North Pole is melting faster than predicted

http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTDATASTA/64199955-1178226923002/21322619/LGDB2007.pdf

The data in there says the opposite. But you never looked anyway, did you?

Actually, no. I haven't had the pleasure to be acquainted with the LITTLE GREEN DATA BOOK until you were so kind as to bring it to my attention. Are there any other Little Greenie books or pamphlets I should know about?

As AUP has suggested, I get my data from the IPCC reports. But I'll be happy to go drag my facts up for your benefit. If I have the facts wrong, I'll admit it.

Gurdur.

Ratios of hunting seals and polar bears have no relation to the question of:
  • global warming, does it exist, and is it (and or the hypothesized man made portion of it) responsible for the Arctic sea ice changes asserted to have recently occurred.
Your frenzy about Bush and Iraq (in other threads and alluded to in your post) has no place here
  • of course you are most welcome to develop some theory about why Bush and Iraq is causing global warming and inform us of that so that we can all consider your science.
Be sure to bring with those theories some "definitative, Authoritative Conclusionary evidenciary stuff":)
 
I wouldn't say that any World Bank publication is greenie, but in this times, who knows ? :D

The name of the book quoted says it all....

But there have been some interesting analysis of why World Bank actions have not helped Africa, and why the rejection of World Bank "help" by China has spurred China's economic development.

Is it related to this thread? Marginally - if you think that "sustainable development" for Africa, eg., not building powerplants and the industrial base - is the right path.

Keeping Africa impoverished would keep the emissions down on a per capita basis. This is handled in the IPCC modeled scenarios.
 
"Sustainable development"?

I have heard about it. It means that you apply to your next global competitors standars that would keep them appart of development for ages.

Good marketing concept BTW
 
....Gurdur.
Ratios of hunting seals and polar bears have no relation to the question of:
  • global warming, does it exist, and is it (and or the hypothesized man made portion of it) responsible for the Arctic sea ice changes asserted to have recently occurred.
Let me explain it for you in tiny little words so you can un-der-stand it.
CD raised the issue of polar bear extinction in relation to GW.
You made a silly appeal to the past.
I suggested you could have made a far better case based on other factors, a suggestion which flew right over your head apparently owing to your illiteracy in general biological sciences.

Never mind: a scientifically skilled person such as CD could have shot down your case even if you had made it. But at least it would have been a far better case than the mess you made.

Got it yet? No? Too bad.
Your frenzy about Bush and Iraq (in other threads and alluded to in your post) has no place here
Please don't make me laugh TOO much. I was referring to you yourself raising the issue in this thread, and what it revealed about your motives. Finished being so utterly silly yet? No?

of course you are most welcome to develop some theory about why Bush and Iraq is causing global warming
You're becoming utterly incoherent.
definitative, Authoritative Conclusionary evidenciary stuff
And you still can't spell, apparently, either.
 
"Sustainable development"?

I have heard about it. It means that you apply to your next global competitors standars that would keep them appart of development for ages.

Good marketing concept BTW

That is an accurate summary of those ideas and their implications. To see the complete opposite here are my views -

Coal fired power plants, industrial infrastructure development and technological infrastructure for Africa. Given that sub Saharan Africa goes from some 800 million people (nobody knows exactly) to 1.6 billion people by 2050 and presuming a resulting $5000 per capita income level (US dollars) at that point, anyone could say, that is one shining beacon of a success story.

Using a simple conservative estimate of CO2 emissions per dollar of GNP of one ton CO2 per $500 (similar to China today) gives roughly 16 billion ton CO2 in the year 2050.

More than double the US production of CO2 today. Those numbers lead back directly to the central question (summarized) of this thread:

Has anyone actually proved that CO2 is bad?

Or, presuming that it is and "urgent action is required" - "something must be done immediately" - the following rather disturbing conclusions exist -

To prevent global warming it is necessary for the developed countries to drastically curtail their CO2 emissions, and for the undeveloped countries to have "substainable development" (eg, not start producing copious amounts of CO2).
 
You are looking at 4 year's old data.

By now, China is emmiting more CO2 than anyone else.

But, following your point, the communists Russia and Central Asia and Rest of Europe are doing it far better than the capitalists in the USA :biggrin:
Per capita, the Americans release more Co2 than any other country.

If you're going only by sheer number of tons emitted, you should compensate for population. One billion Chinese are very likely going to emit far more Co2 than a fifth that number over in the States.
 
Diverging from the debate of Ad Infinitum Sea-Ice-arando and Ad Absurdo PolarBear-idiotica with the tactic of Ad Austuto Sidestep-arama....

here is an interesting 10 minute video on youtube.

Global Warming: An Unsettled Science

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMQH5aa5Q0s

The following reference documents are quoted.

Moberg 2005
Esper et all 2005 "Climate: past ranges and future changes"
2004 Storch
2006 de Matt and Maurellis "Evidence for influence of anthropogenic surface processes on lower tropospheric and surface temperature trends"
2006 NOAA "Temperature trends in the lower atmosphere"
2003 Stott et al
Sept 2005 Scafetta & West
March 2006 Scafetta & West
Sept 2006 Scafetta & West
 
Taking into account the growing in China's urban population and current industrialization rate, in 20 years one billion Chinese wll emit the same as one Billion americans.

Per capita, the Americans release more Co2 than any other country.

If you're going only by sheer number of tons emitted, you should compensate for population. One billion Chinese are very likely going to emit far more Co2 than a fifth that number over in the States.
 
Per capita, the Americans release more Co2 than any other country.

If you're going only by sheer number of tons emitted, you should compensate for population. One billion Chinese are very likely going to emit far more Co2 than a fifth that number over in the States.


No, the US does not release more CO2 than any other country per capita.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_greenhouse_gas_emissions_per_capita


Many, many countries emit more CO2 per dollar of GNP, which is a better measure than per capita emissions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_ratio_of_GDP_to_carbon_dioxide_emissions

The developing nations - China and India, plus Africa (if it can get past the "sustainable development" propaganda and the reverse help of all the well meaning do gooders) will determine the nature of the greenhouse gases in the atmosphere in future decades.

China has already surpassed the US in total emissions and will likely never go backwards on that scale.
 
Let me explain it for you in tiny little words so you can un-der-stand it.

And you still can't spell, apparently, either.

Yes Gurdor, I do appreciate the ad hominems matched only by a lack of substantial content. I do understand your argument about hunting polar bears and it's effects.

If I have misunderestimated the intent of your strategery, you are welcome to tape your broken hockey stick with some actual numerical numbers.

Use some of that fast setting, definitative, Authoritative Conclusionary evidenciary glue.;)

By all means bring in some of that IPCC science too.
 
I stand corrected. There are 13 whole nations, out of 185, ahead of the States.

Right. But look atwhat those countries are doing, what are they producing. That's why dollars of GNP as related to tonnage of CO2 is a better indicator. Breaking that down by industry is even better. For the crude ratio for the whole country, China is about $500 of GNP/ton CO2 and USA about $2000 of GNP/ton CO2.

This is inter related - many schemes to "reduce emissions" have a net effect of moving it offshore. If some large fraction of China's production went to the US (it does) then pro rata fraction of our consumption is at their level of emissions. To reduce it you hurt them, seriously...

Any scheme to "reduce emissions" is either political, a transfer of cash to underdeveloped countries (a la Kyoto) or realistic, which has harsh and non trivial impacts on those developing countries.

In either case, you must look at the developing nations to understand the future, developing problem of greenhouse gas emissions (AGW believer), or question the veracity of the argument based on CO2 directly (AGW skeptic).
 
That is an accurate summary of those ideas and their implications. To see the complete opposite here are my views -

Coal fired power plants, industrial infrastructure development and technological infrastructure for Africa. Given that sub Saharan Africa goes from some 800 million people (nobody knows exactly) to 1.6 billion people by 2050 and presuming a resulting $5000 per capita income level (US dollars) at that point, anyone could say, that is one shining beacon of a success story.

Which hasn't happened yet. Perchance that shining beacon is actually a wrecker's lantern?

(That's a tad obscure; google "Cornwall wrecker".)

Using a simple conservative estimate of CO2 emissions per dollar of GNP of one ton CO2 per $500 (similar to China today) gives roughly 16 billion ton CO2 in the year 2050.

So we're definitely screwed, then.

More than double the US production of CO2 today.

"Today", as in "not in 2050".

Those numbers lead back directly to the central question (summarized) of this thread:

Has anyone actually proved that CO2 is bad?

CO2 is a greenhouse gas, and without it there'd be no liquid water on the planet. OK, maybe a little bit at midday in the tropics, but more than that is better. Consider temperatures on the Moon, which shares our orbit. Without the grenhouse effect that's pretty much what we'd have down here.

CO2 isn't bad. It is what it is, and does what it does. There's third more of it doing just that than in 1850. It's counter-intuitive to suggest that that wouldn't make a significant difference. And it has.


Or, presuming that it is and "urgent action is required" - "something must be done immediately" - the following rather disturbing conclusions exist -

To prevent global warming it is necessary for the developed countries to drastically curtail their CO2 emissions, and for the undeveloped countries to have "substainable development" (eg, not start producing copious amounts of CO2).

:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom