Lyte Trip,
Why do you think we are stupid?
The upper date on the document reads: REV 62, Jan. 28/2007
You claim this is the date the document was accessed in the computer system? Why?
It's clearly a revision date. Anyone with a fraction of a brain can see this. Why is it you cannot see this? More importantly why is it you think that we will not be able to see this, and realise you are lying in a fraction of a second?
Did it never even occur to you to wonder why the person releasing this document blacked out so much of the content, including (crucially) the original document date and software release date?
Did it never even occur to you to wonder why countless official and media reports indicate that American Airlines continued airphone services until March 2002?
Why is it, that a document stating passenger telephone systems have previously been deactivated (and most components removed) also explains maintenance and operation of the Claircom Telephone System? You assume the passenger telephone system and the Claircom Telephone System are the same thing. Why?
To me it reads like the passenger telephone system is being replaced with the Claircom Telephone System.
This is an aircraft maintenance manual. Why would an aircraft maintenance manual explain maintenance for something that is no longer found in the aircraft?
Why would this manual clearly state that American Airlines staff are not to carry out maintenance on a system that is no longer found in the aircraft? Why would the manual clearly state that maintenance will be carried out by Claircom staff on a system that nolonger is found in the aircraft?
Perhaps the Boeing 757 maintenance manual should also detail maintenance practices for the piston engines that 757 aircraft also do not have?
Again, I ask, why is it you think we're stupid enough to fall for such a weak attempt?
-Gumboot
You have brought up some interesting things, and I thought I'd add my 2c worth. So happens that technical publications are my current job. Military manuals, but there are always similarities.
Individual pages - normally pages will carry a revision date / amendment number on them. Our manuals use AL (amendment list). So one page could be AL7 but the reverse is AL2 (because the data on the front page was changed with AL7 but the reverse side data was lasted changed with AL2).
Quality control - the standard which is coming into most aviation (and other) technical manuals is S1000D, not necessarily an ISO standard. S1000D probably wasn't in use for the original maintenance manual, and so being legacy data may not have converted to S1000D.
28 JAN - I also found that strange. That is the date that it is published or authorised. Doing so on a Sunday, except for Alert Service Bulletins or the like, is unusual.
Format - S1000D has manuals being based on SGML or XML. For a 2001 manual, though, I would expect a system like Framemaker to be used.
Now, despite all what I have said, Beachnut has nailed it:
- There is no reason (and this would be highlighted during an audit) for a manual to contain information on a system that was no longer fitted to the aircraft. It might remain for an amendment or two, but 6 years? I don't buy it.
- The manual is simply a proscribed procedure for the authorised maintenance / servicing of an aircraft system. It is NOT an authority to remove or install systems. That must take place via an Engineering Change Order, Special Technical Instruction, etc. As Beachnut said - let's see that. We don't need to see the specific aircraft maintenance log, just the ECO / STI. That will have a date / hours deadline by which the work is to be carried out.