On Again Off Again Airfones

Thanks for posting this, AMTMAN. But all this really tells me is that the phones were deactivated by April 19th of this year and ECOs are in work to remove the equipment. Well at least your manuals tell you something about the removal/deactivation; our manuals don't say squat about it.

In any case, I wonder if it would be too much to ask for a scan of the deactivation ECO(I forgot the number) with the original issue date and latest rev date? Also, is there a way for you to check the accomplishment of the ECOs by tail number? We have a handy system where we just punch in the EO number, ME number(maintenance event) and select the tail number(or the whole fleet) from a pull down list. It shows when each ME was accomplished as well as the EO completion date for each ship number. I realize 644 probably wouldn't appear anyways, but perhaps you could look for anything in the 640's and see when they were deactivated.

Thanks for looking into this.

The TR does not mean they were deactivated by April of this year. They have been deactivated for a number of years now. ECO F1463 and F1532 have just been started. They remove the equipment racks and associated wiring.

AA has the same sort of system for looking up when all ECO's have been accomplished. That is the actual proof. That is what PfT should have been posting and not the first page from 23-19-00. Now I guess the question everyone should be asking PfT is why they have not done so. Is it because they were unaware of this or is it because they knew about it but ignored the facts? If they were unaware it makes me wonder what's up with their "source". He's either not telling PfT everything or he's just not very good at looking up information. If they were aware and choose to ignore the information well that means they were being intentionally deceitful.

The very fact that the only thing PfT has shown so far is 23-19-00 should tell you something. If you look near the bottom of the comments section for this entry at SLC you will notice RB admitting to the existence of ECO F0871. Notice he does not talk about when it was accomplished.

< http://screwloosechange.blogspot.com/search/label/Airfones >
 
how hard can it be for someone to provide a piece of paper...i mean if it is proprietary, that is fine, but if it is not, can't you just find one, print off the ECO, and scan it? I am not accusing, I am just frustrated with it all...

TAM:)

If your frustrated imagine how I feel. There's some moron giving a bunch of crackpots pages from our maintenance manuals and they are using to make it look like AA is either in on the "conspiracy" or were just a bunch of idiots. The question everyone should be asking PfT is why were they not up front about the TR or when the ECO's were actually accomplished.
 
AA has the same sort of system for looking up when all ECO's have been accomplished. That is the actual proof. That is what PfT should have been posting and not the first page from 23-19-00. Now I guess the question everyone should be asking PfT is why they have not done so.

Actually, what we've been asking, repeatedly, is since you have access to this "smoking gun," will you print it out and post it. It's no use complaining what PFT won't do – everyone knows they're dishonest – when you have the ability to settle the matter.

I'm asking you for a straight answer. It will be a big help. I can't print and post the page myself. Will you?
 
This just in from John Hotard:

Kinder’s response was based on information that an order had been issued to remove Airphones from the 757 fleet. He did not have information on the specific aircraft or the timetable to remove them.
 
another blow to Robbies house of cards....

Ron you are very impressive these last few days.

TAM:)
 
another blow to Robbies house of cards....

Ron you are very impressive these last few days.

TAM:)



My goal, TAM, is obvious enough. I want to reduce the fantasists to claiming that every authority who has the specific knowledge to debunk their nonsense is a liar.
 
This just in from John Hotard:

Kinder’s response was based on information that an order had been issued to remove Airphones from the 757 fleet. He did not have information on the specific aircraft or the timetable to remove them.

Nice work, indeed, Ron. :)
 
another blow to Robbies house of cards....

Ron you are very impressive these last few days.

TAM:)

The fact that Rob and his buddy Lyte Trip have been rather quite on this subject should tell you something also.
 
The fact that Rob and his buddy Lyte Trip have been rather quite on this subject should tell you something also.
Noooo! You said the name! Never, ever say the name!

Maybe he didn't hear it...
 
Hi, AMTMAN. Would you mind responding to my post 443? Thanks!
 
Lyte Trip says....

We can draw up contracts protecting you and our source. So long as we can verify your identity, your position within AA, and the authtenticity of your manual page we should be able to get to the bottom of this. If you are right, you shouldn't worry about us knowing your name and position at AA. After all this is about the truth, right? I know CIT will concede that there were working airphones on Flight 77 if you can definitively prove it.

This is too funny. At the beginning of this thread you were going on an on about how you were "right", that the "facts" were on your side, and just try to prove you wrong. Well that has been done and what do you do? You try and change the subject by making me the issue instead of actually defending your position. That should tell everyone that Lyte Trips knows his position is untenable. Quite frankly Craig, I don't trust you as far as I can throw you. Any contract drawn up by you would be of use only as toilet paper.

If you were just some regular guy brought into this by your other anonymous buddy Apathoid you wouldn't have so much bravado. You think you can cast doubt and remain anonymous because we are protecting our source and his job. The second his name is revealed all efforts will be directed to getting him in trouble at work.

Still not defending your position I see. I wonder what your source is afraid of. Is it because he gives AA MM references to nutters like Rob Balsamo without divulging all the facts? Or is he the one giving out AA phone numbers so RB can make harassing phone calls? If so I would be worried to. He should also be worried because he's made himself to look like a complete fool in the eyes of any AA AMT with half a brain

Until then you are just an anonymous sabotuer with a phony, photoshopped manual page.

Well if what I posted is photo shopped then yours must be as well since it has the letters TR next to that first sentence. Care to explain what that TR means then?

My name is Craig Ranke, my partner's name is Aldo Marquis. Rob Balsamo is head of Pilots for 9/11 Truth. We know our contact's first and last name, he has been proven to work for AA, and is a personal friend.

We have to take your word on that. Tell you what, I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. Ask your source the following questions.

1)When did the TR for 23-19-00 come out?
2)When was ECO F0871XX accomplished fleet wide?
3)When was ECO F0878AX and AA accomplished fleet wide?
4)What's ECO F0621BX?

So far you have sounded like Rob Balsamo's parrot. Try thinking for yourself for a change and have your "source" answerthese questions. Like the saying goes "The truth shall set you free". I have a feeling I know how you are going to respond to this.
 
Hi, AMTMAN. Would you mind responding to my post 443? Thanks!

AMTMAN, you responded to this post of Gravy's with "'clean out your mailbox."

Is there some reason you can't answer the question here?
 
Clean out your mailbox.
Sorry, I'm just seeing this now. I've barely been involved with this issue, but I asked for a direct answer out of sympathy for others who've spent considerable time on this, and who've been asking the same thing more gently. I assume that you're not prepared to come forth with this "smoking gun." I make no judgments about that and I thank you for your time. As always, the burden of proof remains squarely on the tense shoulders of the crackpot claimants.
 
Wouldn't the ECO be available under some type of FOI-like request?

Surely that would put the issue to rest, once and for all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom