Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

My mistake.

The substance of the objection stands. It's a news report.
Yes, but you're lumping the media together, as if there is no difference beween a responsible news organization and a supermarket tabloid.

You are correct, and I retract my statement with apologies.
Thank you.

If you add the caveat that the assistance is also overwhelmingly demonstrated to be psychic and not mundane, then yes it will convince me. Where we will likely run into problems is agreeing on what constitutes overwhelming evidence.
I'm sure that will be an issue. ;)

I have never made bones about the fact that one demonstration of abilities will likely not convince me of the general theory (using the layman's definition of that word). It will, however, convince me that there does exist legitimate reason to begin relooking my position.

I don't think that way only in regard to the paranormal. I am the same about medical studies.
I agree that, if there is only one demonstration, skepticism is warranted. However, psychic detectives have demonstrated their abilities on numerous occasions.
 
"Any psychic impressions about a verdict?

"'My answer to that,' Martin said, 'is that everyone is innocent until proven guilty.'"

So, Annette Martin was not a friend of Susan Polk, Martin didn't even know Polk. And would you have liked it better if Martin had said: "My psychic impressions tell me that Polk is guilty as sin"?

Yes, but perhaps phrased differently. Remember, Martin claims to be able to speak with ghosts. She's in a courtroom in the presence of a murderer, a fellow psychic. The accused's murdered husband's ghost is watching the proceedings, screaming "She did it! She killed me!", hoping, praying that someone with psychic ability is near enough to hear.

Martin takes the stand. Mr. Polk's ghost is overjoyed that someone who can speak with him is testifying. He describes to her what happened, shows her. Imagine his dismay when she withholds that information from the court.

Didn't she swear an oath to tell the whole truth? Why did she ignore the pleadings of a murdered man's ghost?
 
Yes, but perhaps phrased differently. Remember, Martin claims to be able to speak with ghosts. She's in a courtroom in the presence of a murderer, a fellow psychic. The accused's murdered husband's ghost is watching the proceedings, screaming "She did it! She killed me!", hoping, praying that someone with psychic ability is near enough to hear.

Martin takes the stand. Mr. Polk's ghost is overjoyed that someone who can speak with him is testifying. He describes to her what happened, shows her. Imagine his dismay when she withholds that information from the court.

Didn't she swear an oath to tell the whole truth? Why did she ignore the pleadings of a murdered man's ghost?
When did Martin ever say that she was in touch with the murdered man's ghost? And even if she thought she was, what would be the point of mentioning it, since a conversation with a ghost would not be considered by the court?
 
When did Martin ever say that she was in touch with the murdered man's ghost?
She didn't. She claims to be able to speak with ghosts, and she was in a courtroom with the murderer, another psychic. You would have us believe that she can circle an area on a map in one case, based on just holding a photo of the missing person in her hand, but in this case, where the murderer, another psychic, is in the same room with her, she didn't pick up anything?

This is from what you have quoted her as saying:

When working on a certain police case, Martin said she is able to delve into the mind of the perpetrator and see the extent of their scars and especially their medical intakes.

"I'm able to pick up on the physical aspect and the emotional aspect," Martin said. "It's a great assistance to the police department."

The process starts out with Martin taking three deep breaths, opening her palms to bring a beam of pure white light through the frontal love and down the body so that it is bathed in white light, as is her aura. To remove her presence from the victim or perpetrator's mind, according to Martin, involves reversing the process by closing her palms and taking two deep breaths. While taking in the third breath, Martin opens her hands as a signal to "let it go."

Why didn't she delve into the mind of the perpetrator in this case, a fellow psychic in the same room? It would have been a great assistance to the police department.

And even if she thought she was, what would be the point of mentioning it, since a conversation with a ghost would not be considered by the court?
She was brought in as a witness to state that psychic phenomena are real, and that therefore Polk was not delusional. Why wouldn't she say "He's standing right here, I can see him, he's telling me she killed him"?

It would then be up to the court whether or not to let that testimony stand.

She did say, "I'm just a tool to help them, to bring more evidence for their cases", in reference to the more than 100 cases over 34 years that she has claimed to have helped law enforcement agencies and families with. So she claims to bring evidence. Why didn't she?
 
Yes, but you're lumping the media together, as if there is no difference beween a responsible news organization and a supermarket tabloid.
When it comes to reporting accuracy regarding these things, both type are in the Little Leagues. Major news outlets such as CNN may perhaps be the Little League champs while tabloids never reach the regional finals, but they are still both in Little League. Neither is definitive or reliable on these topics except as a starting point. You and others seem to take them as the ending point.


Thank you.
You're welcome. I add it to the rather lengthy list of mistakes I have made.


However, psychic detectives have demonstrated their abilities on numerous occasions.
No. Psychic detectives have claimed to have demonstrated their abilities on numerous occasions. And media have repeated those claims, usually with minimal scrutiny.

Huge difference.
 
To add a thought inspired by another thread in this sub-forum:

The reported instances of psychics finding missing persons is of the same caliber as the reports of free energy and perpetual motion.

Media frequently report such claims as if true. Investors put significant money into them. Even the occasional engineer says he's convinced.

But when scrutiny is applied and demonstrations are demanded, an actual working device remains absent.

Yet the claims continue unabated, smart people still invest money, and reporters keep reporting.

If you can see why the free energy claims have no merit until actually demonstrated and not when merely reported, Rodney, you will understand why I don't take any media reports of psychic detectives as even remotely conclusive.
 
To add a thought inspired by another thread in this sub-forum:

The reported instances of psychics finding missing persons is of the same caliber as the reports of free energy and perpetual motion.

Media frequently report such claims as if true. Investors put significant money into them. Even the occasional engineer says he's convinced.

But when scrutiny is applied and demonstrations are demanded, an actual working device remains absent.

Yet the claims continue unabated, smart people still invest money, and reporters keep reporting.

If you can see why the free energy claims have no merit until actually demonstrated and not when merely reported, Rodney, you will understand why I don't take any media reports of psychic detectives as even remotely conclusive.
I will grant you that the media sometimes may be taken in by undocumented claims; however, in the case of several psychic detectives, the claims are backed up by police officers involved in the investigations. In the case of free energy and perpetual motion claims, I think you'll find that all of the proponents have a vested interest in promoting the claims.
 
I will grant you that the media sometimes may be taken in by undocumented claims; however, in the case of several psychic detectives, the claims are backed up by police officers involved in the investigations.
This is a misrepresentation.

A very small number of the claims are backed up by vague statements of a very small number of police officers who do not provide specifics or the case files. Again, huge difference.


In the case of free energy and perpetual motion claims, I think you'll find that all of the proponents have a vested interest in promoting the claims.
No, not all. You may recall Joseph Newman's machine that got all kinds of interest and made it up to a Senate hearing.

But even if I grant that everyone has a vested interest, you can't apply that criterion in one case and not the others. The psychics have a vested interest, therefore we can discount their claims. The newspaper reports are based on the psychic claims, therefore we can discount them.

That leaves the very few police officers. But their statements are vague and have no evidentiary value by themselves until they are substantiated by the actual case file with specifics.
 
She didn't. She claims to be able to speak with ghosts, and she was in a courtroom with the murderer, another psychic. You would have us believe that she can circle an area on a map in one case, based on just holding a photo of the missing person in her hand, but in this case, where the murderer, another psychic, is in the same room with her, she didn't pick up anything?
Who knows whether she did or didn't.

Why didn't she delve into the mind of the perpetrator in this case, a fellow psychic in the same room? It would have been a great assistance to the police department.
How so? The police easily solved the case without Annette Martin's assistance.

She was brought in as a witness to state that psychic phenomena are real, and that therefore Polk was not delusional.
She was called as a witness by Polk. And it's perfectly consistent to believe in both psychic phenomena and that some people are delusional.

Why wouldn't she say "He's standing right here, I can see him, he's telling me she killed him"?

It would then be up to the court whether or not to let that testimony stand.

She did say, "I'm just a tool to help them, to bring more evidence for their cases", in reference to the more than 100 cases over 34 years that she has claimed to have helped law enforcement agencies and families with. So she claims to bring evidence. Why didn't she?
Because: (a) While she may well have helped in more than 100 cases over 34 years, that's only about 3 cases per year, which is hardly the same as helping in every case; (b) She never claimed to be in touch paranormally with the murder victim in this case; and (c) No court that I know of would consider alleged communications with a ghost to be evidence.
 
In the case of free energy and perpetual motion claims, I think you'll find that all of the proponents have a vested interest in promoting the claims.

As with claims of free energy and perpetual motion, we don't always know what interests a person promoting the claim might have. In the case of the police officers, it is quite possible that the officers feel the need to show results after taking such a controversial measure as consulting a psychic. They may therefore have a vested interest in making it seem as though that measure paid off to avoid any number of possible negative ramifications, including looking foolish and having to justify the time (and money) spent consulting with the psychic.

-Bri
 
Thanks, Bri, for that bit about the police officers. I should have thought of that and did not.

And even the newspapers have a vested interest. "Psychic solves murder!" sells. "Psychic wastes police time!" does not.

I have recent anecdotal evidence backing up this claim when a local missing persons case brought out a psychic who got all sorts of media attention. The few responses I got amounted to "It's news whether or not it's true."
 
As with claims of free energy and perpetual motion, we don't always know what interests a person promoting the claim might have. In the case of the police officers, it is quite possible that the officers feel the need to show results after taking such a controversial measure as consulting a psychic. They may therefore have a vested interest in making it seem as though that measure paid off to avoid any number of possible negative ramifications, including looking foolish and having to justify the time (and money) spent consulting with the psychic.

-Bri
First, I am unaware of any psychic being paid by the police. Second, as I alluded to earlier, I think it makes the police look bad for a psychic to help solve a case that they could not solve on their own. In general, I think the police turn to a psychic only when they're at a dead end. Third, if the police credit a psychic where no significant information was provided by the psychic, that increases public pressure to use that psychic in the future, which just creates a needless headache for the police.
 
First, I am unaware of any psychic being paid by the police.
No one claimed they were. The psychics nonetheless have a vested interest which can be related to both finances and image. As Bri said, the vested interest of individual police officers (and remember that this is all we have--do you know of any police departments who say psychics solved cases?) lies in the pressure to (a) solve a case, and (b) demonstrate that the action he took (i.e., use a psychic) is what solved the case.

Second, as I alluded to earlier, I think it makes the police look bad for a psychic to help solve a case that they could not solve on their own.
Not if you are the individual officer who contacted the psychic and you are the individual officer who claims the psychic solved it.

In general, I think the police turn to a psychic only when they're at a dead end.
Or when the family insists. Or when the psychic provides an unsolicited tip which the police are obligated to follow up on as they are with all unsolicited tips.

Third, if the police credit a psychic where no significant information was provided by the psychic, that increases public pressure to use that psychic in the future,
There are police who credit psychics; where is the public pressure?

which just creates a needless headache for the police.
I agree that psychics create a needless headache. A headache which is also wasteful and self-serving.
 
Second, as I alluded to earlier, I think it makes the police look bad for a psychic to help solve a case that they could not solve on their own.

In addition to what Garrette already said, I would guess that it would actually make the police look better if they were unable to find a missing person and it turned out that it required supernatural abilities to solve the case. Indeed, if a novice found the body without using any psychic abilities when the police couldn't that would certainly make them look bad. But the police have good reason to insist that supernatural powers were required to solve the case when they were unable to do so, and might therefore be hesitant to look for more mundane explanations which would make them look bad.

In other words, if Pratt had found the body because he searched for it for many weeks (as was apparently the case) rather than through the use of supernatural abilities, people might begin to ask why the police couldn't have done that.

In general, I think the police turn to a psychic only when they're at a dead end.

That may very well be, but if they're already at a dead end, they wouldn't look any worse for using a psychic other than the fact that they would feel foolish if the psychic either turned out to be a dud or worse yet solved the case without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever (gasp!).

We also cannot discount the fact that some police officers are prone to belief in the supernatural without evidence, ironic as that might be considering that evidence is key to their profession. Maybe not so ironic considering that police often "work backwards" to find evidence that fits their theory of the crime rather than the other way around.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
. . . they would feel foolish if the psychic either turned out to be a dud or worse yet solved the case without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever (gasp!).
Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?
 
Rodney,

Why are you attempting to shift the burden of proof again, and what does your question have to do with my statement?

My point is that the police may had an incentive to suggest that Pratt used psychic abilities whether or not he actually did, and to downplay the fact that Pratt apparently searched for the body for several weeks and may not have used any psychic abilities at all.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Rodney,

Why are you attempting to shift the burden of proof again, and what does your question have to do with my statement?

My point is that the police may had an incentive to suggest that Pratt used psychic abilities whether or not he actually did, and to downplay the fact that Pratt apparently searched for the body for several weeks and may not have used any psychic abilities at all.

-Bri
I'm not attempting to shift the burden of proof -- my point is that Pratt is only one of several psychics who has convinced knowlegeable police officers that psychics have helped solve cases, and I don't know any non-psychics who have done that. However, if you can show that it is not that uncommon for non-psychics to help the police solve cases, I will be more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means.
 
I'm not attempting to shift the burden of proof -- my point is that Pratt is only one of several psychics who has convinced knowlegeable police officers that psychics have helped solve cases, and I don't know any non-psychics who have done that. However, if you can show that it is not that uncommon for non-psychics to help the police solve cases, I will be more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means.

Miss Marple, anyone?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miss_Marple
 
Last edited:
I'm not attempting to shift the burden of proof -- my point is that Pratt is only one of several psychics who has convinced knowlegeable police officers that psychics have helped solve cases, and I don't know any non-psychics who have done that.

Yes, you are. You asked if I could cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve. The burden of proof would be on you to cite a case that was solved WITH the use of psychic abilities. Until you show otherwise, Pratt is probably as good an example as any of a member of the public helping to solve a case without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever.

However, if you can show that it is not that uncommon for non-psychics to help the police solve cases, I will be more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means.

Again, I'm not sure what one has to do with the other, nor how someone who didn't claim to be a psychic helping to solve a case would have any bearing on whether someone who claims to have psychic abilities actually does.

Unless you can present significant evidence that would indicate otherwise, I have no reason to assume that ANY case of a self-proclaimed psychics helping to solve a crime is anything other than an example of a self-proclaimed psychic helping to solve a crime by non-psychic means.

That said, I'm guessing that many cases have been solved by people not claiming to be psychics. For example, I'm fairly certain that hunters who didn't claim to be psychic have found bodies in the woods that the police had been looking for. Additionally, it is not uncommon for people who don't claim to be psychics to join police searches, and fairly often they are successful.

So are you now more receptive to the notion that the so-called psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Yes, you are. You asked if I could cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve. The burden of proof would be on you to cite a case that was solved WITH the use of psychic abilities. Until you show otherwise, Pratt is probably as good an example as any of a member of the public helping to solve a case without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever.
Except that the police sergeant in that case disagrees with you. And he is not the only police officer who believes that psychics have helped solve cases that the police were unable to solve on their own. For example, on this thread, I've cited two police officers who are convinced that Annette Martin's psychic assistance is what led to the finding of the body of a missing person. There are also two retired police officers who vouch for psychic detective Nancy Weber; see -- http://www.nancyorlenweber.com/references.html -- and several police officers who vouch for psychic detective Noreen Renier; see -- http://noreenrenier.com/testimonials.htm

Again, I'm not sure what one has to do with the other, nor how someone who didn't claim to be a psychic helping to solve a case would have any bearing on whether someone who claims to have psychic abilities actually does.

Unless you can present significant evidence that would indicate otherwise, I have no reason to assume that ANY case of a self-proclaimed psychics helping to solve a crime is anything other than an example of a self-proclaimed psychic helping to solve a crime by non-psychic means.

That said, I'm guessing that many cases have been solved by people not claiming to be psychics. For example, I'm fairly certain that hunters who didn't claim to be psychic have found bodies in the woods that the police had been looking for. Additionally, it is not uncommon for people who don't claim to be psychics to join police searches, and fairly often they are successful.

So are you now more receptive to the notion that the so-called psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means?

-Bri
No, because you haven't given me any cases where a non-psychic -- say, a member of this Forum ;) -- has helped the police solve a case that they could not solve on their own. Now, of course, hunters and hikers may sometimes stumble upon a body, but that's hardly the same thing as someone going to the police and suggesting that they look in a location that turns out to be where the body is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom