New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

Really? The polling data indicate that teabaggers "respond with fear and ignorance to anything outside of their comfort zone"?

Wow.

That's gotta be one powerful poll you got there!

:rolleyes:

I'll admit to speculation on my part, but it's founded in fairly sound reasoning.

First of all, the Tea Party is overwhelming conservative. Conservatives, as a general rule, prefer the status quo. If they didn't, they'd be Progressives.

It's not such a great leap to say that someone who resists change is therefore afraid of change. Coupled with the fact that they tend to be aging white people with demonstrable racial resentment who find themselves in an America becoming more and more multi-racial, I can certainly see them as a group fearing the direction the country is inevitably headed.

As far as the ignorance... Do I really have to defend that? Death Panels? Birtherism?
 
I won't disagree with you about that, but it's irrelevant to what I was saying there.

It's true that the far right wing currently has a much better organized corporate/media machine than the left does, to say the least.

But that's on an entirely different level from what I was talking about.

Those higher-level interests were very quick to snap up the opportunity that the Tea Party movement offered them, and to provide them with exposure and venues and such.

But that's a different question from the psychology of the actual members of the movement, who do not join because of what these uber-interests are doing.

The psychology at the individual level is identical for teabaggers and the "No Blood for Oil" crowd.

Perhaps. But "No Blood for Oil" is a concept I can wrap my head around, whether or not I agree with the underlying premise.

The reason I have an issue with the Tea Party, and the reason I don't think it's accurate to compare them to anti-war protesters of the Bush era, is because for such a highly organized group, they don't really seem to be about anything other than anger.

These claims of wanting "smaller government" and "fiscal conservatism" fall apart under the slightest of scrutiny. They only want smaller government as long as it doesn't impact them, and they only wanted fiscal conservatism once Obama was elected.

So once you take away those arguments, all your left with is the anger. Which of course begs the question: What are they so angry about?
 
Oh, give me a break.

I can't believe that anyone on this kind of forum would actually offer the argument that the absence of overt racism is a "flimsy" argument against accusations of racism.

Please.

You're using Truther logic here -- of course they won't announce their racist intentions... so they must be covert!

I'm not claiming that a lack of blatant racism means they must therefore by covertly racist. I'm claiming that just because they're not blatantly racist doesn't mean they're not racist at all.

And your call for better policing is ridiculous.

What would you have them do?

That's a serious question.

How in the world do you think it's possible, in a free society, for an open group to somehow "police" itself so that no racist cranks show up at their rallies or identify themselves with the group?

Tell me exactly how you think that would work.

Not my problem.

And I'm not talking about racist cranks that show up at rallies. I'm talking about organizers and candidates who get caught exhibiting racist behavior.

If they don't have the will or ability to police themselves at least that much, then they certainly don't deserve my sympathy or benefit of the doubt when they get labeled as racist.
 
Ok, let's get some perspective here.

The "Springboro Tea Party" article is anything but an exposee of Tea Party leadership being racist.

We're talking about an extremely small group here, and the gist of the article is that all of the "names" who might have been associated with that group immediately bailed out when they got word of any hint of racism from that little group.

I don't see how it's even remotely possible to reason, from there, that teabaggers are racist.

The article about Paladino is much the same. That's guy's a total nutjob, and everyone around him is saying as much.

Either point to some evidence that the Tea Party movement endorses this idiot's statements, or retract.

As for Dale Robertson, he was ejected from the event for carrying his sign.

And you interpret that to mean that the Tea Party endorses the sign?

"We are through the looking glass, gentlemen...."

And when you get right down to it, the sign was not even racist, unless you believe that any utterance of the so-called "N-word" is racist, in which case there a lot of blacks out there who obviously hate blacks.

The sign was intended to convey the (admittedly misguided) notion that citizens are slaves to the government. But that's not a message of hate against blacks.

In any case, that message was not tolerated.

So none of your citations actually demonstrate any support of racism from Tea Party leadership.

I'm not claiming that any of those incidents is proof positive that the Tea Party is a racist organization. I'm just pointing out this stuff occurs, and it's not just wingnuts showing up at rallies.

Once again, it is the responsibility of the Tea Party to weed these people out. Sure they did so after the fact (And really, what else were they going to do? Say "We support this racist behavior"?), but that doesn't change the fact that these people weren't exactly outcasts prior to these incidents.

I have no idea what the Tea Party can do on a national level to rid themselves of racists and the subsequent stigma, but that doesn't mean they should get a pass for failing to do so. And it certainly doesn't mean that anyone is obligated to turn a blind eye just because the Tea Party responds with indignation when people draw conclusions from the behavior they witness.
 
I'm not claiming that a lack of blatant racism means they must therefore by covertly racist. I'm claiming that just because they're not blatantly racist doesn't mean they're not racist at all.
So just because you THINK they're all out to get you doesn't mean they aren't?
 
I'm not claiming that any of those incidents is proof positive that the Tea Party is a racist organization. I'm just pointing out this stuff occurs, and it's not just wingnuts showing up at rallies.

Once again, it is the responsibility of the Tea Party to weed these people out. Sure they did so after the fact (And really, what else were they going to do? Say "We support this racist behavior"?), but that doesn't change the fact that these people weren't exactly outcasts prior to these incidents.
Evidence that they knew of the racist tendencies of their members beforehand?
 
So just because you THINK they're all out to get you doesn't mean they aren't?

Yeah, you're right. When I argue that racists might not necessarily announce their racism outright, I'm just being paranoid. I keep forgetting we live in a society in which racists have no reason to hide their racism, and therefore gleefully announce it at any opportunity.
 
Evidence that they knew of the racist tendencies of their members beforehand?

I'm not claiming they did know beforehand, nor is it my problem that they didn't.

Just like it's not my problem when their organizers and candidates engage in racist behavior if people then think that behavior reflects on their organization as a whole.
 
I find it funny that they rationalize it by saying, "Well they say bad things, I don't need to be nice." or some such crap.

Oh, it always the other guy who is the crazy, demented loon. Everbody on my side is rational and intelligent....
 
I'm not claiming that any of those incidents is proof positive that the Tea Party is a racist organization. I'm just pointing out this stuff occurs, and it's not just wingnuts showing up at rallies.

Once again, it is the responsibility of the Tea Party to weed these people out. Sure they did so after the fact (And really, what else were they going to do? Say "We support this racist behavior"?), but that doesn't change the fact that these people weren't exactly outcasts prior to these incidents.

I have no idea what the Tea Party can do on a national level to rid themselves of racists and the subsequent stigma, but that doesn't mean they should get a pass for failing to do so. And it certainly doesn't mean that anyone is obligated to turn a blind eye just because the Tea Party responds with indignation when people draw conclusions from the behavior they witness.


Agreed. The Tea Party movement has only itself to blame for not purging the bigots from it ranks.
But that does not justify the broad brush used by some people here to tag every conservative as a bigot..either open or hidden.
 
Yeah, you're right. When I argue that racists might not necessarily announce their racism outright, I'm just being paranoid. I keep forgetting we live in a society in which racists have no reason to hide their racism, and therefore gleefully announce it at any opportunity.

You are such a gullible liberal moron. Of course any "racist" who openly announces their racism is a liberal plant installed in order to smear good honest conservative patriots!
[/conservative mode]
 
First of all, I'm not obligated to defend the platform of any other political organization before I'm allowed to criticize the Tea Party, so whether or not the Democratic Party has an "incoherent platform" is immaterial.

True, but that wasn't my point...

Secondly, the Tea Party is laughably incoherent. They want smaller government except for the big government programs from which they benefit. They oppose socialized healthcare except for their socialized healthcare. They protested being overtaxed despite receiving enormous tax cuts.

These people are all over the map, with their one unified position basically boiling down to "I want what I want". It's petulant nonsense.

My point is that you'll find such contradictions in all platforms, so I find it hard to criticize the Tea Baggers for having an incoherent platform.

To me, it's like criticizing them for holding rallies and raising money and such.

But then, I'm a complete cynic.

I mean, I read political mail all the time -- it's part of my job -- everything from Gingrich to Livingston to Hollywood liberals, and the majority of the evils they rail most intently against, and the causes they claim need immediate action, are utterly bogus.

But that's what people respond to.

But yeah, it is particularly laughable that they have come to focus their movement around the "Taxed Enough Already" theme, given where US taxes are right now, both historically for the US and compared to other developed nations.

I understand they want to draw people to their cause, but when "their cause" translates as unfocused childish rage, I'm not the bad guy for pointing that out.

Not calling you a bad guy, here.

And in fact, I think you come closer to the mark with that point right there.

It's not that the platform is necessarily any less coherent than anyone else's, it's the whole righteous anger thing, and their feeling that the country is somehow "theirs" to "take back".
 
I'll admit to speculation on my part, but it's founded in fairly sound reasoning.

First of all, the Tea Party is overwhelming conservative. Conservatives, as a general rule, prefer the status quo. If they didn't, they'd be Progressives.

It's not such a great leap to say that someone who resists change is therefore afraid of change. Coupled with the fact that they tend to be aging white people with demonstrable racial resentment who find themselves in an America becoming more and more multi-racial, I can certainly see them as a group fearing the direction the country is inevitably headed.

As far as the ignorance... Do I really have to defend that? Death Panels? Birtherism?

Certainly you describe a core faction of the Tea Party movement, but I would say you're still painting with a bit of a broad brush, there.

I read an interesting article recently, on CCN.com of all places, from reporters who spent some time traveling around to Tea Party rallies, and they reported that they saw much more demographic variety at those events than the stereotypical teabagger image would suggest.

And sadly, it seems to me that contemporary conservatism has largely abandoned the principle of caution and gradual, considered change. It's become much more reactionary, in the style of Bill O'Reilly, focusing instead on recapturing some Mayberry America that never really existed.

And now, the belief in that mythic America, coupled with a loss of political power which they had come to believe was their (often literally) divine right, combined with the Murdoch-style right wing media chorus denouncing the Democratic party as America-haters, has transformed that fervor into genuine fear. Which means that some of them are becoming downright revolutionary.

(Btw, you might want to read the chapter in Cialdini's "Influence" describing what happens to groups who have their ideals smashed -- they get even more convinced that those ideals were right! I'm seeing this a lot right now, especially in an insistence that we need even less control and regulation over markets in the wake of the crash.)

And sure, there's a lot of ignorance there. But I saw the same sort of ignorance among the "No Blood for Oil" crowd and the Move-on-istas. So I'm not convinced there's anything special about the teabaggers on that point.

And not all of the teabaggers are birthers and that kind of ilk. Yeah, they're there, no doubt. But it's been interesting to me to watch this whole thing evolve, and more and more I see that group attempting to put some daylight between it and those ideas. But I agree, they won't be able to get away from it -- it's too stuck in their organizational DNA from the get-go... they can't really afford to do what would be necessary to jettison those folks, and plenty of them don't want to.

As for conservative psychology, you might be interested in the studies referenced in this article:

For liberals, morality derives mostly from fairness and prevention of harm. For conservatives, morality also involves upholding authority and loyalty — and revulsion at disgust.

You might want to take the quizzes linked about midway thru the article and see how you score. It's interesting. I gave them a spin, and sure enough, I had a pattern that didn't fit either profile.

I consider myself a conservative -- in the style of of Rockefeller Republicans -- but I don't think the term today means what I mean by it. And I certainly am not now affiliated with the GOP, which has totally crumbled and lost its collective mind.
 
Perhaps. But "No Blood for Oil" is a concept I can wrap my head around, whether or not I agree with the underlying premise.

The reason I have an issue with the Tea Party, and the reason I don't think it's accurate to compare them to anti-war protesters of the Bush era, is because for such a highly organized group, they don't really seem to be about anything other than anger.

These claims of wanting "smaller government" and "fiscal conservatism" fall apart under the slightest of scrutiny. They only want smaller government as long as it doesn't impact them, and they only wanted fiscal conservatism once Obama was elected.

So once you take away those arguments, all your left with is the anger. Which of course begs the question: What are they so angry about?

I think they're angry at losing political power, at losing their demographic dominance, at a lot of trumped up nonsense that they get from Fox and Rush and Beck and right-wing blogs, at a sense of personal powerlessness in the wake of the ecomonic crash, and subsconsciously at seeing some of their cherished beliefs -- e.g., that free markets regulate themselves, and that they could become a "permanent majority" with God's blessing -- get dashed upon the rocks.

Oh, and btw, there was quite a bit of railing against Bush spending in conservative/libertarian circles well before the election.

But it seems to me -- speculating here -- that the misinformation mill that was so ginned up during the campaign has a lot to do with galvanizing this particular movement and converting them into the kind of political charicature they used to laugh at.

If you really believe that the country is now in the hands of people who want to side with our enemies, dismantle our defenses, and institute a doomed-to-fail command economy, of course you're going to be up in arms.

And fwiw, I cannot wrap my head around "No Blood for Oil". It's so profoundly naive. We cannot imagine our lives without oil. It's such a precious resource, of course there will be blood for it.

And let me ask you, were the anti-war protesters under Bush really coherent? Did they have any plan? Did they take time to consider the logistics, the consequences, the trade-offs, and what loss of life might have occurred if they got what they wanted? I don't think so. I think, like the teabaggers, they were just angry at something they saw happening.
 
And sure, there's a lot of ignorance there. But I saw the same sort of ignorance among the "No Blood for Oil" crowd and the Move-on-istas. So I'm not convinced there's anything special about the teabaggers on that point

This is spot on. No side has a monopoly on the crazy. Right now, I think Barack Obama is encountering two groups of people who seriously misread him during the election. The Teabaggers heard him talking about putting aside the old politics and working together with the GOP and said "He's lying! He's a secret socialist! He'll ruin the country!"

The liberals heard him say the same thing and said "He's lying! He's a secret socialist! He'll save the country!"

Both groups spent the last year in total freakout mode.

I've heard you say and completely agree that the guy is a middle-of-the road, centrist liberal. He's to the left on some things, to the right on others, but he's a total pragmatist. It's funny that so many people misread him to project their dreams or their fears onto the guy.
 
I'm not claiming that a lack of blatant racism means they must therefore by covertly racist. I'm claiming that just because they're not blatantly racist doesn't mean they're not racist at all.

Which means nothing.

It's like saying that just because you show no signs of being a child molester doesn't mean you're not one.

Absence of overt racism is absence of overt racism, nothing more.

Sure, maybe there's more racism under the surface than meets the eye -- and the Stanford study indicates that there is -- but it doesn't get us anywhere to observe that a group might have view X even though they don't say it, because you could just as easily counter that they might not, and that's where it stands.



Not my problem.

No no, you can't walk away from this one, b/c you've said you think they ought to police themselves better. If you can't think of a way that's actually possible, then you're talking nonsense.

And I'm not talking about racist cranks that show up at rallies. I'm talking about organizers and candidates who get caught exhibiting racist behavior.

If they don't have the will or ability to police themselves at least that much, then they certainly don't deserve my sympathy or benefit of the doubt when they get labeled as racist.

Hold the phone.

In each example you've given, some obscure figure makes racist remarks, and all the prominent state and national figures disavow it, as does the group.

Yet despite this, you continue to cite these incidents as evidence that there's a problem with the group.

That doesn't add up.
 
I'm not claiming that any of those incidents is proof positive that the Tea Party is a racist organization. I'm just pointing out this stuff occurs, and it's not just wingnuts showing up at rallies.

Once again, it is the responsibility of the Tea Party to weed these people out. Sure they did so after the fact (And really, what else were they going to do? Say "We support this racist behavior"?), but that doesn't change the fact that these people weren't exactly outcasts prior to these incidents.

I have no idea what the Tea Party can do on a national level to rid themselves of racists and the subsequent stigma, but that doesn't mean they should get a pass for failing to do so. And it certainly doesn't mean that anyone is obligated to turn a blind eye just because the Tea Party responds with indignation when people draw conclusions from the behavior they witness.

Wait a minute... you want the Tea Party to root out racists before they make racist statements or take racist actions?

Do they have some sort of Racist RADAR? Some kind of blood test for the bigot gene?

In every example you've shown, they have policed themselves.

In a way, these public incidents are, I believe, actually helping them to purge the fringe bigots, because it's forcing them to take a stand on the issue.
 
Tea Party members need to be aware that racists could be using their movement to gain power, and that other Tea Party members motivations might be racially motivated. Being aware of this means they can avoid advancing ideas that are bad, and that they don't actually support. In other words, they have to admit the problem to prevent themselves from being used.

Denying the problem is the worst thing to do.
 
Tea Party members need to be aware that racists could be using their movement to gain power, and that other Tea Party members motivations might be racially motivated. Being aware of this means they can avoid advancing ideas that are bad, and that they don't actually support. In other words, they have to admit the problem to prevent themselves from being used.

Denying the problem is the worst thing to do.

While I see a lot of rank-and-file bickering over this issue, with quite a few teabaggers denying that there's any racism at all in their numbers, I don't see a problem with denial at a leadership level.

They are talking about it, they are denouncing it, they are taking actions when documented incidents occur.

I mean, really, what more do you want them to do? Specifically, what is it that you want them to do right now?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom