North Pole is melting faster than predicted

http://www.nasa.gov/centers/goddard/news/topstory/2005/sea_ice_prt.htm

The increase in sea ice is due to Global Warming. Ain't science great? No matter what happens, science can explain it.

Hey, Rob, you know. You got to remember, we got three kinds of science around here.

Real science.
IPCC science.
Gore science.

Three kinds is three times better.
You can get just what ya feel like ya want.

It's like this. Would you like to walk in the corner market and find they only had Cokes. No way. You'd like Pepsi, Sprite, Diet Coke, Big Red, and regular Cokes.

See? Those three kinds of science, that's much better fer ya.
 
.Would you like to walk in the corner market and find they only had Cokes. No way. You'd like Pepsi, Sprite, Diet Coke, Big Red, and regular Cokes.

Bad example. All of those are bad for you. But there are places that sell only coke, or only Pepsi products. You know why? Because either Coke or Pepsi has partial or complete ownership of the establishment, or some kind of deal, where they don't allow competition.

I know, I know, hard to believe isn't it? Money, profit, people who want to make money, and already have lots of it, they can influence your choice of beverage.

Which brings us back to science. Does anybody here really think science is free from politics, profit or power? That there is some kind of "pure science", untouched by greed or the motivation for profit?

Not a chance. Then there is the emotional factors, the hidden religious bias, and the really munged reasons, politics, prestige, power and social climbing.
 
According to a show I just watched on the Science Channel, we are supposed to be in a Global Cooling period. Maybe all that CO2 and cutting down trees is really saving us from an Ice Age? What about that?

Rising Sea Levels? Oh well. Real Estate opportunities.

Greenland melting? New real estate.

North Pole ice free? Cheaper shipping.

It's a win-win situation.

It's a very shorted sighted point of view. Read the IPCC.
 
Hey, Rob, you know. You got to remember, we got three kinds of science around here.

Real science.
IPCC science.
Gore science.

Three kinds is three times better.
You can get just what ya feel like ya want.

It's like this. Would you like to walk in the corner market and find they only had Cokes. No way. You'd like Pepsi, Sprite, Diet Coke, Big Red, and regular Cokes.

See? Those three kinds of science, that's much better fer ya.

What do you call Chrichton et al? Opinion is my guess.
 
On the topic of free floating ice melt....

I remember reading a few years back about water having different gravitational properties if frozen or liquid.

I don't recall how it compares to the other -volume of melted water- factors already discussed. I don't even remember if the difference meant more or less volume when melted.
 
A quibble, prehaps, but I think what you mean is mostly covered with. The fluid layer of atmosphere and oceans is a very thin skim on the surface of a rocky planet that really doesn't give a toss about us. Yet :cool: .

AGW means we can significantly influence that thin fluid skim (significant in our terms, since that's where we live). Considered in combination with our ambition, the rocky planet below would be well-advised to regard it as significant, but probably won't until it's too late.

And its back to climate change denial then. Climate never changes at all, never swings from cooling to warming, and is so sensitive to a minor change in a trace gas (which has also never been higher) that it runs away like a runaway train on a rollercoaster.

It's all caused by the sin of man eating from the fruit of the tree of knowledge (science and technology) and only repentence (carbon rationing) will enable us to survive the future apocalyse.

Creationism in other words.
 
And its back to climate change denial then. Climate never changes at all, never swings from cooling to warming, and is so sensitive to a minor change in a trace gas (which has also never been higher) that it runs away like a runaway train on a rollercoaster.

It's all caused by the sin of man eating from the fruit of the tree of knowledge (science and technology) and only repentence (carbon rationing) will enable us to survive the future apocalyse.

Creationism in other words.

If I ever meet anyone who thinks that, I'll be sure to pass the message on.
 
On the topic of free floating ice melt....

I remember reading a few years back about water having different gravitational properties if frozen or liquid.

I don't recall how it compares to the other -volume of melted water- factors already discussed. I don't even remember if the difference meant more or less volume when melted.

You'll find that the answer is exactly the same volume when melted. All of that horrible sea-ice melt won't raise sea-levels by so much as a millimeter.
 
If I ever meet anyone who thinks that, I'll be sure to pass the message on.

That would be you, and the sign is of the Hockey Stick, which you cannot let go of, since it perfectly encapulates your belief system in graphical form.

No matter that the statistical model fails statistical tests, or that the underlying science makes no sense. AUP believes it to be true, like a good creationist should.
 
On the topic of free floating ice melt....

I remember reading a few years back about water having different gravitational properties if frozen or liquid.

I don't recall how it compares to the other -volume of melted water- factors already discussed. I don't even remember if the difference meant more or less volume when melted.

If memory serves, the melted volume is very marginally the greater. It's something to do with the relative densities of salt water and fresh. I don't think it's terribly significant.
 
If memory serves, the melted volume is very marginally the greater. It's something to do with the relative densities of salt water and fresh. I don't think it's terribly significant.

CP you had asked where did the error range I quoted +80% -50% come from. It was based on a study of the loss of ice in a year's time, not the total. Has to do with the difficulties of measuring ice area from satellites and then guessing the thickness.

I may find the actual note or may not, but we could probably go find the general errors just as easy. They would apply to all those calculations although perhaps there have been or will be some improvements.
 
Which brings us back to science. Does anybody here really think science is free from politics, profit or power? That there is some kind of "pure science", untouched by greed or the motivation for profit?

The open nature of science constantly purifies it. Lamarkism hung on for a while because Stalin liked the idea, but it was a minority sport and quickly dumped when Uncle Joe finally got the pillow-in-the-face treatment.

Scientists like money as much as anyone else, but they won't profit much from fraud or bias. If they get things right, they might be able to profit commercially. Get it wrong and the commercial venture goes down the toilet. And it doesn't do your career much good either.

Not a chance. Then there is the emotional factors, the hidden religious bias, and the really munged reasons, politics, prestige, power and social climbing.

Where's the religious bias hiding in thermodynamics? Are you perhaps you're thinking of Einstein's Demon? That pertains to a thought-experiment, not the supernatural.

You'll be making mhaze uncomfortable with sort of stuff. mhaze is dead keen on nuclear power, and surely doesn't want to hear that the science behind it is so undependable.

Science could not possible have advanced as far and fast as it has done over the last two centuries if it had constanly been blown around by the ever-changing winds of religion and politics. It progresses because it has firm foundations to build on. It doesn't have to keep back-tracking when political and social realities change.

Prestige matters to scientists as much as it does to anybody. (In academia, it's indistinguishable from social-climbing.) Prestige is gained by being right, and can be lost by being wrong. So scientists have every incentive to either be right, or to keep quiet.

Some scientists are nutters, of course, and have fixations. Such as Duisberg and his thing about HIV. They are a minority. and easily identified. Then you have examples like Edison's orchestrated campaign against AC, which was commercially motivated. The overall effect is minimal and short-lived.

As to power, forget it. Science is not a route to power, and never has been. To wealth and public prominence, yes, on occasion, but not to power. Defence-related science can get you close to power, but not into it. Money and politics get you there.
 
Hey, Rob, you know. You got to remember, we got three kinds of science around here.

Real science

The science that I, a_unique_person and others post about.

IPCC science.

The IPCC doesn't do science. It's a body that was set up by the international community, aka the governing bodies of nation-states, to collate the existing science on AGW and report on it to the aforesaid international community.

That's why I, aup, etc. don't often bring in the IPCC.

Gore science.

:rolleyes:

Three kinds is three times better.
You can get just what ya feel like ya want.

This must bring you great comfort.

At the same time, there was all that Arctic sea-ice retreat. Predicted in principle by real science, as reported by the IPCC, but not in its precipitate recent detail. It's been quite startling.
 
CP you had asked where did the error range I quoted +80% -50% come from. It was based on a study of the loss of ice in a year's time, not the total. Has to do with the difficulties of measuring ice area from satellites and then guessing the thickness.

So when you said

It would be wise to be somewhat skeptical about all the ice reports.

The numbers are hard to calculate and the stated errors are often like + 80 % and -50%.

on a thread about this year's Arctic sea-ice retreat you were actually referring to projections, not reports. Yet you refer to "reports", and all of them.

I may find the actual note or may not, but we could probably go find the general errors just as easy. They would apply to all those calculations although perhaps there have been or will be some improvements.

Waffle doesn't phase me, you know. Arctic sea-ice extent is a matter of observation, not prediction and only very marginally one of calculation.

Associating uncertainty of 80% with actual observations may well bring you comfort, but it's not going to change reality. Deep inside, I'm sure you know that. You will eventually have to deal with it, perhaps as soon as three to eight years time.

Possibly with Al Gore as President for most it. :jaw-dropp
 
on a thread about this year's Arctic sea-ice retreat you were actually referring to projections, not reports. Yet you refer to "reports", and all of them.

What kind of a report on sea ice is not a projection? The same is true for glaciers. You get satellite data on what is ice (white) vs what is water. Then you apply a rule set to estimate thicknesses at various points, figure the uncertainties, and publish or release some numbers with those uncertainties.

All reports made with the same methods and instruments would have the same error bounds unless someone figured a way to get more precision. Like I said, it is definitely look-up-able.
 
The IPCC doesn't do science. It's a body that was set up by the international community, aka the governing bodies of nation-states, to collate the existing science on AGW and report on it to the aforesaid international community.

That's why I, aup, etc. don't often bring in the IPCC.

AUP doesn't often bring in the IPCC? In what alternate universe?
 
....Which brings us back to science. Does anybody here really think science is free from politics, profit or power? That there is some kind of "pure science", untouched by greed or the motivation for profit....


This reminds me of the usual petty-criminal stock line of argument.

"Everyone lies.So why can't I?"
"You would steal if you could, So I am more honest than you by actually stealing".
"Women are dishonest bitches, so it's OK to rape."


Science, as a group and institution, is one of the more honest things going around, owing to rather relentless peer review. If you happen to be moved much more by political agendas, please do not try pretending science is every bit as bad as you are.
 
http://www.earthtimes.org/articles/show/news_press_release,176495.shtml
[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]
Alarmism on climate has no basis in peer reviewed research, according to a tabulation of hundreds of articles.
[/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]"Not all of these researchers would describe themselves as global warming skeptics," said Avery, "but the evidence in their studies is there for all to see."[/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]
WASHINGTON, Sept. 12 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ --

A new analysis of peer-reviewed literature reveals that more than 500 scientists have published evidence refuting at least one element of current man-made global warming scares. More than 300 of the scientists found evidence that 1) a natural moderate 1,500-year climate cycle has produced more than a dozen global warmings similar to ours since the last Ice Age and/or that 2) our Modern Warming is linked strongly to variations in the sun's irradiance. "This data and the list of scientists make a mockery of recent claims that a scientific consensus blames humans as the primary cause of global temperature increases since 1850," said Hudson Institute Senior Fellow Dennis Avery.

Other researchers found evidence that 3) sea levels are failing to rise importantly; 4) that our storms and droughts are becoming fewer and milder with this warming as they did during previous global warmings; 5) that human deaths will be reduced with warming because cold kills twice as many people as heat; and 6) that corals, trees, birds, mammals, and butterflies are adapting well to the routine reality of changing climate.

Despite being published in such journals such as Science, Nature and Geophysical Review Letters, these scientists have gotten little media attention. "Not all of these researchers would describe themselves as global warming skeptics," said Avery, "but the evidence in their studies is there for all to see."

[/FONT]
 
An analysis conducted and "published" as a press release by a political think tank and authored by industry hacks as infamous as Avery and Singer could be of interest only to those dogmatically and uncritically pushing an agenda.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom