New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

Btw, I would just like to say that this is one of the most pleasant poli threads I've been on. I'm really enjoying trading views with folks like tyr_13 and johnny karate and others -- this is how it should be done... actually have a discussion and find out where we agree, where we disagree. Maybe there's hope after all.
 
I just read today that they're 81% white. The country is 75% white. So they're 8% whiter than the nation as a whole.

That's not really a huge difference there.

It does change drastically in different locations. I read a New York Times poll that showed about 1% of the Tea Party in New York to be black. That certainly plays out where I am located (south western New York). I'm assuming that there are a lot more black Tea Partiers in the south.


Or the poll was flawed.
 
Remember the Tea Party is a conservative movement and blacks (and other minorities) are less likely to be conservative or to have voted against Obama in particular. That they don't gravitate toward the Tea Party doesn't necessarily have anything to do with them not being welcome due to racism.
 
I don't often agree with cornsail, but here he's 100% correct. Why assume an evil racist conspiracy behind the "Tea Party" movement's behavior and makeup, when there are obvious and mundane explanations?
 
I don't often agree with cornsail, but here he's 100% correct. Why assume an evil racist conspiracy behind the "Tea Party" movement's behavior and makeup, when there are obvious and mundane explanations?

Because they keep saying racist things. Hence, it's perfectly reasonable to assume that an inchoate rage based on lies and misinformation, when coupled with racist talk, is based on racism.
 
I just read today that they're 81% white. The country is 75% white. So they're 8% whiter than the nation as a whole.

That's not really a huge difference there.

Granted, but my point was that the Tea Party is white, and middle-aged and conservative, and therefore not really representative of America as a whole as much as they seem to want to portray themselves.

I do not believe this is true.

What happened is that the 2008 campaign, especially the Palin nomination and rallies, caused middle-of-the-road conservatives to abandon the GOP.

And after the election, the far right fringe (tho not the extreme right fringe, which has always been outside the party system) gathered around the Tea Party banner.

So what's happened is that the GOP and the TP have become extremist.

That's not the same as saying that conservatives have become extremist, because right now most of us are not affiliated with either of those groups.

ETA: The numbers back me up here, btw. Last time I posted on this topic, only 21% of voters self-identified as Republicans, and the number of self-identifying Democrats declined slightly after the election, which means that those who abandoned the GOP did not become Democrats, they became independents.

Point taken. But when I referred to "mainstream conservatism", I was referring to the face of conservatism, which seems to be the GOP and the Tea Party. And we seem to agree that whether or not most conservatives are extreme, there is a definite movement by the extremists to hijack the conservative movement. The Tea Party very much strikes me as a big part of that movement.

Well, your first paragraph there doesn't make sense to me. It sounds like you're saying what I'm saying -- they were simply angry at the war and wanted it to end immediately, without thinking through the issue of whether or not that was possible or would actually save lives.

There's a big difference between wanting to stop a war without considering the consequences of doing so, and saying things like "Don't steal from Medicare to support socialized medicine" and "I want smaller government and my Social Security".

As for there being no right-wing opposition to Bush spending, that's simply a myth. Ever read a George Will column, for instance?

There may have been right wing opposition, but nothing on par with the Tea Party. Not even close.

And I hate to burst your bubble, but people of every stripe suffer from the syndrome of wanting gov't programs cut except the ones they benefit from. The "wasteful spending" is always happening somewhere else.

Give me examples of other people being as blatantly hypocritical as the Tea Party, and they shall also receive my derision.

You can't disavow behavior before the fact.

That's all there is to it.

And I'm not suggesting they should be able to. My point is that it's easy to disavow bad behavior once it's occurred, and is an expectation borne of political expediency.

And you can't stop nut jobs from freely associating with an open organization, or attending open events.

No, but you can, say, more thoroughly vet the candidate you're supporting for governor of New York.

But I simply cannot understand how you can claim that these incidents reflect badly on the group, given the fact that in each case the group publicly disavowed the behavior and/or statements and took steps against it (e.g., ejecting the offending party, cancelling speaking engagements, etc.).

These guys can't win with you, no matter what they do.

And I can make the contrary argument to you. You seem to have no limits in how far you'll bend over backwards to excuse them.

That said, there are valid studies indicating that there is indeed a racist element within the Tea Party, but that is bound to happen since the TP is opposed to the Obama administration, and so are anti-black racists, so of course they are going to gravitate toward that group.

And I think when such an element is known to exist, it's much less reasonable to write off incidents of racist behavior as anomalies.

The question, then, is: What is the group going to do about that.

From what we've seen here, they are doing something about it, by speaking up and by taking action against those who act on their racist ideas.

Asking them to somehow proactively vet everyone in the organization and make judgments about their level of racism and kick out the ones who don't pass the bar -- that's simply impossible.

And again, the degree to which the task is difficult is irrelevant. As far as I'm concerned the Tea Party can do nothing about it at all, if that's what they want. How they choose to handle their PR is entirely their business.

But what they can't do is complain when racist behavior occurs within their organization and people hold them accountable for it.
 
Why should they police freedom of expression? If someone wants to go to a protest and express offensive views in a nonviolent manner, that is their right. The error lies with those who use such incidents to generalize, not with the tea party for not "policing themselves better".

You can't proclaim freedom of expression for yourself, anf then deny it to others. Members of the Tea Party have every right to say racist things if they want, and I have every right to call them racists when they do so.

But I think you're missing my point. I'm not demanding they better police themselves. I don't really care if they do. I'm suggesting they do if they want people to stop assoctating them with racisms.

Do you think Reverend Wright's views reflected his church as a whole, thus proving Obama is really an America hating racist, as some conservatives argued incessantly during the election? This strikes me as the same kind of guilt by association / mudslinging politics that I've seen used against Obama (including by some Tea Partiers -- ironic, I guess).

Well, the difference here is you're taking the behavior of one specific person and trying to tie it to the opinions of another specific person by virtue of the fact they were both associated with the same church.

There have been numerous incidents of racist behavior, at many levels, within the Tea Party. Based on that, some people have speculated the organization as a whole might be racist.

How do you know that?

Bush's spending and expansion of government are a matter of record.

Are you saying white middle-aged conservatives can be fairly branded as racists? Sorry if I'm misreading you there, I'm just not seeing the point.

No, but as group I think it's fair to say they are more likely to be racist than most other demographics. And I think the Tea Party polling data speaks for itself. They may not be hardcore Mississippi Burning racists, but they certainly seem to have their issues with minorities.

Remember the bail outs started near the end of the Bush administration. Most conservatives I know were against them under both Bush and Obama.

And even though that bail out was passed on October 2008, the first Tea Party rally to protest it wasn't until it was implemeted. Which just happened to be right after Obama took office.
 
Btw, I would just like to say that this is one of the most pleasant poli threads I've been on. I'm really enjoying trading views with folks like tyr_13 and johnny karate and others -- this is how it should be done... actually have a discussion and find out where we agree, where we disagree. Maybe there's hope after all.

I agree with this sentiment. For a fascist partisan wingnut, Piggy seems like an decent chap. ;)
 
Remember the Tea Party is a conservative movement and blacks (and other minorities) are less likely to be conservative or to have voted against Obama in particular. That they don't gravitate toward the Tea Party doesn't necessarily have anything to do with them not being welcome due to racism.

I don't often agree with cornsail, but here he's 100% correct. Why assume an evil racist conspiracy behind the "Tea Party" movement's behavior and makeup, when there are obvious and mundane explanations?

I don't think it has to be trumped up to an "Evil Racist Conspiracy" in order for reasonable people to look at the polling data and observe their behavior to conclude race might be an issue with the Tea Party.

I'm not particulary comfortable labeling them as a racist organization, and I acknowledge the fallacy of holding the whole responsible for the behavior of the few.

But the fact of the matter is, these people exploded on the scene and forced themselves into the spotlight without taking the time to consider what kind of fringe elements they might find themselves standing next to while the cameras were rolling. They screamed at the top of their lungs for attention without bothering to have anything particularly coherent to say.

And now they're unhappy with some of the scrutiny they've been receiving.

Be careful what you wish for, I guess.
 
Last edited:
Remember the Tea Party is a conservative movement and blacks (and other minorities) are less likely to be conservative or to have voted against Obama in particular. That they don't gravitate toward the Tea Party doesn't necessarily have anything to do with them not being welcome due to racism.

I agree. One cannot simply look at a group, observe no minorities, and assume it's due to bigotry. Said bigotry must actually take place.

I don't often agree with cornsail, but here he's 100% correct. Why assume an evil racist conspiracy behind the "Tea Party" movement's behavior and makeup, when there are obvious and mundane explanations?

I certainly don't assume an 'evil racist conspiracy' being the Tea Party(s). There might be evil racist conspiracies inside the Tea Party, but then again, their might be evil anarchist conspiracies inside anti-war protests, evil theocratic conspiracies inside the Republican party, and evil communist conspiracies inside the Democratic party. It's actual evidence of such conspiracies that are important, not the possibility of them. It is certainly worth noting how various groups can be used of course.
 
Because they keep saying racist things.

(Shrug)

Go to every anti-war protest and find people saying pro-communism things.

Therefore, by your logic, the anti-war protests were really a front for the communist party takeover of the USA.
 
But the fact of the matter is, these people exploded on the scene and forced themselves into the spotlight without taking the time to consider what kind of fringe elements they might find themselves standing next to while the cameras were rolling. They screamed at the top of their lungs for attention without bothering to have anything particularly coherent to say.

That's certainly true, but just because some loonies joined for the attention and the media naturally concentrated on them, doesn't mean we should be doing the same.
 
That's certainly true, but just because some loonies joined for the attention and the media naturally concentrated on them, doesn't mean we should be doing the same.

Then what should we be concentrating on?

I submit that the reason there is a tendency to associate the Tea Party movement with racism is two-fold:

1) There have been numerous incidents of racist behavior among their ranks.

2) They don't seem to be about anything other than inarticulate anger.

So when you look at 2) you naturally have to wonder what are these people about. And then you go back to 1)...

If the Tea Party had a coherent message besides conveniently-timed fiscal responsibility or the elimination of all social programs except theirs, I doubt they'd have as much of an image problem.
 
His questions don't show racial bias, rather desire for a small government. And the question is do you support the tea party. A lot of Republican's now support the movement but do not align with the tea party. The director admits this here;
Another reason to proceed with caution is that I don't have an item that directly measures tea party membership. Indeed, support for the tea party isn't the same as accounting for group membership much less group identification, both if which tend to powerfully predict attitudes and behavior. With that in mind, it's entirely possible that I've underestimated the effect of the tea party on political attitudes, and will likely do so in future analysis on its effect on political behavior.

Those who agree with the tea party are shown to total 65%. On that note, do you think the tea party is 65% of the the population? No. Then how can 65% of this group be considered tea party members?
 
Then what should we be concentrating on?

I submit that the reason there is a tendency to associate the Tea Party movement with racism is two-fold:

Media slandering and gross misrepresentation.

1) There have been numerous incidents of racist behavior among their ranks.

Show these numerous incidents. All I've ever seen is one sign that equates tax payers to N-ar's and a Republican with only a connection to one guy in the tea party. There has been, however, attempts to equate non-racist signs with racism.

2) They don't seem to be about anything other than inarticulate anger.

Nothing like fallacy in argument. Google a tea party page and read. Otherwise you are talking out your arse.

So when you look at 2) you naturally have to wonder what are these people about. And then you go back to 1)...

If you look a 2) it takes two seconds to realize you don't know what you are talking about.

If the Tea Party had a coherent message besides conveniently-timed fiscal responsibility or the elimination of all social programs except theirs, I doubt they'd have as much of an image problem.

Watch The View today and listen to the coherent, articulate woman explain to everyone why you are just slanderous and unacquainted.
 
Instead of snarkily assigning homework, why don't you just make an argument?

Who are the Tea Party and what do they stand for? Please be specific.
 
I find it strange... given that tea partiers as a whole get labeled racist bigots, and sometimes terrorists, or criminals because unsurprisingly, racists decided to take the cowardly approach of hiding behind a legitimate movement to slander others. Meanwhile anarchists cowardly hide behind protesters in Greece angered by their own internal financial woes to commit arson and in any way possible disrupt peaceful protests and that the media is suddenly able to make a distinction between a radical fringe infiltration and peaceful participants.

Anyone else having a little trouble with this?

I find it strange... given that tea partiers as a whole get labeled racist bigots, and sometimes terrorists, or criminals because unsurprisingly, racists decided to take the cowardly approach of hiding behind a legitimate movement to slander others. Meanwhile anarchists cowardly hide behind protesters in Greece angered by their own internal financial woes to commit arson and in any way possible disrupt peaceful protests and that the media is suddenly able to make a distinction between a radical fringe infiltration and peaceful participants.

Anyone else having a little trouble with this?

Instead of snarkily assigning homework, why don't you just make an argument?

Who are the Tea Party and what do they stand for? Please be specific.
If I made the argument that the protests in Greece were orchestrated by anarchists, and I sought to prove this point by showing you every picture I could find of anarchists infiltrating the crowds, and setting things on fire, and attacking police, what would your response be? I suggest when you think about that answer you consider why people might have a problem with ongoing arguments that the tea party is racist.
 
Last edited:
There's a big difference between wanting to stop a war without considering the consequences of doing so, and saying things like "Don't steal from Medicare to support socialized medicine" and "I want smaller government and my Social Security".

I still beg to differ. And perhaps we'll just have to agree to disagree here. The "end the war now" crowd, it seems to me, were reacting emotionally to the horror of war and they simply wanted it to stop right away.

But in doing so, they failed to consider that the response they advocated could very well cause even more death and horror than not doing so.

Both are cases in which emotional responses blind people to contradictions in their positions.
 
And I'm not suggesting they should be able to. My point is that it's easy to disavow bad behavior once it's occurred, and is an expectation borne of political expediency.

But that's no kind of point at all.

You've got them in a no-win situation.

When a few members exhibit racist tendencies, the movement as a whole rejects that, and you call it "political expediency".

When you take that point of view, there is literally nothing that the group can do to avoid an accusation of racism.

Since they can't stop racists from self-affiliating, and since some racists are bound to be attracted to the group simply because they oppose Obama, these incidents are bound to happen.

The only thing they can do is handle it when it comes up, so we should be judging the movement as a whole on how they handle it.

You refuse to do that.

That screams bias on your part.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom