North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Hi mhaze,

The graphs you supplied show just such a trend towards polar ice thinning, and the experts really are taken aback with the speed and extent of this change.

So why does the more recent graph show substantially less ice at minima over the last decade?
 
Yes, of course. Isn't everybody?

My quite reasonable questions were these -
CO2 -> Global Warming -> Extreme Weather Events.
A -> B -> C
Hmm....
Then you can show a curve of increasing "global warming" with increasing CO2, and decreasing "global warming" with decreasing CO2 atmospheric concentrations?

And a statistical chart of extreme weather events that correlates with increasing temperature, and which decreases with decreasing temperature?
​
You asserted -
We haven't had the option of directly observing a CO2-decrease.
​
Without addressing my request that if you want to assert a correlation between extreme weather and increasing temperature, you might be required to prove it up.

Please note there are 2 questions, one asking about proving a correlation between temperature, and extreme weather, and the other asking the same thing about CO2, and extreme weather.

For your position to have merit, you need to prove both, and then show the causative effect. I only have to disprove one of the two or the link.

Actually it doesn't even sound like a fair deal.
 
Without addressing my request that if you want to assert a correlation between extreme weather and increasing temperature, you might be required to prove it up.
I'm not sure what you mean here. The correlation between rising temperatures and rising Co2 levels has been shown repeatedly, as has the correlation between rising temperatures and rising natural disaster numbers.

Then you can show a curve of increasing "global warming" with increasing CO2, and decreasing "global warming" with decreasing CO2 atmospheric concentrations?
You mean besides from the famous graphs which show correlations for 650 000 years? And why does it need to show a decrease of both Co2 and heat? Why are you moving your goalposts?

And a statistical chart of extreme weather events that correlates with increasing temperature, and which decreases with decreasing temperature?
Again, I'm not sure what you're asking for. We already have told you about the increasing hurricane strength from warmer waters and the increased number of landslides in Hordaland county, Norway, both of which correlate with temperature rise. Why does it need to be in chart form?

Now, granted, two or three years is not enough to prove anything, but so far, the predictions of more precipitation and slides in Hordaland have both been supported by reality, as has the prediction of more violent hurricanes in the Caribbean region. See you in ten years, it'll probably be proven then.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what you mean here. The correlation between rising temperatures and rising Co2 levels has been shown repeatedly, as has the correlation between rising temperatures and rising natural disaster numbers.

You mean besides from the famous graphs which show correlations for 650 000 years? And why does it need to show a decrease of both Co2 and heat?

Structuring the argument in a form that was either empirically or scientifically provable, including separating simple correlation and causation.

That would allow figuring out it there was actually something here we should be worrying about or taking action on.

Please do not use the preponderance of news reports as evidence.
 
So why does the more recent graph show substantially less ice at minima over the last decade?

Umm... I'm not sure what you are trying to say here. These are observations, not predictions. Or are you thinking of a conspiracy yourself? :rolleyes:
We can pick at minor differences all we like, but both graphs show what is happening. The ice cap is reducing in area, summer and winter, year on year. As nothing else in the environment seems to be capable of accounting for this, it lends even more credence to AGW.
Naturally, as and when other pertinent facts come to light, our views may change - but for now, at least, man-made contributions seem by far the most likely cause of the enhanced warming we are observing.
 
My quite reasonable questions were these - ...

Your question (singular) was "You sure about that?", that being "We haven't had the option of directly observing a CO2-decrease." Which we haven't, since CO2-load has been rising (on a decadal scale) since we started observing it. From 288ppm in 1850 to 383ppm today (and rising by about 2ppm pa).
 
And a statistical chart of extreme weather events that correlates with increasing temperature, and which decreases with decreasing temperature?

What's a statistical chart?

If you want an annual count of extreme weather events you've got the problem of definition. Do an extreme Indian monsoon and an extreme downpour on an English county both count as one extreme event? And what about long-term droughts? Do they count once, or every year? Where does a bad day become an extreme event? And how soon do repeating extreme events become normal?

In Europe we've had more extremes of weather recently than we're used to, including droughts, downpours, and heatwaves. Not so much in the way of extremely cold winters, although there have been some peculiar ice-storms around the southern North Sea.

A warmer climate leads to more evaporation, which increases the atmosphere's throughput of moisture. That results in more rainfall in wet areas and faster dessication in dry areas - where rain is also more likely to evaporate before it even reaches the ground. So we can expect heavier downpours and harder droughts.

Since the moisture throughput is what transfers energy from ocean to atmosphere in tropical storms, we can also expect them to get stronger.

More heatwaves in a warmer climate goes without saying.

None of this conflicts with observations.
 
What about the 480 landslides in Hordaland county, Norway, from spring '06 to today alone, caused by the increase in precipitation? We've still got ten families living in temporary homes after the worst of them, back in September 2005.

These clearly hit inhabited areas. Do you have any knowledge of how old the settlements affected are? The region itself has a long history, of course, and some villages must go back to before the Dark Ages.
 
The Earth has warmed up and cooled down many times before with Ice Ages and Warm Periods..
And it will continue to do so with or without human aid and intervention.
And at the moment we are entering a warm period after the last Ice Age
Scientists love scaring the masses with dire predictions
 
Umm... I'm not sure what you are trying to say here. These are observations, not predictions. Or are you thinking of a conspiracy yourself? :rolleyes:
We can pick at minor differences all we like, but both graphs show what is happening. The ice cap is reducing in area, summer and winter, year on year.

The staff rescaled the data - Maybe they found an error. Or for some reason made adjustment. Consider 2006 low ice. (millions of square km) Before adjustment about 5.3. After adjustment 4.0.

Unprecedented Loss of Sea Ice Astonishes Scientists!



As nothing else in the environment seems to be capable of accounting for this, it lends even more credence to AGW.
Naturally, as and when other pertinent facts come to light, our views may change - but for now, at least, man-made contributions seem by far the most likely cause of the enhanced warming we are observing.
 
As nothing else in the environment seems to be capable of accounting for this, it lends even more credence to AGW.
That is not reasoning-not when many factors and their interactions are very poorly understood.

Naturally, as and when other pertinent facts come to light, our views may change - but for now, at least, man-made contributions seem by far the most likely cause of the enhanced warming we are observing.
Other pertinent facts have been presented in this thread that perhaps should change your view.
 
Your question (singular) was "You sure about that?", that being "We haven't had the option of directly observing a CO2-decrease." Which we haven't, since CO2-load has been rising (on a decadal scale) since we started observing it. From 288ppm in 1850 to 383ppm today (and rising by about 2ppm pa).

Do your have a chart and sources that you can substantiate that with?
 
The Earth has warmed up and cooled down many times before with Ice Ages and Warm Periods.
Glaciations and interglacials. Not "Ice Ages and Warm Periods".

And it will continue to do so with or without human aid and intervention.

It's happening now by human intervention. Something new.

And at the moment we are entering a warm period after the last Ice Age

We are deep into an interglacial, which is your Warm Period. We entered it ten thousand years ago. Now we've passed through a new door and reached a new level.

Scientists love scaring the masses with dire predictions

No, they don't. Scientists love being right. They don't really care about the masses. Hollywood directors delight in scaring the masses. Priests delight in scaring the masses. Demagogues of all descriptions do also so delight. But scientists, no. Too geeky for that.
 
The Earth has warmed up and cooled down many times before with Ice Ages and Warm Periods.
Yep. Big and little and medium and medieval sized ones.

It's happening now by human intervention. Something new. Now we've passed through a new door and reached a new level. Priests delight in scaring the masses. Demagogues of all descriptions do also so delight. But scientists should be Too geeky for that.
Corrected your statement to reflect unfortunate realities.
 
And it always does so for a reason. I thought we had left behind the ignorance of the past long ago, and sought to understand what was happening and why. At the present, the reason for change is us.

Absolutely, it is "man made global warming".

As it the case above mentioned where "we" changed some data.
The staff rescaled the data - Maybe they found an error. Or for some reason made adjustment. Consider 2006 low ice. (millions of square km) Before adjustment about 5.3. After adjustment 4.0.

Unprecedented Loss of Sea Ice Astonishes Scientists!
​
 
These clearly hit inhabited areas. Do you have any knowledge of how old the settlements affected are? The region itself has a long history, of course, and some villages must go back to before the Dark Ages.
Actually, most of them hit roads. Which doesn't make them harmless, of course, because several of the roads affected have quite a good deal of traffic.

As for the ones hitting inhabited areas (5 that I know of), I have no idea of how old those settlements are. Except Hatlestad, in which construction started in the Seventies. The other ones I don't know, but I'm quite certain at least one was in an old village. And of course, the roads affected, I'm almost certain, are quite old.
 
Actually, most of them hit roads. Which doesn't make them harmless, of course, because several of the roads affected have quite a good deal of traffic.

As for the ones hitting inhabited areas (5 that I know of), I have no idea of how old those settlements are. Except Hatlestad, in which construction started in the Seventies. The other ones I don't know, but I'm quite certain at least one was in an old village. And of course, the roads affected, I'm almost certain, are quite old.

Slight detour. I understand that Kyoto as being implemented by your country is many billions of dollars cost to citizens and industry.

When the physical basis for AGW crumbles, what happens? (Maybe I should phrase that "IF", not meaning to be argumentative).

I mean, your country then does what? Does the government keep the huge taxation scheme that Kyoto enabled it to start? Or do the lawsuits start? If so, in what directions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom