Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

In your scenario, Bri, the police are clueless buffoons. They've been searching the same area for 10 months, but need a psychic to tell them to search in a new location, which by an odd coincidence, turns out to be where the body is.

How is that a coincidence? There are only two possibilities: the body is by the railway where they were searching, or the body is somewhere else. How is it "an odd coincidence" that it turns out to be somewhere else?

You contend that in MY scenario, the police must have been clueless buffoons for searching the same area for 10 months. But that fact is not in dispute. Therefore, in YOUR scenario, the police are equally buffoons.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I have a question for those that think that psychic powers exist and can be used to find missing people:

Why are there still missing people, if psychics have the power to find them?

Here's another one:

Is this the best you've got? Arguing over whether a newspaper article is definitive evidence of a psychic using psychic power to find one person? A newspaper article that just says that the psychic told police something like "yeah, i wouldn't search there anymore, given that you've already searched there and didn't find anything"
 
Yup! That's all they've got, logical muse.

Of course, Rodney has claimed that this is strong evidence of someone using psychic powers to find a missing person. In fact, he believes that this article is even better evidence than a double-blind test, and that "Norm Pratt passed that test with flying colors."

-Bri
 
If the newspaper article won't do it, how about a Swift Online Newsletter of the JREF (dated 2/25/05). Reader Richard Smith of Ottawa, Canada, offers his analysis of the story. It's the third article down, The British Columbia "Psychic" but I'd take it with a grain of salt.

http://www.randi.org/jr/022505thank.html#3
 
The more I read about it, the more I wonder why the police aren't looking at Pratt as more of a suspect.

After all, it's still unclear in the various articles if the coroner has determined the cause of death, whether or not the police in general feel that it doesn't look like foul play.
 
If the newspaper article won't do it, how about a Swift Online Newsletter of the JREF (dated 2/25/05). Reader Richard Smith of Ottawa, Canada, offers his analysis of the story. It's the third article down, The British Columbia "Psychic" but I'd take it with a grain of salt.

http://www.randi.org/jr/022505thank.html#3

I'd have to agree that I could do without the snarky comments. But isn't that just a story about a fellow spending months looking all over the area until he came across her clothes? Why couldn't someone without psychic powers have done that?

Linda
 
I knew that would getcha. :D I'm going to see if I can get some lottery numbers from him.
 
If you think that the newspaper article was a little sketchy, I found another one about a different search with a lot more details. This story definitely gives him more credibility.

http://www.normpratt.com/images/article-2006-12-22_the_Western_Star.jpg

http://www.normpratt.com/coverage/

There isn't any indication that the information came from anyone but Pratt. It would add to his credibility if there was independent corroboration of his claims, from more than one person. And it doesn't seem likely that a non-psychic couldn't have had the same idea - that the body was carried further than they thought.

Linda
(Hehe...he said "tit bit")
</Beavis and Butthead imitation>
 
According to figures from the (USA) National Crime Information Center, as of December 31st, 2006, there were 110,484 active missing person records.

http://www.fbi.gov/hq/cjisd/missingpersons.htm

The American Association of Psychics "directory will only invite the best 144 psychics in each state".

http://www.americanassociationofpsychics.com/member_benefits.htm

There are 50 states in the USA, which means the American Association of Psychics has only (potentially) 7,200 psychics. They also claim that "Less [sic] than 5% of the psychics who request membership are actually invited to join." This indicates that over 144,000 psychics have requested to join.

If, on average, each psychic finds slightly less than one missing person, there will be no missing persons.

Why are there missing persons, with all these psychics around?
 
No, if a psychic achieves 30% in a proper double-blind test then they should not be allowed to claim 80%, and the police can then decide whether a 30% success rate is worth their time. If DNA testing was only accurate 30% of the time, it likely would never be used because 70% of the time police would be wasting their time chasing the wrong person.
If psychics could perform as little as 10 % that would still be sensational and very usefull in search of a missing person. Imagine if we could reduce the number of spots to search to an average of ten, instead of maybe hundreds. When it comes to dna evidence even 99 % isnt enough to prove a case, but 30 % could be usefull in the search of a suspect. Its all about what the results are used for, searching or establishing facts.

Of course, psychics are still useless, as they cant perform better then chanse.
 
Last edited:
If psychics could perform as little as 10 % that would still be sensational and very usefull in search of a missing person. Imagine if we could reduce the number of spots to search to an average of ten, instead of maybe hundreds. When it comes to dna evidence even 99 % isnt enough to prove a case, but 30 % could be usefull in the search of a suspect. Its all about what the results are used for, searching or establishing facts.

Of course, psychics are still useless, as they cant perform better then chanse.

I agree that it depends what the results are used for, and my analogy wasn't a very good one since I was comparing different types of cases.

That said, I doubt that DNA evidence would be useful for finding suspects if it was only 30% accurate, assuming that it produced 70% false negatives and/or false positives. That means that 70% of the time, the police would be tracking down and attempting to independently confirm the guilt or innocence of the wrong person, which would be a huge waste of time. Similarly, if a psychic was only right 30% of the time, they would not be able to provide enough reliable information to find suspects without wasting the police's time 70% of the time trying to confirm the guilt or innocence of the wrong person. And without some idea of the reliability of either DNA or a psychic (i.e. if the reliability was unknown) the police would have no idea how long to search for independent confirmation of a suspect, so much of the time they would be spinning their wheels looking for evidence that isn't there.

So my point was that even if psychic powers were real, police would still need to know the accuracy of a psychic, otherwise they could be wasting precious time and resources. I agree that in reality, the evidence (or lack thereof) would strongly indicate that psychics have a reliability of zero percent.

-Bri
 
You were expecting a better answer?

Yes, I was.

It seems that if you ask a direct question that challenges their (Rodney and Hardenberg) beliefs, they have no answer. I'll ask it again:

How come there are still many thousands and thousands, tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of missing people, when there are all these psychics out there who claim they can find them?

What else do I have to do to get some kind of answer? :confused:
 
Yes, I was.

It seems that if you ask a direct question that challenges their (Rodney and Hardenberg) beliefs, they have no answer. I'll ask it again:

How come there are still many thousands and thousands, tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of missing people, when there are all these psychics out there who claim they can find them?

What else do I have to do to get some kind of answer? :confused:
I've already answered in posts 102 and 129 on this thread. To amplify, however, you seem to think that either psychics can solve all missing person cases or they can't solve any. The truth seems to be that they can occasionally solve a missing person case, but generally they cannot do so. This is how psychic phenomena works in general. For example, the Ganzfeld experiments show significantly above chance results, but the results are not spectacular, in the sense that there are 95% hits, rather than the expected 25%. Rather, there are generally 25-35% hits. If you're looking for the spectacular, stick to magicians and not psychics.
 
I've already answered in posts 102 and 129 on this thread. To amplify, however, you seem to think that either psychics can solve all missing person cases or they can't solve any. The truth seems to be that they can occasionally solve a missing person case, but generally they cannot do so. This is how psychic phenomena works in general. For example, the Ganzfeld experiments show significantly above chance results, but the results are not spectacular, in the sense that there are 95% hits, rather than the expected 25%. Rather, there are generally 25-35% hits. If you're looking for the spectacular, stick to magicians and not psychics.

I checked those posts. All you are really saying in them is that the police can't find them either. So your argument is that it's OK for psychics to pretend to be able to find missing people, since police can't find them either.

You then claim to know a "truth": psychics occasionally can, but generally they can't. I'd agree with the second part of your statement, except I'd state it a little more strongly.

If we look at your claim that they occasionally can, how occasionally? How can we determine if a psychic's pronouncement is correct or incorrect, if their powers only work 'occasionally'? Do the psychics themselves say "I can only find missing people occasionally, generally I can't"?

Actually, that's pretty funny. I'd like to see a psychic's web site that says:

FALLIBLE PSYCHIC SERVICES!
Loved one gone missing? Police clueless?
Our psychics can help (occasionally). For a $750 consultation, call 1800-GENERALLY-I-CANT
We have helped search for thousands of missing people that the police couldn't find either! We generally can't find them either, but at least we care! Don't feel like there is nothing else you can do, pay us and we'll make pronouncements that may or may not be useful (but mostly aren't).
Don't despair, we genuinely generally can't help.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom