New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

While I see a lot of rank-and-file bickering over this issue, with quite a few teabaggers denying that there's any racism at all in their numbers, I don't see a problem with denial at a leadership level.

They are talking about it, they are denouncing it, they are taking actions when documented incidents occur.

I mean, really, what more do you want them to do? Specifically, what is it that you want them to do right now?

Firstly, it is hard to talk about tea party leaders because there are hundreds of them spread all over the country. They say they are a unified group who all want the same thing, but they are obviously not. The same 'no true teabagger' arguments used as a defense against racist seeming talk by form 'leaders' can be turned to the denouncements as well.

Secondly, I am talking about the rank and file. They are the ones who need to recognize there is a problem. Obviously this can't become their main focus (let them fight over what exactly that is apart from abstract statements like 'return to the Constitution'), but as long as I keep hearing from Tea Partiers that 'there aren't any racists' I'm going to point out that yes, there are in fact racists. Racists are drawn to that movement particularly if for no other reason than Obama is black. If it were Hillary this wouldn't be the issue, but there would likely still be a Tea Party.

What do I want them to do? Recognize that they don't all have the same interests to the point where perhaps they are several different groups or become an actual political party. In the US at least, major parties have to build coalition within the party, and that is why the platforms seem so scattered.

Also, it would be nice if the calling everything they don't like 'socialist' and 'un-American' would stop. Seriously, that's a much bigger grip for me personally than any of the race issues. Not as big as my disagreeing with the vast majority of their 'positions' but still big.
 
I find it ironic that a forum full of people who refer to themselves as skeptics has a significant number of posters who find it usefull to play along in a giant ad-hominem attack against an entire political movement.

Most on this forum see the Tea Party people as New American Fascists.
 
Noam Chomsky on the Tea Party Protests:

"It's easy to ridicule them [...] A lot of what they're protesting is pretty sensible. I mean a lot of the protests, for example, are against the bail out. [...] Why should the bankers end up from the recession more powerful than they were before? Which is what's happening. [...] These people have real grievances."

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2zYaKXeyXE
 
True, true, but as G. B. Shaw said, he's not responsible for every idiot who agrees with him about something.
 
Anyone who looks at Obama's personal history and actions and political philosophy will find an accusation of "socialist" to be patently laughable.

For me, this is a stundie.
 
I am talking about the rank and file. They are the ones who need to recognize there is a problem. Obviously this can't become their main focus (let them fight over what exactly that is apart from abstract statements like 'return to the Constitution'), but as long as I keep hearing from Tea Partiers that 'there aren't any racists' I'm going to point out that yes, there are in fact racists.

Well, good luck with that crusade and say hello to Sancho Panza for me. ;)

I can't kid you too much about that, tho, b/c I'm with you there. Sure, when confronted with complete denial of any racist element within the TP movement, we do need to point out that obviously there are some racists who are attracted to the TP movement and attend their events.

But from what I've seen, those discussions quickly degenerate into a battle of the straw men.

What do I want them to do? Recognize that they don't all have the same interests to the point where perhaps they are several different groups or become an actual political party. In the US at least, major parties have to build coalition within the party, and that is why the platforms seem so scattered.

In my experience, plenty of them do recognize that they are not a philosophically unified group, and are quick to tell you that.

But they will also tell you -- correctly -- that the set of core principles shared by most of these overlapping groups are the same. Particularly, lower taxes, more limited government (whatever they may imagine that to mean), and preventing this imaginary socialism they're so afraid of.


Also, it would be nice if the calling everything they don't like 'socialist' and 'un-American' would stop.

And if frogs had wings they wouldn't bump their butts....

I'm afraid you're not going to get your wish there. It's that very meme which gave birth to their entire shabby parade. If it goes, the whole thing falls apart, or morphs into something different.
 
If the Tea Party people are a bunch of racists, why are issues such as immigration and affirmative action never discussed at their rallies?
 
If the Tea Party people are a bunch of racists, why are issues such as immigration and affirmative action never discussed at their rallies?

They aren't? I can't say anything about affirmative action, but immigration was specifically talked about at the last two local rallies.
 
My point is that you'll find such contradictions in all platforms, so I find it hard to criticize the Tea Baggers for having an incoherent platform.

Not that I don’t agree that pretty much every political organization has some degree of incoherence in their platform, but I would be genuinely curious to see examples that rival some of the blatant contradictions of the Tea Party.

Their two most significant concerns, smaller government and fiscal responsibility, were philosophies practically non-existent during the Bush administration. And yet we had no Tea Parties before Obama took office. Furthermore, (and not at all surprising considering they Tea Party is overwhelming conservative) the majority of them view Bush favorably. So not only did they not blame Bush during his presidency for the things they now criticize Obama for, but they don’t seem to really hold him responsible now.

I don’t think of this as merely finding some minor contradictions in the Tea Party philosophy because I’m looking hard enough for them. I honestly can’t think of a single thing that they purport to stand for that isn’t completely hypocritical or contradictory.


It's not that the platform is necessarily any less coherent than anyone else's, it's the whole righteous anger thing, and their feeling that the country is somehow "theirs" to "take back".

I definitely agree with that second part. Which goes back to my earlier characterization of the Tea Party as self-entitled. Everything I observe from them seems to be tantamount to a child having a tantrum after having its toys taken away.

Certainly you describe a core faction of the Tea Party movement, but I would say you're still painting with a bit of a broad brush, there.
I read an interesting article recently, on CCN.com of all places, from reporters who spent some time traveling around to Tea Party rallies, and they reported that they saw much more demographic variety at those events than the stereotypical teabagger image would suggest.

This may be true, but also anecdotal. I don’t doubt that the Tea Party attracts all sorts of demographics (in whatever small percentages), but the polling data indicates they are overwhelmingly white, middle-aged conservatives and hold the beliefs one would expect from white, middle-aged conservatives.

It could be argued that to describe all Tea Partiers as white, middle-aged conservatives is over-generalizing. But then again there are homosexuals in the Republican Party, and I don’t think anyone would describe the Republican Party as gay-friendly.

Unfortunately for the outliers, any large organization is going to be defined by their most prominent members.

And sadly, it seems to me that contemporary conservatism has largely abandoned the principle of caution and gradual, considered change. It's become much more reactionary, in the style of Bill O'Reilly, focusing instead on recapturing some Mayberry America that never really existed.
And now, the belief in that mythic America, coupled with a loss of political power which they had come to believe was their (often literally) divine right, combined with the Murdoch-style right wing media chorus denouncing the Democratic party as America-haters, has transformed that fervor into genuine fear. Which means that some of them are becoming downright revolutionary.

Again, we are in agreement.

And sure, there's a lot of ignorance there. But I saw the same sort of ignorance among the "No Blood for Oil" crowd and the Move-on-istas. So I'm not convinced there's anything special about the teabaggers on that point.

It’s that special brand of ignorant self-entitlement in demanding society and the world be made to exactly reflect their sensibilities and no one else’s, and their pretensions of embodying the core of American values.

You made an excellent point about the desire for a mythical “Mayberry America”. People can disagree about abortion, war, and immigration, but when one side of the debate makes it an all out culture war with the ultimate goal to being the complete and total imposition of their outdated value system, then reasonable debate has come to an end.

And yes, there is similar rhetoric from the Left. But that’s the extreme Left. The disconcerting thing about the Tea Party, and the conservative movement they represent, is that their extremist conservative viewpoints seem to have become mainstream conservative viewpoints.

And let me ask you, were the anti-war protesters under Bush really coherent? Did they have any plan? Did they take time to consider the logistics, the consequences, the trade-offs, and what loss of life might have occurred if they got what they wanted? I don't think so. I think, like the teabaggers, they were just angry at something they saw happening.

I have to disagree. The anti-war protesters were quite clear in their motivations. They didn’t like the war. Period. Whether or not this was a naïve or wrong-headed point of view doesn’t take away from that clear line of thought.

Now, you could make the same argument about the Tea Party regarding government spending, but then you run into the inconvenient fact of them not becoming deficit hawks until Obama was in office. Or the fact that they want government programs cut unless they’re government programs from which they happen to benefit.


It's like saying that just because you show no signs of being a child molester doesn't mean you're not one.

Absence of overt racism is absence of overt racism, nothing more.

Sure, maybe there's more racism under the surface than meets the eye -- and the Stanford study indicates that there is -- but it doesn't get us anywhere to observe that a group might have view X even though they don't say it, because you could just as easily counter that they might not, and that's where it stands.

Don’t get me wrong. I’m not making any claims about racist views of the Tea Party as a whole. I’m basically just saying what you are: We don’t really know. And the fact that they claim to not be racist isn’t necessarily proof that they aren’t racist.

No no, you can't walk away from this one, b/c you've said you think they ought to police themselves better. If you can't think of a way that's actually possible, then you're talking nonsense.
I think they ought to police themselves better if they want to shed their racist image. Whether they do or not, or how they do it, is no concern of mine.

In each example you've given, some obscure figure makes racist remarks, and all the prominent state and national figures disavow it, as does the group.

Yet despite this, you continue to cite these incidents as evidence that there's a problem with the group.

That doesn't add up.

I don’t know how “obscure” these people were (one of them was a viable candidate for New York governor), but it begs the question: At what point do you begin to hold an organization accountable for the behavior of its members?

In the interest of fairness, I’ve already given a pass to the scores of random wingnut rally attendees. How much more of a pass do I need to give them? At what sufficiently high enough rank within the organization must someone be before their behavior reflects on the organization as a whole? And how many such incidents must occur before they reflect on the organization as a whole?

Just because they disavow these people and their behavior after the fact doesn’t address the issue of what they were doing there in the first place.
 
Last edited:
I don’t doubt that the Tea Party attracts all sorts of demographics (in whatever small percentages), but the polling data indicates they are overwhelmingly white, middle-aged conservatives and hold the beliefs one would expect from white, middle-aged conservatives.

I just read today that they're 81% white. The country is 75% white. So they're 8% whiter than the nation as a whole.

That's not really a huge difference there.
 
The disconcerting thing about the Tea Party, and the conservative movement they represent, is that their extremist conservative viewpoints seem to have become mainstream conservative viewpoints.

I do not believe this is true.

What happened is that the 2008 campaign, especially the Palin nomination and rallies, caused middle-of-the-road conservatives to abandon the GOP.

And after the election, the far right fringe (tho not the extreme right fringe, which has always been outside the party system) gathered around the Tea Party banner.

So what's happened is that the GOP and the TP have become extremist.

That's not the same as saying that conservatives have become extremist, because right now most of us are not affiliated with either of those groups.

ETA: The numbers back me up here, btw. Last time I posted on this topic, only 21% of voters self-identified as Republicans, and the number of self-identifying Democrats declined slightly after the election, which means that those who abandoned the GOP did not become Democrats, they became independents.
 
Last edited:
I have to disagree. The anti-war protesters were quite clear in their motivations. They didn’t like the war. Period. Whether or not this was a naïve or wrong-headed point of view doesn’t take away from that clear line of thought.

Now, you could make the same argument about the Tea Party regarding government spending, but then you run into the inconvenient fact of them not becoming deficit hawks until Obama was in office. Or the fact that they want government programs cut unless they’re government programs from which they happen to benefit.

Well, your first paragraph there doesn't make sense to me. It sounds like you're saying what I'm saying -- they were simply angry at the war and wanted it to end immediately, without thinking through the issue of whether or not that was possible or would actually save lives.

As for there being no right-wing opposition to Bush spending, that's simply a myth. Ever read a George Will column, for instance?

And I hate to burst your bubble, but people of every stripe suffer from the syndrome of wanting gov't programs cut except the ones they benefit from. The "wasteful spending" is always happening somewhere else.
 
I don’t know how “obscure” these people were (one of them was a viable candidate for New York governor), but it begs the question: At what point do you begin to hold an organization accountable for the behavior of its members?

In the interest of fairness, I’ve already given a pass to the scores of random wingnut rally attendees. How much more of a pass do I need to give them? At what sufficiently high enough rank within the organization must someone be before their behavior reflects on the organization as a whole? And how many such incidents must occur before they reflect on the organization as a whole?

Just because they disavow these people and their behavior after the fact doesn’t address the issue of what they were doing there in the first place.

You can't disavow behavior before the fact.

That's all there is to it.

And you can't stop nut jobs from freely associating with an open organization, or attending open events.

But I simply cannot understand how you can claim that these incidents reflect badly on the group, given the fact that in each case the group publicly disavowed the behavior and/or statements and took steps against it (e.g., ejecting the offending party, cancelling speaking engagements, etc.).

These guys can't win with you, no matter what they do.

That said, there are valid studies indicating that there is indeed a racist element within the Tea Party, but that is bound to happen since the TP is opposed to the Obama administration, and so are anti-black racists, so of course they are going to gravitate toward that group.

The question, then, is: What is the group going to do about that.

From what we've seen here, they are doing something about it, by speaking up and by taking action against those who act on their racist ideas.

Asking them to somehow proactively vet everyone in the organization and make judgments about their level of racism and kick out the ones who don't pass the bar -- that's simply impossible.
 
I just read today that they're 81% white. The country is 75% white.

I read that 81.2% of americans are jewish too. :rolleyes:

Where did you read that they are 81% white? Why did you believe them? Why is it that it's rare to see any non-white person at a tea party? Why do tea party people have racists signs? Why are leaders of the tea party saying racist things?
 
Last edited:
I read that 81.2% of americans are jewish too. :rolleyes:

Where did you read that they are 81% white? Why did you believe them? Why is it that it's rare to see any non-white person at a tea party? Why do tea party people have racists signs? Why are leaders of the tea party saying racist things?

The survey was done by ABC / Washington Post, released May 5th. I believed them because they are reputable news outlets with no motivation that I know of to risk their reputations by fudging data on this particular question.

Got any contrary evidence to that number, besides your little roll-eye guy?

How many Tea Party events do you attend every month, so that you know how "rare" it is to see non-white persons there? More than the CNN reporters who stated last month, after going to quite a few of them, that there's more minority attendance than is popularly believed?

Would you care to cite these racist quotations from Tea Party "leaders" -- along with the reaction of others within the movement to what they said?

As for the racist signs, how common are they at Tea Party events -- i.e., what percentage of attendees carry them -- and what is the response of the majority of teabaggers to them?

Now, here's some more data from the survey (as reported by CNN) which may be a little more illuminating than your idle speculation:

87-percent of Tea Party supporters said that racism does not play a part in the movement's opposition to the president's policies. A small number, one in 10, said that anger at having an African-American president is a reason to support the Tea Party movement.

While a vast majority of the movement's supporters questioned in the poll deny that prejudice is at play, the survey suggests that the Tea Party may have a tough time convincing its critics.

According to the poll, 57-percent of Tea Party opponents believe that racism is fueling the movement. Meanwhile, 24-percent of Americans who have a neutral view of Tea Parties also feel that racism is a factor.

The poll also delves into a long-debated question: is racism still a major problem in America? Overall, 75-percent of people questioned believe it is, but that belief drops to 61 percent among conservative voters and 58 percent among Tea Party supporters.
 
Last edited:
I think they ought to police themselves better if they want to shed their racist image. Whether they do or not, or how they do it, is no concern of mine.

Why should they police freedom of expression? If someone wants to go to a protest and express offensive views in a nonviolent manner, that is their right. The error lies with those who use such incidents to generalize, not with the tea party for not "policing themselves better".

In the interest of fairness, I’ve already given a pass to the scores of random wingnut rally attendees. How much more of a pass do I need to give them? At what sufficiently high enough rank within the organization must someone be before their behavior reflects on the organization as a whole? And how many such incidents must occur before they reflect on the organization as a whole?

Do you think Reverend Wright's views reflected his church as a whole, thus proving Obama is really an America hating racist, as some conservatives argued incessantly during the election? This strikes me as the same kind of guilt by association / mudslinging politics that I've seen used against Obama (including by some Tea Partiers -- ironic, I guess).
 
Their two most significant concerns, smaller government and fiscal responsibility, were philosophies practically non-existent during the Bush administration.

How do you know that?

And yet we had no Tea Parties before Obama took office.

I think that says more about Glenn Beck than the people who chose to attend Tea Party protests. Sure, some of them are hypocrites or just uninformed partisan followers.

It could be argued that to describe all Tea Partiers as white, middle-aged conservatives is over-generalizing. But then again there are homosexuals in the Republican Party, and I don’t think anyone would describe the Republican Party as gay-friendly.

Are you saying white middle-aged conservatives can be fairly branded as racists? Sorry if I'm misreading you there, I'm just not seeing the point.
 
Remember the bail outs started near the end of the Bush administration. Most conservatives I know were against them under both Bush and Obama.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom