New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

And I can make the contrary argument to you. You seem to have no limits in how far you'll bend over backwards to excuse them.

Excuse who?

I'm not excusing anyone who has made racist comments. And the ones who repudiate those persons don't need to be excused for anything.
 
And again, the degree to which the task is difficult is irrelevant. As far as I'm concerned the Tea Party can do nothing about it at all, if that's what they want. How they choose to handle their PR is entirely their business.

But what they can't do is complain when racist behavior occurs within their organization and people hold them accountable for it.

I didn't say difficult, I said impossible. There's a difference.

There are left-wing nutjob agitators, too, who show up at Democratic events, as well, and there's nothing anyone can do to prevent that, either.

Yet they can indeed complain when they actually take steps to condemn racist acts by members, and remove those members and not support them, and yet they get tarred with the same brush as if they had done nothing, or cheered them on.
 
I find it strange... given that tea partiers as a whole get labeled racist bigots, and sometimes terrorists, or criminals because unsurprisingly, racists decided to take the cowardly approach of hiding behind a legitimate movement to slander others. Meanwhile anarchists cowardly hide behind protesters in Greece angered by their own internal financial woes to commit arson and in any way possible disrupt peaceful protests and that the media is suddenly able to make a distinction between a radical fringe infiltration and peaceful participants.


Anyone else having a little trouble with this?

You're only scratching the surface here. Relatively speaking, the "bad apples" numbers are significantly higher in the US TP movement than in the Greek demos. Also, as colorful a 20th century as Greece had [and remembers], USA's 20th century represents a constant discombobulating of race relations within a nation only a few decades removed from hardcore, in-your-face slavery.

eta: then you throw a Kenyan into the mix...

I don't know about you, but if I was at a 300 strong rally for X, and I saw tens and tens of racist placards being swung about by a disproportionate number of folks from the "opposite race," and I noticed that the 300 strong was disproportionately of the "opposite race," I'd re-assess my purpose for being at rally X...


If I made the argument that the protests in Greece were orchestrated by anarchists, and I sought to prove this point by showing you every picture I could find of anarchists infiltrating the crowds, and setting things on fire, and attacking police, what would your response be? I suggest when you think about that answer you consider why people might have a problem with ongoing arguments that the tea party is racist.

...And if my purpose was not racist, I would then have 2 obvious options: Change the group or leave the group.

...But if my purpose was racist, only the more trendy "casual" flavor of racism currently en vogue in the 'States, I'd welcome the hardcores to do the heavy lifting while I mumbled something something socialism.

The numbers are in: http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/289821
The eyewitness accounts are in: http://www.npr.org/templates/player...n=1&t=1&islist=false&id=126045755&m=126045751

Anyone else having a little trouble with this?
 
Last edited:
You can't proclaim freedom of expression for yourself, anf then deny it to others. Members of the Tea Party have every right to say racist things if they want, and I have every right to call them racists when they do so.

No, I meant Tea Party members cannot really "police" the people who show up to their protests. If it's a public protest they can't just force people to leave, because they have an offensive sign or something.

But I think you're missing my point. I'm not demanding they better police themselves. I don't really care if they do. I'm suggesting they do if they want people to stop assoctating them with racisms.

I realize that. I'm, in contrast, suggesting that that shouldn't/can't.

Bush's spending and expansion of government are a matter of record.

I meant how do you know Tea Party members had no problem with Bush's spending?

No, but as group I think it's fair to say they are more likely to be racist than most other demographics. And I think the Tea Party polling data speaks for itself. They may not be hardcore Mississippi Burning racists, but they certainly seem to have their issues with minorities.

I think the polling data indicates they are slightly more racist than average white Americans, but not by much. Not enough to make sweeping generalizations. It's fair to say that some of them have issues with minorities.

And even though that bail out was passed on October 2008, the first Tea Party rally to protest it wasn't until it was implemeted. Which just happened to be right after Obama took office.
Like I said, that probably has more to do with people like Glenn Beck than individuals who chose to attend the rally.
 
...And if my purpose was not racist, I would then have 2 obvious options: Change the group or leave the group.

...But if my purpose was racist, only the more trendy "casual" flavor of racism currently en vogue in the 'States, I'd welcome the hardcores to do the heavy lifting while I mumbled something something socialism.

I certainly agree, but there's no need to quote a part of the post you're not addressing. Sorry... but seriously, this has absolutely no correlation with the question I was askin Johnny Karate, not the slightest.

What you're doing, is regurgitating statistics that have been established for several decades already with different wording, and dare I say suggesting that the disproportionately white demographic either makes the Republican Party, or the tea party movement inherently racist, or racist leaning.

The civil rights movement had the support of democratic presidents, which helped to accelerate the switch from overwhelmingly republican to the exact opposite we have today, but a large chunk of that demographic shift started with Roosevelt's social programs expanding to minorities. And the social programs which the party advocates is largely responsible for today's demographics. The civil rights issues of the early 20th century did leverage this, but the support tends to lend itself more to the politics than it does to the race.

So short answer, the spread isn't surprising. And the history explains why it happened. If you're going to suggest that demographics have a hand at this consider that prior to the civil rights movement groups like the Ku Klux Klan were overwhelmingly white, southern democrats. So you'll have to forgive me if I don't see the same significance in the race criterion for party affiliation spread that you do from that poll. I'll defer hat information to a party which doesn't have as much of an interpretive bias.
 
Last edited:
Instead of snarkily assigning homework, why don't you just make an argument?

Who are the Tea Party and what do they stand for? Please be specific.

You obviously need to do some homework. Instead of claiming the tea party is incoherent, illiterate racists why don't you compile an argument.

​
 
Last edited:
The survey was done by ABC / Washington Post, released May 5th. I believed them because they are reputable news outlets with no motivation that I know of to risk their reputations by fudging data on this particular question.

Got any contrary evidence to that number, besides your little roll-eye guy?

How many Tea Party events do you attend every month, so that you know how "rare" it is to see non-white persons there? More than the CNN reporters who stated last month, after going to quite a few of them, that there's more minority attendance than is popularly believed?

Would you care to cite these racist quotations from Tea Party "leaders" -- along with the reaction of others within the movement to what they said?

As for the racist signs, how common are they at Tea Party events -- i.e., what percentage of attendees carry them -- and what is the response of the majority of teabaggers to them?

Now, here's some more data from the survey (as reported by CNN) which may be a little more illuminating than your idle speculation:


Here's all the data you need. 8 people in the poll said they were active tea party members. 87% of those said tea party is not racist. The remaining 13% (one person) said the tea party is motivated by racism. So now the slanderous media claims 10% of all tea party is racist, and you believe them. Based on one person. Absolutely ridiculous.
 
If "numerous instances of racism" were the issue, then the anti-war movement in the USA would have been roundly condemned by the media due to "numerous cases of support of terrorism among their ranks", or the protesters in Greece similarly condemned by the media due to "numerous cases of support of violent communist revolution within their ranks".

But neither was the case about reports about either group. Nor was there much criticism of those movements for failing to condemn such fringes. But with the Tea Party folks, every loon with a sign becomes "one of the numerous cases of racism", becoming more and more "numerous" mostly due to media reports recycling them endlessly.

As for the message -- the same applies. Did the average anti-war protester have a coherent message apart from "Bush sucks!"? Does the average Greek protester have a coherent message apart from "I want the government to continue to pay me money for nothing!"? Not really. Angry protesters, about any issue, are not exactly known for the subtlety of their message.

And yet those other groups are taken quite seriously, with media personalities falling over themselves to explain in detail, in the most sophisticated and articulate manner possible, what the protesters really mean.

It is only when it comes to the Tea Party folks -- whose message is "government is getting too much power and disrespecting the Constitution", which is quite a reasonable reason to protest if one believes it is true -- that there is no such effort to understand, and the whole protest is dismissed with "I don't know what they're talking about. Do you, dear viewer? They must be racists or something."

There's an obvious double standard here, leading to circular reasoning.

"Left-wing" protesters just have to be good and noble, so every effort is made to make them look as good as possible, minimize their fringe element, and portray their (supposed) political message in the best possible light. "Right-wing" protesters just have to be stupid or evil (otherwise they won't be right-wing, you see), so every effort is made to find the evil "undercurrent of racism" or emphasize the alleged the "stupid contradictions" or "vacuousness" in their views.

But how does one know that all those right-wing protesters just have to be are stupid and evil and those left-wing ones noble and good in the first place? Why can't you see how the left-wingers are mostly sane and have a reasonable, articulate message, while the right-wingers are stupid racists? Just look at our own reports!

This circular reasoning -- first you find only the "left-wing good, right-wing bad" evidence your blinders allow you to find, and then the very same "evidence" is used to further entrench your conviction the blinders are just "being objective" -- is very common in the media.

Only today, with the internet, it is quite easy to see it's often not accurate, as in the case of these "shocking studies" trumpeted by the media about the Tea Party's "racism", that actually show nothing -- as the article from "reason" magazine notes -- except for the fact that the Tea Party are similar to Americans in general in all except being (duh) more conservative.

I am no big fan of the "Tea Party" movement. I don't think it's particularly articulate or important. But then again, neither are the "Bush sucks!" protesters or the Greek anarchists particularly noble.

What is important about the whole thing is that the widespread, indeed unconscious and automatic, double standard in the mainstream media's treatment of protesters from different groups -- is even more clear than it was before, to all who do not wear the MSM's blinders.

As (I believe) Roger Kimball of the New Criterion predicted, the minute Obama was elected, then as far as the media is concerned, dissent would no longer be the "highest form of patriotism", but merely the "highest form of racism".Kimball was 100% correct -- still, no fair giving him JREF's millions, obvious predictions don't count.

Still, I believe, he missed something. It is true accusations of racism became automatic against every opposition to Obama (I mean, Republicans opposing a Democratic president's policies??? They're just saying that because he's Black!), but the "racist" card was so overused so often that nobody takes such accusations seriously anymore. "Racist!" today means roughly "I disagree with you about that".

Many in the media cannot understand this: they keep accusing Tea Parties and other conservatives of racism, this most horrible of crimes, and yet this has no seeming effect on their popularity! What does hurt their popularity is the usual things -- stupid leaders or sex scandals, for instance. How can Republicans care so much about such things and not care about their AWFUL RACISM?

Their "solution" is that the only explanation is that there is a "deep undercurrent of racism" in America (the same America that a year ago elected a black president in an overwhelming way), and that conservatives are all "hypocrites" for caring about candidate X's extra-marital affair and not about his "racist" statements.

That perhaps people don't take their "racist!" accusations any more because they keep calling everybody who disagrees with left-wing politics "racist" never occurs to them.
 
I certainly agree, but there's no need to quote a part of the post you're not addressing. Sorry... but seriously, this has absolutely no correlation with the question I was askin Johnny Karate, not the slightest.

Hm. I see how I could have been much clearer back there. My fault. :)

What I was trying to do is hold up your manipulated data hypothetical next to my first person hypothetical. The point being that in the case of the Tea Party, its coverage by the media has not been manipulated to any significant degree. The footage, the websites, the first person testimonials - these things are pretty damn entertaining in and of themselves. There is no need for the media to exaggerate. I then took it a step further in examining the mum nature of the so-called "non-racist majority" of the teabaggers, the "non-fringers." Why don't they speak out against the fringe, boot them out, and take control of the Tea Party [if indeed they are truly are the majority?]


What you're doing, is regurgitating statistics that have been established for several decades already with different wording, and dare I say suggesting that the disproportionately white demographic either makes the Republican Party, or the tea party movement inherently racist, or racist leaning.

To your first point, not really. The two links I posted are from 2010, each with relevant data and first person testimony that speaks directly to this thread - which has to do primarily with the current state of affairs. To your second point, not at all. I never suggested anything about the GOP. To clarify, I believe only racist people are inherently racist/racist leaning. They can be black, hispanic, asian, white, etc. In the case of this Tea Party though, the bitter truth is that the vast majority of them are indeed racist and white. Some are brazen about it, while others remain casual, discreet.


The civil rights movement had the support of democratic presidents, which helped to accelerate the switch from overwhelmingly republican to the exact opposite we have today, but a large chunk of that demographic shift started with Roosevelt's social programs expanding to minorities. And the social programs which the party advocates is largely responsible for today's demographics. The civil rights issues of the early 20th century did leverage this, but the support tends to lend itself more to the politics than it does to the race.

So short answer, the spread isn't surprising. And the history explains why it happened. If you're going to suggest that demographics have a hand at this consider that prior to the civil rights movement groups like the Ku Klux Klan were overwhelmingly white, southern democrats. So you'll have to forgive me if I don't see the same significance in the race criterion for party affiliation spread that you do from that poll. I'll defer hat information to a party which doesn't have as much of an interpretive bias.

I'm not sure what you're asking/stating here. Could you clarify?
 
Wow, if only this type of reasoning had been used in the ACORN threads, by exactly the same people using the exact opposite reasoning then.

And before anyone says it, read what I've actually said in both threads and you'll find I'm fairly consistent.
 
Wow, if only this type of reasoning had been used in the ACORN threads, by exactly the same people using the exact opposite reasoning then.

And before anyone says it, read what I've actually said in both threads and you'll find I'm fairly consistent.

What ACORN thread?
 
As for the message -- the same applies. Did the average anti-war protester have a coherent message apart from "Bush sucks!"?

Of course they did. Maybe you weren't paying attention, but their message was:


  1. We have never before engaged in "pre-emptive" war. This is a bad idea, because it puts us in the role of aggressor.
  2. The evidence Bush is presenting for WMD in Iraq is suspect. If we're going to war, we need more evidence.
  3. Why not let the inspectors complete their work? They seem close to finding no WMD, so why not let them finish?
  4. Even if there are WMD, this war will cost too many lives in Iraq, and is therefore immoral.
  5. Even if there are WMD, this war will cost too much money, and is therefore irresponsible.
  6. Even if there are WMD, this war will cost too many US soldiers their lives, and therefore not worth it.
Now, I understand that conservatives will not agree with these arguments against the war, but it's ridiculous to claim they didn't exist at the time, when a cursory Google search will find thousands of articles arguing this.

All of these arguments were based on the reality that:


  1. Bush really was going to war.
  2. There really were no WMD.
  3. People really did die.
  4. We really did spend a trillion dollars on the effort.
Now, the rage against Obama is based on:

  1. He's raising our taxes!
  2. He's a socialist!
  3. He's a racist!
  4. He wants death panels!
  5. He's a secret muslim!
  6. He's not a US citizen and I want my country back!
How do those two protests compare?
 
  • Hm. I see how I could have been much clearer back there. My fault. :)
  • What I was trying to do is hold up your manipulated data hypothetical next to my first person hypothetical.
  • The point being that in the case of the Tea Party, its coverage by the media has not been manipulated to any significant degree. The footage, the websites, the first person testimonials - these things are pretty damn entertaining in and of themselves. There is no need for the media to exaggerate.
  • I then took it a step further in examining the mum nature of the so-called "non-racist majority" of the teabaggers, the "non-fringers." Why don't they speak out against the fringe, boot them out, and take control of the Tea Party [if indeed they are truly are the majority?]

  • To your first point, not really. The two links I posted are from 2010, each with relevant data and first person testimony that speaks directly to this thread - which has to do primarily with the current state of affairs. To your second point, not at all. I never suggested anything about the GOP. To clarify, I believe only racist people are inherently racist/racist leaning. They can be black, hispanic, asian, white, etc. In the case of this
    Tea Party though, the bitter truth is that the vast majority of them are indeed racist and white. Some are brazen about it, while others remain casual, discreet.
  • It's okay :)
  • Just as with any protest you will, regardless of the dominating principals behind them see idiots try to use the existing anger with government policy to leverage their own agendas. I don't doubt any of the testimonials, since as the Greek protests show, this happens. Leaders cannot control or police who joins these protests en mass. You cannot realistically expect a movement to be capable to eliminating fringe elements from acting on their own. What I would be more worried about, is if this radical racial sentiment began to contaminate the principals goals of the movement, something which I've yet to see.
  • I don't think it's an issue of whether they need to manipulate it or not. Part of news coverage is in the ratings, and one of the best ways to get ratings is to cater stories to your core audience. The mainstream media largely doesn't provide any attention to the movement and what bit it does usually seems to deal just with these kooks. Proof of this is the lack of coverage on their own websites of general party events, and the disproportionate attention that violent fringes are covered.
  • Expecting the tea party to denounce violence or racist epitomes... this has happened already, several times, whether they believed the events took place or not. If this isn't satisfactory then you need to express what is. I've had this discussion with several people already here, and none of them have been clear on their expectations.
  • The figures have been consistent since before the Clinton Administration, if not longer. The current state of affairs wrt to voter demographics and the correlation to tea party member demographics is therefore unsurprising, am I wrong about this having not changed significantly? Can you elaborate?
  • To your other point, yes the racists may be racist and white, but your reference to voter demographics is doing nothing to support the claim that the majority of these people comprise the tea party movement. Again the Ku Klux Klan was overwhelmingly white, southern democrats. I'm not sure how much a figure like that has changed since the civil rights movement, but if you're going to argue that a majority of a movement bases its beliefs on racist epitomes then something detailing this particular demographic might be more useful if available. Neither of your sources really make this point to begin with, and what I'm reading here looks more like your personal interpretation of the polling and commentary than anything else. The commentary provided by both differs substantially from what you're stating here.
 
Here's all the data you need. 8 people in the poll said they were active tea party members. 87% of those said tea party is not racist. The remaining 13% (one person) said the tea party is motivated by racism. So now the slanderous media claims 10% of all tea party is racist, and you believe them. Based on one person. Absolutely ridiculous.

Yup, they found the one guy. What luck, eh?
 
Who owned slaves.
Your American history is faulty. The ownership of slaves was not universal, nor for that matter was the institution of slavery universal in 1776 (indeed, the slavery issue was nearly a deal breaker between regions when the Declaration of Independence was being drafted/put to vote), though a general discrimination versus blacks you can argue, and I'll argue along with you.

Heck, an awful lot of the folks who fought in the militias, or in the Continental Army, or as irregulars, could not afford to buy nor keep slaves.

DR
 
Here's all the data you need. 8 people in the poll said they were active tea party members. 87% of those said tea party is not racist. The remaining 13% (one person) said the tea party is motivated by racism. So now the slanderous media claims 10% of all tea party is racist, and you believe them. Based on one person. Absolutely ridiculous.

I'm not sure where you are getting your information, but this tidbit is at the bottom of the poll.

The ABC News/Washington Post poll was conducted April 22-25 and questioned 1,001 adults by telephone. The survey's overall sampling error is plus or minus 3.5 percentage points.

The poll said that "8 percent" were active participants. That's 80 people, not 8. I didn't see the racism thing in that article anywhere, but here is another. My favorite part:

Nigel Coleman, who is black, leads the Danville TEA Party Patriots in southern Virginia. He said the fact that the movement is predominantly white doesn't mean it is inherently racist.

"I went to a wine festival yesterday," he said. "Weren't too many black people there, either. Nobody called them racists."

ETA - I just read the original post's Newsweek article, and that survey also had n over 1000. Unfortunately, they under-sampled whites, so that probably skews the data quite a bit. Half of respondents were non-white. I wonder why they did that?

The survey is drawn from a probability sample of 1006 cases, stratified by state.
 
Last edited:
If I made the argument that the protests in Greece were orchestrated by anarchists, and I sought to prove this point by showing you every picture I could find of anarchists infiltrating the crowds, and setting things on fire, and attacking police, what would your response be? I suggest when you think about that answer you consider why people might have a problem with ongoing arguments that the tea party is racist.

Would your argument also include polling data indicating the Greek protesters had anarchist tendencies? Would your argument also include some organizers of those Greek protests engaging in anarchist behavior?

To pretend that the argument that the Tea Party is racist is based solely on supposed rally infiltrators is a bit disingenuous.
 
Yup, they found the one guy. What luck, eh?

Yeah, now they get to claim 10% of tea partiers everywhere are racist, and your bias won't let you see that as a sham. Anyway, it is not a stretch to think that their opinion (like your's) is the product of media slander and sensationalism.

This poll is only evidence that the media is slanderous. Why would one answer from one person be such big news and why would they claim that 10% are racist across the country like it is a big ah-ha moment when they knew the 13% of the group equaled one person. Is that one guy that important? Is he the guy from the Dos Equis commercial? Or maybe he is Chuck Norris?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom