One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

On the topic of collateral damage you have palestinian terror groups deliberately hiding, operating, and launching attacks from within Palestinian civilian areas. They also disguise themselves as palestinian civilians, they do not wear uniforms.

If you want to lessen collateral damage then the Palestinian Authority should remove terror organizations from operating in civilian areas.

I already replied to this, but I don't know if you rebuted it, so here it is again:

A: Hiding, operating, and launching attacks from civilian areas.
Alternative: Stand in the middle of a desert.

B: Disguise as civilians, no uniforms.
Alternative: Stand with a sign that says: "I'm going to blow up tomorow at 9 AM, don't miss me!"

And as coup de grace, could you please numerate how many of these complaints you listed apply to the French Resistance in France?

Thank you

Gem
 
Gem said:
A: Hiding, operating, and launching attacks from civilian areas.
Alternative: Stand in the middle of a desert.

Better alternative : Stop the terror. Blowing up buses and restaurants full of civilians 100 km from the battle is not 'resistance'.

Gem said:
B: Disguise as civilians, no uniforms.
Alternative: Stand with a sign that says: "I'm going to blow up tomorow at 9 AM, don't miss me!"

Better alternative : Stop the terror. Blowing up buses and restaurants full of civilians 100 km from the battle is not 'resistance'.

Gem said:
And as coup de grace, could you please numerate how many of these complaints you listed apply to the French Resistance in France?

Palestinian suicide bombers are the same as the French Resistance in WW2?...Plaaaaaaaeeeeeze :roll:



Originally posted by Demon
My claim didn`t rely on the PMI website and you know it. You are a piece of ◊◊◊◊ lying scum without the balls to accept when you are wrong. I hope anyone who read my post, agreeing with it or not will realise what a disembling and disingenuous wanker you are.

Sticks and stones may break my bones.....:D



Originally posted by Clancie
Its sickening to me that Israelis (many of whom had relatives who were forced to live in a prison-like ghetto in Europe) don't see the parallel here. Our continuing support for Sharon is a disgrace.

Ghettos?...Palestinans are free to go to Jordan, Egypt, Syria, where ever they want, except into Israel...nor is Israel marching palestinians into death camps or working them to death.....there is no comparison to WW2.
 
zenith-nadir said:


Ghettos?...Palestinans are free to go to Jordan, Egypt, Syria, where ever they want, except into Israel...nor is Israel marching palestinians into death camps or working them to death.....there is no comparison to WW2.

Palestinians who have tried to make it to Australia often are refused refugee status. I get the impression Syria, Egypt and Jordan would not want millions of refugees flooding into their own countries.

Apart from that, maybe they want to live there. The ethnic cleansing you are proposing is part of the Israelis tactics, make life for them so miserable they just up and leave.
 
"Ghettos?...Palestinans are free to go to Jordan, Egypt, Syria, where ever they want, except into Israel...nor is Israel marching palestinians into death camps or working them to death.....there is no comparison to WW2."

quote:
"Israeli government minister Avigdor Liberman has called for the creation of four Palestinian cantons in the West Bank.
The minister told Israel Radio his plan was an alternative to proposals drawn up by Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.
Mr Liberman said Palestinians would be allowed to travel between the cantons, but not to live outside them.
Mr Sharon has proposed that Israel should disengage unilaterally from Gaza and parts of the West Bank.
The prime minister's idea has dismayed many on the Israeli right because it would involve the dismantling of some Jewish settlements. "
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3492561.stm
____________________________________________________

Brilliant idea -then all they'll have to do is rename them as Treblinka, Belsen, Dachau, and Auschwitz.
 
Better alternative : Stop the terror. Blowing up buses and restaurants full of civilians 100 km from the battle is not 'resistance'.

Palestinian suicide bombers are the same as the French Resistance in WW2?...Plaaaaaaaeeeeeze

We aren't talking about suicide bombers. All the complaints you made were about palestinians hiding in civilian areas. Suicide bombers don't fight in palestinian civilian areas. Let's be clear: you critize the palestenian resistance/insurgence/whatever combat methods. in their urban areas by: hiding there, setting up bases there, firing from civilian homes, and not wearing uniforms. We're not talking about suicide bombers. We're talking about gerrilla fighters (the ones that pick up an AK-47). I pointed out to you that this list of complaints could be compared to the french's tactics for resistance of world war 2 (Mainly: no uniform, based in civilian population). I also pointed out the absurdity of not doing these tactics. In another thread, it was mentioned that Great Britain was prepared to do terrorist like cells for resistance against Germany if they ever invaded.

These tactics you cry out against are typical of guerrila fighters and other resistance/rebellion/revolution throughout the modern world and history. Now that I restated my rebutal, your turn.

Gem
 
Mycroft:
"The problem, as I see it, is that it’s not just the one issue. Every defensive measure Israel takes receives the same unfair criticism. Killing a terrorist is characterized as assassination or revenge. If a civilian gets killed in the process, then Israel is accused of doing it on purpose or the action gets labeled as terrorist. When Israel seals its borders, the cry goes up of the economic devastation caused to the Palestinian-Arabs, when Israel opens them up again, the critics say it’s not enough. Checkpoints designed to capture terrorists before they get into Israel are bashed for being humiliating to Arabs. When Israel does Bite the Bullet and give concessions, it’s criticized as being not enough or duplicitous no matter how much is conceded and how little they get in return."
_________________________________________________

"Checkpoints designed to capture terrorists before they get into Israel are bashed for being humiliating to Arabs."

Of course, you prove that you know you're talking nonense when you say that this is a defensive measure. These "checkpoints" are illegal institutions in someone else's land, which Israel illegally invaded and illegally holds. The checkpoints are there to stop armed resistance against an Occupation of which they are a principal component.

You see? A perfect tautology. In your mind, if we are to believe you are sincere, the checkpoints are a defence against attacks provoked by the checkpoints. Of course, you don't believe this because you're presumably not irrational.

Because you say such ridiculous things, I`m really tempted to label you a troll...this should not surprise you.

"When Israel seals its borders, the cry goes up of the economic devastation caused to the Palestinian-Arabs, when Israel opens them up again, the critics say it’s not enough. "

This must also be a joke. Israel never seals its borders. It seals its legal borders yet still occupies other people's land. If it genuinely did seal its borders, after withdrawing behind them, there would be no problem.

This, of course, is the defensive option that would be genuine, and for which Israel would receive no criticism -to obey the law, withdraw its troops, and stop oppressing the Palestinians. That would remove the cause of Palestinian violence and attacks against Israel would cease. The Occupation is NOT a defensive act, it is the cause of the problem. If you want Israelis to stop being killed, press in every way you can for Israel to get off Palestinian land. It really is as simple as that.

Of course, Israel doesn't do this -and for a simple reason. The costs to Israeli civilians are outweighed by the interests of the Israeli comprador class and the US Government. The Israeli Government needs the Occupied Territories for purely imperial reasons -mainly water. The US needs to keep Israel frightened and insecure because it wouldn`t make such a good military base if it wasn't.

That is the cold, hard truth -it is the Israeli and US Governments who are willing to let Israelis get blown up in cafes etc. because it is "a price worth paying".

These are all elementary facts. It requires amazing dedication on your part not to see them.
Ever thought of demoting yourself to Sherlock?
 
it wouldn`t make such a good military base if it wasn't.

Since when did the US have bases in Isreal? Don't you think the Arab world would go up in flames if the US had troops defending Isreal?

Gem
 
"Since when did the US have bases in Isreal? Don't you think the Arab world would go up in flames if the US had troops defending Isreal?"

I didnt make myself clear.
Israel is the American presence in the Middle East, just take a look at the aid it receives.
If you note, I didn`t say "bases", I said "base". Figuratively speaking, Israel is not overly adverse to being one huge American base so long as their interests coincide. It`s America`s Sparta in the ME.
 
I didnt make myself clear.
Israel is the American presence in the Middle East, just take a look at the aid it receives.
If you note, I didn`t say "bases", I said "base". Figuratively speaking, Israel is not overly adverse to being one huge American base so long as their interests coincide. It`s America`s Sparta in the ME.

Oh! That makes much more sense, thank you.

This is a great example of how you can mis understand someone else's claim.

Gem
 
Originally posted by demon
Of course, you prove that you know you're talking nonense when you say that this is a defensive measure. These "checkpoints" are illegal institutions in someone else's land, which Israel illegally invaded and illegally holds. The checkpoints are there to stop armed resistance against an Occupation of which they are a principal component.

You see? A perfect tautology. In your mind, if we are to believe you are sincere, the checkpoints are a defence against attacks provoked by the checkpoints. Of course, you don't believe this because you're presumably not irrational.

I think it’s funny that you ascribe to me the same circular logic you need to support your own point of view. The defensive measures defend against the attacks caused by the defensive measures. Of course, in your own mind, you avoid the cognitive dissonance such reasoning creates with the artifice of denying that the defensive measures are, in fact, defensive.

The attacks are a result of the Intifada ordered by Arafat after the failure of Camp David in 2000. It is absurd to claim that I believe them to be caused by Israeli defense against the attacks when that is at the heart of your belief system.

Originally posted by demon
Because you say such ridiculous things, I`m really tempted to label you a troll...this should not surprise you.

Of course it wouldn’t surprise me. Nothing you could say would surprise me. Nothing. Really.

Originally posted by demon
This must also be a joke. Israel never seals its borders. It seals its legal borders yet still occupies other people's land. If it genuinely did seal its borders, after withdrawing behind them, there would be no problem.

You mean these legal borders?

The problem is that there are so many borders to choose from. The one in the above link is the most legally binding one I can find, having been agreed to by both Israel and Jordan back in 1994 (and there is a similar one between Israel and Egypt) but I don’t think it would be very satisfying to the Palestinian-Arabs, do you? You imply that the 1948 armistice line is a legal border, but it’s not; it’s an armistice line, and if Israel were to withdraw to it you know damn well they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing further to the UN partition plan boundary, and if they withdrew to that, they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing to the west side of the border with the Mediterranean Sea.

Originally posted by demon
This, of course, is the defensive option that would be genuine, and for which Israel would receive no criticism -to obey the law, withdraw its troops, and stop oppressing the Palestinians. That would remove the cause of Palestinian violence and attacks against Israel would cease. The Occupation is NOT a defensive act, it is the cause of the problem. If you want Israelis to stop being killed, press in every way you can for Israel to get off Palestinian land. It really is as simple as that.

It’s the definition of Palestinian land that’s the issue. Some definitions are pretty encompassing.

Originally posted by demon
Of course, Israel doesn't do this -and for a simple reason. The costs to Israeli civilians are outweighed by the interests of the Israeli comprador class and the US Government. The Israeli Government needs the Occupied Territories for purely imperial reasons -mainly water. The US needs to keep Israel frightened and insecure because it wouldn`t make such a good military base if it wasn't.

Comprador class?!

Pure fantasy. Only a conspiracy-theory fruitcake would believe that the United States keeps Israel as a military base when they have to ask Israel to stay out of every conflict that comes along.

Oh yeah, interesting to note that you resent Israel having access to water.

Originally posted by demon
These are all elementary facts. It requires amazing dedication on your part not to see them.
Ever thought of demoting yourself to Sherlock?

Your handle is aptly chosen too.
 
Mycroft said:


The problem is that there are so many borders to choose from. The one in the above link is the most legally binding one I can find, having been agreed to by both Israel and Jordan back in 1994 (and there is a similar one between Israel and Egypt) but I don’t think it would be very satisfying to the Palestinian-Arabs, do you? You imply that the 1948 armistice line is a legal border, but it’s not; it’s an armistice line, and if Israel were to withdraw to it you know damn well they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing further to the UN partition plan boundary, and if they withdrew to that, they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing to the west side of the border with the Mediterranean Sea.


You want to watch that you don't slide down that slippery slope into the sea yourself. Withdrawing to the green line does not mean that Israel will cease to exist by next April. The fact is, Palestine and Israel need each other. Israel has the technology, but not the population, Palestine has the population but not the technology. After Oslo, the economic interdependence of the countries was growing. In case you hadn't noticed, besides there being more deaths since Sharon came to power, the ecnomies of both countries stink worse than ever.
 
Originally posted by a_unique_person
You want to watch that you don't slide down that slippery slope into the sea yourself. Withdrawing to the green line does not mean that Israel will cease to exist by next April. The fact is, Palestine and Israel need each other. Israel has the technology, but not the population, Palestine has the population but not the technology. After Oslo, the economic interdependence of the countries was growing. In case you hadn't noticed, besides there being more deaths since Sharon came to power, the ecnomies of both countries stink worse than ever.

How do you miss the point so consistently? Is English down under really so different? I wasn’t saying withdrawal to the Green Line would make Israel cease to exist, I was saying that the critics of Israel would not be satisfied no matter what she did.
 
Mycroft said:


How do you miss the point so consistently? Is English down under really so different? I wasn’t saying withdrawal to the Green Line would make Israel cease to exist, I was saying that the critics of Israel would not be satisfied no matter what she did.

Cleopatra is a critic.
 
Mycroft said:


Go back and read it again.

I was saying that the critics of Israel would not be satisfied no matter what she did.

You imply that the 1948 armistice line is a legal border, but it’s not; it’s an armistice line, and if Israel were to withdraw to it you know damn well they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing further to the UN partition plan boundary, and if they withdrew to that, they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing to the west side of the border with the Mediterranean Sea.
 
a_unique_person said:
Go back and read it again.

I know you have a problem with ideas that are similar but not the same, but do you get it now or do I have to explain it to you?
 
Mycroft said:
I know you have a problem with ideas that are similar but not the same, but do you get it now or do I have to explain it to you?


I truely believe that some consider blowing up a bus in Tel Aviv or a restaurant in Haifa full of unarmed civilians is 'resistance' to Israeli 'occupation'. But by blowing up a bus in Tel Aviv or a restaurant in Haifa full of unarmed civilians what is one resisting? The bus fare?...the menu selections?

Then when the IDF goes into Nablus to blow up the suicide bomber's house that is blamed as the cause of suicide bombing.

The IDf operations are so great an offence that families eating pizza just have to die.

Then the bogus term "cycle of violence" is applied. Meaning the suicide bombing is equal to the bombers house being blown up or suicide bombing is equal to the checkpoints, or suicide bombing is equal to settlements, etc, etc.

See the strange part is that if the IDF goes into the West Bank or Gaza that is called a "crime against humanity"....if a palestinian blows up a bus it is called 'resistance'.

Crazy situational ethics are in play here.
 
zenith-nadir said:



I truely believe that some consider blowing up a bus in Tel Aviv or a restaurant in Haifa full of unarmed civilians is 'resistance' to Israeli 'occupation'. But by blowing up a bus in Tel Aviv or a restaurant in Haifa full of unarmed civilians what is one resisting? The bus fare?...the menu selections?

Then when the IDF goes into Nablus to blow up the suicide bomber's house that is blamed as the cause of suicide bombing.

The IDf operations are so great an offence that families eating pizza just have to die.

Then the bogus term "cycle of violence" is applied. Meaning the suicide bombing is equal to the bombers house being blown up or suicide bombing is equal to the checkpoints, or suicide bombing is equal to settlements, etc, etc.

See the strange part is that if the IDF goes into the West Bank or Gaza that is called a "crime against humanity"....if a palestinian blows up a bus it is called 'resistance'.

Crazy situational ethics are in play here.
There sure is something crazy in your post...

Answer me just one question: how do you retaliate against a suicide bombing, when the guilty party died in the attack?(see, the word "suicide" means "to kill yourself")
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom