Thanks. I am rarely credited with that quality. But I prefer "nuanced."Now, Garrette is a bit more subtle,
Yes, I did say that. I stand by it.Rodney said:but in post #77, he stated: "What it is also empty of is any demonstration that he [Norm Pratt] can do what he says he can do" -
1. The media report that sentiment.Rodney said:- ignoring the fact that Sgt. Bank believes that, without Pratt's involvement, the police would not have recovered a missing woman's body.
2. SGT Bank is not speaking on behalf of the department.
3. It stands, as I have said repeatedly, an unsubstantiated opinion. There is nothing to back it up.
1. I never called the media evil.Rodney said:Garrette also constantly uses the evil media as a strawman to attempt to discredit psychic detectives;
2. For it to be a strawman, I would have to be presenting it as an argument you have not made. What I have actually done is show that your entire case rests on media reports (with the sole exception of your conversation with Jerry Lewis, years after the fact).
I stand by this, too. And you are ignoring when I said I apply this to more than just psychic detectives or other paranormal claims. I apply it to media reports about medical studies, too. And criminal cases without the involvment of psychics.Rodney said:for example, in post #146, he stated: "It is one indicator of why newspaper articles are poor sources on which to base any belief, opinion, or conclusion"
I've never ignored them Rodney. I've mentioned Banks more than once (not always by name). What I don't do is give his opinion the same evidentiary weight that you do. That's a far cry from ignoring it.Rodney said:-- ignoring the police officers who attest to the ability of some psychic detectives.
But about your general assertion that I have a bias against psychic detectives, it is quite possible that I do. It is more likely that I have a bias against the promotion of abilities which lack evidence establishing their legitimacy, but if you want to erase that distinction, I won't object.
I have a bias against alleged psychic detectives who make the claim without legitimate evidence. You have a bias for.
It doesn't matter. What matters is evidence.
You have admitted indirectly that the entirety of the evidence involves media reports. You have not shown one case file, one police report, or any primary source that is immune to either of our biases.
It is still a burden of proof issue.
Last edited: