On Again Off Again Airfones

SO you have an identical manual. Now, in the page they posted, at the bottom is a part where it says "page 1" but the g has part of itself cut off by a date that is from 2001.

Does your manual have this, or is that part of their original document forged?

TAM:)
 
SO you have an identical manual. Now, in the page they posted, at the bottom is a part where it says "page 1" but the g has part of itself cut off by a date that is from 2001.

Does your manual have this, or is that part of their original document forged?

TAM:)

Lyte Trip does have one thing right, the document is not forged. The fact that the g is cutoff probably has something to do with the printer. I can understand why some people would think it's forged. One, the CT movement has a habit of repeating things that are not true. Two, the g looking like a c does look a bit fishy. Last but not least the REV date and the update at the bottom are the same. That's just a coincidence.
 
SO the document wasnt forged, but from what you are telling us, the order to make the phones inoperable could not have come in 2001, based on your observations and understanding of an identical AA 757 Techincal manual. Correct?

TAM:)
 
SO the document wasnt forged, but from what you are telling us, the order to make the phones inoperable could not have come in 2001, based on your observations and understanding of an identical AA 757 Techincal manual. Correct?

TAM:)


TAM, Hotard said that orders to deactivate the phones started going out in 2001. He found no evidence that the phones on Flight 77 had been affected by the order.
 
Lyte Trip does have one thing right, the document is not forged. The fact that the g is cutoff probably has something to do with the printer. I can understand why some people would think it's forged. One, the CT movement has a habit of repeating things that are not true. Two, the g looking like a c does look a bit fishy. Last but not least the REV date and the update at the bottom are the same. That's just a coincidence.


Thanks for all the info, AMTMAN. We appreciate it, but I've just another small favor to ask you - can you double check the date at the bottom and make sure it says 1/28/2001. I ask because at first glance 2001 and 2007 may look alike. Just wanna see if we have a "smoking gun" here :D .
 
SO the document wasnt forged, but from what you are telling us, the order to make the phones inoperable could not have come in 2001, based on your observations and understanding of an identical AA 757 Techincal manual. Correct?

TAM:)

What I'm saying is that the Claircom system was not deactivated until 2002 by AA M&E. The "order" for M&E to deactivate the system did not hit the shop floor until March 2002 in the form of ECO F0871XX. The decision was made in late 2001 by the higher ups at HQ, after 9-11.

You have to remember that like any large organization decisions are not made on a whim. There are certain procedures to be followed. There have to be cost benefit analysis done, how will something like this affect the customer has to be looked at, costs to remove the system, contracts with the vendor, etc, etc. Once the decision is made its then up to M&E to figure out the scheduling to get this all accomplished.

The conspiracy theorists seem to think that the government or large corporations are well oiled, hyper efficient machines and that people have photographic memories. So when then they don't get the "answers" they want or if the person they are talking to can't remember every exact little detail that automatically means something fishy is going on. No, it means you are dealing with a bureaucracy or the person you are talking to can't remember every little detail.
 
I'm looking at it as I type. The dates are correct. Like I said before I can understand why some people would be suspicious of this. The smoking gun is in the form of ECO F0871 which is dated March 2002. ECO F0878AX/XX orders the removal of the major components of the system. F0871XX is the "order" to turn off the system and collar the associated circuit breakers. The CT's either are unaware of this ECO or choose to ignore it. I'm sure their "source" could find it.
 
What I'm saying is that the Claircom system was not deactivated until 2002 by AA M&E. The "order" for M&E to deactivate the system did not hit the shop floor until March 2002 in the form of ECO F0871XX. The decision was made in late 2001 by the higher ups at HQ, after 9-11.

You have to remember that like any large organization decisions are not made on a whim. There are certain procedures to be followed. There have to be cost benefit analysis done, how will something like this affect the customer has to be looked at, costs to remove the system, contracts with the vendor, etc, etc. Once the decision is made its then up to M&E to figure out the scheduling to get this all accomplished.

The conspiracy theorists seem to think that the government or large corporations are well oiled, hyper efficient machines and that people have photographic memories. So when then they don't get the "answers" they want or if the person they are talking to can't remember every exact little detail that automatically means something fishy is going on. No, it means you are dealing with a bureaucracy or the person you are talking to can't remember every little detail.


Well that seals it then. The order to deactivate them came in 2001, the orders to do so did not hit the shop floor, where the actual deactivation would take place until 2002...another truther bunch of BS bites the dust...

Well Done AMTMAN...

Edit: Any chance you can scan us the same page as the OP, but from your manual for comparison....thanks

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
I'm looking at it as I type. The dates are correct. Like I said before I can understand why some people would be suspicious of this. The smoking gun is in the form of ECO F0871 which is dated March 2002. ECO F0878AX/XX orders the removal of the major components of the system. F0871XX is the "order" to turn off the system and collar the associated circuit breakers. The CT's either are unaware of this ECO or choose to ignore it. I'm sure their "source" could find it.

So it does say 1/28/2001 at the bottom of the page?

I guess what I'm asking is simply clarification on what that date is. Your manuals, like ours, are updated 3X a year - January 28th being one of those days - so that date is (supposed to be) a revision date. So why are there two different dates on the same page? If your manuals are electronic, there should only be one date that appears in the entire manual. The page from our manual which I posted a few pages ago shows the manual relase 87.01(I'm guessing the .01 is the temporary revision made on June 4th) and the date(June 4th/07) appears at the top left, as it does in your manuals - but it also appears at the top right across from the "B757 AMM Release xx.xx" and it is, of course, the same exact date.

Can you shed a little light for me? I don't think that the date could be the original AMM release date as that would certainly be dated around '85ish. Also, that date is before the ECO listed on the page(ECO 0871) which you said was dated 2002.

I guess my point is that PfT can always say that the revision date is 1/28/2001 - ergo the system was deactivated by then because that's what the manual page says....

@Belz - Considering that there are only 3 days a year in which the manuals are updated, I'd say no ;)
 
bump, as I am hoping AMTMAN will provide us with a scanned jpg file of the original manual he has, so we can compare it to the original post image...

TAM:)
 
So it does say 1/28/2001 at the bottom of the page?

I guess what I'm asking is simply clarification on what that date is. Your manuals, like ours, are updated 3X a year - January 28th being one of those days - so that date is (supposed to be) a revision date. So why are there two different dates on the same page? If your manuals are electronic, there should only be one date that appears in the entire manual. The page from our manual which I posted a few pages ago shows the manual relase 87.01(I'm guessing the .01 is the temporary revision made on June 4th) and the date(June 4th/07) appears at the top left, as it does in your manuals - but it also appears at the top right across from the "B757 AMM Release xx.xx" and it is, of course, the same exact date.

Can you shed a little light for me? I don't think that the date could be the original AMM release date as that would certainly be dated around '85ish. Also, that date is before the ECO listed on the page(ECO 0871) which you said was dated 2002.

I guess my point is that PfT can always say that the revision date is 1/28/2001 - ergo the system was deactivated by then because that's what the manual page says....

@Belz - Considering that there are only 3 days a year in which the manuals are updated, I'd say no ;)

It would be hard for PfT to say that's the way the manual appeared in Jan 2001. That's because the Temporary Revision, which in this case refers to the opening statement referring to the deactivation and associated ECO's., did not go into affect until April 2007.
 
First, welcome to the forum, AMTMAN.

Second, no offence, but this is a skeptics' forum, so unless you post the documents, your posts cannot be accepted as compelling evidence. Kindly post the documents here so that others can see it for themselves.

Thanks in advance.
 
I wrote to AA Customer care just now, with links to the "Maintenance Manual" and the reply PfT had recieved - inquiring about the status of airphones onboard AA77 at 911, and about the validity of the scanned document. The automated reply said someone would get back to me by next week.

I'll post anything that comes up in this thread.

Cheers,
SLOB


Got my reply from a guy called John Hotard:

AA Customer Care said:
Mr (My name excluded), we have checked the records of the Boeing 757 aircraft on Flight 77. While there are records that indicate an Engineering Change Order was issues prior to 9/11 to remove the phones from the Boeing 757 fleet, there is no documentation in that particular aircraft’s records that indicate the phones had been disabled or removed by 9/11.

Cheers,
SLOB
 
Last edited:
Slob:

Thanks for the info. Unless AMTMAN can prove otherwise, I am assuming he is a plant courtesy of Rob Basalmo, who had decided, in his psychotic mind, to play a practical joke on all of us, by getting someone to post as AMTMAN did. You can ask him his reasons.

As for your proof, it sounds like the key is that while the order was given to have the fones deactivated prior to 9/11, their are no records that this was done prior to 9/11. Now the key would be, to get a statement from someone of authority to state whether modifications to an indivdual plane are ALWAYS recorded. It would seem to me, when dealing with a vehicle that carries hundreds of people into the air, that even such a simple mod as deactivation of the airfones WOULD HAVE TO BE recorded if it were done...so...

SEEMS LIKE THE AIRFONES ON FLIGHT 77 WERE NOT DEACTIVATED.

there is no documentation in that particular aircraft’s records that indicate the phones had been disabled or removed by 9/11.

and yes Rob, as I know you are watching, I do consider SLOB to be a reliable, trusted source.

TAM:)
 
Last edited:
It's interesting to note the different reaction this board has to someone posting information that appears to support our side of the argument, compared to how the LC Forum would handle that.

A skeptic knows that you have to question the validity of all evidence, even evidence that supports your preconceptions, especially evidence that supports your preconceptions, because you're most easily fooled by that. For more on this, read The Myth of Consistent Skepticism.

AMTMAN, welcome here, and I hope that you're not put off by people who ask for harder evidence of what you're saying. That's what skeptics do, when they're being properly skeptical.
 
It's interesting to note the different reaction this board has to someone posting information that appears to support our side of the argument, compared to how the LC Forum would handle that.

A skeptic knows that you have to question the validity of all evidence, even evidence that supports your preconceptions, especially evidence that supports your preconceptions, because you're most easily fooled by that. For more on this, read The Myth of Consistent Skepticism.

AMTMAN, welcome here, and I hope that you're not put off by people who ask for harder evidence of what you're saying. That's what skeptics do, when they're being properly skeptical.

Well, you see that is where I failed. Call it good nature, call it confirmation bias, but when AMTMAN first came here I accepted, initially, his entire story without question. I did later request a scan of his manual to compare to the original for confirmation, but by then little Robbie Basalmo had revealed the plot. Rob Basalmo knows AMTMAN, and has said that AMTMAN had "suckered us all in" so I am now assuming that AMTMAN was a John Doe X puppet, taking us all for a ride.

TAM:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom