Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Now, of course, hunters and hikers may sometimes stumble upon a body, but that's hardly the same thing as someone going to the police and suggesting that they look in a location that turns out to be where the body is.
So it is conceivable that some people will accidentally find bodies and immediately provide that information to the police without claiming any powers.

It is also conceivable that some people will claim to have solved missing persons cases without actually having done so.

But it is NOT possible for someone to find a body and then provide that information to the police while falsely claiming they found the body psychically?
 
Except that the police sergeant in that case disagrees with you.

To repeat: My point is that the police may have had an incentive to suggest that Pratt used psychic abilities whether or not he actually did, and to downplay the fact that Pratt apparently searched for the body for several weeks before finding the clothing, and may not have used any psychic abilities at all.

No, because you haven't given me any cases where a non-psychic -- say, a member of this Forum ;) -- has helped the police solve a case that they could not solve on their own.

Why would it have to be a member of this forum? As you know, I did mention in my previous post that it is not uncommon for people to volunteer to go searching for a missing person after police are unable to find them, much as Pratt did but without suggesting that they are using psychic abilities to do so. These people have been far more successful at finding missing people through non-psychic means than psychics have been. So, why would you assume that Pratt, having searched for the body for several weeks before finding the clothes, was using some sort of supernatural powers?

And what was the point of your making the following statement if it wasn't true?

However, if you can show that it is not that uncommon for non-psychics to help the police solve cases, I will be more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means.

I provided two examples of people who are not psychics but help police solve cases: hunters who might stumble upon a body, and searchers who actively look for missing people. So...are you now more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means?

Now, of course, hunters and hikers may sometimes stumble upon a body, but that's hardly the same thing as someone going to the police and suggesting that they look in a location that turns out to be where the body is.

That's not what you asked. And I noticed that you focused on "hunters and hikers" as if I hadn't also mentioned people who volunteer to help search for missing people, much as Pratt did but without claiming to be using any supernatural powers. Finally, you are suggesting that Pratt went to the police and suggested that they look in a location that turned out to be where the body was, when we know that's probably not how it happened. Rather, he told police to stop looking where they had already looked, and then he went out himself and searched for the body for several weeks before coming across (stumbling upon?) the clothes.

Again...are you now more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
So it is conceivable that some people will accidentally find bodies and immediately provide that information to the police without claiming any powers.

It is also conceivable that some people will claim to have solved missing persons cases without actually having done so.

But it is NOT possible for someone to find a body and then provide that information to the police while falsely claiming they found the body psychically?
Possible, but not likely, particularly in those cases where a psychic has had success in multiple cases. Also, I would think the police would investigate to rule out that possibility. For example, if the police found unidentified footprints near a body,they would presumably check whether those footprints could have been made by the psychic or an associate.
 
Possible, but not likely, particularly in those cases where a psychic has had success in multiple cases.
Again, we have only the claims of those with a vested interest that this happens.


Also, I would think the police would investigate to rule out that possibility. For example, if the police found unidentified footprints near a body,they would presumably check whether those footprints could have been made by the psychic or an associate.
Uh huh. No person wanting to create a false psychic success story would ever think of that. And we know it is impossible to eliminate footprints around a body because the footprints of the murderers are always always always there.
 
To repeat: My point is that the police may have had an incentive to suggest that Pratt used psychic abilities whether or not he actually did, and to downplay the fact that Pratt apparently searched for the body for several weeks before finding the clothing, and may not have used any psychic abilities at all.

Why would it have to be a member of this forum? As you know, I did mention in my previous post that it is not uncommon for people to volunteer to go searching for a missing person after police are unable to find them, much as Pratt did but without suggesting that they are using psychic abilities to do so. These people have been far more successful at finding missing people through non-psychic means than psychics have been. So, why would you assume that Pratt, having searched for the body for several weeks before finding the clothes, was using some sort of supernatural powers?

And what was the point of your making the following statement if it wasn't true?

I provided two examples of people who are not psychics but help police solve cases: hunters who might stumble upon a body, and searchers who actively look for missing people. So...are you now more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means?

That's not what you asked. And I noticed that you focused on "hunters and hikers" as if I hadn't also mentioned people who volunteer to help search for missing people, much as Pratt did but without claiming to be using any supernatural powers. Finally, you are suggesting that Pratt went to the police and suggested that they look in a location that turned out to be where the body was, when we know that's probably not how it happened. Rather, he told police to stop looking where they had already looked, and then he went out himself and searched for the body for several weeks before coming across (stumbling upon?) the clothes.

Again...are you now more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means?

-Bri
Sorry, Bri, but your examples aren't relevant to what I'm talking about. Of course, searchers can find bodies, just as hunters and hikers can. However, the relevant question is, are there examples of non-psychics going to the police and pointing them in a different direction, which proves to be the correct direction? You still haven't cited any such examples of that happening. Rather, you speculate that, any time a psychic assists the police, it must be through non-psychic means. And bear in mind that we're not talking only about Norm Pratt or missing person cases. For example, check out the link I provided for Nancy Weber. You will find that polygraph expert Jerry Lewis states about one case:

"I remember one day that a detective told me they had talked to a psychic and she had given the initials of the murderer; 'NM'. I remember going through the list of people we were testing to see if any of them matched. We cleared everyone we tested. About nine months after the murder, police in Netcong conducted a search warrant on a burglary suspect and found a stack of newspaper articles about the murder in Mt. Olive. They checked the man's fingerprints and matched them to an unidentified fingerprint that had been lifted from the victim's kitchen window. His name was Nicholas Muscio and he was found guilty of the murders."

I e-mailed Mr. Lewis about this case and he verified the on-line account. So, how do you suppose Nancy Weber came up with the initials "NM"?
 
Again, we have only the claims of those with a vested interest that this happens.
Only if you assume that all of the police officers who support the psychics' accounts have vested interests.

Uh huh. No person wanting to create a false psychic success story would ever think of that. And we know it is impossible to eliminate footprints around a body because the footprints of the murderers are always always always there.
I'm simply saying that, if the police find a body based on information from an alleged psychic, they don't take for granted that the information was obtained paranormally. In fact, as has been suggested on this thread, providing accurate information about the location of a body may make the provider a murder suspect.
 
Only if you assume that all of the police officers who support the psychics' accounts have vested interests.
Until they show the actual case records, it's a reasonable assumption.

Separate that, it isn't necessary. The psychics have vested interest.


I'm simply saying that, if the police find a body based on information from an alleged psychic, they don't take for granted that the information was obtained paranormally. In fact, as has been suggested on this thread, providing accurate information about the location of a body may make the provider a murder suspect.
Show get the case file to show that the psychic's involvement was checked out.
 
Btw, it didn't take long to google this example of non-police people solving cases. Read the second one for them finding out what the police could not.

Read the third one for them showing that the police were holding the wrong person and pointing them to the right person.
 
Read this recent story about law enforcment asking the public for help.

This happens all the time in the US. Now why would the police keep asking the public for help if it never yielded results?
 
Sorry, Bri, but your examples aren't relevant to what I'm talking about.

I can only answer the questions you ask. Of course, I'm not surprised that you don't find the answers relevant given the irrelevancy of the questions. Still, you said that if I can show that it is not that uncommon for non-psychics to help the police solve cases, you would be more receptive to the notion that the psychics actually solved the cases in which they were involved by non-psychic means.

Of course, searchers can find bodies, just as hunters and hikers can. However, the relevant question is, are there examples of non-psychics going to the police and pointing them in a different direction, which proves to be the correct direction?

Did Pratt point the police in the correct direction? I don't think so. He told the police not to keep searching where they already searched. That's it. Then, he searched for the body himself. Seems pretty similar to how a searcher finds a body, except that most searchers don't claim to be doing anything supernatural.

Rather, you speculate that, any time a psychic assists the police, it must be through non-psychic means.

Yes, of course. Without solid evidence to the contrary, I would naturally assume that any psychic who assisted the police probably did it like everyone else who assists the police. I see no reason to assume that Pratt used psychic powers to search for the body given that the evidence seems to indicate otherwise. Of course, I can't prove that he wasn't using supernatural powers during the search, but if so his powers seem to be pretty mundane given that these powers didn't help him to do anything better or different than any other searcher.

And bear in mind that we're not talking only about Norm Pratt or missing person cases.

This conversation is a lot like tossing Play-Doh at a wall. If one example falls, you just keep throwing out another one until something sticks. Rodney, you still don't seem to get it.

Unless you provide evidence that Pratt or anyone else has used psychic powers to solve a crime, I will assume the more likely explanation that they didn't use psychic powers. A statement from a police officer probably won't convince me given the fact that the police officer might very well have reason to downplay more probable but more mundane explanations.

-Bri
 
Btw, it didn't take long to google this example of non-police people solving cases. Read the second one for them finding out what the police could not.

Read the third one for them showing that the police were holding the wrong person and pointing them to the right person.
Uh, Garrette, I thought you were a skeptic? How, exactly, do the two below anecdotes prove anything, when no names are given (other than the name of one attorney)? And the anecdotes aren't on-point anyway. In the first anecdote, a guilty man is alleged to have received a lighter sentence because investigators found the "main actor"; and, in the second anecdote, a woman who shot her husband is alleged to have been released after investigators found a witness who claimed that the shooting was accidental. It's not the job of the police to establish that there may have been extenuating circumstances for those accused of crimes -- that's the job of defense attorneys. And the second anecdote makes little sense to begin with, since it appears that all the woman had to do was tell the police that there was a witness to the shooting. Why she would remain silent and serve two months in jail rather than do that is beyond me. Unless, of course, the anecdote isn't accurate.

Anecdote 1:
SAVED A DEFENDANT 7-YEARS ON HIS SENTENCE: Attorney Feroz Merchant asked us to help him with a federal case he was working. The Defendant admitted his part in the crime a little too late. All the Co-Defendant’s made deals and there was nothing left to bargain with except turning on the main actor. Problem was, no one knew his real name. He went by several street names. The A.U.S.A. offered a 5K1.1 reduction in sentence if our Client could ID the main actor. After interviewing him, we took all the info he could muster up and ran with it. We followed a lot of leads, and rabbit trails but in the end it paid off. We positively identified the main person and turned over a photograph with identifiers to the Federal Agent working the case.

Anecdote 2:
What Happens When You Invoke Your Right to Remain Silent and Wait For Your Attorney? Generally, the Police think you are guilty, put you in jail and the file greatest charge possible. That is what happened to an elderly woman who accidentally shot and killed her husband. She did her grieving in jail for two months and was not allowed to attend the funeral. We interviewed (and taped) the only witness, who was also an elderly man in poor health. He had loaned her husband his revolver with a “hair trigger”, to go to the shooting range. He described the shooting as clearly accidental. On the night before he was to testify before the Grand Jury, he had a heart attack and was taken to the hospital. The DA allowed the videotape to be played and she was No Billed and released.
 
Rodney, the US legal system requires the law to prove a person's guilt, not for the person to prove their innocence. If the police found that their charges were incorrect, it was very much their job to amend them.
 
Rodney, the US legal system requires the law to prove a person's guilt, not for the person to prove their innocence. If the police found that their charges were incorrect, it was very much their job to amend them.
I understand, but in the first anecdote, the person WAS guilty; and, in the second anecdote, the accused apparently did not tell the police that there was a witness who could exonerate her.
 
Uh, Garrette, I thought you were a skeptic?
Thanks you. I am.


Rodney said:
How, exactly, do the two below anecdotes prove anything,
Prove anything? They don't.

In exactly the same fashion that your newspaper articles don't prove anything. You can't have it both ways, Rodney.


Rodney said:
when no names are given (other than the name of one attorney)?
When no specifics are given? When the article doesn't say that Pratt told the police where the body is? When there are no case notes shown?


Rodney said:
And the anecdotes aren't on-point anyway.
Hold on thar, Rodney! Them thar goalposts ain't meant fer movin'.

You said it should be easy to find examples of the non-psychic public solving crimes the police could not. These do that.


Rodney said:
In the first anecdote, a guilty man is alleged to have received a lighter sentence because investigators found the "main actor";
Yup. The police didn't find the person who actually did it. The non-psychic agency did.


Rodney said:
and, in the second anecdote, a woman who shot her husband is alleged to have been released after investigators found a witness who claimed that the shooting was accidental. It's not the job of the police to establish that there may have been extenuating circumstances for those accused of crimes -- that's the job of defense attorneys.
It's not the job of the police to determine the circumstances of the event in question? Stuff and nonsense.

Regardless, it's still the non-psychic public who found it out. Not the police. Not the DA. Not a psychic.


Rodney said:
And the second anecdote makes little sense to begin with, since it appears that all the woman had to do was tell the police that there was a witness to the shooting. Why she would remain silent and serve two months in jail rather than do that is beyond me. Unless, of course, the anecdote isn't accurate.
What? Heaven forfend! Are you suggesting that one cannot take at face value the veracity of an unverified account?

Why, Rodney! This is an epiphany for me. Here I was ready to believe those newspaper articles about psychics. Now I know better.

And so do you.
 
You said it should be easy to find examples of the non-psychic public solving crimes the police could not. These do that.
My question in post #215 on this thread was: "Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?" Your examples are not relevant to my question. In both examples -- assuming that they're accurate -- the police had suspects in custody and had no reason to undertake additional investigation. What I was (rather obviously) referring to were cases where the police had reached a dead end until a member of the public assisted them.

What? Heaven forfend! Are you suggesting that one cannot take at face value the veracity of an unverified account?

Why, Rodney! This is an epiphany for me. Here I was ready to believe those newspaper articles about psychics. Now I know better.

And so do you.
First, you have not presented newspaper articles or other media accounts, but rather self-serving "success stories" from a private investigator. Second, the media accounts that I have cited quote police officers. Are you saying that the officers' opinions of the psychics were misrepresented? (Bear in mind that, with respect to Nancy Weber, I e-mailed polygraph expert Jerry Lewis and he responded with a long e-mail that not only confirmed that she had been helpful in a number of cases, but added additional details regarding her accuracy.)
 
My question in post #215 on this thread was: "Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?" Your examples are not relevant to my question. In both examples -- assuming that they're accurate -- the police had suspects in custody and had no reason to undertake additional investigation.

Except for the annoying little fact that the police didn't actually have the main suspect in custody in one of the cases, and had incorrectly charged the woman in the second one. Either way, both stories meet your initial criteria: "Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?" Oh wait -- we were supposed to read your mind and assume you meant this instead:

What I was (rather obviously) referring to were cases where the police had reached a dead end until a member of the public assisted them.

Oh, but wait again -- both of my examples did meet these amended criteria. That explains why you've simply ignored them rather than addressing them or admitting that Pratt could have used non-psychic means to aid the police. Of course, I suspect that instead of admitting anything, you'll either change the criteria again or just continue to ignore the examples.

First, you have not presented newspaper articles or other media accounts, but rather self-serving "success stories" from a private investigator. Second, the media accounts that I have cited quote police officers. Are you saying that the officers' opinions of the psychics were misrepresented? (Bear in mind that, with respect to Nancy Weber, I e-mailed polygraph expert Jerry Lewis and he responded with a long e-mail that not only confirmed that she had been helpful in a number of cases, but added additional details regarding her accuracy.)

I believe that Garrette was saying that the police officer's statements were possibly self-serving -- the same criteria you use to dismiss the private investigator's statements. Or would you be more apt to believe a private investigator's self-serving statements as long as they're accurately quoted in a newspaper article?

-Bri
 
My question in post #215 on this thread was: "Can you cite any instance where a member of the public -- without the use of any psychic abilities whatsoever -- solved a case the police could not solve?" Your examples are not relevant to my question. In both examples -- assuming that they're accurate -- the police had suspects in custody and had no reason to undertake additional investigation.
So finding the real solution to a case that the police had mistakenly closed isn't the same.

You're wiggling, Rodney. Keep the goal posts where they are.


What I was (rather obviously) referring to were cases where the police had reached a dead end until a member of the public assisted them.
Your example: Police stop looking because they can't find the body.

My example: Police stop looking because they think they've found the guilty party.


First, you have not presented newspaper articles or other media accounts,
Darn straight. They don't count as reliable evidence upon which to base a conclusion.


but rather self-serving "success stories" from a private investigator.
As opposed to self-serving articles from unskeptical reporters whose editors insist on stories that will sell copy?

As opposed to the account of the polygraphist whose own expertise would be in question were he not to corroborate Nancy Weber's account?

As opposed to your examples in which you still have not taken the effort to obtain the actual case files?


Second, the media accounts that I have cited quote police officers. Are you saying that the officers' opinions of the psychics were misrepresented?
1. I'm saying it's possible.

2. I'm saying it's more likely that the officer(s) believe what they are presented as believing but that their beliefs have exactly as much credibility as the evidence which supports them. Evidence which is sorely lacking from their accounts, the newspaper articles, and your retellings.


(Bear in mind that, with respect to Nancy Weber, I e-mailed polygraph expert Jerry Lewis and he responded with a long e-mail that not only confirmed that she had been helpful in a number of cases, but added additional details regarding her accuracy.)
Yes, I was involved in that discussion (a fact which makes my earlier incorrect allegation against you all the more unforgivable; I'm still sorry about that; I should have gone back to correct my original post so that people who merely pop in and out don't read that post only and get the wrong impression.)

First, Lewis is a polygraphist. It's pseudoscience. I'm not an expert on the topic, but I'm not a stranger to it, either. I used to be a supporter of it and even directed its use in a security department I ran.

Second, while Lewis supported Weber, he also did not provide case files. His claims are interesting, but they are still unsupported claims.

Third, I wasn't idle during that conversation. I contacted Mr. English (formerly Detective Lieutenant English) about the same group of cases. He rather curtly rebuffed my questions about specifics regarding the cases.

Fourth, I think I'm the only one who attempted to contact the Mount Olive Police Department. I sent them an email requesting the relevant information, or information on how to properly obtain it. The email was never answered, nor were the phone messages I left. I should have pursued it more, but I did not. Maybe I'll start again.

Or perhaps you can do the work to find the primary source material for the case you claim proves the legitimacy of psychic detectives?
 
There. I've emailed Lieutenant Aagens of the Records Division in the Mount Olive Police Department, again.

If I get no response this week, I will call again.
 
As opposed to self-serving articles from unskeptical reporters whose editors insist on stories that will sell copy?

Additionally, as long as the officer's words are quoted and cited accurately as in "Officer X said Y," the reporter is under no obligation to confirm whether "Y" represents the truth or not.

Which is why I ask Rodney why he would be more apt to believe a self-serving testimony if it is quoted verbatim in a newspaper instead of directly from the person.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I don't see the difficulty in testing one of these 'psychics' or at least them testing themselves. And a lower than 30% hit rate doesn't matter at al.

It doesn't matter how many times they go off into the woods or wherever, and use whatever psychic method they use.
If they go off 60 times and then stumble across one missing person (alive or dead) then they can approach the police and they have found a missing person. Wow! That would be headline news to start with.
That would be great and impressive, (although not overwhelmingly so in terms of psychic ability - they could have done it by luck, research etc.)

If someone managed to do this three times (doesn't matter how many wild goose chases they go on) I would be at the front requesting further study of this phenomenon.

Just three times. That's all I ask any psychic to perform this feat. Percentages are irrelevant.

Of all the thousands of missing persons, some must be locatable to someone with any real paranormal ability whatsoever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom