Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Why would Norm steer the police away to Nowhere Land? He must have had a better place in mind or why would he bother?
 
Why would Norm steer the police away to Nowhere Land? He must have had a better place in mind or why would he bother?
You are still assuming facts not in evidence.

If you want to present the article as evidence, fine, but do not present what isn't even in the article as evidence, because it's not.
 
The article certainly implies that Norm Pratt directed them to the location. At least that's the way I read it. What kind of glasses are you wearing anyway?

If Mr. Pratt had resurrected the body, would you give him any credit then? I don't think so.

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2005/01/27/psychic-body050127.html

Did you even read the article? Read it closely. The relevant part has been posted in this thread before, but I'll post it again:

But local psychic Norm Pratt steered police away from that trail. About a kilometre into nearby woods, police found Sarjeant's clothes. Her remains were discovered in the same area.

Please show us where it says that Pratt found either the clothes or the body. It specifically says that the police found the clothes. It doesn't say who found the body, but one would think it would have been specific if it had been Pratt. The trail that it refers to is the railway that the police had already searched and had found nothing.

So the article indicates only that Pratt told them to stop searching where they had already searched and found nothing.

-Bri
 
Why would Norm steer the police away to Nowhere Land? He must have had a better place in mind or why would he bother?

Why would you assume that he had a better place in mind? If he had a better place in mind, don't you think he would have told the police the exact place and the article would have made that abundantly clear?

No, it is far more likely that Pratt was simply playing the odds. He knew that the body was either 1) along the railway where the police had already searched but didn't find anything, or 2) somewhere else. He chose "somewhere else," which not only seems a pretty safe bet, but is exactly what I would have done if I had been trying to convince people that I had psychic powers that I didn't have.

Making a vague but safe prediction is how nearly all psychics operate, because some people are gullible and will count it as a hit. I won't mention any names, but at least two such people have posted to this very thread!

-Bri
 
The article still suggests that Norm told them to search that spot even though he may not have found the clothes or the body. It appears that at Norm Pratt's suggestion, the police searched the area where her body was found. Maybe the newspaper needs a new editor because the headline certainly suggests that Norm had something to do with her discovery.
 
The article still suggests that Norm told them to search that spot even though he may not have found the clothes or the body.
Yes, it "suggests" that. But that's all.

So you are basing your confidence in Pratt's ability on a suggestion in a newspaper article.

You're fine with that?


It appears that at Norm Pratt's suggestion, the police searched the area where her body was found.
Yes, it "appears" that way.

So you are basing your confidence in Pratt's ability on their vague appearance in a newspaper article.

You're fine with that?


Maybe the newspaper needs a new editor because the headline certainly suggests that Norm had something to do with her discovery.
Yes, it does. Sadly, this is not uncommon.

It is one indicator of why newspaper articles are poor sources on which to base any belief, opinion, or conclusion.
 
This is the point, Rodney. Even in the (meager) evidence you have provided, it does not say that Pratt did any such thing.

It does not say "Pratt directed them to X location."

In fact, it merely says, and I quote, "But local psychic Norm Pratt steered police away from that trail. "

As Bri has been pointing out, that is an entirely different thing than saying "The body is under this rock."


Immediately? Even your article doesn't use that word. Tell me please, Rodney, exactly what the trime frame was from Pratt's initial involvement to the finding of the body.

You won't find that information in the article. Jumping to the conclusion of "immediately" isn't quite fair dinkum.


You have claimed a lot of specificity, Rodney. You have shown none.
Okay, so let's hear your scenario of how the missing woman's body came to be found.
 
Well, Garrette, old friend, when the police have looked in vain for a missing person for 10 months and then Pratt directs them to a different location where that person's body is immediately found, that's specific enough for me and, I suspect, the family of the missing person.

Of course, you have misstated what the article says, but you already know that. If the article indicated that Pratt's psychic abilities lead the police directly to the specific location of the body, you would have answered my hypothetical. I suspect that your failure to answer indicates that in fact you aren't certain enough that you would choose to dig where Pratt indicated instead of where the police suspected your loved one was located.

It's true that most families aren't thinking about time or resources being wasted on psychics, and want the police to pursue every possible avenue. But in reality police cannot waste limited time and resources pursuing dead ends because other victims and their families will suffer as a result.

-Bri
 
Okay, so let's hear your scenario of how the missing woman's body came to be found.
Ah.

You can't prove (or even provide any strong evidence) that a psychic solved the case, so you want me to prove that a psychic didn't solve the case.

No dice, Rodney. Burden of proof and all that.
 
The article still suggests that Norm told them to search that spot even though he may not have found the clothes or the body. It appears that at Norm Pratt's suggestion, the police searched the area where her body was found. Maybe the newspaper needs a new editor because the headline certainly suggests that Norm had something to do with her discovery.

In fact Pratt may have had something to do with her discovery. As the article states, the police sergeant credits Pratt with steering them away from the place they had been searching. I don't see how that indicates the use of any special psychic powers on Pratt's part though. The headline is accurate; according to the sergeant, Pratt did help police find her body. However, if Pratt had lead police directly to the body, I suspect it would have been worded quite differently.

-Bri
 
In fact Pratt may have had something to do with her discovery. As the article states, the police sergeant credits Pratt with steering them away from the place they had been searching. I don't see how that indicates the use of any special psychic powers on Pratt's part though. The headline is accurate; according to the sergeant, Pratt did help police find her body. However, if Pratt had lead police directly to the body, I suspect it would have been worded quite differently.

-Bri
This is worth repeating, especially since my recent posts could be seen as muddling the lines.

There are three possibilities here:

1. Pratt did not help the police find the body.

2. Pratt used non-psychic means to help the police find the body.

3. Pratt used psychic means to help the police find the body.


Even if it is irrefutably demonstrated that Pratt helped the police find the body (something which is definitely not demonstrated), it is still incumbent upon Pratt or his advocates to demonstrate that the means used were psychic as opposed to non-psychic.
 
...when the police have looked in vain for a missing person for 10 months and then Pratt directs them to a different location where that person's body is immediately found, that's specific enough for me and, I suspect, the family of the missing person.
In fairness, I think we can all agree that the police did not direct all of their resources searching for a single missing person for ten months. Not even remotely close. In a perfect world they would, but in this imperfect world there are only so many resources one department can expend.

In fact, the reality is likely closer to they did an initial investigation over the course of several days (I'll be generous and say a week) which included their "dogs, helicopters, and infrared," put up flyers in town for a month or more, kept an open file with the parks service for the duration, and at some point close to that 10 month point resurrected the case file and gave it another look. And one officer decided to consult a psychic.

My other question is, where the hell was Pratt on day 1 of the search? I have to wonder if he'd been helping then if we'd now hear the pro-psychic side of the house saying, "See - if it hadn't been for Pratt working painstakingly for 10 months they never would have found her..."
 
I totally agree, Garrette. My point to Hardenbergh was that the article's suggestion "that Norm had something to do with her discovery" may very well be true. He may very well have had something to do with her discovery, but the article does not state that the something had anything to do with psychic abilities on Pratt's part, specifically the article doesn't state that Pratt led the police to the body.

-Bri
 
Ah.

You can't prove (or even provide any strong evidence) that a psychic solved the case, so you want me to prove that a psychic didn't solve the case.

No dice, Rodney. Burden of proof and all that.
I'm not asking you to prove anything -- I'm merely asking for your most likely version(s) of how the body was located.
 
Not interested in the tangent, but thanks for asking.
Why is it a tangent? Every account I have seen says that Pratt helped the police find the missing woman's body. If you don't think that's what happened, give me some alternative scenarios.
 
Who said that Pratt didn't help police find the missing woman? At least according to the article, Pratt did help -- assuming you consider telling the police to stop searching where they were searching and hadn't found anything is help, as the sergeant apparently does.

However, there is no evidence whatsoever that he used any psychic abilities, nor that he told them where the body was.

-Bri
 
Who said that Pratt didn't help police find the missing woman? At least according to the article, Pratt did help -- assuming you consider telling the police to stop searching where they were searching and hadn't found anything is help, as the sergeant apparently does.

However, there is no evidence whatsoever that he used any psychic abilities, nor that he told them where the body was.

-Bri
In your scenario, Bri, the police are clueless buffoons. They've been searching the same area for 10 months, but need a psychic to tell them to search in a new location, which by an odd coincidence, turns out to be where the body is.
 
In your scenario, Bri, the police are clueless buffoons. They've been searching the same area for 10 months, but need a psychic to tell them to search in a new location, which by an odd coincidence, turns out to be where the body is.

Yes, that really strikes a chord, doesn't it? :)
 
In your scenario, Bri, the police are clueless buffoons. They've been searching the same area for 10 months, but need a psychic to tell them to search in a new location, which by an odd coincidence, turns out to be where the body is.

To repeat once more what has been pointed out ad nauseum already, we don't know that he told them to search in any new location. If he did, we don't know if that was the location she was found. We know that he told them to stop searching in a particular location. And also, the police are very unlikely to have continually searched daily in the same area for 10 months. I suspect that they felt this was a likely location, but will not have been out combing it for 10 months solid.

The police certianly were clueless - in that the had no clues to go on, otherwise they would have been further in their investigations. We can't know what the psychic told them, from this article. We don't know if there was any coincidence of what he told them versus where the body was found.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom