Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

If Pratt was just guessing, at least it was a good one.

It depends on how you define "good" guess. His advice was to stop searching where they had already searched. Sounds like the odds were in his favor to me. The body could have either been where they had already searched and they simply missed it, or it could have been anywhere else.

Had Pratt's guess been wrong, it would have wasted a great deal of time for the police. Of course, that's pretty much par for the course with psychics.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I asked if you know any psychic detectives with a better batting average than any law enforcement agency.

I gather that the answer is no.

I further gather that means you would never choose the psychic in Bri's hypothetical.

I further gather that since you admit you know nothing about Pratt except what is in this one article that you admit you know nothing except that he has made claims which have not been substantiated. Unless, of course, you consider news articles to be sufficient evidence upon which to form a conclusion.


It's not a fact. It's an unsupported claim in an article which no longer even exists at the link (at least when I link it).

You are ignoring the fact that there is no objective evidence that Pratt provided any such assistance.




Police Department: We've been over this area a thousand times and found nothing!

Pratt: Try somewhere else.

Hardenbergh: Pratt's a genius!

Pratt didn't just say somewhere else. He directed them to a specific location.
 
I have seen two articles that contradict each other concerning who found the clothing -- one says it was Pratt and the other clearly indicates that it was the police.

Neither article indicates that Pratt directed them to the specific location of the body.

-Bri
 
(Again, if anyone here has a useful protocol for testing a psychic detective, let's hear what it is.)

I agree with you that double-blind testing is unnecessary at this point - it's putting the cart before the horse. I think a proper investigation of any of these cases, like what Joe Nickell does (or what Robert Lancaster does with Sylvia Browne) would be sufficient to determine whether or not a particular person was a)useful, and b) provided information in a way that made normal means of making guesses or knowing very unlikely. If anyone can be identified that fulfills these criteria, then you could proceed to examining the extent of these abilities through more stringent testing. And also the testing needs to be similar to the Million Dollar Challenge in that it tests under circumstances that the psychic is convinced will work. So it needs to be individualized.

Unfortunately, it does not look like one can generalize and assume that the police can make this determination. This is a specialized process that seems to be outside of their usual skills (like scientists, as James Randi has shown). I did a quick and dirty search looking for some published research, but just found some non-peer-reviewed articles, so I have no real idea what research there is on this subject. But it does look like at least some of the police who think psychics have helped are subject to biases like retro-fitting and re-interpretation, and have been fooled by trickery. So I would recommend an investigator skilled in this area would be the way to go - maybe surveying police departments to identify the best cases to start.

I do think double-blind testing is useful in these situations to demonstrate to psychics or police how they fool themselves (like the Million Dollar Challenge). However, since most people are not interested in discovering this, or will not allow the lesson to penetrate once it is demonstrated (I say this based on the results of the Challenges and on other tests), I think it is pointless to pretend that designing a double-blind trial would be useful. Nobody will take it.

Linda
 
Well, in the case of Kimberley Anne Sarjeant (in the OP), her body was found.

Also, my neighbors sought the assistance of Alex Tanous many, many years ago. Their daughter and her boyfriend had run away and eloped and they hadn't heard from them. Alex told them that they were in the Boston area. The teenagers later contacted their families. I've already mentioned this before. I don't know if Alex actually pinned it down to a specific area in Boston. Maine is in close proximity to Boston so it wouldn't be terribly unusual for the runaway couple to start their life's journey in Bean Town. It could have been an educated guess but I don't think that is true, at least in the case of Alex. He had very unusual gifts.

Wakine G. Tanous, an attorney from Millinocket, Maine and former state senator, (Senate Sessions 104th, 105th, and 106th), was Alex Tanous' brother. He was the attorney of one of my closest friend's parents as well as a personal friend. Wakine was often a guest in their home and Alex would often come with him. From what I have heard, Alex was the real deal.

I just read in the Bangor Daily News that Wakine's wife, Anna, died on August 25th. They had been married 52 years.

You've avoided addressing the issues I've raised. All you've said is that someone called Alex once said some people were in the Boston area.

At the risk of repeating myself, let me repeat myself:

Why can't all those psychics out there find all those missing people?
 
Last edited:
Do you think that psychics should always be able to outperform the police? Consider the case of Chandra Levy, where both psychics and the police fell flat on their collective faces. Police had evidence that Levy was likely either abducted or murdered in Rock Creek Park in Washington, DC on May 1, 2001, because she disappeared that day and someone had used her laptop computer that morning to do an Internet search on the Park's Klingle Mansion. Further, police knew that Levy had been involved in an affair with Congressman Gary Condit, who lived on the outskirts of Rock Creek Park. Police did search the Park, but came up empty. However, more than a year later, a man walking his dog in the Park found her remains just one mile from the Klingle Mansion. Unfortunately, by that time the DNA evidence had been contaminated. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandra_Levy

You've avoided my questions. Let me repeat myself:

With all those psychics with all those powers, why can't they find all those missing people?
 
Source, please?

The OP article certainly does not convey that sense.
All the sources cited convey that impression. For example, the CBC article states:

"Police had already searched along an abandoned railway line where the 23-year-old woman was last seen.

"But local psychic Norm Pratt steered police away from that trail. About a kilometre into nearby woods, police found Sarjeant's clothes. Her remains were discovered in the same area."

Okay, there is a discrepancy in the articles regarding whether Pratt or the police found the clothes, but where is any article that states that the police would have found the body without Pratt's assistance? That doesn't seem to exist. Rather, we consistently find in the articles: "Without the use of the psychic, I think I'd still be looking for this person," according to Sgt. Bank.
 
You've avoided my questions. Let me repeat myself:

With all those psychics with all those powers, why can't they find all those missing people?
And as I've already responded, the police can't seem to find them either. You and others here have created a strawman of the infallible psychic, which neither Hardenbergh nor I has ever claimed exists.
 
I agree with you that double-blind testing is unnecessary at this point - it's putting the cart before the horse. I think a proper investigation of any of these cases, like what Joe Nickell does (or what Robert Lancaster does with Sylvia Browne) would be sufficient to determine whether or not a particular person was a)useful, and b) provided information in a way that made normal means of making guesses or knowing very unlikely. If anyone can be identified that fulfills these criteria, then you could proceed to examining the extent of these abilities through more stringent testing. And also the testing needs to be similar to the Million Dollar Challenge in that it tests under circumstances that the psychic is convinced will work. So it needs to be individualized.

Unfortunately, it does not look like one can generalize and assume that the police can make this determination. This is a specialized process that seems to be outside of their usual skills (like scientists, as James Randi has shown). I did a quick and dirty search looking for some published research, but just found some non-peer-reviewed articles, so I have no real idea what research there is on this subject. But it does look like at least some of the police who think psychics have helped are subject to biases like retro-fitting and re-interpretation, and have been fooled by trickery. So I would recommend an investigator skilled in this area would be the way to go - maybe surveying police departments to identify the best cases to start.
I would think, in general, that the police would be more skeptical of psychics than most people would be. However, I would welcome an objective investigation of psychic detectives.
 
And as I've already responded, the police can't seem to find them either. You and others here have created a strawman of the infallible psychic, which neither Hardenbergh nor I has ever claimed exists.

Nobody has suggested that psychics must be infallible -- that seems to be your straw man, not ours.

We're asking for any evidence that they can do what they claim they can do under the conditions they claim they can do it -- and here's the part you keep missing -- at the rate of success they claim to be able to achieve before police can reasonably decide whether it's worthwhile using them to find missing persons or not.

-Bri
 
Nobody has suggested that psychics must be infallible -- that seems to be your straw man, not ours.

We're asking for any evidence that they can do what they claim they can do under the conditions they claim they can do it -- and here's the part you keep missing -- at the rate of success they claim to be able to achieve before police can reasonably decide whether it's worthwhile using them to find missing persons or not.

-Bri
(1) So, if a psychic claims an 80% success rate and in fact achieves only 30%, you discount the 30%?

(2) The police, not participants on this forum, are in the best position to decide whether to use a psychic in a given case.
 
(1) So, if a psychic claims an 80% success rate and in fact achieves only 30%, you discount the 30%?

No, if a psychic achieves 30% in a proper double-blind test then they should not be allowed to claim 80%, and the police can then decide whether a 30% success rate is worth their time. If DNA testing was only accurate 30% of the time, it likely would never be used because 70% of the time police would be wasting their time chasing the wrong person.

(2) The police, not participants on this forum, are in the best position to decide whether to use a psychic in a given case.

Nobody ever said that participants on this forum are in the best position to decide to use a psychic in a given case. In fact, I just stated that police are in the best position to decide, given accurate information about what the psychic can do, under what conditions, and how often.

Police are not in the best position to determine whether a psychic can actually do as they claim (which requires double-blind testing) any more than police are qualified to determine whether a blood sample came from a suspect (which requires DNA testing).

-Bri
 
(1) So, if a psychic claims an 80% success rate and in fact achieves only 30%, you discount the 30%?

What remarkable news that would be. One third of all missing persons found by psychics. I don't recall reading that headline...

Come to think of it, I don't recall reading any headlines or articles saying that a psychic found a missing person. You know, one that looks like this:

PSYCHIC FINDS MISSING PERSON

In a case that had investigators stumped due to NO clues to the missing person's whereabouts, a psychic yesterday informed police that the person was "wandering in a confused state between platforms three and five of Flinders Street Station, wearing a chartreuse blouse and carrying a three-day-old copy of the MX".

Station staff were alerted and the missing person spotted on CCTV approaching a man on platform five. Station attendants managed to keep her on the platform until police arrived, whereupon she was reunited with her family.

The psychic later told reporters that his "guide from t'other side" showed him the missing person.

Now, why is it that stories like that never appear?
 
Rodney,

I really don't see how you can twist what I say when it is so short and clear unless you do it intentionally.

Hardenbergh said this:
Pratt didn't just say somewhere else. He directed them to a specific location.

To which I replied:
Source, please?

The OP article certainly does not convey that sense.


To which you respond with this ramble:
All the sources cited convey that impression. For example, the CBC article states:

"Police had already searched along an abandoned railway line where the 23-year-old woman was last seen.

"But local psychic Norm Pratt steered police away from that trail. About a kilometre into nearby woods, police found Sarjeant's clothes. Her remains were discovered in the same area."

Okay, there is a discrepancy in the articles regarding whether Pratt or the police found the clothes, but where is any article that states that the police would have found the body without Pratt's assistance? That doesn't seem to exist. Rather, we consistently find in the articles: "Without the use of the psychic, I think I'd still be looking for this person," according to Sgt. Bank.
So where, Rodney, in any source does it say that Pratt directed the police to a specific location?]

Answer: Nowhere.

Your Expected Quibbles: "The clothes were in a specific location, and SGT Bank says Pratt was key."

(I like that. In future, understand that YEQ is shorthand for "Your Expected Quibble(s)")

My Prescient Response: The articles can't even get their story straight about who found the clothes and there is NO corroborating evidence that it happened in such a way. And SGT Bank gives absolutely no specifics and is subject to the same retrofitting and confirmation bias as the rest of us--see fls' excellent response above.
 
So where, Rodney, in any source does it say that Pratt directed the police to a specific location?]
Well, Garrette, old friend, when the police have looked in vain for a missing person for 10 months and then Pratt directs them to a different location where that person's body is immediately found, that's specific enough for me and, I suspect, the family of the missing person.
 
The article certainly implies that Norm Pratt directed them to the location.
Yes, it is written to imply that. Just as many advertisements are written to imply that the product or service is fully tested and/or endorsed when actually they aren't. But those advertisements don't actually state it because it isn't actually true and making false claims would subject the company to legal action in the manner of, oh say Kevin Trudeau and the FTC.

This article implies but does not say that Pratt directed the police to the specific location.

SGT Banks credits Pratt but does not say what the help was.

So the entirety of your evidence for the value of Pratt's help is the complete lack of detail regarding what the help was.


At least that's the way I read it.
I believe you. I suggest without malice that you need to learn to read with a more critical eye.

What kind of glasses are you wearing anyway?
Progressives. Just a few weeks old.

Yep. I will repeat myself:

So the entirety of your evidence for the value of Pratt's help is the complete lack of detail regarding what the help was.


ETA:
Hardenbergh said:
If Mr. Pratt had resurrected the body, would you give him any credit then? I don't think so.
I would give him no credit for claiming he had resurrected the body, nor for SGT Banks claiming he had seen it done.

I sincerely hope you would not either.
 
Last edited:
Well, Garrette, old friend, when the police have looked in vain for a missing person for 10 months and then Pratt directs them to a different location
This is the point, Rodney. Even in the (meager) evidence you have provided, it does not say that Pratt did any such thing.

It does not say "Pratt directed them to X location."

In fact, it merely says, and I quote, "But local psychic Norm Pratt steered police away from that trail. "

As Bri has been pointing out, that is an entirely different thing than saying "The body is under this rock."


where that person's body is immediately found,
Immediately? Even your article doesn't use that word. Tell me please, Rodney, exactly what the trime frame was from Pratt's initial involvement to the finding of the body.

You won't find that information in the article. Jumping to the conclusion of "immediately" isn't quite fair dinkum.


that's specific enough for me and, I suspect, the family of the missing person.
You have claimed a lot of specificity, Rodney. You have shown none.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom