Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

I said that the psychic was Pratt. Do you think that Pratt performed above random chance in the report posted earlier?
It certainly appears that way.

It's a simple question. Let's say that the police used DNA evidence from the place from which your loved one was kidnapped and want to search the house of the person whose DNA was found. The police feel this is the most likely place to find your loved one before she dies, but are far from absolutely certain. Pratt, on the other hand, says that your loved one is buried elsewhere.

I'll give you one more chance to save your loved one. You have to choose one location. Now answer the question. Another non-answer indicates that you are so far gone that you allowed your loved one to die instead of deciding.
In your scenario, the location given by the police has some plausibility, but is still pretty speculative, and so I would have to know specifically what Pratt's suggested location was before I could decide. But, again, you are presenting a false choice. Normally, what would happen is that the police would exhaust all of their other options before bringing in a psychic, and so the location pinpointed by the psychic would be searched only as a last resort.

ETA: I find it interesting that you would require evidence that the psychic had performed above random chance in the past. How would you determine that? You're not advocating that psychics actually be tested are you?
Yes, but the best test is calling in a psychic in a real-world case. The evidence indicates that, at least in one instance, Norm Pratt passed that test with flying colors.
 
Rodney, Hardenbergh,

How do you reconcile the fact that there are so many missing persons, with your belief that psychics can find them? Why haven't the psychics found any? Why does their failure to find even one missing person not seem to indicate to you that perhaps they can't find missing people?

How long can you keep up your belief? I'm being serious here. How long can you keep believing that psychics can find missing persons when clearly they can't?

I have no agenda. If Mr. Pratt were to turn around tomorrow (today would be better) and tell the suffering parents of that poor girl where she is, I would be among the first to acknowledge the amazing power he possesses.

Why can't he, or any of the other psychics, find her, or any of the other missing persons?
Do you think that psychics should always be able to outperform the police? Consider the case of Chandra Levy, where both psychics and the police fell flat on their collective faces. Police had evidence that Levy was likely either abducted or murdered in Rock Creek Park in Washington, DC on May 1, 2001, because she disappeared that day and someone had used her laptop computer that morning to do an Internet search on the Park's Klingle Mansion. Further, police knew that Levy had been involved in an affair with Congressman Gary Condit, who lived on the outskirts of Rock Creek Park. Police did search the Park, but came up empty. However, more than a year later, a man walking his dog in the Park found her remains just one mile from the Klingle Mansion. Unfortunately, by that time the DNA evidence had been contaminated. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandra_Levy
 
It certainly appears that way.

Then why did you ask if the psychic had performed better than chance in the past? You're avoiding the question, which speaks volumes.

In your scenario, the location given by the police has some plausibility, but is still pretty speculative, and so I would have to know specifically what Pratt's suggested location was before I could decide.

Why does it matter where Pratt said your loved one is located? Let's say it was in the woods across town near the big oak tree. Why won't you answer the question? The fact that you won't answer the question is very telling, indeed.

But, again, you are presenting a false choice. Normally, what would happen is that the police would exhaust all of their other options before bringing in a psychic, and so the location pinpointed by the psychic would be searched only as a last resort.

I said it was a hypothetical situation where they would only have time to dig up one spot or the other before she dies. It is clear that you're not going to answer the question. But I think we all know the answer.

Yes, but the best test is calling in a psychic in a real-world case. The evidence indicates that, at least in one instance, Norm Pratt passed that test with flying colors.

Pratt couldn't even tell them where the body was. No, the best test is a double-blind one. The fact that you know this and don't believe that Norm Pratt passed any test with flying colors is evidenced by the fact that you won't answer the question.

One more chance to set the record straight: If this scenario were true and it was your loved one, where would you dig? Answer the question.

-Bri
 
Yes, but the best test is calling in a psychic in a real-world case. The evidence indicates that, at least in one instance, Norm Pratt passed that test with flying colors.

What do you think would happen in the absence of psychic powers? If I was in the habit of going to the police and saying that I was a clever person and had some ideas about where to search, do you think that additional searches based on my suggestions would always be fruitless (assuming that they wouldn't tell me to bugger off)?

Linda
 
Do you think that psychics should always be able to outperform the police? Consider the case of Chandra Levy, where both psychics and the police fell flat on their collective faces.

You seem to be missing the point. Psychics have never succeeded in using psychic abilities to help solve a missing persons case. Even if a psychic has succeeded in the past (and the evidence clearly indicates otherwise), it would be ridiculous for police to use psychics because they fail on almost every occasion. Valuable police time is always better spent either looking for evidence or working on another case rather than following false leads provided by psychics. It would be far better to test psychics before police waste their time on them.

I don't know why psychics often fail, but the evidence suggests to me that they sometimes succeed.

Wow, that statement seems at best ridiculously optimistic and at worst purposefully misleading. You make it sound as though psychics succeed in solving a significant number of cases they attempt. But of course it can't be even close to half, nor even a quarter, nor even an eighth, nor even 1 in 16. It can't even be 1 in 100, 1 in 200, or even 1 in 500 given the utter lack of verifiable reports of success.

So what do you estimate your evidence indicates is the number of psychics who have actually succeeded out of the literally thousands who have failed? How many actual verifiable success stories do you think you can find of anyone using psychic powers to locate a missing person? Remember, having no evidence at all is not the same as "the evidence suggests to me that they sometimes succeed."

Now, let's pretend for a moment that you could find verification that Pratt or some other psychic actually succeeded once (you can't, but let's pretend that you could). Do you think that one success out of thousands of failures would justify the time it would take to track down every lead provided by a psychic? If DNA evidence was only accurate 1 out of 1000 times, do you think it would be useful to police? That's essentially your argument when you say "but if only one psychic could help solve just one case, it would be worth it." But what about the other 999 cases where precious time and effort is wasted fruitlessly searching because of false information?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Then why did you ask if the psychic had performed better than chance in the past? You're avoiding the question, which speaks volumes.
I was speaking of psychics in general. Some are clearly frauds, while others seem to have some ability.

Why does it matter where Pratt said your loved one is located? Let's say it was in the woods across town near the big oak tree. Why won't you answer the question? The fact that you won't answer the question is very telling, indeed.

I said it was a hypothetical situation where they would only have time to dig up one spot or the other before she dies. It is clear that you're not going to answer the question. But I think we all know the answer.

Pratt couldn't even tell them where the body was. No, the best test is a double-blind one. The fact that you know this and don't believe that Norm Pratt passed any test with flying colors is evidenced by the fact that you won't answer the question.

One more chance to set the record straight: If this scenario were true and it was your loved one, where would you dig? Answer the question.

-Bri
I've answered it, but you won't accept my answer because you think this is a one-size-fits-all type of situation. I have limited knowledge about Pratt, but based on him apparently resolving a case that had stymied the police for 10 months, I would have some trust in him. However, if -- based on all of the facts -- his suggested location in your scenario seemed less likely to me than the police's suggested location, I would go with the police's location first. I recognize that, even a gifted psychic such as Edgar Cayce, was not right every time. So, for example, if Pratt suggested that my loved one disappeared while picking blueberries and was being held captive in that blueberry field, but I knew that (s)he disliked blueberries and had never before picked them, I would discount Pratt's suggested location. And, again, in almost all real-world situations, the police would search their suggested location first because they are in charge of the investigation.
 
I was speaking of psychics in general. Some are clearly frauds, while others seem to have some ability.

The hypothetical I posed was about Pratt, not about psychics in general. You implied that you felt that Pratt has the ability to find missing people based on the evidence.

I've answered it, but you won't accept my answer because you think this is a one-size-fits-all type of situation. I have limited knowledge about Pratt, but based on him apparently resolving a case that had stymied the police for 10 months, I would have some trust in him. However, if -- based on all of the facts -- his suggested location in your scenario seemed less likely to me than the police's suggested location, I would go with the police's location first.

I gave you the facts. There are no additional facts. The facts are very straightforward in this situation. Based on what you know about Pratt from the article, where would you dig? It's a simple question.

I recognize that, even a gifted psychic such as Edgar Cayce, was not right every time. So, for example, if Pratt suggested that my loved one disappeared while picking blueberries and was being held captive in that blueberry field, but I knew that (s)he disliked blueberries and had never before picked them, I would discount Pratt's suggested location. And, again, in almost all real-world situations, the police would search their suggested location first because they are in charge of the investigation.

This is a hypothetical situation, not a real-world situation. No, Pratt didn't say she was picking blueberries. All he said is that the police have the wrong location and suggests a different location. Based on what you know about Pratt, where would you dig?

Let's face it, you won't answer the question because we all know the answer. No, the evidence from the report posted earlier does NOT qualify as a test of Pratt's abilities, and does NOT indicate that "Norm Pratt passed that test with flying colors." It's fairly obvious that you know that but simply don't want to admit that you were wrong, and instead prefer to dig yourself in deeper and deeper to avoid it.

-Bri
 
However, if -- based on all of the facts -- his suggested location in your scenario seemed less likely to me than the police's suggested location, I would go with the police's location first.
This gives it away completely, Rodney.

The only way for you to know the relative likelihoods would be either of the two following methods (or a combination of both):

1. Comparison of their track records which presumes testing that has not been done for any psychic.

2. Evidence-based analysis of the proposed locations which presumes the psychic's call was evidence-based in the first place and not at all psychically divined.
 
What do you think would happen in the absence of psychic powers? If I was in the habit of going to the police and saying that I was a clever person and had some ideas about where to search, do you think that additional searches based on my suggestions would always be fruitless (assuming that they wouldn't tell me to bugger off)?

Linda
I agree that, in some instances, the police may simply miss clues. However, in this case, the article says that the police solicited the assistance of a psychic after searching for 10 months. That doesn't necessarily rule out the possibility that Pratt could have simply been a better detective than the police, but it seems unlikely.
 
This gives it away completely, Rodney.

The only way for you to know the relative likelihoods would be either of the two following methods (or a combination of both):

1. Comparison of their track records which presumes testing that has not been done for any psychic.

2. Evidence-based analysis of the proposed locations which presumes the psychic's call was evidence-based in the first place and not at all psychically divined.
Good to hear from you again, Garrette. By "track record", I refer to the record in solving missing person cases, not artificial double-blind testing. (Again, if anyone here has a useful protocol for testing a psychic detective, let's hear what it is.) If the psychic appeared to me to have a better batting average than the police department in solving missing person cases, I would go with the psychic's suggested location in Bri's scenario, all things being equal.
 
Good to hear from you again, Garrette.
Thanks. Discussions with you are always interesting...


By "track record", I refer to the record in solving missing person cases, not artificial double-blind testing.
It ultimately leads to the same objection I mentioned above.

The "record" comprises nothing but newspaper articles, self-promotion on websites, and unofficial (and unspecific) endorsements by a very few law enforcement officers.

Which means you will be comparing a strictly documented track record of the police department to a virtually no-existent track record of the psychic.


(Again, if anyone here has a useful protocol for testing a psychic detective, let's hear what it is.)
When you get a psychic detective to state clearly what he can do under what circumstances to what degree of accuracy, I will gladly oblige.


If the psychic appeared to me to have a better batting average than the police department in solving missing person cases,
Do you know of any psychic detectives with a better batting average than any police department?

If you do, please tell me how you determined relative batting averages.
 
I agree that, in some instances, the police may simply miss clues. However, in this case, the article says that the police solicited the assistance of a psychic after searching for 10 months. That doesn't necessarily rule out the possibility that Pratt could have simply been a better detective than the police, but it seems unlikely.

So, you think the only choices are that Pratt is a better detective than the police, or that Pratt has psychic powers, and that the most likely of the two is that Pratt has psychic powers? That's a fallacy known as a "false dichotomy."

It is far more likely that Pratt simply guessed that the police were searching in the wrong place given that they hadn't found anything there, and suggested that the police search elsewhere. No psychic powers are necessary to explain the story.

-Bri
 
If the psychic appeared to me to have a better batting average than the police department in solving missing person cases, I would go with the psychic's suggested location in Bri's scenario, all things being equal.

What does that mean??? What psychic has a better batting average than a police department in solving missing person cases? All things are not equal, and you've already admitted as such in a previous post!

I'd rather you answer my question in regard to the scenario I suggested rather than in your own dream world where all things are equal and where Pratt has a better batting average than the police.

-Bri
 
Do you know of any psychic detectives with a better batting average than any police department?
All that I know about Norm Pratt and the Nelson, BC police department is based on this one case, in which the police dept. was stymied until they called on Pratt.
 
So, you think the only choices are that Pratt is a better detective than the police, or that Pratt has psychic powers, and that the most likely of the two is that Pratt has psychic powers? That's a fallacy known as a "false dichotomy."

It is far more likely that Pratt simply guessed that the police were searching in the wrong place given that they hadn't found anything there, and suggested that the police search elsewhere. No psychic powers are necessary to explain the story.

-Bri
You're ignoring the fact that Pratt found Sarjeant's clothes. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=34112
 
So, you think the only choices are that Pratt is a better detective than the police, or that Pratt has psychic powers, and that the most likely of the two is that Pratt has psychic powers? That's a fallacy known as a "false dichotomy."

It is far more likely that Pratt simply guessed that the police were searching in the wrong place given that they hadn't found anything there, and suggested that the police search elsewhere. No psychic powers are necessary to explain the story.

-Bri

If Pratt was just guessing, at least it was a good one.
 
The thing that should also be taken into account is that even a broken clock is right twice a day.

If I remember correctly, it's been found in this thread that Pratt has no other documented track record beyond this case. So...how many times has he been wrong?

I just don't see how Pratt's "psychic" powers can really be taken seriously even in this case. The "map" is gibberish - actually it's beyond gibberish and just wasted the police time. The article above infers that Pratt himself went deep into the woods, found clothes, and then her body...but every other account I've seen says he merely told the police where not to look. What did he actually provide them with?

I also can't take the police seriously here. I mean, if I were one of these officers and believed in Pratt's abilities he would never leave the station because I'd have him going over every single missing person/cold case/unsolved mystery file that I had. That they aren't doing so speaks volumes of their confidence in him. And that he isn't volunteering his time to do so speaks volumes of Pratt as a human being.
 
All that I know about Norm Pratt and the Nelson, BC police department is based on this one case, in which the police dept. was stymied until they called on Pratt.
I asked if you know any psychic detectives with a better batting average than any law enforcement agency.

I gather that the answer is no.

I further gather that means you would never choose the psychic in Bri's hypothetical.

I further gather that since you admit you know nothing about Pratt except what is in this one article that you admit you know nothing except that he has made claims which have not been substantiated. Unless, of course, you consider news articles to be sufficient evidence upon which to form a conclusion.


You're ignoring the fact that Pratt found Sarjeant's clothes. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=34112
It's not a fact. It's an unsupported claim in an article which no longer even exists at the link (at least when I link it).

You are ignoring the fact that there is no objective evidence that Pratt provided any such assistance.


Hardenbergh said:
If Pratt was just guessing, at least it was a good one.

Police Department: We've been over this area a thousand times and found nothing!

Pratt: Try somewhere else.

Hardenbergh: Pratt's a genius!
 
If I remember correctly, it's been found in this thread that Pratt has no other documented track record beyond this case. So...how many times has he been wrong?
Even this case is not a documented success.

There is a newspaper article that parrots a claim. That's it.
 
You're ignoring the fact that Pratt found Sarjeant's clothes.

No I'm not, but it does raise the question of why Pratt couldn't find the body.

According to the article posted at the beginning of this thread:

But local psychic Norm Pratt steered police away from that trail. About a kilometre into nearby woods, police found Sarjeant's clothes. Her remains were discovered in the same area.

It is far from clear that Pratt actually discovered her clothes or did anything other than tell the police to stop searching where they had already searched.

My point was that there is no evidence that this was the result of any psychic powers, and there are plenty of more likely explanations other than "he was smarter than the police" and "he used psychic powers." You are arguing a false dilemma if you ignore the other (in this case more likely) possibilities.

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom