North Pole is melting faster than predicted

An analysis conducted and "published" as a press release by a political think tank and authored by industry hacks as infamous as Avery and Singer could be of interest only to those dogmatically and uncritically pushing an agenda.

Hmmm.....

You seem to ignore facts a bit there, don't you?

Avery is saying the scientific literature does not support catastrophic global warming. Why would you have a problem with that? What's even political about it, for that matter?

One establishes if Avery can be trusted by looking at his work and reaching a conclusion about it based on it's merits. Pretty simple. If you have an argument about the facts, please present them.

Television interview (and transcript) 10 minute video of Singer and Avery "Physical evidence of Earth's Unstoppable 1,500 Year Climate Cycles".

No politics there, in the interview.
No obvious agenda except science, the way they understand it.
Are there scientific assertions there that you object to?
If so, what and on what basis?

More here.

Singer, Fred 2007 Physical Evidence of Earth's Unstoppable 1,500 Year Climate Cycle

Nothing about politics or political agendas there.
Again, in this document. Are there facts that you object to?
 
What kind of a report on sea ice is not a projection? The same is true for glaciers. You get satellite data on what is ice (white) vs what is water. Then you apply a rule set to estimate thicknesses at various points, figure the uncertainties, and publish or release some numbers with those uncertainties.

Sea-ice extent is two-dimensional. Its thickness is irrelevant. The thickness is highly relevant when it comes to predicting its future extent, but that's a different matter.

We have good satellite coverage of the Arctic from which the actual extent can be accurately calculated.

All reports made with the same methods and instruments would have the same error bounds unless someone figured a way to get more precision. Like I said, it is definitely look-up-able.

It only takes a moment's thought to realise that sea-ice extent is easily obervable, and that's what we're talking about - the observed reduction in Arctic sea-ice. Which has been quite startling this past summer.
 
http://www.earthtimes.org/articles/show/news_press_release,176495.shtml
[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]
Alarmism on climate has no basis in peer reviewed research, according to a tabulation of hundreds of articles.
[/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]"Not all of these researchers would describe themselves as global warming skeptics," said Avery, "but the evidence in their studies is there for all to see."


And in fact I believe not all of these researchers would agree with their papers being on this list

[/FONT]
 
An analysis conducted and "published" as a press release by a political think tank and authored by industry hacks as infamous as Avery and Singer could be of interest only to those dogmatically and uncritically pushing an agenda.

That's a bit broad, I think. It's of interest to some because they can take comfort from it, and that's what these weasels intended it to provide. You're dead right on the likes of Diamond, though : dogmatic, uncritical, none too bright, and committed to pushing the message. They're no different from the sad types who push Socialist Worker on Saturday morning high-streets.

It's of interest to me because I like to keep up-to-date with the weaseling - for instance, the 1500-year cycle is fairly new to Singer, now that his "it won't happen" and "it's not happening" weaselings are no longer tenable. So on to the "it's nothing special" weaseling. Very similar to the "everybody wheezes when they get older, so it's nothing to do with your smoking" thing Singer cut his teeth on. (He still finds time to bat for the tobacco lobby, on secondary smoking. Praise be! he's discovered it's not a problem :) .)

The unchanging dogma, of course, is that AGW must not be to blame. You've obviously spotted the ideological under-pinning of contrarianism - AGW is the Daddy of all externalities; externalities imply the need for regulation by the wider society; all regulation is evil and damaging; ergo externalities don't exist. Especially not this one. If science says different, then science has to be trashed.

Sadly for the dogmatists, AGW and science just won't go away.
 
Are there scientific assertions there that you object to?

Are there scientific assertions? What, for instance, are the suggested physical mechanisms that might explain this cycle?

It isn't just statistics, is it? Say it ain't so ...

1500-year cycle peaking now, Medieval Warm Period peaking a thousand years ago, which do you want to drop?
 
And in fact I believe not all of these researchers would agree with their papers being on this list

As I read it, the issue was alarmism and skepticism of it, not the broader issue of man made global warming and skepticism about that. Alarmism is a body of thought that goes way beyond IPCC projections and says things such as
  • 20 or (now) 80 foot sea level rise by 2050
  • all the arctic ice could melt in a few decades and not come back
  • greenland melts
  • hurricanes and tornados and droughts increase
  • we must take "drastic action now"
just for a few - it is definitely an "ad naseum" list

Most reasonable people are not on the fringe of any body of thought; alarmism is definitely on the fringe of thought on global warming. Alarmism is not promoted by the IPCC report, and it's scenarios do not contain these projections.

Avery's conclusions are in line with my own reading of the peer reviewed literature. It isn't that often that you read actual peer reviewed reseach that is "alarmist", that invokes these strange "tipping points" and positive feedback mechanisms to invoke the possiblity of a rapidly changing world.

It probably wouldn't get published if it had any large degree of that type of pseudo science, would it? (of course it might make the Guardian and other rags).
 
Sea-ice extent is two-dimensional. Its thickness is irrelevant. The thickness is highly relevant when it comes to predicting its future extent, but that's a different matter.

We have good satellite coverage of the Arctic from which the actual extent can be accurately calculated.

Why do you think thickness is irrelavant? There is an obvious difference between a three inch crust that forms overnight and can easily go away; and a six foot slab that's been there for fifty years. Also, that ice can jumble up on the side wind and current takes it, leaving an area of open sea, but a denser pack on the side where it collected.

Granted, though, I was thinking of ice volume and if you were considering just the sq. km. covered, that's where we got disconnected (well, more disconnected than is always the case).
 
Are there scientific assertions? What, for instance, are the suggested physical mechanisms that might explain this cycle?

It isn't just statistics, is it? Say it ain't so ...

1500-year cycle peaking now, Medieval Warm Period peaking a thousand years ago, which do you want to drop?

What subject are we on here? I responded to Bo's "industry funded yada yada" with some details, and asked him if that was appropriate on this piece of work. Here are the two subjects:
  • Avery has a new paper that reviews a large body of literature to specifically conclude there is no reason for alarmism.
  • Singer and Avery have a book etc on climate cycles.
 
And in fact I believe not all of these researchers would agree with their papers being on this list

[/b][/size][/size][/font][/size]

So there are some noises off-stage, but when the audience has its fingers in its ears while chanting "la-la-la I can't hear you" it has no impact.

Of course, it's a small arts-house that only survives by subsidy (because their scripts suck), and won't for much longer by the look of things. In the end, even mhaze will come to accept that it's been demolished, built over, and will not rise again in his lifetime.

There's a 60-80 year comfort-blanket that's far more pressing than the 1500 year version. But it isn't getting any press these days. What's that all about?
 
What subject are we on here? I responded to Bo's "industry funded yada yada" with some details ...

You cited a video and asked if there were any problems with the scientific assertions it contains. I asked you if there are any, and what they are. You're free enough with your questions, which I make an effort to answer. Could you not do me the same courtesy?

What are the scientific assertions made in the video? I'm not going to waste time watching it when you've done that already. Give me the gist : what are the scientific assertions it contains? They've made enough impression on you that you surely remember.
 
You cited a video and asked if there were any problems with the scientific assertions it contains. I asked you if there are any, and what they are. You're free enough with your questions, which I make an effort to answer. Could you not do me the same courtesy?

What are the scientific assertions made in the video? I'm not going to waste time watching it when you've done that already. Give me the gist : what are the scientific assertions it contains? They've made enough impression on you that you surely remember.

Sure, I was just not certain which study.

The video (going from memory) is a ten minute interview by a pretty good lady, one that we don't get out this direction and who asked tough questions.

Singer and Avery asserted that the temperatures and conditions we see today are the result of natural cycles, and that man's CO2 contribution to the atmosphere, as well as his future contributions, are not even worth considering as a factor in climate. They were pretty clear about land use, albedo and other things having a definite effect, and were no friend of pollution.

There was a question asked about had they ever taken any oil company money and the answer was that there was one very small unsolicited donation.

They made a statement that all the behavior change policies and attempts by government to regulate carbon dioxide emissions will fail to make any dent in climate.
 
Why do you think thickness is irrelavant?

Because the subject is extent. Area. Not volume. One dimension fewer.

There is an obvious difference between a three inch crust that forms overnight and can easily go away; and a six foot slab that's been there for fifty years.

So there is. In the Arctic, those three-inch crusts due to freezing don't occur in Summer, and some fifty year old slabs have gone away over very recent times. Rather a lot of them expiring just this year, quite unexpectedly.

Also, that ice can jumble up on the side wind and current takes it, leaving an area of open sea, but a denser pack on the side where it collected.

Wind, tides, and currents don't pile ice upon ice to any significant extent. Once ice is pushed out of the water wind is all that's left, and wind against a grounded solid is pretty inconsequential.

That's last year's argument for the relatively gradual loss of Arctic sea-ice over the previous decade. It's a knife at a gun-fight when it comes to this year.

Granted, though, I was thinking of ice volume and if you were considering just the sq. km. covered, that's where we got disconnected (well, more disconnected than is always the case).

Arctic sea-ice extent is what I've remained grounded on. I take comfort from a secure grounding.

It was the siren-song of 80% uncertainty that led you so far from shore. As is so often the case.
 
Sure, I was just not certain which study.

The video (going from memory) is a ten minute interview by a pretty good lady, one that we don't get out this direction and who asked tough questions.

Singer and Avery asserted that the temperatures and conditions we see today are the result of natural cycles, and that man's CO2 contribution to the atmosphere, as well as his future contributions, are not even worth considering as a factor in climate. They were pretty clear about land use, albedo and other things having a definite effect, and were no friend of pollution.

There was a question asked about had they ever taken any oil company money and the answer was that there was one very small unsolicited donation.

They made a statement that all the behavior change policies and attempts by government to regulate carbon dioxide emissions will fail to make any dent in climate.


So no scientific assertions were made, and these weasels handled the media just as one would expect them to given their experience in the game.

I don't doubt that you found it impressive and convincing. Especially the last statement you featured.

Where's the science? Face it, there isn't any, is there? All there is is presentation.

And meanwhile the world warms just as predicted by science.
 
Uh huh. Well, let's see. The subject was Avery's assertion that hundreds of peer reviewed articles did not support alarmism. I presented one technical work and one video in response to an ad hominem and suggested that the work be considered on it's own merits. You want information on the video and then you want to criticize it based on my comments?

Singer's summary of the 1,500 year climate cycle book in html. There is something more substantial for you to criticize than a TV interview.

Take your pick of a chapter and go at it.
 
Because the subject is extent. Area. Not volume. One dimension fewer. It was the siren-song of 80% uncertainty that led you so far from shore. As is so often the case.

Siren song...
Suppose

2005 ice is 1,000,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.
2006 ice is 900,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.

How much did ice change?
 
Siren song...
Suppose

2005 ice is 1,000,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.
2006 ice is 900,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.

How much did ice change?

For the actual figure see http://nsidc.org/news/press/2007_seaiceminimum/20070810_index.html

As of September 16, sea ice extent was 4.14 million square kilometers (1.59 million square miles), surpassing the previous one-day record of September 20–21, 2005, by more than 1.2 million square kilometers (461,000 square miles).

The actual reduction has been quite significant.
 
Uh huh. Well, let's see. The subject was Avery's assertion that hundreds of peer reviewed articles did not support alarmism. I presented one technical work and one video in response to an ad hominem and suggested that the work be considered on it's own merits. You want information on the video and then you want to criticize it based on my comments?

I want to know what the scientific assertions you previously referred to are. My question was disingenuous, as I didn't expect there to be any. Nor, apparently, are there. Just a couple of media-savvy weasels humming your sort of mood-music.

Singer's summary of the 1,500 year climate cycle book in html. There is something more substantial for you to criticize than a TV interview.

Take your pick of a chapter and go at it.

Well, why not? Might as well keep up with what the weasels are chewing on these days.

"The report that Dansgaard and Oeschger wrote in 1984, “North Atlantic Climatic Oscillations Revealed by Deep Greenland Ice Cores,” was, in retrospect, almost eerie in its accuracy, its completeness and its logical linking of the climate cycles to the sun.4 The only major correction imposed by subsequent research is that the cycles were more frequent than they thought. The average length of the cycles has now been shortened by almost half — from their original estimate of 2,550 years to 1,500 years (plus or minus 500 years)."

"Almost eerie in its accuracy". That seems to translate as "just what Dr Singer ordered". Solar output has been stable over the last fifty years while we've been observing it rather than speculating about it.

Originally 2550 years, now 1500 plus or minus 500. Not terribly robust, is it? Go looking for a cycle of one to two thousand years in a noisy data set and you can probably find one, given enough effort.

I wonder who introduced that plus or minus? It's suspiciously useful to Singer when so much has already been made of a Medieval Warm Period rather less than 1500 years ago. Would scientists actually publish about a cycle of such variable period?

Dansgaard and Oeschger were correct when they told us that the climate shifts were moderate, rising and falling over a range of about 4° C in northern Greenland, with very little temperature change at the equator — and only half a degree when averaged over the northern hemisphere.

NH climate has warmed 0.6C over a century - not over a whole half-cycle of a period of at least a thousand years. NH climate has warmed rather more than that over the last 500 years. So it seems conditions have broken free of any similar cycle that there may be.

Singer's treatment of the evidence is as self-serving as we'd expect of a weasel, but one thing in particular strikes me as odd. The amplitude remains the same through glaciations and inter-glacials, even though the feedbacks would be different in each case. Glaciations are very different from interglacials, especially in the Northern Hemisphere, in particular albedo. Yet a solar cycle is supposed to have the same effect in both circumstances. I find that counter-intuitive, and doubt I'm alone.
 
Seriously, does anybody know where Singer's "plus or minus 500 years" comes from? He claims to have lots of science support for a 1500-year cycle : how much of this support comes with a "plus or minus 500 years" proviso?

Singer is a weasel, so it can't be discounted that he introduced it all by his own self to get over the Medieval Warm Period problem - the problem being that it hasn't been touted as a Dark Age Warm Period. Rather the reverse : the Dark Ages have been touted as a cold period, preceded by a Roman Warm Period.

mhaze : you'll have checked this out, surely? It's not as if you haven't been warned that Singer is a weasel.
 
Seriously, does anybody know where Singer's "plus or minus 500 years" comes from? He claims to have lots of science support for a 1500-year cycle : how much of this support comes with a "plus or minus 500 years" proviso?
Singer is a weasel....
It's not as if you haven't been warned that Singer is a weasel.

I assume from your ad hominem attacks that you do not want to address the scientific facts addressed by the studies that Singer references, some hundreds of them. In trying to sort through the ad hominem attacks to find something worth replying to, I do see an issue with the concept of "1500 year plus or minus 500 year" cycle.

What part of that do you have a problem with? If a scientist looks at other work other scientists have done, and notes that many of them have seen these cycles, and then reports the range of the cycle, what is wrong with that?

It is wrong if it is actually "plus or minus 500" and it is incorrectly stated "plus or minus 250".

Which leads me right square back to my prior question to you.
Originally Posted by CapelDodger
It was the siren-song of 80% uncertainty that led you so far from shore. As is so often the case.
​
I replied
Siren song...Suppose
2005 ice is 1,000,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.
2006 ice is 900,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.
How much did ice change?
​
One more time. How much did the ice change?
 
You'll find that the answer is exactly the same volume when melted. All of that horrible sea-ice melt won't raise sea-levels by so much as a millimeter.

The "rise" in sea levels just keeps shrinking...

http://www.worldclimatereport.com/index.php/2007/09/14/sea-level-slowdown/#more-266

World Climate Reports a new study on sea level rise being lowered, Woppelmann et al 2007.

By using a network of distributed GPS stations, they measured vertical motion of the earth. Two thirds of these stations were less than 15 km from a tide gauge. Factoring measurements of land motion into the estimate of sea-level rise, they determined a global value of 1.31 ±0.30 mm per year compared to the 1.8±0.5 mm per year value given by the IPCC for the recent half century.
Reference:
Wöppelmann, G., B. Martin Miguez, M.-N. Bouin, and Z. Altamimi. 2007. Geocentric sea-level trend estimates from GPS analyses at relevant tide gauges world-wide. Global and Planetary Change, 57, 396–406.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom