Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

For example, the Ganzfeld experiments show significantly above chance results, but the results are not spectacular, in the sense that there are 95% hits, rather than the expected 25%. Rather, there are generally 25-35% hits.
Oh, please, Rodney. This has been discussed ad nauseum. Do not pretend that it hasn't and that you haven't been involved.

And since you post no references, I will not, either, but for those interested, search for threads started by Ersby.

Or go to skepticreport.com and read Patterns in the Clouds.
 
The truth seems to be that they can occasionally solve a missing person case, but generally they cannot do so.

I've never seen a psychic claim to be "generally" unable to solve a missing person case, so do you agree that psychics are not very honest about their abilities? Do you suppose that's why psychics "generally" refuse to be tested, and those who agree have always failed? Do you agree that if a psychic is "generally" unable to do as they claim that they should disclose that fact before wasting the precious time of the police?

So far, you haven't shown any evidence that they can even occasionally solve a missing person case using psychic ability. Given the lack of evidence, how often would you say they can find missing people, and on what do you base your estimate? Out of the tens of thousands of missing people out there, and out of the thousands of psychics who have attempted to find them, why have you been unable to find any verification that anyone has ever used psychic abilities to find a missing person?

-Bri
 
. . . why have you been unable to find any verification that anyone has ever used psychic abilities to find a missing person?
Please inform me what would constitute verification, from your perspective.
 
It just seems as though a lot of psychics would be on welfare if they weren't right at least some of the time.
 
Please inform me what would constitute verification, from your perspective.

How about the psychic telling the police exactly where the body will be located before searching for the body? As in: "The body is buried behind a shack at the northwest the corner of U.S. 31 and State Road 5, beneath a large oak tree."

Of course, passing a double-blind test would be even better. But my question is, why isn't there a single mainstream news source that has ever verified that a single person has used psychic abilities to solve a crime or find a missing person?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Please inform me what would constitute verification, from your perspective.
It's not difficult in concept, Rodney.

It would be similar to how you test a Remote Viewer's claims.

Specifics, of course, would be dependent upon what the psychic claimed.

Which leads to two criteria that I think are necessary:

Prior announcement by both the psychic and the law enforcement agency that the psychic is to provide assistance. ("Prior" meaning before any investigative contact between the psychic and the LEA)

Prior announcement by the psychic as to what his/her abilities are.
 
It just seems as though a lot of psychics would be on welfare if they weren't right at least some of the time.
Hardenbergh, it truly seems that you are either a troll or that you have no interest in reading posts offering alternate explanations.

Blood-letters must have been right some of the time because they sure used blood-letting a lot.

Most people are not educated regarding the methods of con artists and frauds. Even those who are are still subject to lapses in logic.

Read up on the Forer Effect and confirmation bias.

Sadly, actual effectiveness of a service is not always the arbiter of that service's commercial success.
 
It just seems as though a lot of psychics would be on welfare if they weren't right at least some of the time.

Well, you'd be right at least some of the time if you just guessed rabndomely too, wouldn't you? And more than some of the time using cold reading techniques.

I assume what you mean is that at least some psychics must have genuine psychic abilities in order to make money. You might think that, wouldn't you?
It's kind of ironic, because people who give psychics money often say the same thing, but seldom request any sort of actual evidence that the psychic is able to do what they claim to do. So, given that psychics are almost never held accountable by those who give them money, why would they be on welfare? There seem to be more than enough gullible folks to keep them in business.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
It's not difficult in concept, Rodney.

It would be similar to how you test a Remote Viewer's claims.

Specifics, of course, would be dependent upon what the psychic claimed.

Which leads to two criteria that I think are necessary:

Prior announcement by both the psychic and the law enforcement agency that the psychic is to provide assistance. ("Prior" meaning before any investigative contact between the psychic and the LEA)

Prior announcement by the psychic as to what his/her abilities are.
So, no matter how many missing persons a psychic locates, it doesn't count unless there was a prior announcement by both the psychic and the law enforcement agency that the psychic was to provide assistance?
 
So, no matter how many missing persons a psychic locates, it doesn't count unless there was a prior announcement by both the psychic and the law enforcement agency that the psychic was to provide assistance?
I will be willing to eat all the crow you can dish up when you provide just one instance of a psychic locating a missing person with psychic means.

Until then, I will content myself with pointing out the flaws in your examples.
 
I will be willing to eat all the crow you can dish up when you provide just one instance of a psychic locating a missing person with psychic means.

Until then, I will content myself with pointing out the flaws in your examples.
I'm just trying to figure out a psychic detective would ever meet your criteria. For example, can you name ANY missing persons case where, when the person went missing, there was an announcement by both the psychic and the law enforcement agency that the psychic was providing assistance to that law enforcement agency?
 
I'm just trying to figure out a psychic detective would ever meet your criteria. For example, can you name ANY missing persons case where, when the person went missing, there was an announcement by both the psychic and the law enforcement agency that the psychic was providing assistance to that law enforcement agency?
No, I cannot, and your implied criticism of my position is valid up to a very limited point and not past that point at all.

It is valid in that you are pointing out that I have not clarified how I might be convinced of X.

It is NOT valid in that there is as yet no coherent observation, demonstration, explanation, or theory of X.

Asking me to outline what would convince me of X is a subtle shifting of the burden of proof.

The supporters of X shoulder that burden. Let the supporters make the specific claim. Let the supporters propose a means of demonstrating the claim. Let the supporters propose how the claim might be falsified.

My failure to outline what will convince me of the legitimacy of psychic detectives is no more negligent than is my failure to outline what will convince me that we are living in the Matrix.
 
No, I cannot, and your implied criticism of my position is valid up to a very limited point and not past that point at all.

It is valid in that you are pointing out that I have not clarified how I might be convinced of X.

It is NOT valid in that there is as yet no coherent observation, demonstration, explanation, or theory of X.

Asking me to outline what would convince me of X is a subtle shifting of the burden of proof.

The supporters of X shoulder that burden. Let the supporters make the specific claim. Let the supporters propose a means of demonstrating the claim. Let the supporters propose how the claim might be falsified.

My failure to outline what will convince me of the legitimacy of psychic detectives is no more negligent than is my failure to outline what will convince me that we are living in the Matrix.
Okay, so consider this woman's claims: http://www.closure4u.com/example.htm

And, her claims seem to have support from the San Francisco Chronicle -- http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2005/09/09/PNGV0EII1M1.DTL

For example:

"Pacifica Police sergeant Fernando Realyvasquez said that using a psychic was something that had never entered his realm of thinking -- until the family of Dennis Prado, who had been missing for more than two months, asked him to call in a psychic.

"Prado, 71, had gone missing on May 14, 1997. His car had been left at his apartment, along with his wallet and other personal items. The home showed no signs of a break-in. Though Prado had some issues with neighbors in the apartment complex and he had been threatened with eviction if the problems did not stop, there were no signs of foul play.

"'I had exhausted the leads that came my way as much as I could,' Realyvasquez said. 'I would make flyers on a weekly basis, and the family had also been making their own efforts. The family came to me after a family meeting and asked if we would consider bringing a psychic into the case.'

"The detective said that he had been skeptical of psychics and the like for most of his career. Keeping an open mind, he said he first went to his captain, and then to the chief of police in Pacifica to get permission.

"'The chief said that if it was something that was going to make the family feel better, to do it,' Realyvasquez said.

"Realyvasquez first ran a background check on Martin before contacting her, he said, including checking in with Keaton in Marin to get a read on her credibility. When the psychic passed the mini-investigation, Realyvasquez met Martin at her Campbell office. She held a photograph of Prado in her hands, and then looked at a map of the area around his apartment complex, including the 2,000-acre park that ran behind it. Martin said Prado had gone for a walk in the wilderness area. Taking the map, she drew a small circle, and said that Prado would be found in that area.

"Realyvasquez said he remained skeptical since the area had been combed by search-and-rescue teams. He shared Martin's information with Roberta Hauser, a search-and-rescue volunteer on Tuesday, July 15, 1997. The following Saturday, July 19, 1997, Hauser went to the area that Martin had pointed out -- and within an hour had found Prado's decomposing body.

"'The fact of the matter is that he had been missing for nearly three months,' Realyvasquez said. 'I am still a little bit skeptical, but on the other hand, in this particular case, we probably wouldn't have found him if it hadn't been for Annette Martin.'"
 
Annette Martin, hey? Psychic? Hmmm...

Did you know that she testified on behalf of the defense in a court case? One of her psychic friends, Susan Polk, was on trial for the murder of Mr. Polk. Ms. Martin testified that she (Martin) could speak to ghosts. Poor dead Mr. Polk didn't seem able to tell her that his wife murdered him.

It didn't matter though, Mrs. Polk was convicted based on actual evidence.

http://www.courttv.com/trials/polk/060706_ctv.html?page=1

What did Annette Martin have to say? "Everyone is innocent until proven guilty."

Here was an opportunity, in court, under oath, for a psychic to make a revelation. She didn't.

Wow, I'm convinced.
 
'I am still a little bit skeptical...'

I'm with the sergeant on this one. I'm still a little bit skeptical.

Although it is certainly possible that she used psychic powers to find the body, there are much more likely possibilities.

Perhaps Martin ought to be tested using a proper double-blind test to eliminate those other possibilities and prove that she really has psychic powers. Of course, she won't. One can only assume that she knows what the outcome will be.

-Bri
 
Sigh...

Rodney, you are still at your game of throwing out a bunch of claims, expecting us to debunk each one, anticipating we will eventually get tired of it so you can claim victory.

Except that citing a newspaper article isn't a claim, Rodney, anymore than citing Katie Couric about the latest medical research is a claim.

If you want to be taken seriously, do your own research into this claim. Contact the psychic. Contact the police department. YOU substantiate the claim you want debunked.

Stop relying on us to do your work for you.
 
Annette Martin, hey? Psychic? Hmmm...

Did you know that she testified on behalf of the defense in a court case? One of her psychic friends, Susan Polk, was on trial for the murder of Mr. Polk. Ms. Martin testified that she (Martin) could speak to ghosts. Poor dead Mr. Polk didn't seem able to tell her that his wife murdered him.

It didn't matter though, Mrs. Polk was convicted based on actual evidence.

http://www.courttv.com/trials/polk/060706_ctv.html?page=1

What did Annette Martin have to say? "Everyone is innocent until proven guilty."

Here was an opportunity, in court, under oath, for a psychic to make a revelation. She didn't.

Wow, I'm convinced.
According to your link:

"Outside the courtroom, Martin said she never spoke to Polk before meeting her in court.

"'She's just trying to show that everyone is psychic,' Martin said about why Polk had called her to the stand.

"Any psychic impressions about a verdict?

"'My answer to that,' Martin said, 'is that everyone is innocent until proven guilty.'"

So, Annette Martin was not a friend of Susan Polk, Martin didn't even know Polk. And would you have liked it better if Martin had said: "My psychic impressions tell me that Polk is guilty as sin"?

Now, what is your explanation for the numerous missing person cases that Martin seems to have solved? Here is the perspective of another police officer who worked on the case I referenced yesterday:

"In 1997, Martin was approached by Roberta Hauser. She was part of a search and rescue team in a state park near Pacifica, Calif., looking for a 71-year-old man who had disappeared from his home.

"'I thought this was a needle in a haystack and I was just going to have to crawl through every section of this park to find him,' Hauser says.

"A 40-person search team had already spent several days combing the dense terrain and had given up, but Hauser pressed on by herself for nine more weeks.

"'Pretty much every day after work I would come out here, my husband sometimes would come out here with me, and I would just slowly but surely cover sections of the map,' Hauser continues. 'The park is thickly shrubbed, and the probability of detection was very low.'

"As a last resort, a local police sergeant contacted Martin and gave her a photograph and a map.

"'[I was] absolutely determined to find him,' says Martin. 'And I really felt like he was here. Well, my hand led me…over to where the area was. And I just followed the roads along, and I circled. He's in this area. That's where he is.'

"At first Hauser was skeptical:

"Hauser went out one final time with a search dog. It was then that the corpse was found in very deep shrubs.

"'The mound is exactly in the center of the circle that she had drawn on the map,' says Hauser. 'She was absolutely right on the money.'"

See http://www.closure4u.com/article.htm (June 30, 2000 CBS News story)
 
"In 1997, Martin was approached by Roberta Hauser. She was part of a search and rescue team in a state park near Pacifica, Calif., looking for a 71-year-old man who had disappeared from his home.

"'I thought this was a needle in a haystack and I was just going to have to crawl through every section of this park to find him,' Hauser says.

"A 40-person search team had already spent several days combing the dense terrain and had given up, but Hauser pressed on by herself for nine more weeks.

"'Pretty much every day after work I would come out here, my husband sometimes would come out here with me, and I would just slowly but surely cover sections of the map,' Hauser continues. 'The park is thickly shrubbed, and the probability of detection was very low.'

"As a last resort, a local police sergeant contacted Martin and gave her a photograph and a map.

"'[I was] absolutely determined to find him,' says Martin. 'And I really felt like he was here. Well, my hand led me…over to where the area was. And I just followed the roads along, and I circled. He's in this area. That's where he is.'

"At first Hauser was skeptical:

"Hauser went out one final time with a search dog. It was then that the corpse was found in very deep shrubs.

"'The mound is exactly in the center of the circle that she had drawn on the map,' says Hauser. 'She was absolutely right on the money.'"

See http://www.closure4u.com/article.htm (June 30, 2000 CBS News story)
Rodney, Rodney, Rodney.

You're still tossing out newspaper articles as definitive.

If YOU think this is the golden case that will prove psychics find missing persons via psychic means, then give us some real evidence.

YOU contact Martin. YOU contact the police officer. You contact the volunteer search-and-rescue person.

YOU do a FOIA request for the case records.

When you have those results, we'll have something to discuss. Until then, it's another "newspaper-article-like-all-the-other-newspaper-articles-that-cannot-be-relied-upon-for-accuracy."

In all the time I've been discussing things with you, Rodney, I cannot recall one time where you went beyond the newspaper article regarding psychics. Not once.

DO YOUR OWN DAMNED HOMEWORK!

And, oh by the way, the same link has this precious bit:

A unique part of Martin's clairvoyance is her ability to see what was wrong with a person medically, detailed 3-D images of certain body organs. "I think I'm very versatile," she said.

Formed in 2001, the psychic investigative agency in Campbell specializes in homicide, missing persons, grand theft, arson and industrial espionage cases.

When working on a certain police case, Martin said she is able to delve into the mind of the perpetrator and see the extent of their scars and especially their medical intakes.

"I'm able to pick up on the physical aspect and the emotional aspect," Martin said. "It's a great assistance to the police department."

The process starts out with Martin taking three deep breaths, opening her palms to bring a beam of pure white light through the frontal love and down the body so that it is bathed in white light, as is her aura. To remove her presence from the victim or perpetrator's mind, according to Martin, involves reversing the process by closing her palms and taking two deep breaths. While taking in the third breath, Martin opens her hands as a signal to "let it go."

Although she never had any formal training in developing her psychic abilities, Martin said she is nevertheless aided in clairvoyant work.
Referred to as a 'guide,' the spirit of Edgar Cayce (1877-1945_, the famed early 20th century psychic, has been assisting Martin since her early days.
So Martin can see inside of people a la the Russian girl. Great! She can be tested! Wonder why she hasn't done it?

Martin channels Edgar Cayce. Great! His track record is flawless!

Oh, yeah. Tons of credibility there.
 
Rodney, Rodney, Rodney.

You're still tossing out newspaper articles as definitive.

If YOU think this is the golden case that will prove psychics find missing persons via psychic means, then give us some real evidence.

YOU contact Martin. YOU contact the police officer. You contact the volunteer search-and-rescue person.

YOU do a FOIA request for the case records.

When you have those results, we'll have something to discuss. Until then, it's another "newspaper-article-like-all-the-other-newspaper-articles-that-cannot-be-relied-upon-for-accuracy."

In all the time I've been discussing things with you, Rodney, I cannot recall one time where you went beyond the newspaper article regarding psychics. Not once.
First of all, my most recent reference was to a CBS News report, not to a newspaper article. Second, your recollection is incorrect. I have gone beyond media accounts on several occasions, including corresponding with polygraph expert Jerry Lewis about psychic Nancy Weber and inquiring about FOIA requests in two other cases. Third, if I do a FOIA request here, contact all of the people involved, and the evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that Annette Martin's assistance is what solved this missing person's case, will that convince you and others who disbelieve in the paranormal that Annette Martin has psychic power? Somehow, I think that question can be answered with no psychic power.
 
First of all, my most recent reference was to a CBS News report, not to a newspaper article.
My mistake.

The substance of the objection stands. It's a news report.


Second, your recollection is incorrect. I have gone beyond media accounts on several occasions, including corresponding with polygraph expert Jerry Lewis about psychic Nancy Weber and inquiring about FOIA requests in two other cases.
You are correct, and I retract my statement with apologies.

Now that you mention this, I recall it.


Third, if I do a FOIA request here, contact all of the people involved, and the evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that Annette Martin's assistance is what solved this missing person's case, will that convince you and others who disbelieve in the paranormal that Annette Martin has psychic power?
Bolding is mine.

If you add the caveat that the assistance is also overwhelmingly demonstrated to be psychic and not mundane, then yes it will convince me. Where we will likely run into problems is agreeing on what constitutes overwhelming evidence.

Somehow, I think that question can be answered with no psychic power.
I have never made bones about the fact that one demonstration of abilities will likely not convince me of the general theory (using the layman's definition of that word). It will, however, convince me that there does exist legitimate reason to begin relooking my position.

I don't think that way only in regard to the paranormal. I am the same about medical studies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom