On Again Off Again Airfones

Arus808 - I'm not overly familiar with JPEG compression but, as I understand it, the image is split up into 8x8 pixel blocks before any compression is done. Is it possible that the absence of the rainbow effect in that particular piece of the image is due to the red line, by pure chance, lining up with an 8x8 pixel boundary?

I think it's unlikely. The artifacting from the red line at the top of the page is 28 pixels from top to bottom (11 above, 12 below). The left side of the red box is consistant with that and shows 10-14 pixels, however the right side only has 6 and the top none. That seems suspicious to me.
 
To be fair, I suspect that the person that did the blacking out is different to the person that did the red lines and editing, since the black outs don't exhibt the same artifacting as the red. I suspect that the first editing was done in MSPaint to alter to the document, and then sent on to someone else who used Photoshop to censor the blacked out sections. As such it is likely that the second person believed that what they had was a genuine scan.
 
R.Mackey after you were exposed twisting words and lying within a thread about Val's photograph on multiple occasions, using hypocritical logic and the fallacy of omission I find it very difficult to accept anything you say be it sarcasm, humor, proof or fact as credible.

Apparently you're still grousing about the drubbing you received starting here. [Count Rugen] How marvellous. [/CountRugen]

You still fail to understand "burden of proof." Notably, just because you choose to call me a liar, it doesn't necessarily make it so.

Perhaps an illustrative exercise will help you grasp "burden of proof."

I begin, thus: Swing Dangler, are you Killtown? Yes or no, please.
 
Apparently you're still grousing about the drubbing you received starting here. [Count Rugen] How marvellous. [/CountRugen]

You still fail to understand "burden of proof." Notably, just because you choose to call me a liar, it doesn't necessarily make it so.

Perhaps an illustrative exercise will help you grasp "burden of proof."

I begin, thus: Swing Dangler, are you Killtown? Yes or no, please.

There's a possibility that Swing Dangler is Killtown?



Jeez, we'll never get the carpets clean again.
 
I gravely doubt it, but it's the best instructive example I could think of. Think of it as a hypothetical question.
 
I gravely doubt it, but it's the best instructive example I could think of. Think of it as a hypothetical question.

Hypothetical, my foot! Someone has to think of the children!
 
Last edited:
Looking at it again I am even more convinced that the date at the bottom was originally 1/28/2007. The 1 in the 2001 is either smudged or a differint font than the 1 at the front of the date. This would make sense if the system is set to print the rev date automatically at the bottom of everypage to match the header on page one. I think the probablity that he two dates were both January 28 is astronomical.
For what it is worth 28 January 2001 was a Sunday. Would it be expected that this sort of document would be published on a Sunday?
 
R.Mackey after you were exposed twisting words and lying within a thread about Val's photograph on multiple occasions, using hypocritical logic and the fallacy of omission I find it very difficult to accept anything you say be it sarcasm, humor, proof or fact as credible.

I hope you're not referring to your pathetic Stundie nomination. You know, the "20-18=0" flub? You couldn't even get that right.
 
and as stated, no company would be saving their invidual document pages out as JPG files and try to edit them via a graphics type program.
Indeed. That's what page layout programs like QuarkXPress or InDesign are for, or at the lower end of the spectrum, a word processing program like Microsoft Word.

Given the simple layout of the manuals in question, I'd bet it's kept in a simple Microsoft Word or similar file and then prints made of the updated pages as needed.
 
R.Mackey after you were exposed twisting words and lying within a thread about Val's photograph on multiple occasions, using hypocritical logic and the fallacy of omission I find it very difficult to accept anything you say be it sarcasm, humor, proof or fact as credible.
Val's photo is real, so?

80 plus videos? Funny stuff.
 
Arus808 - I'm not overly familiar with JPEG compression but, as I understand it, the image is split up into 8x8 pixel blocks before any compression is done. Is it possible that the absence of the rainbow effect in that particular piece of the image is due to the red line, by pure chance, lining up with an 8x8 pixel boundary?

Guys, I'm not 100% convinced about the colour noise. The noise aligns exactly with JPEG boundaries. (In photoshop overlay a 8x8 grid) By coincidence, whoever added the red box around the date DID draw it to align with a boundary. That means the lack of artifacts above the line isn't evidence.

I do notice that in some places the JPEG noise extends two blocks away from the red, but in other places its only 1. That could be caused simply by cropping the document after it was first saved. The document is clearly cropped. Or it could be that chroma information (colour) is stored in this JEPG as 16x16 blocks rather than 8x8. If you overlay a 16x16 grid on the image the colour blocks align perfectly.

Having said that of course, the 1 is too small. This single doubt about the 1, the the most significant digit of the document, raises enough questions to warrant a better quality scan, and leaves the burden of proof with Pffft.
 
Wow, you guys are impressive. I thought the document was probably kosher enough, but just didn't mean what they were implying it meant (after all, why go on and on about maintenance routines for equipment you've just declared has been removed?). I thought all the nitpicking about tampering was OTT.

OK, not OTT. Nice detective work.

For what it is worth 28 January 2001 was a Sunday. Would it be expected that this sort of document would be published on a Sunday?

However, 28th January was a Sunday in both 2001 and 2007. Can any conclusions be drawn from this?

Rolfe.

PS. I thought it was established fact that Mrs. Olsen used her mobile phone on at least one of the occasions she called. Wasn't it the case that she went into the toilet or hid somewhere else to try to make the call unobserved by the hijackers? I don't think you could do that with a seat back phone.

On the other hand, wasn't it also established that the calls from United 93 were mostly made from seat back phones?

Now I don't take much interest in all this, this is just what I remember from reports as they came out. I'd have thought that people obsessively picking apart the details would have got such simple facts clear by now.
 
A control sample of a genuine image. The grid is 16 x 16 pixels. Note that luma noise (black & white) occurs in 8x8 blocks. Chroma noise occurs in 16x16 blocks.

36174683893164f00.jpg

36174683893176fde.jpg


The 1 in 2001 is still odd but I could believe the document is genuine since, like all non-faked truther evidence, you need to trust the honesty and interpretation of a bunch of truthers before it actually amounts to anything. The 'Pace' thing... well it could be a typo :boggled:
 
Last edited:
A copy of the original manual would make things easier. As to whether Apathoid can get one, or something close, is another matter.

Anyway, I suspect in the end this is much ado about nothing...just another forgery.

TAM:)
 
Lyte Trip,

Why do you think we are stupid?

The upper date on the document reads: REV 62, Jan. 28/2007

You claim this is the date the document was accessed in the computer system? Why?

It's clearly a revision date. Anyone with a fraction of a brain can see this. Why is it you cannot see this? More importantly why is it you think that we will not be able to see this, and realise you are lying in a fraction of a second?

Did it never even occur to you to wonder why the person releasing this document blacked out so much of the content, including (crucially) the original document date and software release date?

Did it never even occur to you to wonder why countless official and media reports indicate that American Airlines continued airphone services until March 2002?

Why is it, that a document stating passenger telephone systems have previously been deactivated (and most components removed) also explains maintenance and operation of the Claircom Telephone System? You assume the passenger telephone system and the Claircom Telephone System are the same thing. Why?

To me it reads like the passenger telephone system is being replaced with the Claircom Telephone System.

This is an aircraft maintenance manual. Why would an aircraft maintenance manual explain maintenance for something that is no longer found in the aircraft?

Why would this manual clearly state that American Airlines staff are not to carry out maintenance on a system that is no longer found in the aircraft? Why would the manual clearly state that maintenance will be carried out by Claircom staff on a system that nolonger is found in the aircraft?

Perhaps the Boeing 757 maintenance manual should also detail maintenance practices for the piston engines that 757 aircraft also do not have?

Again, I ask, why is it you think we're stupid enough to fall for such a weak attempt?

-Gumboot

You have brought up some interesting things, and I thought I'd add my 2c worth. So happens that technical publications are my current job. Military manuals, but there are always similarities.

Individual pages - normally pages will carry a revision date / amendment number on them. Our manuals use AL (amendment list). So one page could be AL7 but the reverse is AL2 (because the data on the front page was changed with AL7 but the reverse side data was lasted changed with AL2).

Quality control - the standard which is coming into most aviation (and other) technical manuals is S1000D, not necessarily an ISO standard. S1000D probably wasn't in use for the original maintenance manual, and so being legacy data may not have converted to S1000D.

28 JAN - I also found that strange. That is the date that it is published or authorised. Doing so on a Sunday, except for Alert Service Bulletins or the like, is unusual.

Format - S1000D has manuals being based on SGML or XML. For a 2001 manual, though, I would expect a system like Framemaker to be used.

Now, despite all what I have said, Beachnut has nailed it:

- There is no reason (and this would be highlighted during an audit) for a manual to contain information on a system that was no longer fitted to the aircraft. It might remain for an amendment or two, but 6 years? I don't buy it.

- The manual is simply a proscribed procedure for the authorised maintenance / servicing of an aircraft system. It is NOT an authority to remove or install systems. That must take place via an Engineering Change Order, Special Technical Instruction, etc. As Beachnut said - let's see that. We don't need to see the specific aircraft maintenance log, just the ECO / STI. That will have a date / hours deadline by which the work is to be carried out.
 
I begin, thus: Swing Dangler, are you Killtown? Yes or no, please.
It wouldn't surprise me in the least because why would some random "truther" remember such a mundane thing as that. Obviously he (Killtown?) still has a HUGE "chip on his shoulder" about your responses in that thread, obsessed much?!?
 
A control sample of a genuine image. The grid is 16 x 16 pixels. Note that luma noise (black & white) occurs in 8x8 blocks. Chroma noise occurs in 16x16 blocks.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/36174683893164f00.jpg
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/36174683893176fde.jpg

The 1 in 2001 is still odd but I could believe the document is genuine since, like all non-faked truther evidence, you need to trust the honesty and interpretation of a bunch of truthers before it actually amounts to anything. The 'Pace' thing... well it could be a typo :boggled:
I hope to heck it isn't a typo. Page numbers should be manage by the software. "Pace" on one page should equate to "Pace" on every page, in that case. If they are manually numbering pages (and placing footers on every one,) that scares me. What kind of limp wang pathetic software would they be using to manage the task of tracking thousands of pages of changes that would require them to manully number the pages? It scare me because something that basic wouldn't be done, so what about more important features like tracking the versions? How well would they be done by a system that can't even number pages?

Even granting that the document is real (though the blacked out dates are troublesome,) it still doesn't do much on its own. It refers to another document for the when and the how of the removal. Without that other document, this one changed page doesn't say much of anything useful.

Until a copy of ECO F0878 shows up, there isn't much point in speculating.
 
Interestingly folks, Lytes original posting of the document on page #1 of this thread has now magically disappeared. Did anyone save the image for posterity?

How typical

TAM:)

Edit: My apologies, the image seems to be back where it was now, with no editing note, so Lyte did not remove it or alter it...must be my stupid comp.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
Interestingly folks, Lytes original posting of the document on page #1 of this thread has now magically disappeared. Did anyone save the image for posterity?

How typical

TAM:)


I've got it--all you long-time JREFers have taught me well. :jedi:

ETA: The image appears to be back now.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom