On Again Off Again Airfones

Well it is not as easy as that. If we assume AMTMAN is being truthful (right now that is in doubt, but we are working on trying to come to some truth on that matter) than yes, it appears to be a forgery. Apathoid is also working on getting a copy of this manual. If we can get a scan from AMTMAN of the page from his manual, and one from apathoid, prove both those match, and then compare to the original P4T version, we might be somewhere.

TAM:)
 
Well, you see that is where I failed. Call it good nature, call it confirmation bias, but when AMTMAN first came here I accepted, initially, his entire story without question. I did later request a scan of his manual to compare to the original for confirmation, but by then little Robbie Basalmo had revealed the plot. Rob Basalmo knows AMTMAN, and has said that AMTMAN had "suckered us all in" so I am now assuming that AMTMAN was a John Doe X puppet, taking us all for a ride.

TAM:)

Well of course he's going to say things like this. Why, because he wants to deflect the issue at hand. Notice he will not come on this forum to try and dispute the date for the TR. Nor will he talk about ECO F0871XX and the date it came out. His "source" could easily find out when it was issued and when it was completed for each aircraft. That's assuming he knows what he's doing. So Rob, why don't you put your "source" to work and find out this info? Once you get it come back here and tell us what the dates are for turning the system off and pulling the associated circuit breakers.
 
Well of course he's going to say things like this. Why, because he wants to deflect the issue at hand. Notice he will not come on this forum to try and dispute the date for the TR. Nor will he talk about ECO F0871XX and the date it came out. His "source" could easily find out when it was issued and when it was completed for each aircraft. That's assuming he knows what he's doing. So Rob, why don't you put your "source" to work and find out this info? Once you get it come back here and tell us what the dates are for turning the system off and pulling the associated circuit breakers.


Ummm...how bout that scan?

Cheers,
SLOB
 
Rob Basalmo has been banned from this forum for many breeches of his membership agreement. He once tried to return here, using the username "weedwacker" as a sock puppet, and was caught, and that username banned as well.

AMTMAN, a post from you over at SLC Blog toward him might help, although he reads this forum religiously. Likewise, a scan of your manual page would help alot.

Thanks

TAM:)
 
Work Order ECO-F0878 dated prior to above 757 AMM page could not be located.

I said it before and I'll say it again. It really doesn't matter if the document is real. The missing ECO is the key. The ECO is the action that is performed and it's date is when. With out it this document might just as well be about toilet repair! It's useless as evidence to anything.

DGM
 
Well, I am a little out of my technical expertese to say the least, so can someone, for clarity sake, explain.

My interpretation is this:

It is immaterial when the order came out, which is all they have shown us in the OP. What is important, is the ECO, which I am gathering, tells up when the mechanic actually performed the order?

SLOB got an email back from AA, that says there are no records of the airfones on AA77 being disabled or removed prior to 9/11.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
AMTMAN, a post from you over at SLC Blog toward him might help, although he reads this forum religiously.
He does have to take breaks due to lip fatigue.

Likewise, a scan of your manual page would help alot.Thanks

TAM:)
I join others here in thanking AMTMAN for all his help in shedding light on this interesting issue. And, as some others have expressed, we skeptics are a "show me" bunch. I'd prefer to see a few pages from the manual for comparison. Most digital cameras can sufficiently resolve the fine print on a document. And although it has no bearing on when the phones were disconnected, as Apathoid has said it would be good to have an explanation of the revision date discrepancy.
 
Last edited:
My interpretation is this:

It is immaterial when the order came out, which is all they have shown us in the OP. What is important, is the ECO, which I am gathering, tells up when the mechanic actually performed the order?

TAM:

This is right.
The document posted is part of the instructions for HOW the mechanic should perform the work.
The actual work order would be in the form of a ECO (engineering change order) giving the effective date.
From there it would be logged into the aircrafts service log.

DGM
 
You know I just spent 10 minutes typing out a long rant belittling and bitching on Robbie, but you know what? I just deleted it. Why? Because Robbie is such a sad, PATHETIC individual, that I felt it would be too harsh. I also do not want to lower myself to his level.

So Robbie, you can continue your ragging on me, as you have been, obsesively for the last 4-5 days in the same thread over at SLC Blog. I know it makes you feel better, and with so little in the world to make you feel that way, who am I to deny you. okie Robbie I'm stupid, I'm an idiot, I am a poor debunker...what ever makes you feel better about yourself.

I am sure 6 years from now, he will still be here, doing the same thing, no further ahead.

TAM:)

Oh I just notice in one of his rants Rob asked me to post this, so who am I to deny him...

"Rob Balsamo said the pilot certificates and 757 AMM page is forged."

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
You know I just spent 10 minutes typing out a long rant belittling and bitching on Robbie, but you know what? I just deleted it. Why? Because Robbie is such a sad, PATHETIC individual, that I felt it would be too harsh. I also do not want to lower myself to his level.

So Robbie, you can continue your ragging on me, as you have been, obsesively for the last 4-5 days in the same thread over at SLC Blog. I know it makes you feel better, and with so little in the world to make you feel that way, who am I to deny you. okie Robbie I'm stupid, I'm an idiot, I am a poor debunker...what ever makes you feel better about yourself.

I am sure 6 years from now, he will still be here, doing the same thing, no further ahead.

TAM:)

Oh I just notice in one of his rants Rob asked me to post this, so who am I to deny him...

"Rob Balsamo said the pilot certificates and 757 AMM page is forged."

TAM:)

This seems to be Rob Balsamo's MO. In spite of his claims that he only wants the truth anytime someone gives him info he does not like he goes on the attack. He tried to make it sound like I was trying to pull some sort of scam on this site over on the SLC comments section. Have to admit he managed to hoodwink some people. However in the end you never saw him refute anything that I have said with facts of his own.

Quite frankly at this point I hope he and that sad old man David Ray Griffin go on talking about the air phones being deactivated as if it were fact. That way they will dig themselves a deeper hole. I did notice that RB admitted the existence of ECO F0871 over on the comments section on SLC. He just won't admit when it was accomplished. Just like he won't talk about the TR that is associated with 23-19-00.
 
That looks to me like the original page in this thread has been edited to change the date at the bottom

how embarrassing for Lyte and his gang
 
That looks to me like the original page in this thread has been edited to change the date at the bottom

how embarrassing for Lyte and his gang


Actually no it was not edited. The date on the bottom of the page posted by PfT is the correct one. The reason for the difference is that the TR came out after REV 62. Basically what this TR is saying is that the first sentence with the TR next to it did not appear until April 2007.
 
Our mechanic told us.. prove it wrong.




The page itself obviously wasn't revised since the date noted...
QUOTE]

Well Lyte Trip we know that's a false statement, a lie in other words. You forgot to mention the TR along with all the associated ECO's. Why is that? It's either becasue you were ignorant of the facts or you willing ignored them. Either way makes you look a bit silly.
 
Actually no it was not edited. The date on the bottom of the page posted by PfT is the correct one. The reason for the difference is that the TR came out after REV 62. Basically what this TR is saying is that the first sentence with the TR next to it did not appear until April 2007.

ah, i get you now

good stuff
 
bump for further discussion...

is the document in post #432 PROOF that the carrying out of the order to deactivate the airfones on AA 757's did not occur prior to 9/11? Apathoid, Beachnut, or others care to weigh in??

TAM:)
 


Thanks for posting this, AMTMAN. But all this really tells me is that the phones were deactivated by April 19th of this year and ECOs are in work to remove the equipment. Well at least your manuals tell you something about the removal/deactivation; our manuals don't say squat about it.

In any case, I wonder if it would be too much to ask for a scan of the deactivation ECO(I forgot the number) with the original issue date and latest rev date? Also, is there a way for you to check the accomplishment of the ECOs by tail number? We have a handy system where we just punch in the EO number, ME number(maintenance event) and select the tail number(or the whole fleet) from a pull down list. It shows when each ME was accomplished as well as the EO completion date for each ship number. I realize 644 probably wouldn't appear anyways, but perhaps you could look for anything in the 640's and see when they were deactivated.

Thanks for looking into this.
 
bump for further discussion...

is the document in post #432 PROOF that the carrying out of the order to deactivate the airfones on AA 757's did not occur prior to 9/11? Apathoid, Beachnut, or others care to weigh in??

TAM:)

It proves that first sentence did not appear until 4/2007. Let me point something out here. Just becasue the MM says the system was deactivated and the date on the bottom is 1/28/2001 does not mean the system was inop on 9-11. That's what the TR proves this. Likewise just becasue a MM makes no mention of a system being deacitvated does not mean it's still operational. An example is 23-19-00 on AA's 737 fleet. There is no mention of the system being deactivated, last I looked. Using PfT logic I guess that means the system is still operational. However the airphone system on the 737 fleet was deactivated as well.

Now I guess it's up to PfT to prove me wrong with hard evidence of their own. One way would be for their "source" to give them a list on when all the ECO's I have mentioned being accomplished on the 757 fleet PRIOR to 9-11. However I don't think you will see that. For the simple reason it did not happen until AFTER 9-11.
 
how hard can it be for someone to provide a piece of paper...i mean if it is proprietary, that is fine, but if it is not, can't you just find one, print off the ECO, and scan it? I am not accusing, I am just frustrated with it all...

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom