One way the fence is good for Palestinian-Arabs

Lets talk about the wall and how it is good for Palestinians.

By NOAM CHOMSKY
Published: February 23, 2004

AMBRIDGE, Mass. — It is a virtual reflex for governments to plead security concerns when they undertake any controversial action, often as a pretext for something else. Careful scrutiny is always in order. Israel's so-called security fence, which is the subject of hearings starting today at the International Court of Justice in The Hague, is a case in point.

Few would question Israel's right to protect its citizens from terrorist attacks like the one yesterday, even to build a security wall if that were an appropriate means. It is also clear where such a wall would be built if security were the guiding concern: inside Israel, within the internationally recognized border, the Green Line established after the 1948-49 war. The wall could then be as forbidding as the authorities chose: patrolled by the army on both sides, heavily mined, impenetrable. Such a wall would maximize security, and there would be no international protest or violation of international law.

This observation is well understood. While Britain supports America's opposition to the Hague hearings, its foreign minister, Jack Straw, has written that the wall is "unlawful." Another ministry official, who inspected the "security fence," said it should be on the Green Line or "indeed on the Israeli side of the line." A British parliamentary investigative commission also called for the wall to be built on Israeli land, condemning the barrier as part of a "deliberate" Israeli "strategy of bringing the population to heel."

What this wall is really doing is taking Palestinian lands. It is also — as the Israeli sociologist Baruch Kimmerling has described Israel's war of "politicide" against the Palestinians — helping turn Palestinian communities into dungeons, next to which the bantustans of South Africa look like symbols of freedom, sovereignty and self-determination.

Even before construction of the barrier was under way, the United Nations estimated that Israeli barriers, infrastructure projects and settlements had created 50 disconnected Palestinian pockets in the West Bank. As the design of the wall was coming into view, the World Bank estimated that it might isolate 250,000 to 300,000 Palestinians, more than 10 percent of the population, and that it might effectively annex up to 10 percent of West Bank land. And when the government of Ariel Sharon finally published its proposed map, it became clear the the wall would cut the West Bank into 16 isolated enclaves, confined to just 42 percent of the West Bank land that Mr. Sharon had previously said could be ceded to a Palestinian state.

The wall has already claimed some of the most fertile lands of the West Bank. And, crucially, it extends Israel's control of critical water resources, which Israel and its settlers can appropriate as they choose, while the indigenous population often lacks water for drinking.

Palestinians in the seam between the wall and the Green Line will be permitted to apply for the right to live in their own homes; Israelis automatically have the right to use these lands. "Hiding behind security rationales and the seemingly neutral bureaucratic language of military orders is the gateway for expulsion," the Israeli journalist Amira Hass wrote in the daily Haaretz. "Drop by drop, unseen, not so many that it would be noticed internationally and shock public opinion." The same is true of the regular killings, terror and daily brutality and humiliation of the past 35 years of harsh occupation, while land and resources have been taken for settlers enticed by ample subsidies.

It also seems likely that Israel will transfer to the occupied West Bank the 7,500 settlers it said this month it would remove from the Gaza Strip. These Israelis now enjoy ample land and fresh water, while one million Palestinians barely survive, their meager water supplies virtually unusable. Gaza is a cage, and as the city of Rafah in the south is systematically demolished, residents may be blocked from any contact with Egypt and blockaded from the sea.

It is misleading to call these Israeli policies. They are American-Israeli policies — made possible by unremitting United States military, economic and diplomatic support of Israel. This has been true since 1971 when, with American support, Israel rejected a full peace offer from Egypt, preferring expansion to security. In 1976, the United States vetoed a Security Council resolution calling for a two-state settlement in accord with an overwhelming international consensus. The two-state proposal has the support of a majority of Americans today, and could be enacted immediately if Washington wanted to do so.

At most, the Hague hearings will end in an advisory ruling that the wall is illegal. It will change nothing. Any real chance for a political settlement — and for decent lives for the people of the region — depends on the United States.

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/02/23/opinion/23CHOM.html?hp
 
NOAM CHOMSKY?....Noam Chomsky?...Hahahahahahahahaha!

Quoting Noam Chomsky Demon on the middle east problem has about as much validity as quoting Jerry Falwell on homosexuality and the Telly Tubbies!

I find it sad and ironic that on the day before the Arabs and Palestinians go to court in the Hauge to fight the "wall" to stop suicide bombers another palestinian blows up a bus full of Israeli civilians.

That is like showing up for court for a DWI completely stone drunk.

As Abba Eben once said; "The Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity".
 
PA envoy to ICJ: Fence prevents ability to create state

Opening the hearing at the International Court of Justice at The Hague on the legality of the West Bank security fence on Monday, the head of the Palestinian delegation said that the security fence prevents the establishment of an independent Palestinian state


Arafat Says No Peace Possible with W. Bank Barrier

Palestinian President Yasser Arafat, in a speech marking World Court hearings on Israel's West Bank barrier, said on Monday no peace was possible unless the screen of fences and walls was removed.



Excuses, excuses, excuses.....once again the Palestinian Authority makes up excuses why they haven't had free and fair elections over the past 10 years, why they haven't had a palestinian constitution over the past 10 years, why they haven't tried to stop the terrorist groups over the past 10 years, why they couldn't negotiate for a peaceful settlement over the past 10 years, why they couldn't stop Palestinian Authority corruption over the past 10 years....

This latest flavor-of-the-day excuse is "the wall", before that it was "IDF raids to stop terror groups", before that it was "checkpoints", before that it was "closures", before that it was "Mossad plots", before that it was "Sharon policies", before that it was the "offer at Camp David", before that it was more excuses, excuses, excuses....
 
ZN:
"I find it sad and ironic that on the day before the Arabs and Palestinians go to court in the Hauge to fight the "wall" to stop suicide bombers another palestinian blows up a bus full of Israeli civilians."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Once again, you seem to assume that "the Palestinians" are some sort of homogenous entity, as with "Israel" and "America". This is something everyone should be careful of, I think, since as somebody pointed out earlier, nations and states are not human beings. "The Palestinians" (have you ever met any ZN?), are a group of people with a common culture who claim the right to live in a certain part of the world. Some Palestinians are suicide bombers. Some are terrorists and fanatics. Most are not - just as most Americans are not gun-toting survivalists or election-stealing oil barons, and most Israelis are not the kind of people who run peaceful protesters over with bulldozers.

It follows, then, that the Palestinian authorities do not necessarily have the power to stop suicide bombers from murdering Israeli citizens, just as the President, Congress and the Senate do not have the power to stop every crime now being committed in the USA - even though the people of the USA, for all their troubles, are in a far less parlous state than the Palestinians. Countries under military occupation by a foreign power are not that easy to keep under control, as the Iraqi experience testifies even now.

"Excuses, excuses, excuses...../...latest flavor-of-the-day excuse is "the wall", before that it was "IDF raids to stop terror groups", before that it was "checkpoints", before that it was "closures", before that it was "Mossad plots", before that it was "Sharon policies", before that it was the "offer at Camp David", before that it was more excuses, excuses, excuses.... " (ZN)

I thought that Mycroft dude was insane but you're 10x worse. A true schizoid.
 
demon said:
Once again, you seem to assume that "the Palestinians" are some sort of homogenous entity, as with "Israel" and "America". This is something everyone should be careful of, I think, since as somebody pointed out earlier, nations and states are not human beings. "The Palestinians" (have you ever met any ZN?), are a group of people with a common cultureArab culture who claim the right or who are forced to, it’s not as though they have a choice.to live in a certain part of the world. Some Palestinians are suicide bombers. Some are terrorists and fanatics. Most are not - just as most Americans are not gun-toting survivalists or election-stealing oil barons, and most Israelis are not the kind of people who run peaceful protesters over with bulldozers. [/B]

I’ll point out that recognizing this diversity in Palestinian, American and Israeli thought makes your assertion that Zionists still harbor secret desires to conquer Jordan even more bizarre.

demon said:
It follows, then, that the Palestinian authorities do not necessarily have the power to stop suicide bombers from murdering Israeli citizens, just as the President, Congress and the Senate do not have the power to stop every crime now being committed in the USA - even though the people of the USA, for all their troubles, are in a far less parlous state than the Palestinians. Countries under military occupation by a foreign power are not that easy to keep under control, as the Iraqi experience testifies even now. [/B]

The difference is that the President, Congress and the Senate, through funding of federal, state and local law enforcement, do make an effort to stop crime. If the Palestinian Authority made any effort at all to stop terrorism, it would be understandable if the efforts were not 100% effective. Instead we have PA officials publicly praising shaheeds and Arafat getting caught passing money to terrorist organizations.
 
Mycroft said:


I’ll point out that recognizing this diversity in Palestinian, American and Israeli thought makes your assertion that Zionists still harbor secret desires to conquer Jordan even more bizarre.


I have pointed out many times that the majority of Israelis are happy to give the Palestinians the West Bank and Gaza for peace, and couldn't care less about the settlers. The vagaries of the Israeli electoral system mean that the majority opinion is ignored.
 
demon said:
You seem to be implying that the desire/intent for a greater Israel is some sort of historical curiosity.Yep. As it isn`t it would seem by your own reasoning that the original question was perfectly legitimate.
Let’s look at your “evidence”.
Likud members speaking at a Likud Party meeting June 2003..

Gilad Erdan, Knesset member:
"Dear Brothers. Go up every mountian. Seize every hill. It`s not an occupation. It`s Zionism."
A clear reference to the disputed territories. Controversial? Yes. Inflammatory? Yes. An indication that Zionism still harbors secret plans on Jordan? No.
Eli Shitrit code named "Commandar Elizar" from his Irgun days:
recited an anthem which says that both the west bank and the east bank of the Jordan are "ours".Imagine! An old warrior singing an old war song! Tell me, if a politician from the deep South sang and old southern Civil War song, would you think he supported a return of the Confederacy and slavery?
He said "You (Sharon) were not elected on a personal ticket but as Likud`s representative...That`s why you have no right to announce redines to give the Palestinians a state, whatever the conditions and restrictions might be".Again, a clear reference to political decisions to be made about the disputed territories. He’s telling Sharon not to overstep his mandate. So?

Uzi Landau, Likud Cabinet Minister:
"How is it that you, a prime minister in Israel, offers to give land of our forefathers to strangers". Another clear reference to the disputed territories. Where does he say there is a plan to march on Jordan?

Seems the intent to establish a Jewish state both sides of the Jordan is still the Likud`s anthem. It`s not such an outdated idea after all.Yet the only evidence you have of that is someone reciting the lyrics of an old song. Are you kidding? The fuzzy reasons you give for questions being "founded in racism" because they address some long lost historical issue don`t apply here but we all really knew that anyway, didn`t we? The question was and is, do you sing from the same hymn sheet?I am the secret Master Zionist that controls the world.
So we all know, I`ll ask you again: Mycroft, in your own mind, can you tell us where/when the desire for a "Greater Israel" ends? Didn’t you read the book? You know the one I’m talking about. It doesn’t end, the world is not enough! Your sons will be my slaves and your daughters will be my whores! Muhahahahaa!

I’ll also take this opportunity to point out the double standard you apply to your evidence. Some Likud party member reciting the words to an old song is “proof” of secret Zionist plans to march on Jordan, but you scoff at the idea that the Palestinian Authority still wants to destroy Israel even though they say so on their website. When it comes to the Palestinian Authority, you will talk about changing times and changing circumstances, but you will shut your eyes and cover your ears if someone points out that editing an HTML page is so very easy, and a simple asterisk with a footnote saying no longer applies would be an indication of a willingness to reconciliation, and that they don’t even make that effort should say something.

One last thing, I ran your quotes through google and came up with zero hits. What's your source?
 
Originally posted by The Fool
I'm trying to be patient.....exactly where did I describe purchasing of land from its owners as "invading, evicting and looting" I said it in connection to this statement of yours

"It couldn’t be that that a small group of people just wanted a place where they didn’t have to worry that the next change in the political wind might bring on a new series of persecutions. No, it couldn’t be. That would make them seem too human, too much like everybody else.

I’m trying your patience? Suddenly you’ve become E.J.Armstrong! My statement was said in connection to this statement of yours:

you must know what that map looks like mycroft... The zionists were showing it to anyone who was interested when they were trying to convince the british..

When were they trying to convince the British? What time period was that? Were they invading anyone then? Does buying land and building a community count as invading? Does it count as evicting and looting? When was the Balfour Declaration? When was the League of Nations Mandate?

I’ll save you the effort of looking it up. The Balfour Declaration was in 1917 and the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine was in 1920. At this period in history, they were buying land and building communities. Nobody was being invaded, evicted or looted.

Originally posted by The Fool
It seems the "small group of people" was quite happy to drive out the original population at the point of a gun to ensure thier majority...Later in the thread you stated that when they first arrived they purchased thier land and I agreed with that. It was when they realised that imigration was not going to provide enough people to comfortably outnumber the "arab problem" that the solution of ethnic cleansing was implemented.

The British, charged with the Mandate for establishing a national home for the Jewish people, placed stiff limitations on Jewish immigration into Palestine even in the 1930’s when anti-Semitism in Europe was on the rise and European Jews were in great danger. At the same time, there was a great deal of Arab immigration into the region, which the British did not restrict.

The issue of a Jewish majority in the region mandated to become a future Jewish state was the lesser issue. The greater issue was that people were dying because they were not allowed to immigrate.

What you characterize as a small group of people driving out the original population was the Israeli war of independence. It was a defensive war against five invading Arab armies launched within 24 hours of the declaration of independence. Prior to and during this war, many Arabs did flee, both on their own and at the urging of the invading Arab armies. Arabs were also expelled who had taken up arms against the new state of Israel, or who had supported those who had. Some also were expelled who should not have been, who were not belligerents. It was a war for survival. Defeat was not an option, and security after victory was of paramount importance.

Even so, it’s worth noting that large Arab populations were not expelled. The 1.1 million Arab-Israelis in Israel today are these Arabs and their descendents.

Originally posted by The Fool To claim I described the purchasing of land to live on as "Invading, evicting and looting" is simply dishonest....why do you do that? You even highlight your fabrication in your very next statement where you tell me I have no problem with land purchase...Oh what a tangled web we weave eh? Which one is it...I have no problem with land purchase or I think its Invading, evicting and looting?

When you talk about Zionists convincing the British you can only be referring to the period of time prior to the Balfour Declaration in 1917. At that time Jews were purchasing land and building communities. If you refer to that time and characterize Jewish activity as invading, evicting and looting, what am I supposed to think?

Originally posted by The Fool Once again this is simply not true.

here is what I said..

"The only way to retain a majority is to drive out the Arabs at the point of a gun... That is the point where the dream turned sour. When the oppressed were willing to become the oppressors."

Now where am I characterising "defending that land, defending your people against an invasion" as the oppressed becoming the oppressors"????

I clearly stated (don't know how I could have been any clearer) that I was refering to the eviction of Arabs at gunpoint.....Why do you constantly misrepresent my statements.

I’ve read it again, and it still reads as you characterizing the Israeli war of independence as the oppressed becoming the oppressors. I call it defending your land and your people from invasion. How am I reading this wrong?

Originally posted by The Fool I have grown to expect this from Zenith-nadir who thinks quoting half sentences is clever, I have come to expect it from "skeptic" because he lives in a fantasy world anyway.....But you too? I spend more time in these pointless Middle East threads correcting misrepresentations of my statements than I spend actually making the statements....

Either everyone else is wrong, or you need to learn a bit more history.
 
Mycroft said:


Either everyone else is wrong, or you need to learn a bit more history.
Whatever.......As I said, I spend more time in these threads correcting misrepresentations of my statements than making the statements in the first place.....
and anyone who thinks that zionists lobbying the british about the borders of the new jewish homeland somehow ended in 1917 needs a serious reality check. And anyway...even if it were true it has squat to do with your straw version of my opinions...and you say Its me that needs to learn a bit more about history?

Anyway...what would us anti-semites know....I give up...
 
Originally posted by Noam Chomsky
As the design of the wall was coming into view, the World Bank estimated that it might isolate 250,000 to 300,000 Palestinians, more than 10 percent of the population, and that it might effectively annex up to 10 percent of West Bank land. And when the government of Ariel Sharon finally published its proposed map, it became clear the the wall would cut the West Bank into 16 isolated enclaves, confined to just 42 percent of the West Bank land that Mr. Sharon had previously said could be ceded to a Palestinian state.

Map of fence.

Be patient. It takes a while to load.
 
The Fool said:

Whatever.......As I said, I spend more time in these threads correcting misrepresentations of my statements than making the statements in the first place.....
and anyone who thinks that zionists lobbying the british about the borders of the new jewish homeland somehow ended in 1917 needs a serious reality check. And anyway...even if it were true it has squat to do with your straw version of my opinions...and you say Its me that needs to learn a bit more about history?

Anyway...what would us anti-semites know....I give up...

Then maybe you could clear this up and show one of these maps?
 
Top 10 Reasons you can't take 'Demon' or 'the fool' seriously.


10) All humans that are jewish are refered to as "zionists".

9) They quote Chomsky as intellectual evidence.

8) They use maps from electronic intifada.

7) They characterize the 1948 war where Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and Egypt attacked Israel simultaneously as "driving out the original population, [palestinians], at the point of a gun to ensure thier majority"

6) They claim "zionists" want to take over the entire middle east.

5) They call Israel 'racist' when they themselves call all jews 'zionists'

4) They call Israel 'apartheid' when they themselves can't stand even one jew living anywhere on the West Bank

3) They refuse to answer the question "After 30 years of Arafat's rule has the quality of life for Palestinians become better or worse?"

2) They feel suicide bombing Israeli civilians far from the battle is 'resistance' because A) Palestinians don't have F-16s or Apaches, B) the settlements, C) the anti-terror wall, D) evil zionist plots.

1) They never ever critisize Arafat or the Palestinian Authority for the plight of the Palestinians or hold them responsible as the leaders of the Palestinians.
 
zenith-nadir said:
Top 10 Reasons you can't take 'Demon' or 'the fool' seriously.


10) All humans that are jewish are refered to as "zionists".

first Lie...please show where I have said this

9) They quote Chomsky as intellectual evidence.

2nd lie please site one time i have quoted him.

8) They use maps from electronic intifada.

3rd lie please show one example

7) They characterize the 1948 war where Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and Egypt attacked Israel simultaneously as "driving out the original population, [palestinians], at the point of a gun to ensure thier majority"

4th lie please show one example of where I have said this.....I believe mycroft decided that when I talked about ethnic cleansing of arabs I was specifically talking about one perticular war...you must be confused...no I take that back, you are probably not confused...this is the 4th lie in a row. That tends to indicate deliberate lying rather than confusion.

6) They claim "zionists" want to take over the entire middle east.

5th lie...not the entire middle east. I said it is the goal of zionism to have israel cover the entire original british mandate...this is the last time I correct you on this topic.


5) They call Israel 'racist' when they themselves call all jews 'zionists'

6th lie....please show me where I have "called israel racist" and show me where I have called all jews zionists.

4) They call Israel 'apartheid' when they themselves can't stand even one jew living anywhere on the West Bank

7th lie....please show me anywhere I have ever mentioned anything about jews living on the west bank????

3) They refuse to answer the question "After 30 years of Arafat's rule has the quality of life for Palestinians become better or worse?"

8th lie...please show me where you have asked me this question and I have refused to answer .....anyway, answering it is easy. The quality of life of palestinians has become much worse in the last 30 years. Arafat is an Idiot, can you think of any other contributing factors in the decline of the palestinians?

2) They feel suicide bombing Israeli civilians far from the battle is 'resistance' because A) Palestinians don't have F-16s or Apaches, B) the settlements, C) the anti-terror wall, D) evil zionist plots.

9th lie... Please quote me saying this.

1) They never ever critisize Arafat or the Palestinian Authority for the plight of the Palestinians or hold them responsible as the leaders of the Palestinians.

10th lie....Now to be fair I can't ask you to quote me not critisizing Arafat or the palestinian authority...I do, people who post here or a little longer than you and have an IQ above room temperature have probably noticed this....If you want to make an issue of it try searching my posts for the word ARAFAT....possibly you could have checked before you shot your mouth but as this is obviously yet another part of your goebbells disinformation campagn it would have been pointless to gather facts first.


So what is it to be ZN...are you going to put up this time....or will this be yet another lie and run effort. This many blatant fabrications in one post is some sort of record....I can't wait to hear your excuses for not being able to find a single shred of evidence to support them....come on doofus...just a single little quote to back up your fantasies...just one.


[/B]
 
Mycroft said:


Then maybe you could clear this up and show one of these maps?
what? you cannot enter eretz israel on a search engine?

ok...if you insist.

firstly the American Zionists movement pointing out one of its goals of jewish people occupying the historic "eretz israel".....A current goal...not some ancient expired desire as you try to present it.

http://www.azm.org/aboutus.html

"The ingathering of the Jewish people in the historic homeland, Eretz Israel, through Aliyah from all countries



here is an interesting map showing the names of the provences east of the jordan.

http://www.us-israel.org/jsource/History/geomap.html

In his Complete Diaries, Vol II, Page 711, Theodor Herzl, the founder of Zionism, says that the area of the Jewish state stretches: "From the Brook of Egypt to the Euphrates."

Rabbi Fischmann, member of the Jewish Agency for Palestine, declared in his testimony to the U.N. Special Committee of Enquiry on July 9, 1947: "The Promised Land extends from the River of Egypt to the Euphrates. It includes parts of Syria and Lebanon."

Here is a definition of what is meant by the common usage term "eretz israel"...from

http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Eretz-Israel

The Land of Israel (Hebrew: Eretz Yisrael) refers to the land making up the ancient Jewish Kingdoms of Israel and Judah. The term has been used by Jews and Christians throughout history. This territory includes the modern State of Israel, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip as well as parts of the modern Kingdom of Jordan, south-western Syria, and southern Lebanon.


I really find it hard to believe that you don't accept the vast majority of zionists believe they have an absolute right to the god given lands. The west bank, Gaza and bits and pieces of Jordan, Syria and lebanon.....God gave it to them and god never mentioned the arabs did he.....Do you ever listen to what modern Zionist are saying? do you read thier published works?
 
Originally posted by The Fool
what? you cannot enter eretz israel on a search engine?

I have, on many occasions. Your whole posts seems to stem from a basic misunderstanding of the term Eratz Israel. You read it like it’s some sort of secret Zionist code word with a sinister meaning. It’s not.
Originally posted by The Fool firstly the American Zionists movement pointing out one of its goals of jewish people occupying the historic "eretz israel".....A current goal...not some ancient expired desire as you try to present it

"The ingathering of the Jewish people in the historic homeland, Eretz Israel, through Aliyah from all countries

Eratz is Hebrew for “land of”. If you take the Hebrew words in that paragraph you quote and translate them to English, it reads: The ingathering of the Jewish people in their historic homeland, the land of Israel, through immigration from all countries.

It doesn’t sound very sinister to me.

Originally posted by The Fool
here is an interesting map showing the names of the provences east of the jordan.

A very interesting historical map.

Originally posted by The Fool
In his Complete Diaries, Vol II, Page 711, Theodor Herzl, the founder of Zionism, says that the area of the Jewish state stretches: "From the Brook of Egypt to the Euphrates."

Rabbi Fischmann, member of the Jewish Agency for Palestine, declared in his testimony to the U.N. Special Committee of Enquiry on July 9, 1947: "The Promised Land extends from the River of Egypt to the Euphrates. It includes parts of Syria and Lebanon."

You know, you make my argument for me. I accuse you of using fifty and hundred year old statements as though they were relevant today, as though Jewish thought never changes, and here you are! Two quotes, one fifty years old, the other one hundred years old.

Yes, those statements were made, they were made a very long time ago when the borders of this “Jewish State” was still vague and undefined, they are no longer relevant in today’s political reality.

Are there still some fruitcakes who subscribe to this vision? Absolutely! Do they represent the majority of Zionist thought? Absolutely not! Are they even a significant voice? Not really. If you talk to them, they tend to have this vague idea that somehow God will make all this happen regardless of what humans do. Some of the Christian Zionists see this vision of “greater Israel” as becoming a reality after the “rapture” after the Messiah has come back, presumably by then all the Jews and Muslims will have become Christians.
Originally posted by The Fool
Here is a definition of what is meant by the common usage term "eretz israel"...from

http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Eretz-Israel

The Land of Israel (Hebrew: Eretz Yisrael) refers to the land making up the ancient Jewish Kingdoms of Israel and Judah. The term has been used by Jews and Christians throughout history. This territory includes the modern State of Israel, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip as well as parts of the modern Kingdom of Jordan, south-western Syria, and southern Lebanon.

I’m so very disappointed in you, Fool. I expect lies and half-truths from the likes of Demon and AUP, but I thought you had more intellectual honesty than that. Why would you quote only part of a definition? Here is the rest of it:
During the British Mandate of Palestine, the name Eretz Yisrael (abbreviated Aleph-Yod), was part of the official name of the territory, when written in Hebrew.

Consequently, in its modern usage, the term usually denotes only those parts of the land which came under the British mandate, i.e. the land currently occupied by Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip, and sometimes also Transjordan (currently occupied by the Kingdom of Jordan).

And frankly, that’s not a very good definition. Transjordan is an archaic term, and what kind of idiot would say that Jordan is occupied by the Kingdom of Jordan? As that site gets it’s articles from user contributions, it’s not surprising that some of them are not as good as others.

Eratz Israel translates to “land of Israel”. The precise definition of this will change depending on the context and the time period you’re referring to. If I said Eratz Israel in reference to the bible, obviously I’d be talking about the ancient kingdom of the Israelites, which is different from the Eratz Israel of the British Mandate period which is different from the Eratz Israel of modern Israel today.

Check out a modern usage of the term:

http://ohr.edu/a/study/derech/love.htm

They offer tours for people who want to become acquainted with Eratz Israel. the tour includes:

The scenic Jordan Valley, swimming in Tiberias, feeling the holy mysticism of Ancient Tzefat, walking in the Old Jewish Quarter in Jerusalem (including the Kotel Tunnel Tour), climbing Masada, visiting an authentic Bedouin camp (and riding camels), hiking and swimming at Ein Gedi, visiting Yad Vashem (Israel's holocaust museum), crawling through the Bar Kochba caves, etc.

Now, I invite you to check out these locations on a map and see where they are.


Originally posted by The Fool
I really find it hard to believe that you don't accept the vast majority of zionists believe they have an absolute right to the god given lands. The west bank, Gaza and bits and pieces of Jordan, Syria and lebanon.....God gave it to them and god never mentioned the arabs did he.....Do you ever listen to what modern Zionist are saying? do you read thier published works?

No. While there are Zionists who are Zionists for purely religious reasons, the vast majority of Zionists are not. Perhaps the difficulty is with your understanding of what Zionism is.

Zionism was a movement to establish a homeland for the Jewish people in the Holy Land. It was a response to anti-Semitism worldwide, the very same anti-Semitism that culminated in the murder of millions of Jews. Its goal was to create a refuge; one that history has proven was badly needed.

Modern Zionism is the support for the continued existence and defense of Israel.

Within these frameworks, the old goal to create a Jewish State and the modern goal to preserve it, there is a wide variety of opinion, methods and goals. To fixate only on the religious aspect is to adopt a very skewed perception of what Zionism is as a whole.
 
Mycroft said:


I have, on many occasions. Your whole posts seems to stem from a basic misunderstanding of the term Eratz Israel. You read it like it’s some sort of secret Zionist code word with a sinister meaning. It’s not.

Are you seriously suggesting that the term Eretz Israel is used in any context to mean the modern boundries of Israel? I'd love to see some examples...I liked the one example you claim supports this interpretation of "Eretz Israel"...a tourist itinerary...lol, pardon me for laughing but sheeeeesh...is this all you can find? I suppose if you were taking groups of Jewish American tourists around historic jewish ruins you would march them through the west bank and Gaza? Lol....Mycroft, don't ever start a tour company.

you also casually dismiss the words of the founders of Zionism as if they were some irrelevant historic curiosity...do you have the same dismissive attitude to the words of the founding fathers of America? I don't think so...

To suggest that the overwelming central theme of Zionism is some sort of ancient curiosity that nobody takes seriously is a long stretch indeed....Once again I ask, do you spend much time reading current zionist material?

And just to sum up you pull up this additional material defining the term "eretz israel"


During the British Mandate of Palestine, the name Eretz Yisrael (abbreviated Aleph-Yod), was part of the official name of the territory, when written in Hebrew.

Consequently, in its modern usage, the term usually denotes only those parts of the land which came under the British mandate, i.e. the land currently occupied by Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip, and sometimes also Transjordan (currently occupied by the Kingdom of Jordan).

and claim I was dishonestly hiding it....why? because it apparently reinforces your theory that Eretz Israel should be interpreted as meaning only the current modern borders of Israel????

Please continue to do this as I sometimes miss some stuff that reinforces my position and its nice of you to gather it for me.


Mycroft you can continue to try to massage reality into some sort of version of Zionism that does not include a desire to occupy the promised land....the fact that this is what zionism was founded to achieve seems to be irrelevant. The fact that this goal is a foundationstone of modern zionism is apparently irrelevant. The fact that all actions of Zionists in Israel appear to be moving towards that goal is irrelevant

The conclusive fact is apparently that tour group brochure....
 
originally posted by Mycroft
I’m trying your patience? Suddenly you’ve become E.J.Armstrong!

Asking you to justify your own claims is trying your patience?

Modern Zionism is the support for the continued existence and defense of Israel.
Do you have a definition for the land of Israel as implied in this definition?
 
The Fool said:
Are you seriously suggesting that the term Eretz Israel is used in any context to mean the modern boundries of Israel? It translates to land of Israel.. You tell me how that should be interpreted. I'd love to see some examples...I liked the one example you claim supports this interpretation of "Eretz Israel"...a tourist itinerary...lol, pardon me for laughing but sheeeeesh...is this all you can find? The first example I came across that wasn’t in a historical context.I suppose if you were taking groups of Jewish American tourists around historic jewish ruins you would march them through the west bank and Gaza? Lol....Mycroft, don't ever start a tour company.

you also casually dismiss the words of the founders of Zionism as if they were some irrelevant historic curiosity...do you have the same dismissive attitude to the words of the founding fathers of America? I don't think so...It depends on the statement. Thomas Jefferson raised doubts that negro slaves had the intellectual capacity of whites, yes I dismiss that. It was based on a perception of a people who, being slaves, had not the opportunity to develop their intellectual abilities. Even more enduring documents, such as the Constitution of the United States of America have gone through 200+ years of interpretation based on new political and cultural realities. Are you telling me that there are no writings of the first settlers of Australia that are no longer relevant?

To suggest that the overwelming central theme of Zionism is some sort of ancient curiosity that nobody takes seriously is a long stretch indeed....Once again I ask, do you spend much time reading current zionist material?The overwhelming central theme of Zionism was the establishment of a homeland and refuge for the Jewish people. That has been accomplished, but the support for the continued existence and defense of that state is very much a central theme of Zionism today. Pointing to 50 and 100 year old statements as evidence to the contrary makes no more sense than pointing to 50 and 100 year old statements of Australian politicians as evidence of what current Australian political thought is. That it seems natural and reasonable for you to do this for this one group of people is what I point to as bias.

and claim I was dishonestly hiding it....why? because it apparently reinforces your theory that Eretz Israel should be interpreted as meaning only the current modern borders of Israel????Not only did you cherry pick a questionable definition, but having done so you only quoted part of that definition. Honest?

Mycroft you can continue to try to massage reality into some sort of version of Zionism that does not include a desire to occupy the promised land....the fact that this is what zionism was founded to achieve seems to be irrelevant. The fact that this goal is a foundationstone of modern zionism is apparently irrelevant. The fact that all actions of Zionists in Israel appear to be moving towards that goal is irrelevant. All actions? Including the peace agreements between Jordan and Egypt? Withdrawing from the Sinai Peninsula?

The conclusive fact is apparently that tour group brochure....
 
demon said:
Lets talk about the wall and how it is good for Palestinians.

By NOAM CHOMSKY
Published: February 23, 2004

AMBRIDGE, Mass. — It is a virtual reflex for governments to plead security concerns when they undertake any controversial action, often as a pretext for something else. Careful scrutiny is always in order. Israel's so-called security fence, which is the subject of hearings starting today at the International Court of Justice in The Hague, is a case in point.

Few would question Israel's right to protect its citizens from terrorist attacks like the one yesterday, even to build a security wall if that were an appropriate means. It is also clear where such a wall would be built if security were the guiding concern: inside Israel, within the internationally recognized border, the Green Line established after the 1948-49 war. The wall could then be as forbidding as the authorities chose: patrolled by the army on both sides, heavily mined, impenetrable. Such a wall would maximize security, and there would be no international protest or violation of international law.

This observation is well understood. While Britain supports America's opposition to the Hague hearings, its foreign minister, Jack Straw, has written that the wall is "unlawful." Another ministry official, who inspected the "security fence," said it should be on the Green Line or "indeed on the Israeli side of the line." A British parliamentary investigative commission also called for the wall to be built on Israeli land, condemning the barrier as part of a "deliberate" Israeli "strategy of bringing the population to heel."

What this wall is really doing is taking Palestinian lands. It is also — as the Israeli sociologist Baruch Kimmerling has described Israel's war of "politicide" against the Palestinians — helping turn Palestinian communities into dungeons, next to which the bantustans of South Africa look like symbols of freedom, sovereignty and self-determination.

Even before construction of the barrier was under way, the United Nations estimated that Israeli barriers, infrastructure projects and settlements had created 50 disconnected Palestinian pockets in the West Bank. As the design of the wall was coming into view, the World Bank estimated that it might isolate 250,000 to 300,000 Palestinians, more than 10 percent of the population, and that it might effectively annex up to 10 percent of West Bank land. And when the government of Ariel Sharon finally published its proposed map, it became clear the the wall would cut the West Bank into 16 isolated enclaves, confined to just 42 percent of the West Bank land that Mr. Sharon had previously said could be ceded to a Palestinian state.

The wall has already claimed some of the most fertile lands of the West Bank. And, crucially, it extends Israel's control of critical water resources, which Israel and its settlers can appropriate as they choose, while the indigenous population often lacks water for drinking.

Palestinians in the seam between the wall and the Green Line will be permitted to apply for the right to live in their own homes; Israelis automatically have the right to use these lands. "Hiding behind security rationales and the seemingly neutral bureaucratic language of military orders is the gateway for expulsion," the Israeli journalist Amira Hass wrote in the daily Haaretz. "Drop by drop, unseen, not so many that it would be noticed internationally and shock public opinion." The same is true of the regular killings, terror and daily brutality and humiliation of the past 35 years of harsh occupation, while land and resources have been taken for settlers enticed by ample subsidies.

It also seems likely that Israel will transfer to the occupied West Bank the 7,500 settlers it said this month it would remove from the Gaza Strip. These Israelis now enjoy ample land and fresh water, while one million Palestinians barely survive, their meager water supplies virtually unusable. Gaza is a cage, and as the city of Rafah in the south is systematically demolished, residents may be blocked from any contact with Egypt and blockaded from the sea.

It is misleading to call these Israeli policies. They are American-Israeli policies — made possible by unremitting United States military, economic and diplomatic support of Israel. This has been true since 1971 when, with American support, Israel rejected a full peace offer from Egypt, preferring expansion to security. In 1976, the United States vetoed a Security Council resolution calling for a two-state settlement in accord with an overwhelming international consensus. The two-state proposal has the support of a majority of Americans today, and could be enacted immediately if Washington wanted to do so.

At most, the Hague hearings will end in an advisory ruling that the wall is illegal. It will change nothing. Any real chance for a political settlement — and for decent lives for the people of the region — depends on the United States.

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/02/23/opinion/23CHOM.html?hp


Ah! Like all Chomsky writings, he ends with the same old basic tired theme; "if you are a thoughtful and reasonable reader you will plainly see that it's all the USA's fault"

Indeed...if continued Israeli security is our fault then I am a proud American that we have helped our little friend defeat the combined military might of the Arab world. While bus bombings may never end, at least the Jewish citizens of Israel have no fear of being defeated militarily as long as we are with them.

Thanks Demon and Chomsky....you've both given me yet further good reasons to vote proudly for George W. Bush come November. ;)

-z
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom