North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Of course this argument reference to the movie "Idiocracy" .

In that dystopia, you pickup your Phd at Costco.

Irony 304 ;)

Wow, an attempt at flaming... I'm overwhelmed with your wit, only surpassed by your lack of contact with the real world.

But your irony hit deep. I will now bow my head in shame, abandon my studies and not finish my thesis.

Instead, I'll dedicate my time to try to convince people that AGW is a communist scam, evolution is an atheist one, and that the sky is green.

Wait, I can't... I have thoughts...
 
Wow, an attempt at flaming... I'm overwhelmed with your wit, only surpassed by your lack of contact with the real world.

But your irony hit deep. I will now bow my head in shame, abandon my studies and not finish my thesis.

You'd be joining up with me.

I abandoned the thesis/phD when my professor quit to play pro golf.

Best thing I ever did.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
  • IPCC temperature rise of 1C in last century based largely on Jones et al.
  • Jones refuses to release his data and methods.
  • Jones has been formally charged with scientific fraud separately.
Do you refute any of this?
​
1. Yes.
2. Yes.
3. Yes.

Do you reject it because you just don't like those facts, or what?
 
[/indent]Well, how about some actual demonstration of this exponential trend in the last 50 years? A relation between CO2 and temperatures of that sort.

Retreating glaciers. Vanishing sea-ice. Tree-line moving northwards and upwards. Species migrating in the same way - north and up, not south and down. Earlier spings, later autumns. All the stuff that's happening around us.

Temperature increase won't be exponential, nor will it directly reflect CO2 levels at any particular time. The relationship is between CO2-level and the equilibrium temperature, which we haven't reached yet, and obviously won't while CO2-load keeps increasing. The rate of warming depends on the global energy-balance at any particular time.

That would be what, an exponential temperature increase? I know quite well you can say it exists. I'm asking if you can objectively demonstrate it.

See above. All these events and more, which you could go and confirm yourself, given the funds and time. They're not being made up or extracted from manipulated statistics. They're real. Anybody my age can tell you their regional climate has changed over the last forty years. As a gardener I've seen it change markedly in the last twenty. Apples in August, two crops of strawberries, lavender flowering twice (that's happened for the last few years), jasmine flowering in December despite not being a winter jasmine. General confusion amongst the plantlife. A plague of slugs, with no hard frosts to cull them. That's a real pain.

Then you can look to the measurements, from ground-stations, satellites and ocean buoys. You'll get the same message. The atmosphere and oceans are warming significantly, and there's no sign of it stopping.
 
Retreating glaciers. Vanishing sea-ice. Tree-line moving northwards and upwards. Species migrating in the same way - north and up, not south and down. Earlier spings, later autumns. All the stuff that's happening around us.

Temperature increase won't be exponential, nor will it directly reflect CO2 levels at any particular time. The relationship is between CO2-level and the equilibrium temperature, which we haven't reached yet, and obviously won't while CO2-load keeps increasing.

No quantifiable relation of global temperatures to co2 levels.
 
Still looks like the ice is melting - even now, in the middle of September (Should be starting to re-freeze by now?).

It should be stabilised about now. The freezing normally becomes evident in late September/early October. It's difficult to be specific because the ice moves quite a bit, so you can't just say "Ice here today, no ice here yesterday, ergo freezing."

The opening of the North-West Passage may well be down to ice-movement rather than ice-loss. If it is down to movement, then the ice had space to move into, of course. Which in previous years it presumably hasn't, since this is a new phaenomenon.

The North-West Passage. All those lives lost trying to find it, when all we had to do was wait for it to come to us ...
 
No quantifiable relation of global temperatures to co2 levels.

About 3C temperature rise for a doubling of CO2.

On a more general point : more CO2, higher temperature. Higher temperature : retreating glaciers, vanishing sea-ice, yadda-yadda.

The subject only matters because of its effects. Not because of the numbers. Things happen even if they're not precisely measured. Graphs and equations are not reality, they are attempts to represent reality. Since reality is what we're concerned about we can cut to the chase and observe what's happening. Retreating glaciers, vanishing sea-ice, yadda-yadda.
 
How do you know? Was your thesis that obviously worthless?

Given the lack of contextual scientific knowledge and the lack of logic mhaze has shown here, give you one guess and one guess only?

But it does explain why mhaze both has such an animus against genuine science and why he thinks he is superior to it.
 
But it does explain why mhaze both has such an animus against genuine science and why he thinks he is superior to it.

Suggests an explanation, perhaps. mhaze's PhD may not have been in the field of science. I get the impression that it wasn't.

I never started a PhD, nor ever intended to. Degree, job, money, boo-yah! :) Hey, it worked for me.
 
Are you saying it was never navigated in the 20th century?

No.

Or doesn't the recent past matter either?

Of course it does. A damn' sight more than the distant past, in this context. Not so much in the "human condition" context; that carries on being much of a muchness. First Denial, then Anger, Blame, Revenge, and then Moving On.
 
What happens when the Gulf Stream stops?

You find someone to blame for not winding it up :) .

It's not something to worry about. Very, very unlikely, and only then in conditions where AGW will compensate for North Atlantic cooling. It's really not an issue.

Sea-level rise of a metre or more over the next century definitely is an issue. Not dramatic, but insidious. You couldn't write a film around it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom