On Again Off Again Airfones

Well done Ron.

Of course, with the Kinder email and their alleged talk with AA's legal person, the Pentacon and PFT people will likely call this man a shill or liar.

This still does not solve whether the document from the AA manual for the 757 that they presented was tampered or not.

TAM:)
 
Well done Ron.

Of course, with the Kinder email and their alleged talk with AA's legal person, the Pentacon and PFT people will likely call this man a shill or liar.

This still does not solve whether the document from the AA manual for the 757 that they presented was tampered or not.

TAM:)


If someone can post a clearer image of the page, I will send it to Mr. Hotard.
 
Some more info for the mix here. According to the 9/11 CR, the FBI prepared a document called 'American Airlines Airphone Usage' on Sept. 20, 2001.

Page 453 (pdf 470) - Amy Sweeney tried to use an airphone to call AA. The first two attempts failed, but the third went through. That phone call was not recorded, but it lasted for 12 minutes.

Page 455 (pdf 472) - There are numerous references to this report in the notes for Flight 77. Renee May is thought to have used a cellphone, as all four of the airphone calls from Flight 77 were described as "connected calls to unknown numbers". All four of this airphone calls were believed to be attempts of Barbara Olson to reach Ted, with only two making it to his desk.

So Mr. Kinder is either clueless about airphones aboard Flight 77 (and 11!) or he's admitting that AA lied to the FBI. I'm going with the first option.

PS: I have no love for the politics of the Olsons whatsoever. In fact, an opposite term could be used to describe my feeling about their politics and methods. However, I'm quite willing to cut Ted Olson some slack about discrepancies in his accounts, because I imagine that any usual attention to details gets swept out of the mind when in the space of fifteen minutes, you go from the Solicitor General of the United States to a man that conceivably listened to his wife die.
 
Some more info for the mix here. According to the 9/11 CR, the FBI prepared a document called 'American Airlines Airphone Usage' on Sept. 20, 2001.

Page 453 (pdf 470) - Amy Sweeney tried to use an airphone to call AA. The first two attempts failed, but the third went through. That phone call was not recorded, but it lasted for 12 minutes.

Page 455 (pdf 472) - There are numerous references to this report in the notes for Flight 77. Renee May is thought to have used a cellphone, as all four of the airphone calls from Flight 77 were described as "connected calls to unknown numbers". All four of this airphone calls were believed to be attempts of Barbara Olson to reach Ted, with only two making it to his desk.

So Mr. Kinder is either clueless about airphones aboard Flight 77 (and 11!) or he's admitting that AA lied to the FBI. I'm going with the first option.

PS: I have no love for the politics of the Olsons whatsoever. In fact, an opposite term could be used to describe my feeling about their politics and methods. However, I'm quite willing to cut Ted Olson some slack about discrepancies in his accounts, because I imagine that any usual attention to details gets swept out of the mind when in the space of fifteen minutes, you go from the Solicitor General of the United States to a man that conceivably listened to his wife die.


I would love to see the full, unedited, original email sent to Mr. Kinder. Have PFT made it available to their members?

TAM:)
 
It took several days and many, many phone calls to reach Mr. Hotard. Here are the e-mails he sent me:

(June 27, 2007:)

Ron, I am doublechecking with my maintenance folks so I give you accurate data.

(June 29, 2007:)

Ron, engineers at our primary Maintenance & Engineering base in Tulsa tell me that they cannot find any record that the 757 aircraft flown into the Pentagon on 9/11 had had its seatback phones deactivated by that date. An Engineering Change Order to deactivate the seatback phone system on the 757 fleet had been issued by that time.

(June 29, 2007, in response to the photos Apathoid posted of 757 cabins in 2002 and 2003:)

Ron, be a little careful here. While you may see photos of the seatback phones, they may or may not have been disabled. We did two things: issued the engineering change orders to disconnect/disable the phones, but then did not physically remove the phones until the aircraft went through its next “heavy C” check, which is when you take it in for a complete overhaul, such as removing the seats, sidewalls, floorboards,etc and inspect the wiring, and then refurbish the seats with new seatcovers, etc.

(June 29, 2007, in response to my request that we nail down the myth of cell phones not working in flight:)

Cell phones may or may not work on aircraft, just as they may or may not work on the ground. It depends whether or not the caller is in range of a tower or satellite. I believe the seatback phones worked by having the signal picked up by land based towers as the aircraft moved across the country.

We do not allow use of cell phones in flight because they can potentially interfere with the cockpit’s navigational and other avionics equipment and thus become a safety issue.

It is our contention that the seatback phones on Flight 77 were working because there is no entry in that aircraft’s records to indicate when the phones were disconnected.

(Who is John Hotard?)

I am a manager in the Corporate Communications department of American, meaning I deal with media.

Of course, nothing will satisfy the conspiracy liars, as they have no interest in finding out the facts. For the rest of us, I believe my communications with Mr. Hotard confirmed what we already knew.



Nicely done Ron.

This caught my eye though:

...."An Engineering Change Order to deactivate the seatback phone system on the 757 fleet had been issued by that time."

I originally read it as...."....not been issued...", but apparently the ECO to deactivate the phones was written before 9/11. Not that it really matters though, since he also states that (ship 644) was not decativated at that time.


JamesB said:
I don't quite understand your wording. So are you saying that the date in the bottom right should not be there at all, or should match with the revision date of software?

Also, shouldn't it state "Page 1 of x" instead of "Paoe 1"?

The date being there at the bottom really doesn't concern me, but it should match the other date. We still have some manuals that are only available in PDF and hardcopy, and the revision dates in those are typically found at the bottom right on each page.

Notice on the page that I posted, the date appears twice - just as it does on the AA doc - but it's the same. But the bigger issue is that AA's manuals, like ours, are updated and maintained electronically - meaning each page printed from the manual should have the same revision date. Also, the date should correspond to the last permanent update(the 3X a year I mentioned above), or the last temporary revision. Suffice to say that AA wouldn't slip up on updating their B757 AMM for 6 years.

I'm thinking that whoever got the manual page from the AA guy sat on it for awhile because it was printed out before the last update(5/28/2007).

ETA: I just heard today that we are taking all of AA's ex-TWA 757s(757-231) in the next few weeks and that our department will be doing the conversion mods on them. Since we are getting the AA planes, hopefully we should also be getting the AA manuals.
 
Last edited:
It doesn't say remove all. It says most. But ok I'll give you that.

They were deactivated and removed.

If you think the document was faked or the information is untrue it will be easy to refute via American Airlines.

We know for a fact it is real because we personally know the A&P mechanic that obtained it.

Really, do you realize that the A&P mechanic who obtained it left out some very important information?
 
Really, do you realize that the A&P mechanic who obtained it left out some very important information?


Lyte Trip won't be returning calls for a while. He is using his incontrovertible evidence showing that the plane that crashed into the Pentagon really flew over it to win fame and fortune for himself and a Pulitzer Prize for some extremely fortunate reporter.
 
Very funny that Lyte gave up harping on/promoting this.

Also Odd that JDX (yournightmare on SLC now) has given up harping as well.

TAM:)
 
The upper left page date is the date and time of logon to the computer which was used to search for this document. It was redacted to protect our source.

The only thing that anyone would find out is the date and time it was printed. Lets say it was printed on 06/01/2007 at 08:00. It would bascially mean that one of AA's 10000 mechanics printed it out on that date and time. Not much to go on if you ask me. Besdies, I doubt AA legal would even bother.
 
AMTMAN:

What information, that was left out, do you feel was important?

TAM:)
 
Let's just say that he's either leaving out certain facts by design or he's doing it out of ignorance.;)

Is there any reason you can't just tell us what information you think he is withholding?
 
Our mechanic told us.. prove it wrong.



If you know anything about manuals and doing revisions. each last revision date is on the page itself... not every page has the same date... have you ever revised your manual?

The page itself obviously wasn't revised since the date noted.. but I'm sure other pages in the manual were. Ever seen a revision log at beginning of manuals? Not every revision is the whole manual. And if they do replace full manuals, they do not revise a date on a page that hasn't been revised.



I'll check.

Well you obviously don't know how AA manuals work either. Do you know what the TR next to that first sentence signifies? If you do why don't you tell us the date that is associated with that TR?
 
Listen....we have obtained this evidence from a licensed A&P mechanic employee within American Airlines.

He remembers clearly the phones with inoperable placards and was pissed he had to keep replacing the phones during C Checks (IIRC it was C Checks)... because the phones didnt even work and he felt it was double the work for nothing.. they should have kept the phones out since they weren't even operative he thought. But AA told their mechanics to put them back in even though they were deactivated. you cant leave a hole in the back of a seat.

We think this maintenance manual is strong evidence so PFT and DRG have ran with it and we back them 100%.

If you can prove them incorrect with stronger evidence then by all means go right ahead.

I'm quite certain they would have no problem admitting their error.

So get to work!

If your source is so good then why can't he find ECO F0878?

Memories are a funny thing. People have a tendancy to get their times mixed up. I'm sure he does remember doing this. However he remembers doing it in 2002, not 2001.
 
Paint your picture and make the accusations all you want because that's all you have.

I had 100% support for the story in the beginning and throughout the entire thread and still do.

And that's right my posts are all there to prove it.

I was being treated like the authority on the issue so I clarified my level of involvement.

Never ONCE did I express a lack of faith in the legitimacy of the information.

You are twisting my words and misrepresenting my claims.

Nothing has been faked no matter how many times you push your conspiracy theory and lie about my beliefs/claims.

And what do you have, a single page from the AA maintenance manual. You don't have the associated ECO's dealing with the Calircom system. If you did you would have posted them. However you probably would not want to do that since it would make you look rather silly. You don't even bother to explain what the TR next to the first sentence really means.
 
Since I doubt Lyte Trip will give an answer, or at least an honest one I guess I'll have to explain what the TR means. TR means Temporary Revision. Instead of doing a major update TR's will be periodically added to the manual. This particular TR was added April 2007. In other words that sentence did not appear until April of this year. I can understand why Pilots for Truth would not want that known. Or they themselves don't know. I'm not sure which is worse.
 
So are you saying, that you have proof that this revision to the manual that they have posted, was made in April 2007?

How do you know this, do you have access to an identical manual.

Please Elaborate.

Thanks in advance.

TAM:)
 
So are you saying, that you have proof that this revision to the manual that they have posted, was made in April 2007?

How do you know this, do you have access to an identical manual.

Please Elaborate.

Thanks in advance.

TAM:)


Yes I do have access to the identical manual. Since the system was first deactivated in March-April 2002 and the present day there probably were other TR's attached to that manual reference. However none dated prior to 2002. It's most interesting that PfT say they could not locate F0878 yet they have several others dated for 2002. Well there's ECO F0871 that states that the Claircom system will be switched to the off position and associated circuit breakers pulled and collared. It's dated March 2002.

I guess it's up to the CT's to get a hold of their source and prove me wrong.:rolleyes:
 
Another one bites the dust.

You'd think some 'truthers' might start to get a bit suspicious about what their 'shining lights' are trying to sell them.

Oh and welcome to the forum AMTMAN!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom