North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Given the lack of contextual scientific knowledge and the lack of logic mhaze has shown here, give you one guess and one guess only?

But it does explain why mhaze both has such an animus against genuine science and why he thinks he is superior to it.

No, that line of research could have been continued with that professor gone. I would have had to have started all over. But it was fun while it lasted. Hey, stuff happens.
 
No, that line of research could have been continued with that professor gone. I would have had to have started all over. But it was fun while it lasted. Hey, stuff happens.

Too tired to be logical, correction. That line of research could not have been continued with that prof gone.
 
Antarctic Ice Levels Hit Record High

Highest amount seen since record-keeping began


Researchers at the University of Illinois are reporting a sharp increase in the total amount of sea ice in the Southern Hemisphere. Recent observations show the total ice area now at 16.26 million square kilometers -- the highest amount seen since record-keeping began, and up more than 8% over the past five years.

http://www.dailytech.com/Antarctic+Ice+Levels+Hit+Record+High/article8871.htm
 
Antarctica is an interesting place - unlike the Arctic, it has no direct injection of warm, tropical waters. There is an injection into the circumpolar current though, although this may only handle so much uptake before transferring it to the atmosphere. Even so, the winds are circumpolar as well so insulating (to a degree) the Antarctic continent. If Global Warming is real (I think it is, whether Anthropic or not), then some degree of 'catch-up' is almost inevitable. The AGW skeptics might be advised not to put all their chips on current Antarctic stability! It will be of some interest to see what happens this, and subsequent, (Antarctic) summers.
 
I told you I checked. See? See? It's true.

It would be wise to be somewhat skeptical about all the ice reports.

The numbers are hard to calculate and the stated errors are often like + 80 % and -50%.
 
It would be wise to be somewhat skeptical about all the ice reports.

The numbers are hard to calculate and the stated errors are often like + 80 % and -50%.

What? There could be 80% less Arctic sea-ice than is thought? Or 80% more?

Where do you get this stuff from? I can understand why you love it, but where do you find it?
 
Retreating glaciers. Vanishing sea-ice. Tree-line moving northwards and upwards. Species migrating in the same way - north and up, not south and down. Earlier spings, later autumns. All the stuff that's happening around us.

Oh the horror!

Temperature increase won't be exponential, nor will it directly reflect CO2 levels at any particular time. The relationship is between CO2-level and the equilibrium temperature, which we haven't reached yet, and obviously won't while CO2-load keeps increasing. The rate of warming depends on the global energy-balance at any particular time.

Complete nonsense. There is no such thing as an equilibrium temperature for the Earth's atmosphere. You talk about CO2 load as if it meant anything but it doesn't - the ice core record is unequivocal on this point: CO2 does not cause warming, rather temperature rise causes (delayed) CO2 rise. Never the other way around.

There is also no such thing as a "global energy balance" at any time, never mind any particular time.

If you knew anything about quantum physics (which you don't) then you'd know that the supposed mechanism by which increasing CO2 causes temperature cannot occur by simply increasing the partial pressure of CO2.

See above. All these events and more, which you could go and confirm yourself, given the funds and time. They're not being made up or extracted from manipulated statistics. They're real. Anybody my age can tell you their regional climate has changed over the last forty years. As a gardener I've seen it change markedly in the last twenty. Apples in August, two crops of strawberries, lavender flowering twice (that's happened for the last few years), jasmine flowering in December despite not being a winter jasmine. General confusion amongst the plantlife. A plague of slugs, with no hard frosts to cull them. That's a real pain.

Yes its the end of the world as we know it. We're going to be overrun by slugs. It's like a horror movie. We're defenseless against them as our saltshakers have been emptied by ExxonMobil.

Then you can look to the measurements, from ground-stations, satellites and ocean buoys. You'll get the same message. The atmosphere and oceans are warming significantly, and there's no sign of it stopping.

Why would we want it to stop? Besides which, the Antartic continues to cool and the sea ice is thickening and extending fast. But that's probably a disaster too, because the Earth's climate isn't stable and keeps warming and cooling without permission.

Incidentally the NorthWest passage has opened for the first time in history: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/918448.stm

That was in 2000. So only seven years. It's amazing how short history gets when you're trying to rewrite it, isn't it?
 
Antarctica is an interesting place - unlike the Arctic, it has no direct injection of warm, tropical waters. There is an injection into the circumpolar current though, although this may only handle so much uptake before transferring it to the atmosphere. Even so, the winds are circumpolar as well so insulating (to a degree) the Antarctic continent. If Global Warming is real (I think it is, whether Anthropic or not), then some degree of 'catch-up' is almost inevitable. The AGW skeptics might be advised not to put all their chips on current Antarctic stability! It will be of some interest to see what happens this, and subsequent, (Antarctic) summers.

Partly for the reasons you've given, Antarctica is a very stable system. Even between glaciations and interglacials it doesn't change much. For a start, Central Antarctica is so far above sea-level that it never gets above zero. And on the periphery, ice-cover has to expand onto ocean, not land, as it does in the North. That's a much slower process.

The Arctic and the continental mass surrounding it react pretty violently to climate change. The Central Arctic is never very high, and ice can spread onto land. As it does during a glaciation.

Notice how the contrarians have switched the subject from the Arctic to the Antarctic, one of their favourite refuges because it is so stable. Utterly unrepresentative of the globe in general, but the globe in general is a problem for them. So they point to peculiarities - a few expanding glaciers out of a few hundred, say - and ask "What about that, then? Eh? How do you explain that?"

Other refuges are the past (the deeper the better), planets and moons (but not ours, and not all of them), and the inexactitude of measurements (however slight and inconsequential).

The Arctic region is worth watching because it's the most sensitive to climate change. Antarctica, not so much. Greenland (a blend of the two), definitely. The Arctic has changed, and is changing, quite radically.
 
According to a show I just watched on the Science Channel, we are supposed to be in a Global Cooling period. Maybe all that CO2 and cutting down trees is really saving us from an Ice Age? What about that?

Rising Sea Levels? Oh well. Real Estate opportunities.

Greenland melting? New real estate.

North Pole ice free? Cheaper shipping.

It's a win-win situation.
 
http://www.nasa.gov/centers/goddard/news/topstory/2005/sea_ice_prt.htm

The increase in sea ice is due to Global Warming. Ain't science great? No matter what happens, science can explain it.


"Typically, warming of the climate leads to increased melting rates of sea ice cover and increased precipitation rates. However, in the Southern Ocean, with increased precipitation rates and deeper snow, the additional load of snow becomes so heavy that it pushes the Antarctic sea ice below sea level. This results in even more and even thicker sea ice when the snow refreezes as more ice. Therefore, the paper indicates that some climate processes, like warmer air temperatures increasing the amount of sea ice, may go against what we would normally believe would occur."

Do you have a problem with the scientific explanation? It may seem counter-intuitive, but that's not a flaw.
 
I love science. In another thread here, a while back, I stated with no quibbling, that Global Warming will lead to greater precipitation, including snow and ice. It is easy to forget what our planet is mostly made of. And what Global Warming means.
 
I've covered this topic repeatedly in both this and the Global Warming thread.

I've looked at various links provided, and "Southern Ocean" and "Antarctic" sea-ice is used interchangeably. Adding a little confusion. At least the Arctic Ocean stays inside the Arctic.

Do you by chance know how much of this southern sea-ice is in the form of icebergs outside the Antarctic?
 
I love science. In another thread here, a while back, I stated with no quibbling, that Global Warming will lead to greater precipitation, including snow and ice. It is easy to forget what our planet is mostly made of.

A quibble, prehaps, but I think what you mean is mostly covered with. The fluid layer of atmosphere and oceans is a very thin skim on the surface of a rocky planet that really doesn't give a toss about us. Yet :cool: .

And what Global Warming means.

AGW means we can significantly influence that thin fluid skim (significant in our terms, since that's where we live). Considered in combination with our ambition, the rocky planet below would be well-advised to regard it as significant, but probably won't until it's too late.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom