One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Originally posted by The idea
This is just speculation on my part, but perhaps the answer is the amount on their side of the fence. Of course, that's based on the assumption that the fence would be difficult to move. Is that true?

That's a fair question.

One of the controversies surrounding the fence is that the Palestinian-Arabs and their apologists say it’s an attempt to create new borders that would prejudice future negotiations. The Israelis say it’s just a fence and it can be taken down or moved.

Overall, the fence follows the borders pretty closely except in some areas where it loops into Palestinian-Arab territory to protect some Israeli settlements. I posted a map in some other threads, later I’ll pm it to you if you want a look.

The overall answer to your question is yes, it’s probably pretty close to what a future border would be. Hopefully, in the event such a thing is ever negotiated, the fence will no longer be necessary.
 
Mycroft said:

Crap, I quoted it back at you and put it in my signature. What more do you want? Should I come visit and tattoo it on your forehead? It’s time for the true goals of Zionism to be clearly identified…

well, sorry but I don't think its an unreasonable thing to miss...."its time for the true goals of zionism to be clearly identified" is a racist statement is it? what a jolly joker you are becoming. I suppose "its time for the true goals of hamas to be clearly identified" is racist too? I always have to be mindfull of the fact that you don't see anything racist in refering to palestinians as bloodthirsty savages....Lol, selective vision must be a very handy power.

True goals, huh? Are you contrasting them with some false goals?

yes... the false goal that zionists see any possibility of any other fate than subjugation for the palestinians


You see, you didn’t ask my opinion of a fair and just border between Israel and a potential future state of Palestine should be. If you had, you would have gotten an honest straightforward answer. Instead, you asked, ”Is Israel marching relentlessly on towards the Zionist goal of occupying the entire mandate plus all of the Jordanians part of the Jordan valley plus the Golan plus southern Lebanon plus the west bank and Gaza.”


In that case I humbly apologise if you were offended and ask you to tell us all what, in your opinion, is the limit of Israels expansion.



They published maps a hundred years ago. Just like your ancestors, they had grand ideas some of which turned out great, others didn’t. So what? The world has changed a lot since then. Of what relevance are they today except as historical curiosities?

are they just historical curiosities mycroft? There are plenty of people who still subscribe to them, are you not one of them? Are Zionists misguided?


Oh yeah, I forgot. Jewish thought never changes, it never progresses. If a Jew said it a hundred years ago, you know there must still be a secret cabal of Jews hidden away somewhere diligently working away to make it a reality.

Unless you are trying to suggest I have stated this I would encourage you not to copy the methods of "skeptic" I don't see the point in straw man conspiracy theories.



Oh, okay. Now it’s me personally. I must be part of the cabal. I must be following a directive of the Grand Zionist Conspiracy never to define the limits of Zionist aspirations otherwise the secret would be out. It’s in the handbook you get when you reach the 4th circle of the conspiracy.

Or I could just be some guy on a computer in some backwater town in the Midwestern United States.



The ultimate goal is world domination, didn’t you read the book? Control the money, control the media, control the politicians and pit all the goyim against each other. No evil is too vile to be contemplated. That must be it, right?

your straw men are much more entertaining than "skeptics"




It couldn’t be that that a small group of people just wanted a place where they didn’t have to worry that the next change in the political wind might bring on a new series of persecutions. No, it couldn’t be. That would make them seem too human, too much like everybody else.

At who's expence mycroft? It sounds like a noble romantic adventure when you state it in childrens bible story style....What about the small group of people that didn't want to be invaded, evicted and looted?
 
Mycroft said:


The overall answer to your question is yes, it’s probably pretty close to what a future border would be. Hopefully, in the event such a thing is ever negotiated, the fence will no longer be necessary.
probably pretty close? would you have a problem if it wasn't? This fence is designed to separate palestinians from land not terrorists from Israelis. It is a structure designed to enforce and formalise land confiscation..... So, when future outposts and settlements continue to take more and more palestinian land will it be ok to say that the fence surrounding those new settlements will also be "probably pretty close to the new borders"

Once again I have to ask, when is enough enough? How much more is to be annexed? What it Israels final territorial demands in the middle east?
 
Originally posted by The Fool
yes... the false goal that zionists see any possibility of any other fate than subjugation for the palestinians.
.

Really? What exactly do you think a Zionist is?

Originally posted by The Fool
In that case I humbly apologise if you were offended and ask you to tell us all what, in your opinion, is the limit of Israels expansion.

If you’re asking my opinion on what a fair and just border between Israel and a potential future state of Palestine should be, my honest answer is I don’t care. Really.

There are many potential solutions to this issue, and a two-state solution is only one of them. At the moment, it is getting the most attention and it’s likely to be implemented. Whatever solution is implemented, if ever, I want it to be one that provides for the safety and security of all peoples involved. As for preferring one solution over another, wanting a border to jig here or jag there, the bottom line is I’m an American and Israel is very far away. I’ve never been there, and I don’t know anybody that lives there.

Originally posted by The Fool
are they just historical curiosities mycroft? There are plenty of people who still subscribe to them, are you not one of them? Are Zionists misguided?

Unless you are trying to suggest I have stated this I would encourage you not to copy the methods of "skeptic" I don't see the point in straw man conspiracy theories.

Unbelievable! In response to my pointing out that your referring to hundred year old maps as though they were relevant today is absurd, you do it again and then deny doing it in the very next paragraph!

Originally posted by The Fool
At who's expence mycroft? It sounds like a noble romantic adventure when you state it in childrens bible story style....What about the small group of people that didn't want to be invaded, evicted and looted?.

One of the things I’ve noticed that conspiracy theories have in common is the assumption that anything that happens is always the intended consequence of someone’s planning. The law of unintended consequences never applies. Do you think your ancestors first came to the shores of Australia with the plan of spending the next two hundred years killing the natives? I don’t think so, I bet they just wanted a place to put a farm. Sure, that meant the natives couldn’t use that specific piece of land anymore, but Australia is so big and a farm, or even a town, is so tiny by comparison, it doesn’t seem like very much is being taken away. Do you think anyone stopped to think what effect that tiny action would have when it was multiplied by a few hundred thousand?

Contrast that to the earliest days of Zionism. The year is 1881 and about 35,000 people fleeing persecution in Russia come to Palestine and build a community. Do they just pick a spot and start building? Do they just take the land away from the natives? No, they purchased land.

At who’s expense?

I don’t know, I can’t see a victim here. I don’t see anything fundamentally wrong with moving to another country, buying some land, and building a community. World history is filled with the migrations of people. The only thing different about Zionist migration is that they didn’t all come from one place. Does that change anything? I don’t see how.

Originally posted by The Fool
This fence is designed to separate palestinians from land not terrorists from Israelis. It is a structure designed to enforce and formalise land confiscation..... So, when future outposts and settlements continue to take more and more palestinian land will it be ok to say that the fence surrounding those new settlements will also be "probably pretty close to the new borders"

1) The fence is to block terrorism. It’s a non-violent solution to a very ugly problem.

2) It’s a fence, it can be moved or taken down.

3) There is no “Palestinian land” until there is a “Palestine” to govern it. If Arafat had lived up to his obligations under Oslo, Palestine would have been formed in 1998. If he hadn’t walked away from Camp David in 2000, there would have been another opportunity to form a state called Palestine.
 
Mycroft said:


Really? What exactly do you think a Zionist is?


There are, of course, many types. The ones who seem to be calling the tune are the ones who want all of the 'traditional' or mythological boundaries of Israel.





If you’re asking my opinion on what a fair and just border between Israel and a potential future state of Palestine should be, my honest answer is I don’t care. Really.

There are many potential solutions to this issue, and a two-state solution is only one of them. At the moment, it is getting the most attention and it’s likely to be implemented. Whatever solution is implemented, if ever, I want it to be one that provides for the safety and security of all peoples involved. As for preferring one solution over another, wanting a border to jig here or jag there, the bottom line is I’m an American and Israel is very far away. I’ve never been there, and I don’t know anybody that lives there.



Unbelievable! In response to my pointing out that your referring to hundred year old maps as though they were relevant today is absurd, you do it again and then deny doing it in the very next paragraph!



One of the things I’ve noticed that conspiracy theories have in common is the assumption that anything that happens is always the intended consequence of someone’s planning. The law of unintended consequences never applies. Do you think your ancestors first came to the shores of Australia with the plan of spending the next two hundred years killing the natives? I don’t think so, I bet they just wanted a place to put a farm. Sure, that meant the natives couldn’t use that specific piece of land anymore, but Australia is so big and a farm, or even a town, is so tiny by comparison, it doesn’t seem like very much is being taken away. Do you think anyone stopped to think what effect that tiny action would have when it was multiplied by a few hundred thousand?

Contrast that to the earliest days of Zionism. The year is 1881 and about 35,000 people fleeing persecution in Russia come to Palestine and build a community. Do they just pick a spot and start building? Do they just take the land away from the natives? No, they purchased land.

At who’s expense?

I don’t know, I can’t see a victim here. I don’t see anything fundamentally wrong with moving to another country, buying some land, and building a community. World history is filled with the migrations of people. The only thing different about Zionist migration is that they didn’t all come from one place. Does that change anything? I don’t see how.



1) The fence is to block terrorism. It’s a non-violent solution to a very ugly problem.

2) It’s a fence, it can be moved or taken down.

3) There is no “Palestinian land” until there is a “Palestine” to govern it. If Arafat had lived up to his obligations under Oslo, Palestine would have been formed in 1998. If he hadn’t walked away from Camp David in 2000, there would have been another opportunity to form a state called Palestine.

The land of the people who live there. They are people, you are committing genocide by sophistry.
 
Mycroft said:


Really? What exactly do you think a Zionist is?

In my view it is a person that believes someone has the right to land because a god promised it to them.....


If you’re asking my opinion on what a fair and just border between Israel and a potential future state of Palestine should be, my honest answer is I don’t care. Really.

fair enough at least we know that you don't care.



Unbelievable! In response to my pointing out that your referring to hundred year old maps as though they were relevant today is absurd, you do it again and then deny doing it in the very next paragraph!

deny doing what? I have reread this thread and can't find anywhere that I have denied that the zionist vision of an Israel occupying the entire british mandate and more is very old indeed...maybe you can point out to me when the zionist movement dropped this Idea? Or is saying that Zionists exist a conspiracy theory in itself?



One of the things I’ve noticed that conspiracy theories have in common is the assumption that anything that happens is always the intended consequence of someone’s planning. The law of unintended consequences never applies.

Is it your suggestion that Israel is accidentally expanding? Is the IDF in the west bank because they took a wrong turn?


Do you think your ancestors first came to the shores of Australia with the plan of spending the next two hundred years killing the natives? I don’t think so, I bet they just wanted a place to put a farm. Sure, that meant the natives couldn’t use that specific piece of land anymore, but Australia is so big and a farm, or even a town, is so tiny by comparison, it doesn’t seem like very much is being taken away. Do you think anyone stopped to think what effect that tiny action would have when it was multiplied by a few hundred thousand?

Once again you refer to Australia. I honestly can't see the point you are trying to make. The First British to arrive proclaimed "Terra nullius" (no ones land) They simply erased the indiginous population from any consideration with one proclaimation. The natives were viewed as part of the wildlife...A common zionist line about palestine was "a land with no people for a people with no land" they also liked the myth that there was nobody in the way. Is this the comparison you want to make?

Contrast that to the earliest days of Zionism. The year is 1881 and about 35,000 people fleeing persecution in Russia come to Palestine and build a community. Do they just pick a spot and start building? Do they just take the land away from the natives? No, they purchased land.

At who’s expense?

I don’t know, I can’t see a victim here. I don’t see anything fundamentally wrong with moving to another country, buying some land, and building a community. World history is filled with the migrations of people. The only thing different about Zionist migration is that they didn’t all come from one place. Does that change anything? I don’t see how.

I don't disagree with your summary of the early migration of people to palestine....but what happened when it dawned on zionists that there were an awful lot of Arabs there...the "arab problem" (what a lovely expression). They were then stuck in a bind. Democracy? how can this be achieved if there is not a Jewish majority? No point in establishing a homeland for displaced people if they don't control it. The only way to retain a majority is to drive out the Arabs at the point of a gun... That is the point where the dream turned sour. When the oppressed were willing to become the oppressors.


1) The fence is to block terrorism. It’s a non-violent solution to a very ugly problem.

Terrorists are going to be stopped by a wall? The Atlantic ocean can't keep terrorists out of America...

2) It’s a fence, it can be moved or taken down.
Or not built...but you are right. Once its job is finished, ending all possibility of a palestinian nation on the west bank, it will most likely be removed....

3) There is no “Palestinian land” until there is a “Palestine” to govern it.

"a land with no people for a people with no land"

If Arafat had lived up to his obligations under Oslo, Palestine would have been formed in 1998. If he hadn’t walked away from Camp David in 2000, there would have been another opportunity to form a state called Palestine.

lol...that is just a sick joke mycroft. The "offer" was just silly. Have you ever looked at the "offer"? Splintered fragments surrounded and crossed by fences, restricted roads, military posts, settlements...It was simply a fomalisation of the occupation. The creation of a large ghetto.
 
a_unique_person said:



And your completely irrelevant point is?

1) Because 5 settlers attacked some Rabbis in October 2003 it justifies Arafat's corruption?

2) Because 5 settlers attacked some Rabbis in October 2003 it justifies armed terror groups marching in the streets of Gaza?

3) Because 5 settlers attacked some Rabbis in October 2003 it justifies suicide bombing?

4) Because 5 settlers attacked some Rabbis in October 2003 it justifies why the Palestinians chose terrorism to negotiate and the Australian Aboriginies did not?

5) Because 5 settlers attacked some Rabbis in October 2003 it justifies blowing up a Fulbright Scolarship Convoy in Gaza killing three Americans?


Which one a_unique_person?
 
The Fool said:
Once again I have to ask, when is enough enough? How much more is to be annexed? What it Israels final territorial demands in the middle east?



This argument always makes me laugh...

"What is Israels final territorial demands in the middle east?"


Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Egypt = 3,249,912 sq km

...and....

Israel = 20,330 sq km



Wow, look how much land Israel has, they've pretty well taken over the entire middle east....;).....better go stop them the fool!
 
Suicide bomber kills 7 in Jerusalem


Sunday, February 22, 2004 - CNN - JERUSALEM (CNN) -- A suicide bomber on Sunday killed at least seven passengers on a crowded bus in Jerusalem at the height of rush hour, according to police in the city and Israeli ambulance services.

Jerusalem police spokesman Gil Kleiman said the suicide bomber also died in the terrorist attack, which wounded more than 50 people, 11 of them seriously.

One of the people killed in the attack was an 18-year-old high school student identified by the Jerusalem daily Haaretz as Lior Azulai, a pupil at the Gymnasia Rehavia. Nine other students at the school were wounded in the blast, Haaretz reported.

The Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades -- the military offshoot of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat's Fatah movement -- claimed responsibility for the blast in a statement.

So what was the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades "resisting" on the Egged number 14 bus?

1) occupation?

2) the price of bus fare?

3) the anti-terrorist barrier?

4) an IDF incursion into Gaza?

If they are "resisting" an IDF incursion into Gaza why don't they go after the IDF? What do kids going to school and passengers on the #14 bus today have to do with an IDF incursion into Gaza ?

Herein lies the bizzare logic of the palestinian terror groups. If all Israeli civilians are legit targets for the Palestinians, then all Palestinians should be legit targets because of the Hamas, Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Fatah Tanzim and Islamic Jihad....Those are the 'rules' the Palestinian terror groups are playing by.

But it gets even better,

Chief Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erakat condemned Sunday's attack. "We condemn this attack and once again we urge the United States, and other members of the Quartet [Russia, EU and U.N.] to exert every possible effort to revive the peace process and put it back on track," Erakat said,

See how clever that is.

The Palestinians condemn the attack that they failed to stop and lay the responsibility on the United States, and other members of the Quartet [Russia, EU and U.N.] for failing to exert every possible effort to revive the peace process.

Very savvy P.R. All the responsibility is taken off the Palestinian Authority by Saeb Erakat. And here is the problem with Saeb Erakat, some here, and the Palestinian Authority....a complete lack of responsibility for the current situation.
 
Here is a snapshot of life with suicide bombers;

Police close Maxim restaurant after security flaw

Police issued a closure order to Haifa's Maxim restaurant, the scene of a suicide attack on October 4 in which 21 people were killed, after a policewoman wearing a dummy explosive belt successfully entered the restaurant after she was checked by a security guard.

Haifa Police Chief Asst. Cmdr. Nir Meriesh told the Jerusalem Post that the inspection was part of routine police work.

"It is a serious [security] flaw and the restaurant owners are to be held responsible," Meriesh said. "We issued the closure order for thirty days until they come up with an alternative security plan."


Imagine if the Maxim restaurant was in New York City and the NYPD had to have policemen go around wearing dummy explosive belts to check New York's restaurant security systems!...wow, what a crazy mixed up world...
 
ZN:
"So what was the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades "resisting" on the Egged number 14 bus?

1) occupation?

2) the price of bus fare?

3) the anti-terrorist barrier?

4) an IDF incursion into Gaza?

If they are "resisting" an IDF incursion into Gaza why don't they go after the IDF? What do kids going to school and passengers on the #14 bus today have to do with an IDF incursion into Gaza ?

Herein lies the bizzare logic of the palestinian terror groups. If all Israeli civilians are legit targets for the Palestinians, then all Palestinians should be legit targets because of the Hamas, Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Fatah Tanzim and Islamic Jihad....Those are the 'rules' the Palestinian terror groups are playing by.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Just more proof of the abject failure of the zionist project.

And if you want anybody to take you seriously here, you'll have to start posting articles about pregnant Palestinian women who lose their unborn children at checkpoints and then ask pointless rhetorical questions about what the Israeli Defence Fascists were trying to achieve by keeping her at the checkpoint all day.
 
demon said:
Just more proof of the abject failure of the zionist project.

And if you want anybody to take you seriously here, you'll have to start posting articles about pregnant Palestinian women who lose their unborn children at checkpoints and then ask pointless rhetorical questions about what the Israeli Defence Fascists were trying to achieve by keeping her at the checkpoint all day.

Chill out demon ok? Today's attack was condemned even by the Palestinian authority.

If God exists and he has some pity in him will make the injured die. I have read some stories about the injured that I started thinking that those who died were the lucky ones.

May God forgive this person who spread horror and may he rest in peace.

edited to re-write a phrase in English
 
Cleo:
"Chill out demon ok? Today's attack was condemned even by the Palestinian authority."

I know that, why are you telling me? I`m also aware of the reasons they gave for it too. Why don`t you direct that comment at some of the others here who don`t seem to know it?

As an aside, would it be racist of me to ask you where and when in your own mind, the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends?
I`m not saying you think there should be a "Greater Israel". I`m just asking if you think this question is "founded in racism" and if you do, then why.
Haven't you heard? Jews who criticize Israeli policy have internalised the perverse value systems of their oppressors and thus subconsciously hate their own Jewishness. (What other rational explanation could there be, after all?) Hence the term "self-hating Jew" or "Jewish anti-Semite."
There's a lot of it about.
 
Originally posted by demon
Mycroft, are these racist questions?

To a Nazi -"can you tell us where/when the desire for a "thousand year Reich and liebensraum" ends?"

No, but putting this question to a German of today would be. By taking statements, ideas, political aspirations out of context of time and situation without regard to the changes of history, you can demonize anyone. Would it be fair for me to criticize the Democratic party based on positions from decades ago? Would it be fair to criticize the Catholic Church for positions taken centuries ago? No rational person would think so.
 
Originally posted by The Fool
In my view it is a person that believes someone has the right to land because a god promised it to them.....

In your view, huh? Did you ever bother to look it up and find out? Did you ever stop and consider that your definition applies to both sides?


Originally posted by The Fool
fair enough at least we know that you don't care.

I care about the people. Jewish and Arab. I want to see a solution that brings peace and security to everybody. The violence and killing is sickening, but it’s also sickening to see the double standards that are applied, to see Israel and only Israel vilified for defending itself in war and from terrorism.

Originally posted by The Fool deny doing what? I have reread this thread and can't find anywhere that I have denied that the zionist vision of an Israel occupying the entire british mandate and more is very old indeed...maybe you can point out to me when the zionist movement dropped this Idea? Or is saying that Zionists exist a conspiracy theory in itself?

The problem isn’t that you don’t recognize that the ideas are old, the problem is that you take some vague fantasy from a century ago and pretend that it has relevance today. Do you really think it’s rational to look at some map from 1920 and say that it proves that Israel wants to conquer Jordan today? That can’t possibly be supported unless you believe that Zionist thought, unlike any other group, never changes.


Originally posted by The Fool
Is it your suggestion that Israel is accidentally expanding? Is the IDF in the west bank because they took a wrong turn?

No, but that’s a nice straw man. What I’m saying is that those early Zionists didn’t anticipate a century of conflict any more than your or my ancestors anticipated the consequences to the natives of their settlements.

Originally posted by The Fool
Once again you refer to Australia. I honestly can't see the point you are trying to make. The First British to arrive proclaimed "Terra nullius" (no ones land) They simply erased the indiginous population from any consideration with one proclaimation. The natives were viewed as part of the wildlife...A common zionist line about palestine was "a land with no people for a people with no land" they also liked the myth that there was nobody in the way. Is this the comparison you want to make?

Not comparison, contrast. Your ancestors just showed up and declared the land free for the taking because the natives didn’t have the same concepts of land ownership that the Europeans did. The early Zionists, by contrast, worked within the framework of the government in place by purchased land from its owners, and negotiated with the government in charge. This behavior you describe as invading, evicting and looting.


Originally posted by The Fool
I don't disagree with your summary of the early migration of people to palestine....but what happened when it dawned on zionists that there were an awful lot of Arabs there...the "arab problem" (what a lovely expression). They were then stuck in a bind. Democracy? how can this be achieved if there is not a Jewish majority? No point in establishing a homeland for displaced people if they don't control it. The only way to retain a majority is to drive out the Arabs at the point of a gun... That is the point where the dream turned sour. When the oppressed were willing to become the oppressors.

What happened when it dawned on the Arabs that there were an awful lot of Jews there? What happened to the British when it dawned on them they had made seemingly conflicting promises to two different peoples? What happened to those Zionists when it dawned on them they had the armies of five Arab nations coming at them with the purpose of obliterating them as a people?

You agree that there is nothing wrong with buying land and creating a settlement, you agree that there is nothing wrong with a people migrating to seek safety, but you then turn around and characterize defending that land, defending your people against an invasion as the oppressed becoming the oppressors. Outrageous!


Originally posted by The Fool
Terrorists are going to be stopped by a wall? The Atlantic ocean can't keep terrorists out of America...

And police don’t stop crime, should we get rid of them?

The wall works. It’s virtually shut down terrorism from the Gaza Strip and it’s reducing terrorism from the West Bank. Will it stop it completely? No, but it will stop a lot.
 
zenith-nadir said:




This argument always makes me laugh...

"What is Israels final territorial demands in the middle east?"


Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Egypt = 3,249,912 sq km

...and....

Israel = 20,330 sq km



Wow, look how much land Israel has, they've pretty well taken over the entire middle east....;).....better go stop them the fool!
It makes you laugh does it? but you won't answer it.....Can I then assume that you believe Israel has the right to take whatever land it can get away with? Anything you can manage short of triggering a US invasion?;)
 
demon said:
I know that, why are you telling me?

I am telling you because since you live so far away I expected you had some respect for the victims. You can continue tomorrow which is another day.

As an aside, would it be racist of me to ask you where and when in your own mind, the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends?

Well, it's well known in this forum that I am not afraid of question and above all I am not afraid to give a honest answer.

Haven't you heard? Jews who criticize Israeli policy have internalised the perverse value systems of their oppressors and thus subconsciously hate their own Jewishness. (What other rational explanation could there be, after all?) Hence the term "self-hating Jew" or "Jewish anti-Semite."
There's a lot of it about.

People that claim such things do not believe in Yahweh but in Saint Elsewhere.
 
"No, but putting this question to a German of today would be. By taking statements, ideas, political aspirations out of context of time and situation without regard to the changes of history, you can demonize anyone. Would it be fair for me to criticize the Democratic party based on positions from decades ago? Would it be fair to criticize the Catholic Church for positions taken centuries ago? No rational person would think so."

You seem to be implying that the desire/intent for a greater Israel is some sort of historical curiosity. As it isn`t it would seem by your own reasoning that the original question was perfectly legitimate.

Likud members speaking at a Likud Party meeting June 2003..

Gilad Erdan, Knesset member:
"Dear Brothers. Go up every mountian. Seize every hill. It`s not an occupation. It`s Zionism."

Eli Shitrit code named "Commandar Elizar" from his Irgun days:
recited an anthem which says that both the west bank and the east bank of the Jordan are "ours".
He said "You (Sharon) were not elected on a personal ticket but as Likud`s representative...That`s why you have no right to announce redines to give the Palestinians a state, whatever the conditions and restrictions might be".

Uzi Landau, Likud Cabinet Minister:
"How is it that you, a prime minister in Israel, offers to give land of our forefathers to strangers".

Seems the intent to establish a Jewish state both sides of the Jordan is still the Likud`s anthem. It`s not such an outdated idea after all. The fuzzy reasons you give for questions being "founded in racism" because they address some long lost historical issue don`t apply here but we all really knew that anyway, didn`t we? The question was and is, do you sing from the same hymn sheet?
So we all know, I`ll ask you again: Mycroft, in your own mind, can you tell us where/when the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends?
 
Mycroft said:

The early Zionists, by contrast, worked within the framework of the government in place by purchased land from its owners, and negotiated with the government in charge. This behavior you describe as invading, evicting and looting.

I'm trying to be patient.....exactly where did I describe purchasing of land from its owners as "invading, evicting and looting" I said it in connection to this statement of yours

"It couldn’t be that that a small group of people just wanted a place where they didn’t have to worry that the next change in the political wind might bring on a new series of persecutions. No, it couldn’t be. That would make them seem too human, too much like everybody else.

It seems the "small group of people" was quite happy to drive out the original population at the point of a gun to ensure thier majority...Later in the thread you stated that when they first arrived they purchased thier land and I agreed with that. It was when they realised that imigration was not going to provide enough people to comfortably outnumber the "arab problem" that the solution of ethnic cleansing was implemented.
To claim I described the purchasing of land to live on as "Invading, evicting and looting" is simply dishonest....why do you do that? You even highlight your fabrication in your very next statement where you tell me I have no problem with land purchase...Oh what a tangled web we weave eh? Which one is it...I have no problem with land purchase or I think its Invading, evicting and looting?





You agree that there is nothing wrong with buying land and creating a settlement, you agree that there is nothing wrong with a people migrating to seek safety, but you then turn around and characterize defending that land, defending your people against an invasion as the oppressed becoming the oppressors. Outrageous!

Once again this is simply not true.

here is what I said..

"The only way to retain a majority is to drive out the Arabs at the point of a gun... That is the point where the dream turned sour. When the oppressed were willing to become the oppressors."

Now where am I characterising "defending that land, defending your people against an invasion" as the oppressed becoming the oppressors"????

I clearly stated (don't know how I could have been any clearer) that I was refering to the eviction of Arabs at gunpoint.....Why do you constantly misrepresent my statements.

I have grown to expect this from Zenith-nadir who thinks quoting half sentences is clever, I have come to expect it from "skeptic" because he lives in a fantasy world anyway.....But you too? I spend more time in these pointless Middle East threads correcting misrepresentations of my statements than I spend actually making the statements....

[/B]
 
Cleo:
"I am telling you because since you live so far away I expected you had some respect for the victims. You can continue tomorrow which is another day."

Hold on a minute here; ZN jumps on todays attack in Israel to score cheap political points and I answer him and I`m the one not showing respect? If I had dived on here to use it an an example of the failure of the Israeli policy then fair enough but I didn`t. I don`t get it.

Cleo:
"Well, it's well known in this forum that I am not afraid of question and above all I am not afraid to give a honest answer."

Well, I take it then that you don`t find my original question to Mycroft as "founded in racism" and reject his characherization of Jews who might ask this question as being the same "as children who are abused and women who are raped", who "often develop feelings that it’s their fault, that they did something wrong".
He seems to think Jews who question expansionist policy are suffering from some psychological disorder.
There he goes again. He gets better all the time doesn`t he?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom