Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Now, Garrette is a bit more subtle,
Thanks. I am rarely credited with that quality. But I prefer "nuanced."


Rodney said:
but in post #77, he stated: "What it is also empty of is any demonstration that he [Norm Pratt] can do what he says he can do" -
Yes, I did say that. I stand by it.


Rodney said:
- ignoring the fact that Sgt. Bank believes that, without Pratt's involvement, the police would not have recovered a missing woman's body.
1. The media report that sentiment.

2. SGT Bank is not speaking on behalf of the department.

3. It stands, as I have said repeatedly, an unsubstantiated opinion. There is nothing to back it up.


Rodney said:
Garrette also constantly uses the evil media as a strawman to attempt to discredit psychic detectives;
1. I never called the media evil.

2. For it to be a strawman, I would have to be presenting it as an argument you have not made. What I have actually done is show that your entire case rests on media reports (with the sole exception of your conversation with Jerry Lewis, years after the fact).


Rodney said:
for example, in post #146, he stated: "It is one indicator of why newspaper articles are poor sources on which to base any belief, opinion, or conclusion"
I stand by this, too. And you are ignoring when I said I apply this to more than just psychic detectives or other paranormal claims. I apply it to media reports about medical studies, too. And criminal cases without the involvment of psychics.


Rodney said:
-- ignoring the police officers who attest to the ability of some psychic detectives.
I've never ignored them Rodney. I've mentioned Banks more than once (not always by name). What I don't do is give his opinion the same evidentiary weight that you do. That's a far cry from ignoring it.

But about your general assertion that I have a bias against psychic detectives, it is quite possible that I do. It is more likely that I have a bias against the promotion of abilities which lack evidence establishing their legitimacy, but if you want to erase that distinction, I won't object.

I have a bias against alleged psychic detectives who make the claim without legitimate evidence. You have a bias for.

It doesn't matter. What matters is evidence.

You have admitted indirectly that the entirety of the evidence involves media reports. You have not shown one case file, one police report, or any primary source that is immune to either of our biases.

It is still a burden of proof issue.
 
Last edited:
Okay, that got a chuckle.


I'm the debunker. You want me to present your evidence before I present mine?

Actually, I wondered if you'd say something along these lines. What you are doing in asking this question in response to mine is admitting that you have no evidence other than media accounts and the uncorroborated statement of someone not officially representing a law enforcement agency and stated years after the fact without corroboration.

And that's your BEST case.

Except it's not really your best case even though you said it was your best case because when Bri pointed out it's not a good case you said it's not your best case even though when I asked for your best case you said this was your best case. Even though it's not.

So I will recap, in all seriousness now:

1. You said this Weber case is the best example of a psychic detective using psychic means to solve a case.

2. You admit you have done nothing to corroborate the claims.

3. You say it isn't really the best case after all.


ETA: Don't worry, Rodney. I actually AM on this case. I have mailed the OPRA (Official Public Records Act) Information Requests to Mount Olive.
I appreciate your efforts. However, to clarify my views on the Nicholas Muscio case, I think it's one of the best -- if not the best -- example of a psychic detective knowing things that the police did not know, but it is not the best example of a psychic detective solving a case. By the way, I did corroborate certain facts given by Detective Lewis. For example, he stated: "The only other person in the apartment at the time of the murder was the victim's daughter, who was apparently sleeping . . . I remember asking them what the initials were. They were 'N.M.' I remember this because I then went through my files of all the people I had tested on the case to see if any of them had those initials. None did. Months after that, and 9 months after the murder, I picked up the paper and read that a man from Netcong was arrested for the murder." The January 12, 1996 Newark Star-Ledger newspaper states that the victim "was stabbed to death on Jan. 2, 1988 in her Village Green apartment bedroom as her 17-year old daughter slept in an adjacent room. Muscio was arrested nine months later . . ."

I also note that, since it was only "months" after Lewis checked to see if any of the people he had polygraphed matched the initials "NM", it would hardly be surprising that he remembered those initials when Muscio was arrested just nine months after the murder.
 
Your verification of the facts extended, again, to checking the newspaper articles.

Why won't you go back to the primary source? Actually, I should ask why you didn't go back to the primary source since you are now vicariously going back to it through me.

Regardless if it was only months between Lewis checking for the initials and the case being solved, it was years between the case being solved and you talking to him.

And it still goes back to non-primary sources.


ETA: I accept your distinction between "solving a case" and "providing information unknown to the police." We'll keep it in mind.
 
Okay, I was responding to your hyperbolic statement -- "If this is the best you've got, I think we can safely rest our case" -- with my own hyperbolic statement.

Fair enough. Only my hyperbolic statement was true and I don't think yours was. If you've already presented your BEST evidence for your BEST example, then indeed your claim is unsupported and we need not continue the discussion. However, if you think you can obtain better evidence, then I've already indicated that I'll wait patiently until it is presented. If the evidence for your claim is stronger than the evidence against it, then I'll change my opinion about your claim.

However, you each have shown a clear bias against psychic detectives.

I can't speak for Garrette, but I don't have a bias against psychic detectives any more than I have a bias against goats. Both are equally successful in using their unique abilities to solve police cases.

That said, I suppose I DO have a bias against the use of psychic abilities or goats to solve crimes without any evidence that they actually CAN solve crimes. It would seem that you have a similar bias against goats, but an entirely different bias concerning psychic abilities, whereas the evidence would indicate that both have been equally successful in solving crimes.

I also admit that I may have a bias against people who make claims without sufficient evidence. Incidentally, this doesn't seem to be a problem for goats, for whom I have the deepest respect in that regard.

For example, in post #51 on this thread, in response to my tongue-in-cheek question -- "Ah, so is the all-knowing Bri -- when she becomes Emperor of the Whole Wide World -- going to decree that police departments may no longer use psychics who haven't been tested?" -- you responded: "Correct, yes. And in the meantime, police departments worldwide would be wise to implement a similar standard so as not to waste the taxpayer's money and more importantly their own valuable time and resources."

Obviously, I don't think that I will become Emperor of the Whole Wide World, and was being facetious in my response. However, my response reflects the fact that the evidence strongly indicates that it is far more likely that psychic abilities don't exist than that they do exist, and that if they do exist they likely can't help police to solve crimes any more than goats can.

So, yes, if I were in a position to affect such changes, I'd mandate that police departments not use psychics who haven't been tested (nor would they be permitted to use goats who haven't been tested), as a matter of practicality. Governments often have rules about wasting time and resources paid for by public taxes on unproven methods, as they should.

Now, Garrette is a bit more subtle, but in post #77, he stated: "What it is also empty of is any demonstration that he [Norm Pratt] can do what he says he can do" -- ignoring the fact that Sgt. Bank believes that, without Pratt's involvement, the police would not have recovered a missing woman's body. Garrette also constantly uses the evil media as a strawman to attempt to discredit psychic detectives; for example, in post #146, he stated: "It is one indicator of why newspaper articles are poor sources on which to base any belief, opinion, or conclusion" -- ignoring the police officers who attest to the ability of some psychic detectives.

Garrette, subtle? I find Garrette's responses to be quite direct and clear.

I obviously don't read Garrett's statements to represent a bias any more than mine do, but he does seem to hold the same opinion concerning psychics making claims that they can't prove, and about the use of unproven methods by police. It sounds to me that he would just like some evidence that psychics can actually do what they claim they can do before assuming that they can.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I can't speak for Garrette,
You almost do. I can't think of anything you've written in this thread with which I disagree.


Bri said:
Garrette, subtle? I find Garrette's responses to be quite direct and clear.
Now, now. I was starting to revel in the subtletly of my nuance.

It's the key to open-mindedness, you know.
 
You almost do. I can't think of anything you've written in this thread with which I disagree.

Except for my repeated misspelling of your name. Darned "e" keeps getting left off!

Now, now. I was starting to revel in the subtletly of my nuance.

It's the key to open-mindedness, you know.

Yes, but YOU more subtle than ME? I don't think so!

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I appreciate your efforts. However, to clarify my views on the Nicholas Muscio case, I think it's one of the best -- if not the best -- example of a psychic detective knowing things that the police did not know, but it is not the best example of a psychic detective solving a case.

Well why don't you give us the best example of a psychic solving a case through paranormal means? (Sorry--a psychic using conventional methods doesn't count.)

The standard I suggest is the same one they use for giving out rewards--providing information leading to the arrest and conviction in the case.

Guessing "N.M." (and maybe lots of other stuff that turned out to be wrong), and the police later (through their own, non-psychic efforts) arresting someone with those initials is not what I would call "solving" or even "helping". It's right up there with Sylvia Browne supporters claiming a hit for the name "Michael" in the Shawn Hornbeck case.
 
Well why don't you give us the best example of a psychic solving a case through paranormal means? (Sorry--a psychic using conventional methods doesn't count.)
It's a good thought, but you ought to caveat it that Rodney needs to provide what he considers to be the complete evidence in support of his case. Obtaining police reports ought to be on him.

I'm only doing it this time because I had begun the process some time ago and Rodney and I are just really really great friends. Really.
 
Well why don't you give us the best example of a psychic solving a case through paranormal means? (Sorry--a psychic using conventional methods doesn't count.)
Post #197 on this thread gives a good example. There are many other good examples, and so I hesitate to say that one is the best, but you can start there.
 
It's a good thought, but you ought to caveat it that Rodney needs to provide what he considers to be the complete evidence in support of his case. Obtaining police reports ought to be on him.
It's always desirable to obtain police reports, if they're available, but they don't necessarily tell the whole story. In some cases, the involvement of a psychic may be downplayed or not even mentioned in a police report, even though (s)he provided major assistance. Therefore, it's also desirable to obtain the perspective of police officers who worked on the case, but whose opinions may not be reflected in the report.

I'm only doing it this time because I had begun the process some time ago and Rodney and I are just really really great friends. Really.
Absolutely, we have so much in common . . .
 
It's always desirable to obtain police reports,
And yet you so rarely do so.

but they don't necessarily tell the whole story.
No. For that we rely on the psychic websites and the newspaper articles and maybe some unsubstantiated and unspecific claims of police officers not officially representing the law enforcement agency.

In some cases, the involvement of a psychic may be downplayed or not even mentioned in a police report, even though (s)he provided major assistance.
Of course. Because we have such overwhelming evidence that this happens as opposed to pure speculation.


Therefore, it's also desirable to obtain the perspective of police officers who worked on the case, but whose opinions may not be reflected in the report.
Or the unsubstantiated perspectives only? That seems to be what you've done so far.

How many police reports have you obtained again?


Absolutely, we have so much in common . . .
In all seriousness, I find nothing in any of our conversations to indicate that we wouldn't have a grand time at the pub.
 
Post #197 on this thread gives a good example. There are many other good examples, and so I hesitate to say that one is the best, but you can start there.

What is it that makes that psychic? For example, what if I knew the police officer and offered to help and did the same thing - drew a circle on a map after focussing on the map and picture - but did not claim any special abilities (other than my keen wit, of course ;)). What would you make of that?

And now for something completely different that I thought was kinda cool:
Today, in the bookstore, I was walking by the help desk on my way somewhere else when I overhead the clerk say, "the author on that book is *****" and it just happened to be my last name.

Linda
 
<snip>

And now for something completely different that I thought was kinda cool:
Today, in the bookstore, I was walking by the help desk on my way somewhere else when I overhead the clerk say, "the author on that book is *****" and it just happened to be my last name.

Linda

For a moment there I thought you had a rude last name:D

BTW, you didn't write the book, did you?
 
And yet you so rarely do so.
The authorities don't want to give me anything.

No. For that we rely on the psychic websites and the newspaper articles and maybe some unsubstantiated and unspecific claims of police officers not officially representing the law enforcement agency.
So only the police report can be trusted and every other responsible opinion can be ignored?

In all seriousness, I find nothing in any of our conversations to indicate that we wouldn't have a grand time at the pub.
I think that's true and, after a few drinks, I might find your arguments more plausible.* :)

* And, hopefully, vice-versa.
 
What is it that makes that psychic? For example, what if I knew the police officer and offered to help and did the same thing - drew a circle on a map after focussing on the map and picture - but did not claim any special abilities (other than my keen wit, of course ;)). What would you make of that?

I would be impressed if a body were found.

And now for something completely different that I thought was kinda cool:
Today, in the bookstore, I was walking by the help desk on my way somewhere else when I overhead the clerk say, "the author on that book is *****" and it just happened to be my last name.
Linda
Are you saying: (a) you are the author of that book? or (b) you have an uncommon (at least somewhat) last name, and it was an interesting coincidence?
 
And now for something completely different that I thought was kinda cool:
Today, in the bookstore, I was walking by the help desk on my way somewhere else when I overhead the clerk say, "the author on that book is *****" and it just happened to be my last name.

Is your last name "Talented" or "Awesome?"

-Bri
 
So only the police report can be trusted and every other responsible opinion can be ignored?

You miss the point Rodney. You cannot decide whether or not a person is psychic based on a quote in a newspaper report of the opinion of a single person who may or may not have had reason to fudge the facts. In that case, corroborating evidence is necessary to make the leap to the conclusion that psychic abilities were at work. Otherwise, in light of all of the evidence against the existence of psychic abilities, one would have to assume much more likely scenarios involving no psychic abilities. In other words, Rodney, you need to have some compelling evidence before I will believe your claim.

-Bri
 
So only the police report can be trusted and every other responsible opinion can be ignored?

What would be most useful is stuff written beforehand, so that memory tricks and wishful thinking haven't had their chance to work magic - a list of the hundred things the psychic said instead of the few that turned out to be right or retrofitable; the actual sequence of events; the source of specific tidbits of information.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom