North Pole is melting faster than predicted

The staff rescaled the data - Maybe they found an error. Or for some reason made adjustment. Consider 2006 low ice. (millions of square km) Before adjustment about 5.3. After adjustment 4.0.

Unprecedented Loss of Sea Ice Astonishes Scientists!

who was asking for "No conspiracy theories please"? :D
Anyway, whether you look at the earlier or current graph, the same trend is seen. Global Warming, with the greatest likelihood of it being driven mostly by human activities, is a reality. You may not like the impositions you perhaps feel are being foisted upon you, but there it is. The question we should be asking is, what effective measures we can take?
Yes, this does mean looking at the cost/benefit analysis of reducing fossil fuel use. Will the economy of the world be more adversely affected by taking action, or not taking action, and what action would be required. This is where the debate should be at now, not being buried under the blanket of denial.
 
That is not reasoning-not when many factors and their interactions are very poorly understood.

Huh?? I pretty much said as much! Just because we don't fully understand the interactions, doesn't mean we can just turn away and pretend nothing is happening!

Other pertinent facts have been presented in this thread that perhaps should change your view.

This is perhaps the major problem here. What are these 'pertinent facts'? Merely repeating "it's not our fault" over and over, is not 'pertinent facts'.

Atmospheric CO2 has been rising for the last century or so.
Global temperatures have been rising over this same period - increasing almost exponentially.
Sea-levels have been rising over the same period - again, at a greater and greater rate.
Arctic sea-ice has been diminishing over the same period - again, speeding up more and more each year.

CO2 is a greenhouse gas. The known properties of CO2 in the atmosphere are well enough understood to make predictions of global warming (This was first done way back in the 19th century). The correlation is clear and demonstrated. Higher CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere leads to higher global temperatures. There can be only one real debate - where did this increase in CO2 come from, natural agencies or human agencies?
 
Last edited:
who was asking for "No conspiracy theories please"? :D
Anyway, whether you look at the earlier or current graph, the same trend is seen.

Yep, that was me asking for no conspiracy theories because there is no conspiracy. Just regular people doing regular jobs and regular newspaper reporters looking for scoops, right? It is kind of funny though. Just like last year when the big story hit the news about the Larsen B ice shelf breaking off....(but the event had occurred 16 months previously and was well known).

Global Warming, with the greatest likelihood of it being driven mostly by human activities, is a reality. You may not like the impositions you perhaps feel are being foisted upon you, but there it is. The question we should be asking is, what effective measures we can take?

Yes, this does mean looking at the cost/benefit analysis of reducing fossil fuel use. Will the economy of the world be more adversely affected by taking action, or not taking action, and what action would be required. This is where the debate should be at now, not being buried under the blanket of denial.
Well, we may disagree but I appreciate your use of phrases such as "greatest likelihood" instead of the absolute religious certainty that is often seen. The issue in this thread is pretty narrow in scope, Arctic sea ice.

I don't think this has any meaningful direct link to the issue of AGW, of course others differ. But in support of my position I have cited scientific studies that show the low ice is a natural trend - and I have cited one, (Dr. Dick) who notes that we have a problem if the ice doesn't come back as the cycle indicates that it should start to shortly.

I am curious what actions you believe the nations of the world must take and in what amounts, and what tonnage of emissions reduction therein would show a reduction in the presumed AGW component of the temperature. This is not a "let's feel good and say we are or ought to do something question" but instead, how many million or billion tons of co2 you want to see a reduction in and where they would come from.

Is that a fair question? It is definitely not the "let's feed good and say we are going to do something" assertion, which produces no beneficial effects. Not saying that was your point of view, just want to clarify that my request is for quantitative numbers and some reasonable estimates of results from those reductions.
 
Actually, most of them hit roads. Which doesn't make them harmless, of course, because several of the roads affected have quite a good deal of traffic.

As for the ones hitting inhabited areas (5 that I know of), I have no idea of how old those settlements are. Except Hatlestad, in which construction started in the Seventies. The other ones I don't know, but I'm quite certain at least one was in an old village. And of course, the roads affected, I'm almost certain, are quite old.

Out of hundreds of landslides, most will hit between settlements - where the roads are - rather than in settlements themselves. But roads are just as deep-rooted, historically. They work together.

Norwegian history is something I must look closer into. In particular, its medieval period.
 
Yep, that was me asking for no conspiracy theories because there is no conspiracy. Just regular people doing regular jobs and regular newspaper reporters looking for scoops, right?

You can't scoop Arctic sea-ice. You can scoop celebrity, politics, high-finance, any kind of scandal, but you can't scoop the sea-ice story. You're stuck with reporting it.

It is kind of funny though. Just like last year when the big story hit the news about the Larsen B ice shelf breaking off....(but the event had occurred 16 months previously and was well known).

Larsen B hit the news when it went away. I follow the news and I remember it clearly. It may only have come to your attention a long time after, but for most people, not so. You probably had to wait until it got filtered through to you with the right slant.

Well, we may disagree but I appreciate your use of phrases such as "greatest likelihood" instead of the absolute religious certainty that is often seen.

The alternative to your "it might not" attitude is not absolute religious certainty. When the "greatest likelihood" is well above 90%, the smart money is convinced.

The issue in this thread is pretty narrow in scope ...

Al Gore's out of the picture, then.

... Arctic sea ice.

And the world shortage thereof.

I don't think this has any meaningful direct link to the issue of AGW ...

Nobody's surprised by that.

... of course others differ.

Most normal people differ.

But in support of my position I have cited scientific studies that show the low ice is a natural trend ...

They show that it is a natural trend? Does that trump "greatest likelihood" in belief terms?

... and I have cited one, (Dr. Dick) who notes that we have a problem if the ice doesn't come back as the cycle indicates that it should start to shortly.

And what you reported him as saying was that if the ice doesn't come back over the next eight years time it would be possible evidence of AGW. Now you upgrade that to it being a "problem". But then, you don't think that the Arctic necessarily matters anyway. I can understand that. Dr Dick feels differently.

I am curious what actions you believe the nations of the world must take and in what amounts, and what tonnage of emissions reduction therein would show a reduction in the presumed AGW component of the temperature.

:rolleyes:
 
We still don't care until you care to give a non woo-woo answer as to why the Antarctic sea ice is expanding, and why and how a minor change in a trace gas in the atmosphere has anything to do with either. Net positive feedbacks in the Earth's climate would have killed everything long ago if they ever existed, so please stay away from the antiscience and try some rationality for a change.

The truth is that you don't give a toss about sea ice, polar bears or penguins. What you care about is justifying your own prior beliefs in catastrophism and neo-marxist analysis that capitalism and market economies are the roots of all evil.

It doesn't matter that the sea ice is currently melting (in the late summer early autumn, its supposed to). There have been many times in Earth's history when the Arctic has been entirely free of ice. Yet somehow life has thrived during those warm periods.

Its your belief system that builds the natural variation of climate into this huge destructive monster that must absolutely postively beyond all possible doubt be due to whether people drive to work or catch the bus. You deny all contrary evidence regarding the natural variation of climate and you deny the words of clearly qualified scientists on spurious grounds such as "they've been saying the same thing for years" as if consistency were a point against them and not against your fixed views on environmental catastrophe.

Its not William Gray who is unteachable, its you. You won't learn from previous mistaken assumptions, which is why you continue to make the same mistaken declarations. You're a catastrophism junkie desperately searching the news archives looking for the next fix of catastrophe. Naturally given the bias of news media for sensationalism and bad news, you get repeat doses and then tell us all how blind we are to not see the reality that only you are too aware of.
 
Wow.

That's it?

Oh noes teh marxists?!!?

Hark the silence... of the foundations of the IPCC and the consensus on AGW not shaking and falling.
 
Wow.

That's it?

Oh noes teh marxists?!!?

Hark the silence... of the foundations of the IPCC and the consensus on AGW not shaking and falling.

There's science, IPCC science, and Gore science...
Which has that consensus you are so sure of?
 
I just checked. The Antarctic sea ice, as well as most of the Antarctic, is growing in ice, not melting.
 
Oh sure, you trust NASA? They are in on it man, they are part of the NWO, the people who want to take away our SUVs and make us use solar energy and stuff. Don't fall for it.
 
The truth is that you don't give a toss about sea ice, polar bears or penguins. What you care about is justifying your own prior beliefs in catastrophism and neo-marxist analysis that capitalism and market economies are the roots of all evil.

You're a catastrophism junkie desperately searching the news archives looking for the next fix of catastrophe.
Prove it. It's easy to sit there and throw around accusations - backing them up is an entirely different thing.

It doesn't matter that the sea ice is currently melting (in the late summer early autumn, its supposed to). There have been many times in Earth's history when the Arctic has been entirely free of ice. Yet somehow life has thrived during those warm periods.
There have also been two World Wars, both of which we've lived through. Does that mean those shouldn't be prevented either? You know, since we survived them as a species and all?

We still don't care until you care to give a non woo-woo answer as to why the Antarctic sea ice is expanding, and why and how a minor change in a trace gas in the atmosphere has anything to do with either.
First of all, as a whole, Antarctican sea ice is decreasing, as was stated a few posts up. Secondly, the parts of Antarctica that are getting more ice is getting it because the warming is producing more precipitation, which in the -50 degrees celcius regions of Antarctica comes in the form of snow, which then freezes. Put a snowball from outside in the freezer and it becomes solid ice. Of course, this growth is negated by the melting, so when we sum it all up, Antarctican sea ice is decreasing.

You deny all contrary evidence regarding the natural variation of climate
No, we don't. I realize fully that there is a natural cycle - which humans are contributing to.
 
Last edited:
Oh sure, you trust NASA? They are in on it man, they are part of the NWO, the people who want to take away our SUVs and make us use solar energy and stuff. Don't fall for it.


Sure I trust NASA, I just don't let them drive, navigate or do anything involving getting me from point A to point B.

Nothing wrong with SUVs (Think Hummers) other than how often they are used to drive 6 year olds to school, when a Prius would be more appropriate.
 
We still don't care until you care to give a non woo-woo answer as to why the Antarctic sea ice is expanding, and why and how a minor change in a trace gas in the atmosphere has anything to do with either.

You haven't heard? CO2 is an amazingly powerful serial fertiliser.

http://www.co2science.org/scripts/CO2ScienceB2C/Index.jsp Not bad for a trace gas. That's where all those big trees and farm crops get their carbon for organic compounds.

Net positive feedbacks in the Earth's climate would have killed everything long ago if they ever existed, so please stay away from the antiscience and try some rationality for a change.

That is what Hansen is saying happens, the climate can flip from one state to another. These don't kill everything, but mass extinctions have been recorded. I seriously doubt everyone will be killed by global warming. A lot of people will experience serious disruption and chaos because of it, which usually means a lot of deaths.

The truth is that you don't give a toss about sea ice, polar bears or penguins. What you care about is justifying your own prior beliefs in catastrophism and neo-marxist analysis that capitalism and market economies are the roots of all evil.

I seriously think that the failure of capitalism to come up with a rational response to global warming will be a serious setback for the free market philosophy that is so powerful at the moment.

It doesn't matter that the sea ice is currently melting (in the late summer early autumn, its supposed to). There have been many times in Earth's history when the Arctic has been entirely free of ice. Yet somehow life has thrived during those warm periods.

It's the change that's the issue. The projected rate of change, in earth terms, is extremely rapid. Rapid change = chaos, basic thermodynamics.

Its your belief system that builds the natural variation of climate into this huge destructive monster that must absolutely postively beyond all possible doubt be due to whether people drive to work or catch the bus. You deny all contrary evidence regarding the natural variation of climate and you deny the words of clearly qualified scientists on spurious grounds such as "they've been saying the same thing for years" as if consistency were a point against them and not against your fixed views on environmental catastrophe.

CD seems to me to have come up with a lot of reasons based on science for thinking what he thinks on the topic.

Its not William Gray who is unteachable, its you. You won't learn from previous mistaken assumptions, which is why you continue to make the same mistaken declarations. You're a catastrophism junkie desperately searching the news archives looking for the next fix of catastrophe. Naturally given the bias of news media for sensationalism and bad news, you get repeat doses and then tell us all how blind we are to not see the reality that only you are too aware of.

Gray has got it wrong. Witness Humberto. That really got their eyes popping open. Disorganised depression one minute, hurricane the next. No one saw that coming.
 
I seriously think that the failure of capitalism to come up with a rational response to global warming will be a serious setback for the free market philosophy that is so powerful at the moment.

It's the change that's the issue. The projected rate of change, in earth terms, is extremely rapid. Rapid change = chaos, basic thermodynamics.

Gray has got it wrong. Witness Humberto. That really got their eyes popping open. Disorganised depression one minute, hurricane the next. No one saw that coming.

Regarding capitalism, I have to note that the US has done on a percentage wise basis better than the Kyoto protocol nations over the same time period in reducing emissions. Those trends seem likely to continue. So I don't see how the evidence can support your view...

As for the "extremely rapid" and projected rate of change, I'm preparing to show the possible extents of rate of change and of man made change overlaid on the natural 60-80 year cycles. Is it alarming? Is it an accelerating trend? We shall see.

As for Humberto, note the inkblot analogy. Different people look at an inkblot and see different things. That's why we need to have hard data that everyone can agree on, then use scientific methods in analysis of it, including statistical correlations as opposed to "eyeballing it".

AGW has not been doing too well in the last year or two because more is being understood every day. More science is emerging literally every day in the published literature.

Don't expect wrong ideas to go away nicely. Not when numerous countries have established legal and regulatory systems, Ministries of Climate Change and rake in huge amounts of taxes. It will be interesting to see what happens as the disconnect between the actual science and the legislation and implementation of the AGW theory grows.

How long before "An Inconvenient Truth" is not taught as scientific fact in high schools in the USA?

Skeptics would like to know.
 
Thanks for the insight.

IPCC Scenario A2, discussion of Greenland melting/not melting, not provided by Gurdor.

And I thought we were going to have some definitative, Authoritative Conclusionary evidenciary stuff coming in!

Trolling is not much use when you can't even get your spelling right. Weird capitalizations going on there too. Posting while drunk? PWD?

What I find of minor interest in all of this is the weird limitations you have placed on yourself through the ideological blinkers that form your view and your incentive here. It's kind of obvious, Bush is too difficult to defend, Iraq too messy, so you think you can do the course on GW; yet you really don't understand ecological biology, I've noticed, for one thing, let alone a few other associated sciences.

Carpel Dodger, for example, pointed out that polar bears are in danger of extinction, and laid the blame firmly on GW. You could have actually raised a scientifically interesting and valid objection to that, but because your POV is so coloured by rightwing prejudice and ignorance, you didn't.

When Carpel Dodger talks about the modern extinction risk, all you needed to do was raise the issue of food supply -- and how many seals get commercially killed annually by humans, thus robbing polar bears of food supply at a time when they are also threatened by the local effects of GW, and their ability to be able to respond to GW challenges is severely limited by human expansion.

But you couldn't even make a good case from that, even though it's quite easy; it's simply move the goalposts each and every time instead, and evade, and troll a bit, huh?
 
You are looking at 4 year's old data.

By now, China is emmiting more CO2 than anyone else.

But, following your point, the communists Russia and Central Asia and Rest of Europe are doing it far better than the capitalists in the USA :D
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom