One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Zero said:
There sure is something crazy in your post...

Answer me just one question: how do you retaliate against a suicide bombing, when the guilty party died in the attack?(see, the word "suicide" means "to kill yourself")


Suicide bombings are always claimed by one Palestinian organization or another. It is one of the most hideous acts a human being can commit...suicide AND murder at the same time...

Suicide bombers leave videos, pictures, statements, get bombs made, are smuggled into Israel...all that takes planning, organization and money...therefore someone is helping them.

If you want me to believe that the average palestinian knows how to manufacture a bomb and uses thier own money and can smuggle themselves into Israel without help then you are delusional.


So here are your choices.


1) Target the organizations who help the suicide bombers.

2) Target the organizations that finance the suicide bombers.

3) Arrest or kill the planners and facilitators of the suicide bombers.

4) Show an effect for suicide bombing -- checkpoints, closures, destroying the bombers house are examples of saying "if you suicide bomb here is the repercussion"

5) Try to thwart the suicide bomber infiltrations by building physical barriers.



Or would you be happier Zero if Israel just acted like Assad did in Hama Syria or Saddam did in Halabja and just wipe out 10,000 people in one move and be done with it all.
 
See, you try to pretend you are rational, and then you trip yourself up with your own words.

How does murdering a dead criminal's family, or his neighbors, punish the dead criminal? You have repeatedly said "destroy the bomber's house"...the bomber is dead, are you saying that an appropriate response is to at best make his wife and kids homeless, or at worse kill them and anyone standing too close to the building?
 
Zero said:
See, you try to pretend you are rational, and then you trip yourself up with your own words. How does murdering a dead criminal's family, or his neighbors, punish the dead criminal? You have repeatedly said "destroy the bomber's house"...the bomber is dead, are you saying that an appropriate response is to at best make his wife and kids homeless, or at worse kill them and anyone standing too close to the building?



Well theres a really cool thing called "time" Zero.

"Time" didn't start yesterday, or the day before or the day before that even.

And there was a "time" when Israel didn't destroy the bombers house Zero. They tried other ways to stop the suicide bombers.

Some examples are;

Agreement on the Gaza Strip and the Jericho Area, May 94.

Agreement on the Preparatory Transfer of Powers and Responsibilities, Aug 94.

Interim Agreement between Israel and the Palestinians, September 28 1995.

The Wye River Memorandum, Oct 98.

The Sharm el-Sheikh Memorandum, Sept 99.

Protocol Concerning Safe Passage between the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, Oct 99.

Israeli-Palestinian Joint Statement (Taba), Jan 2001.

The Tenet cease-fire, Jun 2001.

Beirut Declaration on Saudi Peace Initiative, Mar 2002.



....But guess what Zero, those "other methods" didn't stop the suicide bombers... and when those methods failed to stop suicide bombers from blowing up in Israel, Israel chose Sharon and chose to start destroying bombers houses as a punishment.


Crazy huh?
 
Zero said:
See, you try to pretend you are rational, and then you trip yourself up with your own words.

How does murdering a dead criminal's family, or his neighbors, punish the dead criminal? You have repeatedly said "destroy the bomber's house"...the bomber is dead, are you saying that an appropriate response is to at best make his wife and kids homeless, or at worse kill them and anyone standing too close to the building?

They don't kill the criminal's family and neighbors, you just destroy the house.

It is a very controversial measure, but the reason for it is that the families of suicide-bombers get enormous financial benefits for raising a shaheed. They get a cash award, their debts are paid off, and they get a continuing pension for the rest of their lives. The purpose of knocking down a house is to take away this financial incentive to raise suicide-bombers.
 
Mycroft said:
They don't kill the criminal's family and neighbors, you just destroy the house.

It is a very controversial measure, but the reason for it is that the families of suicide-bombers get enormous financial benefits for raising a shaheed. They get a cash award, their debts are paid off, and they get a continuing pension for the rest of their lives. The purpose of knocking down a house is to take away this financial incentive to raise suicide-bombers.



I don't think Zero remembers Saddam's $25,000 for suicide bombers families or that the Hamas supports the families of "martyrs"....
 
Zero said:
See, you try to pretend you are rational, and then you trip yourself up with your own words.

How does murdering a dead criminal's family, or his neighbors, punish the dead criminal? You have repeatedly said "destroy the bomber's house"...the bomber is dead, are you saying that an appropriate response is to at best make his wife and kids homeless, or at worse kill them and anyone standing too close to the building?

You dont think that there could be a deterrant? The PA, Hamas, Saddam in his day, lionised, financially supported etc the families of the suicide bombers. If you see little hope for your family, but at the cost of your own life you could "strike a blow for the cause" and far from leaving your dependants in the lurch, actually improve their finances, their status in the community etc. Targetting bombers homes isnt just punishing dead bombers. It discourages new ones.

(heck - life insurance policies dont tend to cover suicide - can you figure out why for extra credit?)

It would be better if the bombers assets could be siezed and liquidated and donated to victims of terror (on either side) but short of that - which seems a bit impractical - a policy of deterance has some logic behind it (you could argue the dependants are innocents/accomplices - should they / shouldn't they be targets-, and its certainly a far from perfect solution but its also a far from perfect, and rather messy situation).

(heck - life insurance policies dont tend to cover suicide - can you figure out why for extra credit?)
 
zenith-nadir said:



If wanting to punish suicide bombing innocent civilians is insane Zero then I am certifiable.
You sure are...because the person who committed the crime is dead. That is a fact you seem to miss.
 
Zero said:
You sure are...because the person who committed the crime is dead. That is a fact you seem to miss.



So in Zero's world once the suicide bomber blows themselves up all responsibility dies with the bomber? The planners, financiers, bombmakers and smugglers who facilitated the bomber's mission are absolved of all responsibility?

:nope:
 
Originally posted by Zero
You sure are...because the person who committed the crime is dead. That is a fact you seem to miss.

In a sense, the suicide-bomber is a victim too of the terror networks that recruit him, indoctrinate him, train him, arm him and smuggle him to his target. The individual bomber is just a tool, the real responsibility lay with the terrorists that use him.
 
zenith-nadir said:




So in Zero's world once the suicide bomber blows themselves up all responsibility dies with the bomber? The planners, financiers, bombmakers and smugglers who facilitated the bomber's mission are absolved of all responsibility?

:nope:
No, but making victims of his children is no solution either. You want to take out terrorist camps, sieze assets of the financiers, etc? Perfect, sounds like a grand idea. Leave the children out of it.
 
Zero said:
No, but making victims of his children is no solution either. You want to take out terrorist camps, sieze assets of the financiers, etc? Perfect, sounds like a grand idea. Leave the children out of it.


I wish the IDF didn't have to blow up houses Zero. I wish the IDF didn't have to protect Israel from the north, south, east and west. I wish the world never heard of the PLO, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Hizbollah, Al Aksa Martyrs Brigade, Fatah and Tanzim. I wish alot of things.

But guess what?...they exsist, there are groups who are not fighting Israeli 'oppression', they are only interested in killing as many jews as possible and destroying Israel....and these groups blow up arab and jewish Israelis, they don't distinguish between the two...and they have to be stopped so that an Arab Israeli who wants to own a restaurant or a jewish family from America eating pizza on holiday in Jerusalem doesn't have to pay for it with their lives.
 
Originally posted by zenith-nadir
I wish the IDF didn't have to blow up houses Zero. I wish the IDF didn't have to protect Israel from the north, south, east and west. I wish the world never heard of the PLO, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Hizbollah, Al Aksa Martyrs Brigade, Fatah and Tanzim. I wish alot of things.

And that’s really the bottom line here is that it’s not reasonable to expect perfect solutions in an imperfect world. Yes, it would be great if somehow it were possible to only punish bad people in a way that innocents were never affected, but that doesn’t happen anywhere.

War is by its very nature brutal and ugly. People get hurt, innocents suffer. When there is terrorism involved, it gets even uglier, more brutal. There are no easy solutions.

And let’s not forget that innocents suffer on both sides.
 
zenith-nadir said:



I wish the IDF didn't have to blow up houses Zero. I wish the IDF didn't have to protect Israel from the north, south, east and west. I wish the world never heard of the PLO, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Hizbollah, Al Aksa Martyrs Brigade, Fatah and Tanzim. I wish alot of things.

But guess what?...they exsist, there are groups who are not fighting Israeli 'oppression', they are only interested in killing as many jews as possible and destroying Israel....and these groups blow up arab and jewish Israelis, they don't distinguish between the two...and they have to be stopped so that an Arab Israeli who wants to own a restaurant or a jewish family from America eating pizza on holiday in Jerusalem doesn't have to pay for it with their lives.

Once again, the only lives that matter are those lost in Israel. The West Bank and Gaza are like a different universe, they don't exist.
 
Originally posted by a_unique_person
Once again, the only lives that matter are those lost in Israel. The West Bank and Gaza are like a different universe, they don't exist.

Interesting how you can turn an expression of sympathy for the Palestinian-Arabs into its exact opposite. How did you develop such selectivity in your reading skills?

A question that’s been nagging at me for a few days: In Australian lingo, is the word unique used as a euphemism in the same way that the word special is used the United States?

Maybe you’re not the best person to ask, but if another of the Australian crew sees this, I’d be interested to learn the answer.
 
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by demon
Of course, you prove that you know you're talking nonense when you say that this is a defensive measure. These "checkpoints" are illegal institutions in someone else's land, which Israel illegally invaded and illegally holds. The checkpoints are there to stop armed resistance against an Occupation of which they are a principal component.

You see? A perfect tautology. In your mind, if we are to believe you are sincere, the checkpoints are a defence against attacks provoked by the checkpoints. Of course, you don't believe this because you're presumably not irrational.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I think it’s funny that you ascribe to me the same circular logic you need to support your own point of view. The defensive measures defend against the attacks caused by the defensive measures. Of course, in your own mind, you avoid the cognitive dissonance such reasoning creates with the artifice of denying that the defensive measures are, in fact, defensive.

The attacks are a result of the Intifada ordered by Arafat after the failure of Camp David in 2000. It is absurd to claim that I believe them to be caused by Israeli defense against the attacks when that is at the heart of your belief system.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by demon
Because you say such ridiculous things, I`m really tempted to label you a troll...this should not surprise you.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Of course it wouldn’t surprise me. Nothing you could say would surprise me. Nothing. Really.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by demon
This must also be a joke. Israel never seals its borders. It seals its legal borders yet still occupies other people's land. If it genuinely did seal its borders, after withdrawing behind them, there would be no problem.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You mean these legal borders?

The problem is that there are so many borders to choose from. The one in the above link is the most legally binding one I can find, having been agreed to by both Israel and Jordan back in 1994 (and there is a similar one between Israel and Egypt) but I don’t think it would be very satisfying to the Palestinian-Arabs, do you? You imply that the 1948 armistice line is a legal border, but it’s not; it’s an armistice line, and if Israel were to withdraw to it you know damn well they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing further to the UN partition plan boundary, and if they withdrew to that, they would get the same criticism for not withdrawing to the west side of the border with the Mediterranean Sea.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by demon
This, of course, is the defensive option that would be genuine, and for which Israel would receive no criticism -to obey the law, withdraw its troops, and stop oppressing the Palestinians. That would remove the cause of Palestinian violence and attacks against Israel would cease. The Occupation is NOT a defensive act, it is the cause of the problem. If you want Israelis to stop being killed, press in every way you can for Israel to get off Palestinian land. It really is as simple as that.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It’s the definition of Palestinian land that’s the issue. Some definitions are pretty encompassing.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by demon
Of course, Israel doesn't do this -and for a simple reason. The costs to Israeli civilians are outweighed by the interests of the Israeli comprador class and the US Government. The Israeli Government needs the Occupied Territories for purely imperial reasons -mainly water. The US needs to keep Israel frightened and insecure because it wouldn`t make such a good military base if it wasn't.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Comprador class?!

Pure fantasy. Only a conspiracy-theory fruitcake would believe that the United States keeps Israel as a military base when they have to ask Israel to stay out of every conflict that comes along.

Oh yeah, interesting to note that you resent Israel having access to water.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by demon
These are all elementary facts. It requires amazing dedication on your part not to see them.
Ever thought of demoting yourself to Sherlock?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


That's quite an easy post to respond to, since you haven't really said much of substance, Mycroft.

For you to argue that the current attacks are simply the result of the current Intifada is to be wilfully blind. As you well know, this is the second intifada and Palestinian armed resistance has been going on since 1967. The current intifada is just the latest phase of the resistance against the Occupation. The cause of all the Palestinian violence is the Occupation -or are you seriously suggesting that, if Israel withdrew to its legal, 1967 borders that the situation wouldn`t change as far as Palestinian attacks are concerned?

The checkpoints are not a defensive measure -they are a measure of population control -designed to restrict freedom of movement and to cripple Palestinian economic activity. That they have a ancillary security function is entirely dependent on the continuance of the Occupation.

Your argument that there are a variety of legal borders to choose from is not correct. Israel's legally binding borders were specified in UNGAR 181 and reinforced by UNSCR 242.
The Israel Jordan Treaty has no bearing on the borders since Israel, in that Treaty, made decisions about territory over which it has no jurisdiction. The only reason Jordan signed the Treaty is that niether state has been in favour of an indpendent Palestinian State and both saw the treaty as a way of preventing large scale population transfer (by signing the Treaty, Israel agreed not to forcibly transfer the Palestinians to Jordan, while Jordan agreed not to allow Palestinian refugees in Jordan to return to Palestine).
The idea that Israel can sign a treaty which affects land that does not belong to it is forbade by UNGAR 1514, which was passed in 1960.

My argument that Israel is the US's policeman on the block is not a fantasy -simply the straightforward military analysis which has applied for decades. A peaceful Israel is worthless to the US. Israel's value stems from its function as a modern day Sparta: It has an advanced military, is technologically sophisticated, but doesn't have an independent economy. Therefore, it is reliable and can perform tasks unacceptable to other clients, such as supporting genocide in Guatemala, and acting as a base for US power projection in the Middle East. This it has done very well, and, for the most part, very obediently -a point you tellingly make yourself when you rightly state that Israel has stayed out of conflicts when it hasn't suited the US's purposes.

Israel has also acquired various secondary functions: it has been a conduit for US clandestine action in African states as well as providing arms and training (on the US's behalf) to various thrid world dictatorships. In fact Israel was the frontline state in the US's (and UK's), fight to undermine sanctions against Apartheid South Africa and was the main contact with the SA military. All of this only works, so long as the Israeli population are frightened and are willing to serve the function America wants it to. If that ever stops, the US will transfer its funding (probably to Turkey, perhaps one day to a compliant Iraq), and Israel will become what it would be without US subsidy -Luxembourg, effectively. If you'd like to learn about this, I suggest, for a start, you read "Issues Arising Out of the Situation in the Near East,” (29th July, 1958, Foreign Relations of the United States, 1958-1960, Vol.XII ) or "The United States and the Israeli Lobby" by Clinton Fernandes.

As for your final point, I don't resent Israel having water -that's just a cheap shot by you. What I resent is Israel stealing water from territory that isn't its own and, in the process, depriving other people. According to the Israeli Human Rights group, B't selem, Israeli per capita water consumption if four to five times that in the Occupied Territories and results from a policy of discrimination.
(http://www.btselem.org/english/water/consumption_gap_eng.asp)

The Israeli military also enforce a permits system which bars Palestinians from drilling wells in their own territory and amount to a tool of racial discrimination
(http://www.btselem.org/english/water/control_over _water_eng.asp).

All of this (and I'm just scratching the surface) is a clear violation of Article 27 of the Fourth Geneva Convention
(http://www.btselem.org/english/water/international_law_eng.asp)

Incidentally, water is the principle reason for the Occupation (as is also a major guiding principle behind much of Israel's actions, annexations (Lebanon and Mount Hermon and the Litani river, deals with Jordan and Turkey), etc. Much of this motivation is detailed by Yossi Beilin, the former Labor Party Minister in his study of internal Government documents, "Mechiro shel Ihud".

As I said before, it really does require an amazing dedication on your part keep arguing against the obvious.
Do you discuss any of this with Palestinians Mycroft?
 
Mycroft, in your own mind, you can tell us where/when the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends?
 
demon [/i][B] For you to argue that the current attacks are simply the result of the current Intifada is to be wilfully blind. As you well know said:
Mycroft, in your own mind, you can tell us where/when the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends?

Didn’t you hear? The Jooz want it all! They put it down in this book that was smuggled out of one of their secret meetings a hundred years ago. It talks all about how all us goyim are cattle and they’re going to control the world to ensure their supply of the bones of Christian babies to make their matsa!!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom