On Again Off Again Airfones

Now, despite all what I have said, Beachnut has nailed it:

- There is no reason (and this would be highlighted during an audit) for a manual to contain information on a system that was no longer fitted to the aircraft. It might remain for an amendment or two, but 6 years? I don't buy it.




Just a nitpick, that was Gumboot that nailed it... :p

-Gumboot
 
Just a little thing...

The claim is that the top dates are blacked out to hide the date the document was accessed, because this would reveal the identity of the naughty guy that printed it out.

However there's one big slobbering flaw in this theory...

Lyte Trip has stated, numerous times, that the 2007 date at the top is the date it was accessed on the system. Never mind that it quite clearly states this is the revision date.

In addition, the document labels for the blacked out dates quite clearly indicate they are the date for the document, not the date for it being accessed. Since we are supposed to believe the bottom 2001 date is the document date, at least one of the blacked out dates should be the same as this 2001 date.

The fact that these dates are blacked out clearly indicates to me that they are NOT the 2001 date, and left visible, they would reveal the deception of the document.

-Gumboot
 
yes it is back again now, but it was gone, and I am on the same computer...how very odd...oh well. My apologies.

TAM:)
 
I find it strange that the pic was gone though. Is it possible the pic could have been removed/changed at the host, and hence not come up temporarily, and now be restored? Is it possible the server for the image could have been down?

oh well... it is back up..

TAM:)

I downloaded the image and checked it...same modification date as original, so it must have been either (A) an issue with my comp (less likely as all other pics on the page loaded properly) or (B) a problem with his server (more likely).
 
Last edited:
I didn't have much time to research this at work, but while I was looking up a manual reference for the plane I was working(which happens to have been a 757), I decided to read a little about revisions. I also printed out the first page of the Airfone system "Description and Operation" in our B757 AMM for comparison, as well the "Revision Highlights" page.

Firstly, our electronic manuals are kept current by the software 3 times a year, the 28th of January, 28th of May and the 28th of September being the 3 days. That tells me that AA uses the same service for these updates. Secondly, as I browsed the manual, I could not note the revision date for any part of the manual I was browsing(something I never took notice of before). And I should stress that the AMM, depending on what section you're in isn't really in a book-page format. It's broken down by chapter-section-subsection-task-subtask ... In any given chapter-section-subsection-task(ie 23-19-00-501 Description and Operation) the manual reads as a single continuous page, it's not like Acrobat Reader in that sense. Only when you print the manual do the page numbers and the revision date show up.


B757 AMM Sample page

Revision Highlights Page

The release 87.01 is the current revision level of the manual, and it reflects a temporary revision which was made on the 4th of this month.

This basically tells me that the manual page in the OP cannot possibly be genuine as it shows 2 conflicting revision dates on the same page!
 
Just a nitpick, that was Gumboot that nailed it... :p

-Gumboot


Hate to burst your bubble, but we don't have Airfones anymore either, yet the manual reference is still there. ;)

And it's not just AMMs, wiring prints and schematics which no longer reflect any aircraft configuration, for any effectivity, still come up in the Wiring Diagram Manual - and they come up first. You actually have to read the flagnotes for each like print(there could be 10-15 different sets of prints for a given system in a given the fleet) to find which one has been updated for the accomplishment of an EO or Service Bulletin for your effectivity. It's very easy to start troubleshooting with a set of prints that don't pertain to your airplane. I've done it many times. :o

Why they keep all that stuff in there is beyond me, but I think the FAA has something to do with it....
 
So this sort of explains the oddity of the two dates, seperated by year, but having the same month and day as not so odd after all, but the two revision dates makes it extremely likely that it has been tampered with?

TAM:)

EDIT: I think there are enough differences between manuals, from airline to airline, that only a copy of the AA version of the 757 manual from that year will put this to rest.
 
Last edited:
Hate to burst your bubble, but we don't have Airfones anymore either, yet the manual reference is still there. ;)



Ah okay, thanks for that.

It's interesting that the layout you gave us is almost identical in terms of date placements etc. and it's worth noting that there's no page count in the bottom right corner.

-Gumboot
 
Ah okay, thanks for that.

It's interesting that the layout you gave us is almost identical in terms of date placements etc. and it's worth noting that there's no page count in the bottom right corner.

-Gumboot
Both of the images Apathoid posted have page numbers in the lower right corner. "1 of 5" and "1 of 1." They just don't say "Pace:" ;)

The spot light from your Avatar must have gotten in your eyes.:)
 
EDIT: I think there are enough differences between manuals, from airline to airline, that only a copy of the AA version of the 757 manual from that year will put this to rest.


I agree and I mentioned yesterday that even though I was going to pull up the exact same section of the AMM, they would likely be very different. I just posted these for comparison, specifically for the revision dates.

I'll get ahold of the AA manual soon enough, don't worry. :D
 
no sweat man...you da man.

I was argueing via SLC blog posts with JDX. His latest point, which until I zoomed in on the doc, I thought was a valid one, is that if the bottom of the g were cut off, why would it leave a "c"...it should leave an "o". So then I bring up the document/jpg in my photoshop...low and behold when you zoom in...it is an "o" not a "c"...

So we should be calling this defect the "Paoe 1" defect, not "Pace 1".

TAM:)
 
I didn't have much time to research this at work, but while I was looking up a manual reference for the plane I was working(which happens to have been a 757), I decided to read a little about revisions. I also printed out the first page of the Airfone system "Description and Operation" in our B757 AMM for comparison, as well the "Revision Highlights" page.

Firstly, our electronic manuals are kept current by the software 3 times a year, the 28th of January, 28th of May and the 28th of September being the 3 days. That tells me that AA uses the same service for these updates. Secondly, as I browsed the manual, I could not note the revision date for any part of the manual I was browsing(something I never took notice of before). And I should stress that the AMM, depending on what section you're in isn't really in a book-page format. It's broken down by chapter-section-subsection-task-subtask ... In any given chapter-section-subsection-task(ie 23-19-00-501 Description and Operation) the manual reads as a single continuous page, it's not like Acrobat Reader in that sense. Only when you print the manual do the page numbers and the revision date show up.


B757 AMM Sample page

Revision Highlights Page

The release 87.01 is the current revision level of the manual, and it reflects a temporary revision which was made on the 4th of this month.

This basically tells me that the manual page in the OP cannot possibly be genuine as it shows 2 conflicting revision dates on the same page!

I don't quite understand your wording. So are you saying that the date in the bottom right should not be there at all, or should match with the revision date of software?

Also, shouldn't it state "Page 1 of x" instead of "Paoe 1"?
 
Just a little thing...

The claim is that the top dates are blacked out to hide the date the document was accessed, because this would reveal the identity of the naughty guy that printed it out.

However there's one big slobbering flaw in this theory...

Lyte Trip has stated, numerous times, that the 2007 date at the top is the date it was accessed on the system. Never mind that it quite clearly states this is the revision date.

In addition, the document labels for the blacked out dates quite clearly indicate they are the date for the document, not the date for it being accessed. Since we are supposed to believe the bottom 2001 date is the document date, at least one of the blacked out dates should be the same as this 2001 date.

The fact that these dates are blacked out clearly indicates to me that they are NOT the 2001 date, and left visible, they would reveal the deception of the document.

-Gumboot

Sorry!

Ah, okay. All our manuals (except for the new MHR-90) are paper-based with the e-copy being a PDF version of the original files.
 
Last edited:
Also the blacked out dates on the top left (if Apathoid is any guide) are probably in the same dd/mm/yyyy format as the date on the bottom right, and the likely source for any cut and paste.
 
It took several days and many, many phone calls to reach Mr. Hotard. Here are the e-mails he sent me:

(June 27, 2007:)

Ron, I am doublechecking with my maintenance folks so I give you accurate data.

(June 29, 2007:)

Ron, engineers at our primary Maintenance & Engineering base in Tulsa tell me that they cannot find any record that the 757 aircraft flown into the Pentagon on 9/11 had had its seatback phones deactivated by that date. An Engineering Change Order to deactivate the seatback phone system on the 757 fleet had been issued by that time.

(June 29, 2007, in response to the photos Apathoid posted of 757 cabins in 2002 and 2003:)

Ron, be a little careful here. While you may see photos of the seatback phones, they may or may not have been disabled. We did two things: issued the engineering change orders to disconnect/disable the phones, but then did not physically remove the phones until the aircraft went through its next “heavy C” check, which is when you take it in for a complete overhaul, such as removing the seats, sidewalls, floorboards,etc and inspect the wiring, and then refurbish the seats with new seatcovers, etc.

(June 29, 2007, in response to my request that we nail down the myth of cell phones not working in flight:)

Cell phones may or may not work on aircraft, just as they may or may not work on the ground. It depends whether or not the caller is in range of a tower or satellite. I believe the seatback phones worked by having the signal picked up by land based towers as the aircraft moved across the country.

We do not allow use of cell phones in flight because they can potentially interfere with the cockpit’s navigational and other avionics equipment and thus become a safety issue.

It is our contention that the seatback phones on Flight 77 were working because there is no entry in that aircraft’s records to indicate when the phones were disconnected.

(Who is John Hotard?)

I am a manager in the Corporate Communications department of American, meaning I deal with media.

Of course, nothing will satisfy the conspiracy liars, as they have no interest in finding out the facts. For the rest of us, I believe my communications with Mr. Hotard confirmed what we already knew.
 
It took several days and many, many phone calls to reach Mr. Hotard. Here are the e-mails he sent me:

(June 29, 2007:)

Ron, engineers at our primary Maintenance & Engineering base in Tulsa tell me that they cannot find any record that the 757 aircraft flown into the Pentagon on 9/11 had had its seatback phones deactivated by that date. An Engineering Change Order to deactivate the seatback phone system on the 757 fleet had been issued by that time.

(June 29, 2007, in response to the photos Apathoid posted of 757 cabins in 2002 and 2003:)

Ron, be a little careful here. While you may see photos of the seatback phones, they may or may not have been disabled. We did two things: issued the engineering change orders to disconnect/disable the phones, but then did not physically remove the phones until the aircraft went through its next “heavy C” check, which is when you take it in for a complete overhaul, such as removing the seats, sidewalls, floorboards,etc and inspect the wiring, and then refurbish the seats with new seatcovers, etc.

(June 29, 2007, in response to my request that we nail down the myth of cell phones not working in flight:)

Cell phones may or may not work on aircraft, just as they may or may not work on the ground. It depends whether or not the caller is in range of a tower or satellite. I believe the seatback phones worked by having the signal picked up by land based towers as the aircraft moved across the country.

We do not allow use of cell phones in flight because they can potentially interfere with the cockpit’s navigational and other avionics equipment and thus become a safety issue.

It is our contention that the seatback phones on Flight 77 were working because there is no entry in that aircraft’s records to indicate when the phones were disconnected.

(Who is John Hotard?)

I am a manager in the Corporate Communications department of American, meaning I deal with media.

Of course, nothing will satisfy the conspiracy liars, ...
You forgot to make an announcement to some earth shattering data! You need practice being a truther, they do not present the whole story. You need to cherry pick this and make it a smoking gun.

Good info, good research, good follow up. Excellent. I wonder when PFT will present the whole story?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom