My question in post #215 on this thread was: "Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?" Your examples are not relevant to my question. In both examples -- assuming that they're accurate -- the police had suspects in custody and had no reason to undertake additional investigation.
So finding the real solution to a case that the police had mistakenly closed isn't the same.
You're wiggling, Rodney. Keep the goal posts where they are.
What I was (rather obviously) referring to were cases where the police had reached a dead end until a member of the public assisted them.
Your example:
Police stop looking because they can't find the body.
My example:
Police stop looking because they think they've found the guilty party.
First, you have not presented newspaper articles or other media accounts,
Darn straight. They don't count as reliable evidence upon which to base a conclusion.
but rather self-serving "success stories" from a private investigator.
As opposed to self-serving articles from unskeptical reporters whose editors insist on stories that will sell copy?
As opposed to the account of the polygraphist whose own expertise would be in question were he not to corroborate Nancy Weber's account?
As opposed to your examples in which you still have not taken the effort to obtain the actual case files?
Second, the media accounts that I have cited quote police officers. Are you saying that the officers' opinions of the psychics were misrepresented?
1. I'm saying it's possible.
2. I'm saying it's more likely that the officer(s) believe what they are presented as believing but that their beliefs have exactly as much credibility as the evidence which supports them. Evidence which is sorely lacking from their accounts, the newspaper articles, and your retellings.
(Bear in mind that, with respect to Nancy Weber, I e-mailed polygraph expert Jerry Lewis and he responded with a long e-mail that not only confirmed that she had been helpful in a number of cases, but added additional details regarding her accuracy.)
Yes, I was involved in that discussion (a fact which makes my earlier incorrect allegation against you all the more unforgivable; I'm still sorry about that; I should have gone back to correct my original post so that people who merely pop in and out don't read that post only and get the wrong impression.)
First, Lewis is a polygraphist. It's pseudoscience. I'm not an expert on the topic, but I'm not a stranger to it, either. I used to be a supporter of it and even directed its use in a security department I ran.
Second, while Lewis supported Weber, he also did not provide case files. His claims are interesting, but they are still unsupported claims.
Third, I wasn't idle during that conversation. I contacted Mr. English (formerly Detective Lieutenant English) about the same group of cases. He rather curtly rebuffed my questions about specifics regarding the cases.
Fourth, I think I'm the only one who attempted to contact the Mount Olive Police Department. I sent them an email requesting the relevant information, or information on how to properly obtain it. The email was never answered, nor were the phone messages I left. I should have pursued it more, but I did not. Maybe I'll start again.
Or perhaps you can do the work to find the primary source material for the case you claim proves the legitimacy of psychic detectives?