New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

Without Rights, I have been through this thread a few times, and don't see "one guy" in any of the studies referenced. Could you please enlighten me where you are finding this "one guy" you talk about?

Thanks! :)
 
Yeah, now they get to claim 10% of tea partiers everywhere are racist, and your bias won't let you see that as a sham. Anyway, it is not a stretch to think that their opinion (like your's) is the product of media slander and sensationalism.

This poll is only evidence that the media is slanderous. Why would one answer from one person be such big news and why would they claim that 10% are racist across the country like it is a big ah-ha moment when they knew the 13% of the group equaled one person. Is that one guy that important? Is he the guy from the Dos Equis commercial? Or maybe he is Chuck Norris?

First, it wasn't big news. It was a short item on the ticker.

But again, here's your error: You're ignoring the original sample size, which was large enough to make the study valid.

If I use valid methodologies, and a sample size of 1,000+, and I find that 90 percent of the population eats ice cream, and 10 percent do not, and that 90 percent of folks who don't eat ice cream are lactose intolerant, while only 10 percent are not lactose intolerant, then it's entirely acceptable to report that the poll found that about 10% of people who don't eat ice cream are not lactose intolerant.

It would make no sense to object to that survey on the grounds that only 10 respondents fell into that last group.

But in cases where you have small subgroups like that, it's always a good idea to try to follow up with a group-only survey which also has a large sample size.

What's not a good idea is to simply claim that this poll just happened to find the one nutjob.
 
First, it wasn't big news. It was a short item on the ticker.

But again, here's your error: You're ignoring the original sample size, which was large enough to make the study valid.

If I use valid methodologies, and a sample size of 1,000+, and I find that 90 percent of the population eats ice cream, and 10 percent do not, and that 90 percent of folks who don't eat ice cream are lactose intolerant, while only 10 percent are not lactose intolerant, then it's entirely acceptable to report that the poll found that about 10% of people who don't eat ice cream are not lactose intolerant.

It would make no sense to object to that survey on the grounds that only 10 respondents fell into that last group.

But in cases where you have small subgroups like that, it's always a good idea to try to follow up with a group-only survey which also has a large sample size.

What's not a good idea is to simply claim that this poll just happened to find the one nutjob.

I agree with most of your posts in the thread, but not this one.

With polling statistics what we should be concerned with (validity-wise) are confidence intervals. If 8 Tea Party members were polled and within that group 1 was found to be racist, it becomes irrelevant that the those 8 were a subset of a sample of 1000 people. All we can say with 95% confidence is something like: somewhere between 0.1% and 49.2% of Tea Party members in the population are motivated by anger at having a black President.

That is a huge margin of error, and the statistic shouldn't have been reported without mentioning that. However, I doubt it was intentional. Blunders in the use of statistics are so common even in scientific articles that it never surprises me at all to see them in journalism anymore.
 
Btw, your ice cream example would be a lot more valid since it would amount to 100 person sample with about a 5% margin of error.
 
I agree with most of your posts in the thread, but not this one.

With polling statistics what we should be concerned with (validity-wise) are confidence intervals. If 8 Tea Party members were polled and within that group 1 was found to be racist, it becomes irrelevant that the those 8 were a subset of a sample of 1000 people. All we can say with 95% confidence is something like: somewhere between 0.1% and 49.2% of Tea Party members in the population are motivated by anger at having a black President.

That is a huge margin of error, and the statistic shouldn't have been reported without mentioning that. However, I doubt it was intentional. Blunders in the use of statistics are so common even in scientific articles that it never surprises me at all to see them in journalism anymore.

Thanks for the correction.

I deal w/ stats at work, but in a very narrow way. All the polls are the same, so I can simply apply the formula to find the confidence level and leave it at that.

We don't do anything as complex as that poll.
 
1
Grizzly Bear: Leaders cannot control or police who joins these protests en mass. You cannot realistically expect a movement to be capable to eliminating fringe elements from acting on their own. What I would be more worried about, is if this radical racial sentiment began to contaminate the principals goals of the movement, something which I've yet to see.

Here's an example of what sound leadership can effect: California Agricultural Labor Relations Act. I use this example because it has to do with livelihood [what the TP claims it is about] as opposed to race. As for the contaminating bit, from what I can tell, that happened last summer [at the latest]. You gotta wonder when folks with medicare are holding a "no socialism" sign in one hand and a bone-nosed Obama sign in the other.

2
Grizzly Bear:
...The mainstream media largely doesn't provide any attention to the movement and what bit it does usually seems to deal just with these kooks...

... this has happened already, several times, whether they believed the events took place or not. If this isn't satisfactory then you need to express what is. I've had this discussion with several people already here, and none of them have been clear on their expectations.

Bit of a contradiction there.


3
I said: I then took it a step further in examining the mum nature of the so-called "non-racist majority" of the teabaggers, the "non-fringers." Why don't they speak out against the fringe, boot them out, and take control of the Tea Party [if indeed they are truly are the majority?]
then you said: The figures have been consistent since before the Clinton Administration, if not longer. The current state of affairs wrt to voter demographics and the correlation to tea party member demographics is therefore unsurprising, am I wrong about this having not changed significantly? Can you elaborate?

Not sure what "figures" you are referring to here. The TP did not exist until just over a year ago. To elaborate on what I was saying:

you said: If I made the argument that the protests in Greece were orchestrated by anarchists, and I sought to prove this point by showing you every picture I could find of anarchists infiltrating the crowds, and setting things on fire, and attacking police, what would your response be? I suggest when you think about that answer you consider why people might have a problem with ongoing arguments that the tea party is racist.
then I said: I don't know about you, but if I was at a 300 strong rally for X, and I saw tens and tens of racist placards being swung about by a disproportionate number of folks from the "opposite race," and I noticed that the 300 strong was disproportionately of the "opposite race," I'd re-assess my purpose for being at rally X...
And if my purpose was not racist, I would then have 2 obvious options: Change the group or leave the group. ...But if my purpose was racist, only the more trendy "casual" flavor of racism currently en vogue in the 'States, I'd welcome the hardcores to do the heavy lifting while I mumbled something something socialism.

Again we find ourselves at the question: Why didn't they speak out against the fringe and take control of the Tea Party a long time ago?


4
Grizzly Bear: To your other point, yes the racists may be racist and white, but your reference to voter demographics is doing nothing to support the claim that the majority of these people comprise the tea party movement...

Okay. So I did say something to that effect - and it was not as well thought out as it should've been. It was conjecture and so I recant. [Also, I think it's mavericky to recant on the jref]

The question remains: Why did it take so long for the teabag leadership to speak out against the fringe? And, have they indeed taken control of the Tea Party and its message?
 
  • Would your argument also include polling data indicating the Greek protesters had anarchist tendencies? Would your argument also include some organizers of those Greek protests engaging in anarchist behavior?

  • To pretend that the argument that the Tea Party is racist is based solely on supposed rally infiltrators is a bit disingenuous.
  • Reading the results of the survey addressed in the OP, all I see is a reflection of voter demographics, which I explained to cienanos earlier why I doubted them in favor of a more useful gauge. If you think such vague questions are viable criteria for playing the race card in the tea party movement you really should consider having another look at the history behind the existing political demographics.
  • No, twisting existing voter demographics without understanding the spread and calling it racist inclined is a bit disingenuous. Some don't do it intentionally, others know very well what they're doing.


1
  • Here's an example of what sound leadership can effect: California Agricultural Labor Relations Act. I use this example because it has to do with livelihood [what the TP claims it is about] as opposed to race. As for the contaminating bit, from what I can tell, that happened last summer [at the latest]. You gotta wonder when folks with medicare are holding a "no socialism" sign in one hand and a bone-nosed Obama sign in the other.
  • 2


    Bit of a contradiction there.

  • 3


    Not sure what "figures" you are referring to here. The TP did not exist until just over a year ago. To elaborate on what I was saying:


  • 4 Again we find ourselves at the question: Why didn't they speak out against the fringe and take control of the Tea Party a long time ago?

    The question remains: Why did it take so long for the teabag leadership to speak out against the fringe? And, have they indeed taken control of the Tea Party and its message?
  • (1) I think the problem in comparing the Agricultural Labor Relations Act to the tea party is in trying to compare a union with a grassroots movement. The legislation you point out was spearheaded by the efforts of the National Farm Workers Association and Agricultural Workers Organizing Committee. The Tea party, as opposed to a centralized union is a movement which organizes itself loosely around local chapters. The tea party from what I can tell is trying to effect change through voters in order to either elect new officials to support their cause or to effect changes in the manner in which policies are carried out by congressional leaders. Since elections aren't until November the overall success or failure isn't really clear at this time. Likelihoods are the movement will be long term.
  • (2) Doubt it. It's easier to find this material on local news channels than it is on most of the national news networks. Look on MSNBC, or CNN, and you'll be hard pressed to find anything significant. The coverage of the te party movement is about as healthy as the coffee party coverage...
  • (3) LINK

    Hence my point, that the demographics representing both the tea party movement and the republican party are unsurprising... To further break this down you can check out a Gallup poll posted on April 5th of this year. Again, why I find the polls being used in this thread dubious without any other context to put this into perspective.
  • (4)Not everyone realizes the impact of something until it hits them in the face. The bulkiest coverage of violence being associated in one fashion or another has been since the passing of the health care bill. Perhaps they underestimated the coverage or the tenacity of this stuff before then? I've passed some of the smaller rallies here in Miami last year and personally didn't see any of the racist epitomes jerking out of the seams. I haven't passed any rallies recently, but I've read where local chapters here have condemned the stuff happening after the health care bill. But seems to me either the coverage wasn't there before, they underestimated it, or a combination of those.
 
  1. He's raising our taxes!
  2. He's a socialist!
  3. He's a racist!
  4. He wants death panels!
  5. He's a secret muslim!
  6. He's not a US citizen and I want my country back!
How do those two protests compare?

The anti-war movement said that Bush was a terrorist, a Nazi, a Fascist, a war criminal and that he's trying to take over Iraq's oilfields. Those claims are just as hysterical as calling Obama a Communist.
 
The anti-war movement said that Bush was a terrorist, a Nazi, a Fascist, a war criminal and that he's trying to take over Iraq's oilfields. Those claims are just as hysterical as calling Obama a Communist.

How so?
 
I think the problem in comparing the Agricultural Labor Relations Act to the tea party is in trying to compare a union with a grassroots movement. The legislation you point out was spearheaded by the efforts of the National Farm Workers Association and Agricultural Workers Organizing Committee. The Tea party, as opposed to a centralized union is a movement which organizes itself loosely around local chapters. The tea party from what I can tell is trying to effect change through voters in order to either elect new officials to support their cause or to effect changes in the manner in which policies are carried out by
congressional leaders. Since elections aren't until November the overall success or failure isn't really clear at this time. Likelihoods are the movement will be long term.

At their core, both are community organizations. And let's not ignore the fact that the UFW had its share of growing pains:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Farm_Workers

So, really, the organization (or lack thereof) of the TP is only relevant in terms of its length of existence. Understandable. Though the TP movement may hang around for a while, the real likelihood is that it shan't get close to any of its "Taxed Enough Already" goals. Among the reasons for this are their blatant inconsistency along with the mean age of the typical teabagger. In other words, not only are they out of touch with the American youth and its knack for making history (see Obama) - but also, they contradict themselves seemingly at every turn.

Our topic tonight is that our wonderful federal government is trying to cram health care and whatnot down our throats.

I’m from Ohio,” she said. “Massachusetts is a foreign country to me.” She moved in 2004, for her husband’s job, and although, with the exception of an internship with the Ohio Republican Party in 1992, she had never been involved in politics before, living in Taxachusetts triggered something in her. “I started blogging in 2006, and in early 2009 I just thought we should have a Tax Day thing,” she said. (Varley’s old blog is called GOPMom.) She had been home raising her daughter, but last year she took a job with the Coalition for Marriage and Family, a nonprofit formed to try to get a same-sex marriage ban on the ballot.

-Christen Varley, Boston Teabagger

This is a perfect example of the TP movement being anti-government about one thing: having the "well-off" help pay for the healthcare of their "not-so well-off" fellow American; yet in the same breath being pro-government about another: cramming same-sex marriage legislation down the throat of all Americans. The reality is, that today, healthcare for children is an easier thing to get behind than say, denying a particular group their civil rights.


We are judged by the company we keep:

Everyone was gabby, and excited. Varley had important information: the Tea Party Express would be bringing Sarah Palin to Boston on April 14th, for a rally on the Common, the day before the Tax Day protest on the Washington Mall. Palin’s visit, Varley said, was good news, “no matter what you think of her.” Varley talked about the plan for the big day: “The Obama Hitler sign. Let’s look out for those people, and make sure people know they’re not us.” A middle-aged, out-of-work Republican from Jamaica Plain agreed that it was crucial to police the line between the reasonable Tea Party people and party crashers: “We need to disabuse the public of some of the more exotic rumors out there.” Someone said that the problem is that too few people know that the “tea” in Tea Party is an acronym. Blank stares. “Taxed Enough Already. People need to know that’s what we stand for.”


What the average African American probably thinks when the Tea Party gripes about getting ripped off:

... the Afro-American Bicentennial Corporation, James Earl Jones read an 1852 speech of Frederick Douglass’s, asking, “What, to the American slave, is your 4th of July?”: “I answer; a day that reveals to him, more than all other days in the year, the gross injustice and cruelty to which he is the constant victim. To him, your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license; your national greatness, swelling vanity.”

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/05/03/100503fa_fact_lepore


Regions:

The Midwest and West experienced increases in both their poverty rate and the number in poverty. The Midwest poverty rate increased to 12.4 percent (8.1 million) in 2008, up from 11.1 percent (7.2 million) in 2007, and the West poverty rate increased to 13.5 percent (9.6 million) in 2008, up from 12.0 percent (8.4 million) in 2007. The poverty rates for the Northeast (11.6 percent) and the South (14.3 percent) were both statistically unchanged.

- http://www.census.gov/Press-Release/www/releases/archives/income_wealth/014227.html

So you take these folks who skew right politically, many from under the GOP umbrella - the party that lost the african american demographic in the second 3rd of the 20th century, the party with the guvna that just pissed off hispanics with SB1070, a signifcant increase in poverty in the "fly-over, real american" region of the country, the leadership (ahem) of Palin and Beck, the tendency to want and not want government interference depending on what day it is, and you get a picture of a bunch of whining, incoherent, poorly led, disgruntled hypocrites who show an utter lack of understanding as to how this country was both built - as well as how its political system works.
 
In that he's not a terrorist, a Nazi, a Fascist, or a war criminal and he didn't take over Iraq's oilfields.

I think a case could be made that he is a war criminal, since he authorized torture of detainees.
 
So you take these folks who skew right politically, many from under the GOP umbrella - the party that lost the african american demographic in the second 3rd of the 20th century, the party with the guvna that just pissed off hispanics with SB1070, a signifcant increase in poverty in the "fly-over, real american" region of the country, the leadership (ahem) of Palin and Beck, the tendency to want and not want government interference depending on what day it is, and you get a picture of a bunch of whining, incoherent, poorly led, disgruntled hypocrites who show an utter lack of understanding as to how this country was both built - as well as how its political system works.
I understand why you believe the tea party movement and the Republican party may be hypocrites for the policies they push, but this has nothing to do with explaining how their demographics render them racially inclined. What I'm attempting to get people to address is how you or they derive these figures when they look at an incomplete set of information. The tea party largely represents conservatism, more so than it does overall American politics, so I can understand why it would be labeled mainstream partisanship. But a good chunk of those who hold a negative view the movement choose of all things a stance which at this stage doesn't even deserve to be taken seriously. And I say this because they take the questions as absolute proof, instead of looking at any kind of context.
 
Last edited:
http://www.newsweek.com/id/236996

Them darn libral mediests R just tryin to paint us all as racialists!
Ever since I learned from first hand knowledge that Newsweek prints crap, I have not believed anything you say. I was involved in the Peace Keeping Effort in Lebanon. I knew Lt. Bobby Young who was rescued by Jessie Jackson. Weeks after the events, a copy of NewsWeek made its way in the mail delivery onto the USS JFK. Everything -- every detail of the mission -- was reported incorrectly in NewsWeek. Because of this and because I know that black people participate in the Tea party movement, I think this article just might be bunk.
 
The writers of the study referenced in the Newsweek article never replied to my email about additional crosstabs. Too bad, it would have been interesting to see how blacks answered some of those questions. These guys wasted money interviewing 500 non-whites (half their sample) and then didn't publish the results. Pretty silly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom