Originally posted by The Fool
yes... the false goal that zionists see any possibility of any other fate than subjugation for the palestinians.
.
Really? What exactly do you think a Zionist is?
Originally posted by The Fool
In that case I humbly apologise if you were offended and ask you to tell us all what, in your opinion, is the limit of Israels expansion.
If you’re asking my opinion on what a fair and just border between Israel and a potential future state of Palestine should be, my honest answer is
I don’t care. Really.
There are many potential solutions to this issue, and a two-state solution is only one of them. At the moment, it is getting the most attention and it’s likely to be implemented. Whatever solution is implemented, if ever, I want it to be one that provides for the safety and security of all peoples involved. As for preferring one solution over another, wanting a border to jig here or jag there, the bottom line is
I’m an American and Israel is very far away. I’ve never been there, and I don’t know anybody that lives there.
Originally posted by The Fool
are they just historical curiosities mycroft? There are plenty of people who still subscribe to them, are you not one of them? Are Zionists misguided?
Unless you are trying to suggest I have stated this I would encourage you not to copy the methods of "skeptic" I don't see the point in straw man conspiracy theories.
Unbelievable!
In response to my pointing out that your referring to hundred year old maps as though they were relevant today is absurd, you do it again and then deny doing it
in the very next paragraph!
Originally posted by The Fool
At who's expence mycroft? It sounds like a noble romantic adventure when you state it in childrens bible story style....What about the small group of people that didn't want to be invaded, evicted and looted?.
One of the things I’ve noticed that conspiracy theories have in common is the assumption that anything that happens is always the intended consequence of someone’s planning. The law of
unintended consequences never applies. Do you think your ancestors first came to the shores of Australia with the
plan of spending the next two hundred years killing the natives? I don’t think so, I bet they just wanted a place to put a farm. Sure, that meant the natives couldn’t use that specific piece of land anymore, but Australia is so big and a farm, or even a town, is so tiny by comparison, it doesn’t seem like very much is being taken away. Do you think anyone stopped to think what effect that tiny action would have when it was multiplied by a few hundred thousand?
Contrast that to the earliest days of Zionism. The year is 1881 and about 35,000 people fleeing persecution in Russia come to Palestine and build a community. Do they just pick a spot and start building? Do they just take the land away from the natives? No, they
purchased land.
At who’s expense?
I don’t know, I can’t see a victim here. I don’t see anything fundamentally wrong with moving to another country, buying some land, and building a community. World history is filled with the migrations of people. The only thing different about Zionist migration is that they didn’t all come from one place. Does that change anything? I don’t see how.
Originally posted by The Fool
This fence is designed to separate palestinians from land not terrorists from Israelis. It is a structure designed to enforce and formalise land confiscation..... So, when future outposts and settlements continue to take more and more palestinian land will it be ok to say that the fence surrounding those new settlements will also be "probably pretty close to the new borders"
1) The fence is to block terrorism. It’s a non-violent solution to a very ugly problem.
2) It’s a fence, it can be moved or taken down.
3) There is no “Palestinian land” until there is a “Palestine” to govern it. If Arafat had lived up to his obligations under Oslo, Palestine would have been formed in 1998. If he hadn’t walked away from Camp David in 2000, there would have been another opportunity to form a state called Palestine.