair or not, if it were just a matter of changing a few things and moving on, I say do it.

The problem, as I see it, is that it’s not just the one issue. Every defensive measure Israel takes receives the same unfair criticism. Killing a terrorist is characterized as assassination or revenge. If a civilian gets killed in the process, then Israel is accused of doing it on purpose or the action gets labeled as terrorist. When Israel seals its borders, the cry goes up of the economic devastation caused to the Palestinian-Arabs, when Israel opens them up again, the critics say it’s not enough. Checkpoints designed to capture terrorists before they get into Israel are bashed for being humiliating to Arabs. When Israel does Bite the Bullet and give concessions, it’s criticized as being not enough or duplicitous no matter how much is conceded and how little they get in return.

After a while you get the idea that it’s not any one measure that the critics object to, it’s that Israel defends itself at all.
 
Its sickening to me that Israelis (many of whom had relatives who were forced to live in a prison-like ghetto in Europe) don't see the parallel here.

Our continuing support for Sharon is a disgrace.
 
Originally posted by Clancie
Its sickening to me that Israelis (many of whom had relatives who were forced to live in a prison-like ghetto in Europe) don't see the parallel here.

Our continuing support for Sharon is a disgrace.

I agree it’s sickening and I’m sure the parallels are not lost on many Israelis, but the Ghettos (most often called Refugee Camps) are not maintained by Sharon, they are maintained by the Palestinian-Authority, and the nations of Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Egypt. Fifty-five years is too long, it’s time to let them get on with their lives.
 
demon said:
Ah, ZN, there you are.


zenith-nadir, I`m calling you out for the fourth time now.

You said: "Show everyone on the Palestinian Ministry of Information Website where it says the Palestinian Charter is "effectively annulled" Demon. Failure to do so will mean only one thing. You are lying."

I supplied entirely different reasons for why I stated that the PC was "effectively annulled" as you and anyone else who read my post will know, if they agree with it or not.
Those reasons have nothing to do with anything appearing on or off of the PMI website.
You have accused me of being a liar on the basis of a straw man argument. Will you now show some character and retract your "you are lying" statement?

I`ve called you three times on this already, why won`t you address it? Are you letting your silence answer that which you are incapable of answering?
demon.

You might also want to call him out on using the Bible as part of his 'facts'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom