Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Except for the annoying little fact that the police didn't actually have the main suspect in custody in one of the cases, and had incorrectly charged the woman in the second one. Either way, both stories meet your initial criteria: "Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?" Oh wait -- we were supposed to read your mind and assume you meant this instead:

Oh, but wait again -- both of my examples did meet these amended criteria. That explains why you've simply ignored them rather than addressing them or admitting that Pratt could have used non-psychic means to aid the police. Of course, I suspect that instead of admitting anything, you'll either change the criteria again or just continue to ignore the examples.
What I'm looking for is an example where a non-psychic has done something comparable to what the police say psychics have done, such as telling the police where a body is or giving police the initials of the murderer.

I believe that Garrette was saying that the police officer's statements were possibly self-serving -- the same criteria you use to dismiss the private investigator's statements. Or would you be more apt to believe a private investigator's self-serving statements as long as they're accurately quoted in a newspaper article?

-Bri
What is your evidence that the police officers' statements are self-serving?
 
Oh, but wait again -- both of my examples did meet these amended criteria. That explains why you've simply ignored them rather than addressing them or admitting that Pratt could have used non-psychic means to aid the police. Of course, I suspect that instead of admitting anything, you'll either change the criteria again or just continue to ignore the examples.

What I'm looking for is an example where a non-psychic has done something comparable to what the police say psychics have done, such as telling the police where a body is or giving police the initials of the murderer.

Can I call 'em or what? Rodney, Pratt neither told the police where the body was, nor did he give them any initials of the murderer. Pratt did precisely what other searchers have done -- looked for the body for several weeks. But you still want to deny that Pratt may have found the body through non-psychic means. It is becoming clear that you are going to refuse to admit the obvious at all costs here.

What is your evidence that the police officers' statements are self-serving?

Can you show me where I said that the police officers' statements are self-serving? I said that the police officer's statements were possibly self-serving -- the same criteria you use to dismiss the private investigator's statements. If you want to shift the burden or proof, then what is your evidence that the investigator's statements are self-serving? You can't have it both ways, Rodney.

-Bri
 
I commend you on your effort, but it can be difficult to get a response. I tried to do the same thing in the case involving Valerie Morrison, but never heard back. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2299109&postcount=36
I got a response (from someone to whom LT Aagens forwarded my request.

Now I have to download the appropriate request form, fill it out by hand, and mail it hard copy. I have been cautioned that two things make it more difficult and more time-consuming to find the appropriate records:

1. Passage of time since the case.

2. Lack of specificity regarding the case.

Both of these apply to what I'm trying to find, so we'll see. Here's what I'm trying to find info on:

1. A rape-murder case that occurred in 1980 or before. The victim was found in a local lake. COD was "drowning and an injury to the head." Suspect eventually confessed to Detective English.

2. Burglary in which a rifle and other items were stolen (this may have occurred at Nancy Orlen Weber's home; it is unclear in the letter). 2 juveniles arrested when a warrant search produced the stolen rifle at their home.

3. Internal Affairs investigation headed by Detective English and assisted by county, state, and federal authorities resulted in "over 100 indictments."
 
Hi Rodney,

What did you think of my suggestion?

Surely a psychic with even 10% accuracy could find three missing people over a few years.
 
Can I call 'em or what? Rodney, Pratt neither told the police where the body was, nor did he give them any initials of the murderer. Pratt did precisely what other searchers have done -- looked for the body for several weeks. But you still want to deny that Pratt may have found the body through non-psychic means. It is becoming clear that you are going to refuse to admit the obvious at all costs here.
So why is it that Pratt's assistance -- and no one else's -- is what led to the body being found? And how was it that Nancy Weber pinpointed murderer Nicholas Muscio's initials before he was considered a suspect by police? Did Pratt and Weber simply get lucky?

Can you show me where I said that the police officers' statements are self-serving? I said that the police officer's statements were possibly self-serving -- the same criteria you use to dismiss the private investigator's statements. If you want to shift the burden or proof, then what is your evidence that the investigator's statements are self-serving? You can't have it both ways, Rodney.

-Bri
The private investigator's statements are self-serving because they are claiming success with two clients with no evidence -- the statements don't even mentioning their clients' names. In contrast, the police -- who have no ties with the psychics, as far as I am aware -- are on the record as saying that the psychics provided crucial assistance in solving cases.
 
Hi Rodney,

What did you think of my suggestion?

Surely a psychic with even 10% accuracy could find three missing people over a few years.
It appears Annette Martin has already does that. And what is your specific protocol that would allow Martin or another psychic detective to win the million dollar prize?
 
So why is it that Pratt's assistance -- and no one else's -- is what led to the body being found?

For the same reason that other people searching for bodies have been successful. Pratt searched for several weeks to find the clothing, and there is no evidence that he used any psychic means to do so. As for "and no one else's" -- once a body is found, other people generally stop looking so it would be rather unusual for more than one person's assistance to lead to the body being found. However, Pratt's case seems to be an exception since it is extremely likely that other people contributed to finding the body given that Pratt didn't find the body.

So again, this all begs the question of why you can't seem to admit that Pratt might have assisted the police without the use of psychic means.

The private investigator's statements are self-serving because they are claiming success with two clients with no evidence -- the statements don't even mentioning their clients' names. In contrast, the police -- who have no ties with the psychics, as far as I am aware -- are on the record as saying that the psychics provided crucial assistance in solving cases.

Your answer makes no sense to me. Why does that make the police's statement any less self-serving than the investigator's?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
It appears Annette Martin has already does that. And what is your specific protocol that would allow Martin or another psychic detective to win the million dollar prize?
Yes. It appears that she has. Because her website says so. Because books by self-interested promoters of psychics say so. Because uncritical media accounts say so.

It also appears that there is no actual evidence to support the claim that she has done so.
 
Rodney, in bringing up Annette Martin, you're throwing crap on the wall hoping something sticks and hoping that the critics get lost in a never-ending cycle of whack-a-psychic.

Let's cut to the chase:

1. Media accounts aren't anything more than a questionable starting point

2. Unofficial endorsements by individual police officers (or polygraphers) without corroborating evidence aren't anything more than a questionable starting point

3. The websites of self-proclaimed psychic detectives aren't anything more than a questionable starting point

If you want us to take you seriously, then do your work. Get the case files.

Pick one, Rodney. Just pick the one case you think is the best example of a psychic detective using psychic means to solve a case.

You present your evidence, and we'll (I'll?) evalute it.

Just one, just the best. Is it Pratt? Is it Weber? Is it Martin?
 
Rodney, in bringing up Annette Martin, you're throwing crap on the wall hoping something sticks and hoping that the critics get lost in a never-ending cycle of whack-a-psychic.

Let's cut to the chase:

1. Media accounts aren't anything more than a questionable starting point

2. Unofficial endorsements by individual police officers (or polygraphers) without corroborating evidence aren't anything more than a questionable starting point

3. The websites of self-proclaimed psychic detectives aren't anything more than a questionable starting point

If you want us to take you seriously, then do your work. Get the case files.

Pick one, Rodney. Just pick the one case you think is the best example of a psychic detective using psychic means to solve a case.

You present your evidence, and we'll (I'll?) evalute it.

Just one, just the best. Is it Pratt? Is it Weber? Is it Martin?
I would focus on the 1988 Nicholas Muscio case, which involved Nancy Weber. According to an e-mail that former police detective and polygraph expert Jerry Lewis sent me:

"Some of the cases in the book [Psychic Detective] I had worked on. One was the murder of a woman in Mt. Olive. She was stabbed in the throat while she slept. The apartment was locked, with no apparent forced entry. The knife which was used was taken out of the kitchen. The only other person in the apartment at the time of the murder was the victim's daughter, who was apparently sleeping. Due to the lack of forced entry and the murder weapon being taken from within the home, the daughter was definitely a suspect. On the advice of an attorney, she refused to submit to the polygraph. I polygraphed twelve other possible suspects and cleared them. Nancy's book states that she had met with the police and told them a stranger had watched from outside the building, then removed a screen from the kitchen window, entered through the window, and killed the woman. She was adamant that the daughter was not involved. In fact, she was mad that the police were treating her as a suspect. What she did not know was that about 6 months after the murder, the daughter wanted to come in and take the polygraph to prove her innocence. She also hoped that she might remember something during the intensive interview that would aid the investigation. I called her truthful and recommended that she be cleared as a suspect. I remember that on one of the days I was conducting a polygraph on this case, the detectives told me that they had been in contact with a psychic (Nancy Weber) who gave them the initials of the murderer. I remember asking them what the initials were. They were 'N.M.' I remember this because I then went through my files of all the people I had tested on the case to see if any of them had those initials. None did. Months after that, and 9 months after the murder, I picked up the paper and read that a man from Netcong was arrested for the murder. He was being arrested for burglary and a subsequent search of his apartment revealed a stack of articles about the Mt. Olive murder. His fingerprints were checked against an unidentified print on the kitchen window and matched. He was arrested for the murder and is currently serving his time in prison for it. His name is Nicholas Muscio. He was a stranger to the victim. He had just been watching her through the window. He removed the screen, entered through the window, took the knife out of the sink there and stabbed her."
 
I would focus on the 1988 Nicholas Muscio case, which involved Nancy Weber. According to an e-mail that former police detective and polygraph expert Jerry Lewis sent me:

"Some of the cases in the book [Psychic Detective] I had worked on. One was the murder of a woman in Mt. Olive. She was stabbed in the throat while she slept. The apartment was locked, with no apparent forced entry. The knife which was used was taken out of the kitchen. The only other person in the apartment at the time of the murder was the victim's daughter, who was apparently sleeping. Due to the lack of forced entry and the murder weapon being taken from within the home, the daughter was definitely a suspect. On the advice of an attorney, she refused to submit to the polygraph. I polygraphed twelve other possible suspects and cleared them. Nancy's book states that she had met with the police and told them a stranger had watched from outside the building, then removed a screen from the kitchen window, entered through the window, and killed the woman. She was adamant that the daughter was not involved. In fact, she was mad that the police were treating her as a suspect. What she did not know was that about 6 months after the murder, the daughter wanted to come in and take the polygraph to prove her innocence. She also hoped that she might remember something during the intensive interview that would aid the investigation. I called her truthful and recommended that she be cleared as a suspect. I remember that on one of the days I was conducting a polygraph on this case, the detectives told me that they had been in contact with a psychic (Nancy Weber) who gave them the initials of the murderer. I remember asking them what the initials were. They were 'N.M.' I remember this because I then went through my files of all the people I had tested on the case to see if any of them had those initials. None did. Months after that, and 9 months after the murder, I picked up the paper and read that a man from Netcong was arrested for the murder. He was being arrested for burglary and a subsequent search of his apartment revealed a stack of articles about the Mt. Olive murder. His fingerprints were checked against an unidentified print on the kitchen window and matched. He was arrested for the murder and is currently serving his time in prison for it. His name is Nicholas Muscio. He was a stranger to the victim. He had just been watching her through the window. He removed the screen, entered through the window, took the knife out of the sink there and stabbed her."
Great.

What have you done to verify Lewis' account?
 
Rodney, I thought Pratt was your best example. So this case involving Weber is REALLY your best example, right? You're not just going to throw more against the wall later and see if they stick are you?

I'm sorry Rodney, but according to your story, and according to Nancy Weber's website, Weber did nothing to help the police solve the crime.

We have to accept Jerry Lewis' memory after the fact that Weber gave the police the initials "N.M." According to Lewis' account that you posted, the reason he remembers the initials is because he tried to match them to the names of suspects cleared based on polygraphs. But since none of them matched, I cannot imagine why he would necessarily remember the initials. Perhaps he only "remembered" the initials after he read the murderer's name in the paper. Conveniently, we must rely on his memory since he apparently didn't write down or document the initials beforehand in any way.

Nevertheless, according to Mr. Lewis' account on Nancy Weber's own website (http://www.nancyorlenweber.com/references.html), Weber's initials nor anything else she supposedly told the police had anything whatsoever to do with the arrest or conviction of the murderer:

About nine months after the murder, police in Netcong conducted a search warrant on a burglary suspect and found a stack of newspaper articles about the murder in Mt. Olive. They checked the man's fingerprints and matched them to an unidentified fingerprint that had been lifted from the victim's kitchen window.

So, the murderer was found and convicted based on good ol' police work and hard evidence. Weber's initials didn't help one iota to find the murderer (in fact, the murderer was only caught because evidence that he was involved in the murder was found during an unrelated robbery investigation).

Unlike the hard evidence the police found that eventually convicted the murderer, they apparently kept no hard evidence of Weber's involvement. Odd, that.

Rodney, why must we always do your work for you? Is this really your best example?

-Bri
 
Rodney, I thought Pratt was your best example. So this case involving Weber is REALLY your best example, right? You're not just going to throw more against the wall later and see if they stick are you?
There are so many good examples, Bri, that I could endlessly regale you with them, but I'll stick with this one for the time being.

I'm sorry Rodney, but according to your story, and according to Nancy Weber's website, Weber did nothing to help the police solve the crime.
It may be that the police didn't take Weber seriously, but, if Lewis is correct, they should have, and that might have led to a quicker resolution of the case.

We have to accept Jerry Lewis' memory after the fact that Weber gave the police the initials "N.M." According to Lewis' account that you posted, the reason he remembers the initials is because he tried to match them to the names of suspects cleared based on polygraphs. But since none of them matched, I cannot imagine why he would necessarily remember the initials. Perhaps he only "remembered" the initials after he read the murderer's name in the paper. Conveniently, we must rely on his memory since he apparently didn't write down or document the initials beforehand in any way.
Come now, Bri, it would be unusual if he did not remember the initials after going through the names of 12 suspects.

Nevertheless, according to Mr. Lewis' account on Nancy Weber's own website (http://www.nancyorlenweber.com/references.html), Weber's initials nor anything else she supposedly told the police had anything whatsoever to do with the arrest or conviction of the murderer:

So, the murderer was found and convicted based on good ol' police work and hard evidence. Weber's initials didn't help one iota to find the murderer (in fact, the murderer was only caught because evidence that he was involved in the murder was found during an unrelated robbery investigation).

Unlike the hard evidence the police found that eventually convicted the murderer, they apparently kept no hard evidence of Weber's involvement. Odd, that.

Rodney, why must we always do your work for you? Is this really your best example?

-Bri
It's not the best example of a psychic detective assisting the police in solving a case, but it is a good example of a psychic being on the money.
 
There are so many good examples, Bri, that I could endlessly regale you with them, but I'll stick with this one for the time being.

How quickly you have begun your backpedaling dance, Rodney! Only 3 posts ago you said this was the best case you could come up with.

I predict that as this example falls flat like the others, you'll soon throw out yet another example and hope that one sticks. My record at predicting your future actions is currently 100%, and I don't even claim to be psychic. Don't disappoint us and ruin my record now, Rodney.

It may be that the police didn't take Weber seriously, but, if Lewis is correct, they should have, and that might have led to a quicker resolution of the case.

Sheer speculation on your part. It is highly unlikely that initials, even if correct, would have lead them to the murderer given that he was a total stranger.

Come now, Bri, it would be unusual if he did not remember the initials after going through the names of 12 suspects.

After how many months did he recall the initials? Please, Rodney. Maybe if one of the suspects was a match he might remember the initials, but I seriously doubt that he would have otherwise. It's possible, however, that he sincerely believes he remembered the initials after he saw the name in the paper. We'll never know, of course, since he didn't seem to have bothered to make any sort of record of it at the time.

It's not the best example of a psychic detective assisting the police in solving a case, but it is a good example of a psychic being on the money.

First, we were discussing whether or not psychics have ever helped solve crimes. As far as we know, they haven't, and this is a great example of that, thanks.

Second, what evidence do you have to support your statement that she was "on the money?" Do you have any evidence that she was correct about any prediction made before the murderer was caught whatsoever? Is there even any record made before the event occurred as to what those predictions were and when she made them? Odd how the only records of predictions of future events always seem to pop up only after the event has occurred.

Third, even if she was correct about the initials (which is highly questionable), so what? Guessing initials was completely and utterly useless to the police in this case and in almost every other case. Why should police waste their precious time and resources with psychics if psychic abilities have never been shown to have lead to the resolution of a single case?

If this is the best you've got, I think we can safely rest our case. Thanks for playing, Rodney! It's been fun!

-Bri
 
Last edited:
How quickly you have begun your backpedaling dance, Rodney! Only 3 posts ago you said this was the best case you could come up with.

I predict that as this example falls flat like the others, you'll soon throw out yet another example and hope that one sticks. My record at predicting your future actions is currently 100%, and I don't even claim to be psychic. Don't disappoint us and ruin my record now, Rodney.

Sheer speculation on your part. It is highly unlikely that initials, even if correct, would have lead them to the murderer given that he was a total stranger.

After how many months did he recall the initials? Please, Rodney. Maybe if one of the suspects was a match he might remember the initials, but I seriously doubt that he would have otherwise. It's possible, however, that he sincerely believes he remembered the initials after he saw the name in the paper. We'll never know, of course, since he didn't seem to have bothered to make any sort of record of it at the time.

First, we were discussing whether or not psychics have ever helped solve crimes. As far as we know, they haven't, and this is a great example of that, thanks.

Second, what evidence do you have to support your statement that she was "on the money?" Do you have any evidence that she was correct about any prediction made before the murderer was caught whatsoever? Is there even any record as to what those predictions were and when she made them? Odd how the only records of predictions of future events always seem to pop up only after the event has occurred.

Third, even if she was correct about the initials (which is highly questionable), so what? Guessing initials was completely and utterly useless to the police in this case and in almost every other case. Why should police waste their precious time and resources with psychics if psychic abilities have never been shown to have lead to the resolution of a single case?

If this is the best you've got, I think we can safely rest our case. Thanks for playing, Rodney! It's been fun!

-Bri
You and Garrette were resting your case at the beginning of the thread, Bri! (Yes, I can use exclamation points, too!) But consider Detective Lewis's account of this case: The police thought that the daughter was the perpetrator of her mother's murder. That seemed logical because there was no forced entry, the daughter was in the home with her mother, and the murder weapon was a knife taken from the home's kitchen. However, Nancy Weber told the police that their scenario was completely off-base. Weber said that the daughter was innocent and that the murder was committed by a stranger with the initials "NM". Since that turned out to be correct, I would say she was on the money.
 
You and Garrette were resting your case at the beginning of the thread, Bri!

Can you show me where either Garrett or I (much less both of us) rested our case at the beginning of the thread? I recall that you have been given multiple opportunities to prove your claim that psychic abilities have been used to solve crimes. You haven't even presented evidence to indicate that even one case has ever been solved as a result of the use of psychic abilities.

Your BEST example provided no evidence whatsoever to indicate that this case was solved by a psychic -- much less through psychic means. So if this is your BEST case, and you have presented your BEST evidence that Nancy Weber used psychic abilities to solve it, I think we can safely rest at this point. The fact that you continue to insist so strongly that what you've presented proves your claim tells me that it is unlikely that you have some other evidence up your sleeve that you haven't disclosed yet.

But I'm willing to wait for you to do your homework and produce the evidence that Weber used her psychic abilities to solve this case. Prove me wrong, if you think you can.

But consider Detective Lewis's account of this case...

As Garrett already pointed out: "Unofficial endorsements by individual police officers (or polygraphers) without corroborating evidence aren't anything more than a questionable starting point."

As Garrett already asked: "What have you done to verify Lewis' account?"

Do you have even a shred of evidence of what Weber actually told the police before the murderer was found -- any documentation at all that was recorded before the murderer was found -- or are you simply relying on Lewis' after-the-fact recollection of what Weber said?

Even if Weber said exactly what Lewis claimed she said before the murderer was found (which I highly doubt), by Lewis' own account Weber didn't help the police one bit to find the murderer. NOT ONE BIT!

So please tell me again, how does this case -- your BEST example, remember -- prove your claim that psychic abilities have been used to solve crimes?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Gave him a polygraph. ;)
Okay, that got a chuckle.


But I thought you were already on this case.
I'm the debunker. You want me to present your evidence before I present mine?

Actually, I wondered if you'd say something along these lines. What you are doing in asking this question in response to mine is admitting that you have no evidence other than media accounts and the uncorroborated statement of someone not officially representing a law enforcement agency and stated years after the fact without corroboration.

And that's your BEST case.

Except it's not really your best case even though you said it was your best case because when Bri pointed out it's not a good case you said it's not your best case even though when I asked for your best case you said this was your best case. Even though it's not.

So I will recap, in all seriousness now:

1. You said this Weber case is the best example of a psychic detective using psychic means to solve a case.

2. You admit you have done nothing to corroborate the claims.

3. You say it isn't really the best case after all.


ETA: Don't worry, Rodney. I actually AM on this case. I have mailed the OPRA (Official Public Records Act) Information Requests to Mount Olive.
 
Can you show me where either Garrett or I (much less both of us) rested our case at the beginning of the thread?
Okay, I was responding to your hyperbolic statement -- "If this is the best you've got, I think we can safely rest our case" -- with my own hyperbolic statement. However, you each have shown a clear bias against psychic detectives. For example, in post #51 on this thread, in response to my tongue-in-cheek question -- "Ah, so is the all-knowing Bri -- when she becomes Emperor of the Whole Wide World -- going to decree that police departments may no longer use psychics who haven't been tested?" -- you responded: "Correct, yes. And in the meantime, police departments worldwide would be wise to implement a similar standard so as not to waste the taxpayer's money and more importantly their own valuable time and resources."

Now, Garrette is a bit more subtle, but in post #77, he stated: "What it is also empty of is any demonstration that he [Norm Pratt] can do what he says he can do" -- ignoring the fact that Sgt. Bank believes that, without Pratt's involvement, the police would not have recovered a missing woman's body. Garrette also constantly uses the evil media as a strawman to attempt to discredit psychic detectives; for example, in post #146, he stated: "It is one indicator of why newspaper articles are poor sources on which to base any belief, opinion, or conclusion" -- ignoring the police officers who attest to the ability of some psychic detectives.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom