New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

Another liberal plant.
http://gawker.com/5529952/arizona-republican-leader-follows-white-supremacist

StormfrontWPWW (White Pride Worldwide) is the Twitter account for Stormfront, a racist organization that is the latest project of uber-racist Stephen Donald Black, better known as Don Black. He was a Grand Wizard in the KKK and a member of the American Nazi Party. In 1981 he was convicted and jailed for trying to invade the Dominican Republic with a boatload of weapons, in order to set up some kind of utopian state. (He's pictured below, at a conference organized by the infamous white supremacist David Duke.) Stormfront.org, the website he set up on his release from jail, is a hate-filled racist forum.

thumb160x_0503_donblack.jpg


Its Twitter account is one of 4,819 that Arizona State Senate Majority Leader Chuck Gray (top) follows. (See screenshot below.) Stormfront does not reciprocate, however—the group follows no one. Which means that Gray, or whoever is responsible for his Twitter account, sought out the racist organization specifically and decided its tweets were essential reading. Perhaps because they've linked heavily on their feed to stories about the recent Arizona immigration bill and similarly racist-tinged measures in the state to remove teachers with "ethnic" accents from classrooms? Of course, this isn't the first time Arizona's right-wing politicians have been linked with racist groups.
 
Why did you cite a thread that Bill Thompson never posted in?

Ah... humor. Did you notice the little smiley? Bill staid he confronted a "liberal plant" at a teabagger shindig and I linked to a thread with a video of a teabagger confronting a liberal.


It was a joke. Sorry you didn't get it. I was not of course suggesting that Bill would rip someone a new one with Old Glory.

So there is some "rule" that when we rely we can only link to a thread that the author of the post we are replying to has posted in? Can you give me a link to this rule?

Edit:

Looks like it's a generally a bad idea to joke around with teabaggers. :eek:

Some of the infiltrators [at the teabagger rally] were just apolitical jokers -- even if their humor was lost on the participants. A group of students from American University belonging to a club that mocks mass protests brandished signs reading “I Have A Sign,” “Down With King George,” and “No $ 4 Education I Don’t Want It.” The group was chased across the protest by a screaming, red-faced tea partier in a denim jacket who identified himself only as “Spider.”

“They’re interlopers!” Spider shrieked as the nervous youngsters tried to make their way to a police officer. “These people are not the tea party!”

After being pushed to the outskirts of the protests, the phony demonstrators told The Daily Beast they were terrified of Spider, who they said threatened to “kick their ass.”

http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2010-04-16/infiltrating-the-tea-party/#

4525796954_24c1e38085.jpg
 
Last edited:
So there is some "rule" that when we rely we can only link to a thread that the author of the post we are replying to has posted in? Can you give me a link to this rule?

I didn't get the joke so I asked a question. Why are you so touchy?
 
I find it ironic that a forum full of people who refer to themselves as skeptics has a significant number of posters who find it usefull to play along in a giant ad-hominem attack against an entire political movement.
 
I find it ironic that a forum full of people who refer to themselves as skeptics has a significant number of posters who find it usefull to play along in a giant ad-hominem attack against an entire political movement.

I find it funny that they rationalize it by saying, "Well they say bad things, I don't need to be nice." or some such crap.
 
I guess it takes a big heart and a open mind, to understand the long-term effects of slavery, segregation, and the epidemic of single-parent homes on the African-American community.

It's interesting that many are willing to make a cultural argument against the teabaggers -- that there is what amounts to a culture of (sometimes subconscious) racial bias among certain conservative groups -- while at the same time denying that it's possible that any corresponding argument could be made that there are internal cultural impediments within some black communities that contribute to their own problems.

I've seen it cut both ways.

On the one hand, I remember working for a grading company, and there was one black guy on the crew. The other fellows (including a foreman who was a Klansman) continually disparaged him behind his back for being lazy and shirking work, when I could plainly see that he was doing just as much work as everyone else.

On the other hand, I remember the frustration of a friend of mine from high school, who inherited his dad's business, at having to hire "Mexicans" (i.e., Hispanics) because he didn't like working with them, but they worked harder than most of the non-Hispanics he hired.

Let's face it... culture can work for good and ill. And there's no reason to simply decide that it's impossible that both external racism and internal culture can be factors in determining the success, or lack of success, for various groups.

I'm reminded of Dr. Tyson's keynote address at TAM 2 years ago, in which he described the devastating impact of a shift in Islamic religious culture, which marked the watershed between what was once the leading scientific culture in the modern world, and what is now a scientific backwater, to the detriment of all of us.

If we're going to look at these issues, we need to keep a truly open mind, which includes being open to the possibility that internal cultural problems can indeed have a profoundly negative impact on groups of people.
 
I find it ironic that a forum full of people who refer to themselves as skeptics has a significant number of posters who find it usefull to play along in a giant ad-hominem attack against an entire political movement.

I find it funny that they rationalize it by saying, "Well they say bad things, I don't need to be nice." or some such crap.

I'm pretty sure that if you pay attention, you'll see that the actual arguments used by the Tea Party get plenty of discussion apart from the discussions of their even less savory characteristics.

That their positions don't fare well regardless of racial motivations by some of them is mostly ignored by supporters. It's almost comical.
 
Let me be clear: I don't think the Tea Party as an organization is necessarily racist. What I think they are, as indicated by the polling data, are self-entitled, reactionary white conservatives who respond with fear and ignorance to anything outside of their comfort zone.

I think you've got that wrong.

They're no different from the leftists wingnuts who pulled the same kind of street theater under Republican administrations.

Which is why they're such an embarrassment.

Literally overnight, self-proclaimed conservatives started dressing up in costumes, shouting down meetings, and holding up pasteboard signs and chanting slogans -- just like the people they had always ridiculed.

It's simply human psychology.

There is always going to be a fringe element in any political camp that will pull these kinds of stunts when they feel they've been cut out of the power equation.

But it's interesting that there seems to be absolutely nothing they can do to shake these accusations of racism.

They've gone out of their way to disavow racism, and denounce it. And as far as I can see, they've done absolutely nothing to attempt to promote a racist agenda.

Sure, there are going to be racists who oppose Obama. If you're anti-black, of course you're going to be against him. Therefore, it's inevitable that racists are going to show up at Tea Party rallies and are going to identify themselves with the movement.

But hey, that's simply the result of our having a free society. There's nothing the Tea Party folks can do to prevent racists from showing up at their rallies or identifying themselves with the Tea Party.

So the question is not whether there are racists affiliated with the Tea Party movement. Of course there are.

The important question is whether or not the Tea Party actually embraces or endorses racism or promotes a racist agenda. And as far as I can see, they do not.
 
I find it ironic that a forum full of people who refer to themselves as skeptics has a significant number of posters who find it usefull to play along in a giant ad-hominem attack against an entire political movement.

Hmm... yeah. Not quite.

I haven't seen anyone calling the Tea Party racist, and then claiming because they are racist their arguments are invalid.

That would be an ad hominem attack.

What is happening here is people pointing out that due to their blatant hypocrisy the Tea Party's arguments are invalid, and positing about the degree to which they might be racist.

And of course, the charges of racism are borne of the behavior of some aspects of the Tea Party coupled with the very troubling fact that due to their overwhelming hypocrisy, it's difficult to get a handle on why they exist in the first place.
 
Again... why did no Tea Party appear under Bush I, Clinton or Bush II?

Exactly by what does Obama differ from these three, except by skin color and foreign-sounding name?

Chaos, think about it this way....

Obviously, the teabaggers are not the brightest bulbs on the marquee when it comes to political thinking. I know quite a few of them, and many of them are quite smart when it comes to other things -- such as business and logistics, for example -- but politically they are followers who buy into slogans and pat answers rather than analysis of the facts.

The political rhetoric leading up to the 2008 election was fierce. And much of it played upon subconscious racial stereotypes, particularly the accusation of socialism.

Anyone who looks at Obama's personal history and actions and political philosophy will find an accusation of "socialist" to be patently laughable.

But to someone who buys into political stereotypes, it's reflexively obvious that a black Chicago Democrat is going to take resources from hard-working people and dole it out to cronies and undeserving, lazy minorities, because that's what those people do.

Btw, here's a link to an interesting study finding that:

Individuals’ implicit racial prejudices corresponded with a reluctance to vote for President Barack Obama and with opposition to his health care reform plan, according to a study coauthored by Stanford Graduate School of Business Professor Brian Lowery. Subjects were more likely to support a health care reform proposal attributed to former President Bill Clinton than the same proposal from Obama.

So the teabaggers were steeped (pardon the pun) in this months-long media environment which proclaimed, day after day, that Obama is a socialist who hates our military and is a secret Muslim and on and on and on.

So the reason we have a Tea Party now, rather than before, isn't because all the teabaggers are racists who hate seeing a black man in the White House, but rather because a year-long media campaign exploited the fears of people who were predisposed to believe that a black Chicago Democrat would be ultra-liberal, and manipulated those fears to the extreme.

They're not as racist as they are partisan. And as ultra-partisans, they were (and are) submerged in the echo chamber of Fox News, right-wing Web sites, and like-minded associates.

Yes, those larger players certainly took advantage of racially-based biases, but their tactics worked across the board, for anyone who consumed what they were feeding their audience, even if they were not themselves racist.

So sure, there was an inherent racist element to the broad smear campaign against Obama (which I contrast with legitimate opposition to his actual positions) but not everyone who bought into that campaign necessarily shared those racist biases.

ETA: To clarify, the far right-wing media campaign against Obama played upon stereotypes, including racial ones but also political ones, because that's what pushed their core audience's buttons, but the fact that they chose certain smears (particularly the Socialist meme) partly on the grounds of racist predispositions among many of their viewers does not mean that everyone who bought into those smears is racist -- many, perhaps most, bought into them simply because they were immersed in that media environment + they are hard-core partisans + they don't take time to fact-check + they don't seek out any other points of view. In other words, the die-hard right-wingers don't need to be racist in order to buy into the media campaign which, in its calculations, catered to the segment of its audience which is racist.
 
Last edited:
I think you've got that wrong.

The polling data indicates otherwise.

They're no different from the leftists wingnuts who pulled the same kind of street theater under Republican administrations.

Which is why they're such an embarrassment.

Literally overnight, self-proclaimed conservatives started dressing up in costumes, shouting down meetings, and holding up pasteboard signs and chanting slogans -- just like the people they had always ridiculed.

It's simply human psychology.

There is always going to be a fringe element in any political camp that will pull these kinds of stunts when they feel they've been cut out of the power equation.

Granted, but the Tea party have self-anointed themselves as the Voice of America, and have the support and sponsorship of corporations and major Republican political figures.

That's hardly a direct correlation to the far less organized anti-Bush protesters.

It seems the Tea Party wants to have it both ways. They want to present themselves as some kind of highly-organized populist front right up until the moment one them does something stupid that makes national headlines. Then all of the suden they're just a rag-tag group of protesters that might have inadvertantly attracted a few wingnuts.

But it's interesting that there seems to be absolutely nothing they can do to shake these accusations of racism.

They've gone out of their way to disavow racism, and denounce it. And as far as I can see, they've done absolutely nothing to attempt to promote a racist agenda.

Sure, there are going to be racists who oppose Obama. If you're anti-black, of course you're going to be against him. Therefore, it's inevitable that racists are going to show up at Tea Party rallies and are going to identify themselves with the movement.

But hey, that's simply the result of our having a free society. There's nothing the Tea Party folks can do to prevent racists from showing up at their rallies or identifying themselves with the Tea Party.

So the question is not whether there are racists affiliated with the Tea Party movement. Of course there are.

The important question is whether or not the Tea Party actually embraces or endorses racism or promotes a racist agenda. And as far as I can see, they do not.

That the Tea Partiers aren't wearing hooded robes and burning crosses as an argument that they're not racist is a bit flimsy. Racism comes in many forms, and it's not always blatant. And any political organization trying achieve legitimacy on a national stage certainly isn't going to announce their less savory agendas, supposing they have them in the first place.

The bottom line is this: The Tea Party has exhibited numerous occasions of racist behavior, sometimes even at the leadership level. While this doesn't necessarily mean the organization as a whole is racist, or that they have a racist agenda, it certainly casts them in a negative light.

And I personally don't feel they're owed any kind of apology or special measure of understanding when this happens. If they don't want to be associated with racism, then they need to better police themselves. Their public image is no one's responsibility but their own.
 
And if the Tea Party doesn't like the fact that some people assume those factors are tied to the Tea Party's fringe elements, then they need to A) police themselves better, and B) come up with a platform that isn't so laughably incoherent.

I invite you to read the Democratic Party platform and tell me with a straight face that it is not also "laughably incoherent".

Party platforms are not made to be coherent.

They're made to draw people to the group.

To do that effectively, you cannot produce a coherent document without dooming yourself to niche status.
 
The polling data indicates otherwise.

Really? The polling data indicate that teabaggers "respond with fear and ignorance to anything outside of their comfort zone"?

Wow.

That's gotta be one powerful poll you got there!

:rolleyes:
 
Granted, but the Tea party have self-anointed themselves as the Voice of America, and have the support and sponsorship of corporations and major Republican political figures.

That's hardly a direct correlation to the far less organized anti-Bush protesters.

I won't disagree with you about that, but it's irrelevant to what I was saying there.

It's true that the far right wing currently has a much better organized corporate/media machine than the left does, to say the least.

But that's on an entirely different level from what I was talking about.

Those higher-level interests were very quick to snap up the opportunity that the Tea Party movement offered them, and to provide them with exposure and venues and such.

But that's a different question from the psychology of the actual members of the movement, who do not join because of what these uber-interests are doing.

The psychology at the individual level is identical for teabaggers and the "No Blood for Oil" crowd.
 
That the Tea Partiers aren't wearing hooded robes and burning crosses as an argument that they're not racist is a bit flimsy. Racism comes in many forms, and it's not always blatant. And any political organization trying achieve legitimacy on a national stage certainly isn't going to announce their less savory agendas, supposing they have them in the first place.

The bottom line is this: The Tea Party has exhibited numerous occasions of racist behavior, sometimes even at the leadership level. While this doesn't necessarily mean the organization as a whole is racist, or that they have a racist agenda, it certainly casts them in a negative light.

And I personally don't feel they're owed any kind of apology or special measure of understanding when this happens. If they don't want to be associated with racism, then they need to better police themselves. Their public image is no one's responsibility but their own.

Oh, give me a break.

I can't believe that anyone on this kind of forum would actually offer the argument that the absence of overt racism is a "flimsy" argument against accusations of racism.

Please.

You're using Truther logic here -- of course they won't announce their racist intentions... so they must be covert!

:rolleyes:

And your call for better policing is ridiculous.

What would you have them do?

That's a serious question.

How in the world do you think it's possible, in a free society, for an open group to somehow "police" itself so that no racist cranks show up at their rallies or identify themselves with the group?

Tell me exactly how you think that would work.
 
Only the liberal plants at the Tea Parties are racists.
I confronted one. It was clear someone paid him to be there.

Please don't be an idiot. It makes it so much harder for the rest of us. You can't possibly know that every single racist at a Tea Party rally is a "liberal plant". And it defies logic.

There are racists. And of course white racists will oppose Obama. And some of those are bound to be attracted to Tea Party rallies.
 
I honestly have no idea if you're being serious, but random wingnuts with monkey dolls don't particularly concern me. I'm sure random wingnuts showed up at anti-Bush rallies, too.

But what the Tea Party and its defenders can't rationalize away is when racist behavior occurs at the leadership level:

Self-proclaimed Tea Party founder brings racist sign to rally.

Tea Party organizer tweets racist comments.

Tea Party-backed politician caught sending racist and obscene e-mails.

Unless there is some truly deep-level Machiavellian sabotage going on, it's kind of hard to blame that stuff on "liberal plants", isn't it?

And once we've established that racist behavior is exhibited by Tea Party organizers and candidates, how much of a leap is it to think that an old white guy at a Palin rally holding an Obama monkey doll might not be a liberal plant?

Ok, let's get some perspective here.

The "Springboro Tea Party" article is anything but an exposee of Tea Party leadership being racist.

We're talking about an extremely small group here, and the gist of the article is that all of the "names" who might have been associated with that group immediately bailed out when they got word of any hint of racism from that little group.

I don't see how it's even remotely possible to reason, from there, that teabaggers are racist.

The article about Paladino is much the same. That's guy's a total nutjob, and everyone around him is saying as much.

Either point to some evidence that the Tea Party movement endorses this idiot's statements, or retract.

As for Dale Robertson, he was ejected from the event for carrying his sign.

And you interpret that to mean that the Tea Party endorses the sign?

"We are through the looking glass, gentlemen...."

And when you get right down to it, the sign was not even racist, unless you believe that any utterance of the so-called "N-word" is racist, in which case there a lot of blacks out there who obviously hate blacks.

The sign was intended to convey the (admittedly misguided) notion that citizens are slaves to the government. But that's not a message of hate against blacks.

In any case, that message was not tolerated.

So none of your citations actually demonstrate any support of racism from Tea Party leadership.
 
I invite you to read the Democratic Party platform and tell me with a straight face that it is not also "laughably incoherent".

Party platforms are not made to be coherent.

They're made to draw people to the group.

To do that effectively, you cannot produce a coherent document without dooming yourself to niche status.

First of all, I'm not obligated to defend the platform of any other political organization before I'm allowed to criticize the Tea Party, so whether or not the Democratic Party has an "incoherent platform" is immaterial.

Secondly, the Tea Party is laughably incoherent. They want smaller government except for the big government programs from which they benefit. They oppose socialized healthcare except for their socialized healthcare. They protested being overtaxed despite receiving enormous tax cuts.

These people are all over the map, with their one unified position basically boiling down to "I want what I want". It's petulant nonsense.

I understand they want to draw people to their cause, but when "their cause" translates as unfocused childish rage, I'm not the bad guy for pointing that out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom