New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

So nice to base all these assumptions on polling 1000 people. Absurd.

The survey is drawn from a probability sample of 1006 cases

I took a poll, and it said this poll is full of crap.
 
How so? If you conducted a poll with the same respondents asking about how much they like NASCAR, you'd likely find the Tea Partiers would have a much greater affinity towards NASCAR than the middle-of-the-roaders. Is that evidence that the Tea Party is motivated by a love of auto racing?

Well, no. Primarily because auto-racing plays absolutely no role in the current political climate. With a black president in office, however, race is clearly a factor.

Now, one could make the argument that an organization with a demonstrable resentment towards black people doesn't let that resentment influence their opinion of Obama, but it would be a pretty flimsy one.
 
So nice to base all these assumptions on polling 1000 people. Absurd.

That's right! Since they didn't call ME at MY house, the results are garbage!

P.S. polling methodologies are also garbage if they don't take the time to survey each of the 6 billion + of us...

:rolleyes:
 
While not necessarily proving the Tea Party to be racist, it certainly makes a strong case against one of the Tea Party's most vocal arguments: That they are not racially motivated.
So you believe that if Hillary were president, and took the exact same political actions as Obama, there would be no Tea Party as such?
 
So you believe that if Hillary were president, and took the exact same political actions as Obama, there would be no Tea Party as such?

No, but I think it would be smaller. Do you think if McCain/Palin had won and took the same actions as Obama had taken there would still be a Tea Party? Considering there really wasn't one under Bush I knida doubt it.
 
So you believe that if Hillary were president, and took the exact same political actions as Obama, there would be no Tea Party as such?

The Teabaggers are a creation of Freedom Works. They are run by Dick Armey, hyped by Fox News, and exist to elect Republicans.

So yes, if Hillary Clinton were president, they'd exist.
 
So you believe that if Hillary were president, and took the exact same political actions as Obama, there would be no Tea Party as such?

Who knows. But considering that the Tea Party sprung up immediately after Obama too office, and didn't exist during the financial irresponsibility of the Bush years, it's really hard for me to believe that it's all about fiscal conservatism for them.
 
Who knows. But considering that the Tea Party sprung up immediately after Obama too office, and didn't exist during the financial irresponsibility of the Bush years, it's really hard for me to believe that it's all about fiscal conservatism for them.

But you're missing the much more obvious explanations:

1). They are (as the article I linked to noted) conservatives (duh), and they therefore liked Bush's policies on many issues even if they disliked his financial policies, while they don't like Obama's other policies, either;

2). As long as a Republican had a chance to be elected, they were careful not to oppose a Republican president too vocally so as to not hurt the republican candidate's chances.

What race has to do with this? Nothing, that's what. People getting all pissed off when the opposing party's candidate does something when they were quiet before when their own guy did it is an American tradition.

The problem with such accusations is that they're easy to make and impossible to disprove. Remember all those who were fascinated by Obama during the election campaign? A lot of them had never felt the need to support any candidate nearly as strongly as they supported Obama. Does this waiting until the first Black serious candidate were in the running to get politically involved mean they are secretly haters of White people?

"It's hard for me to believe it's all about political activism for them". There just has to be some racist reason for their behavior!
 
Last edited:
So you believe that if Hillary were president, and took the exact same political actions as Obama, there would be no Tea Party as such?

Tell me, under which white presidents was there such a thing as the Tea Party in living memory?

Well, under Hillary we´d probably have a "women should stay in the kitchen" sort of Tea Party rather than a "blacks should stay in the slums" sort of Tea Party.
 
Tell me, under which white presidents was there such a thing as the Tea Party in living memory?
This is the first time the "Tea Party" has ever protested the government in power. It must be because Obama is black! Science!
 
That's right! Since they didn't call ME at MY house, the results are garbage!

P.S. polling methodologies are also garbage if they don't take the time to survey each of the 6 billion + of us...

:rolleyes:

Too bad you are blinded by your own dogma. If you weren't you would have seen the meaning that the sample is way too small for any meaningful results. I see you've made 2 more ludicrous assumptions. Thanks for playing.:rolleyes:
 
Tell me, under which white presidents was there such a thing as the Tea Party in living memory?

You seem to have forgotten the "Bush is a murderous thug election-stealer who will make the USA into a theocratic dictatorship" folks of the last 8 years or so.

MAD magazine had an article about what the "magic 8 ball" novelty toy SHOULD have had as "answers" to anybody stupid enough to think shaking a plastic ball with dice in it will give them answers to life's problems.

The answers included "what part of 'NO' didn't you understand?", for example. Another one was "you're only saying that because I'm black".

Rather relevant to this thread, I think.

Well, under Hillary we´d probably have a "women should stay in the kitchen" sort of Tea Party rather than a "blacks should stay in the slums" sort of Tea Party.

Yes, because these folks just hate women in positions of power, as can be seen by their disgust and hatred of Sarah Palin.
 
As "reason" magazine pointed out, it's the usual case of lying with statistics.

Interesting read. Thanks for the link.

However, the "lying with statistics" charge is a bit of reach, at least as applied to the overall study. It certainly puts the racial stereotyping aspects into better perspective, but the charges of "racial resentment" still stand, and only seem to get rationalization offered as a refutation.
 
Too bad you are blinded by your own dogma. If you weren't you would have seen the meaning that the sample is way too small for any meaningful results. I see you've made 2 more ludicrous assumptions. Thanks for playing.:rolleyes:
What is your background in polling and statistics to back up that claim? Do you have evidence that a polling size of 1000 is not sufficient for meaningful results?
 
However, the "lying with statistics" charge is a bit of reach, at least as applied to the overall study. It certainly puts the racial stereotyping aspects into better perspective, but the charges of "racial resentment" still stand, and only seem to get rationalization offered as a refutation.

Well, those rationalizations are refutations in many cases, since apparently the study makers are deeply troubled by the popularity of such "racist" statements as "Blacks need to get ahead by their own efforts and without special help like other minority groups". That would make, to name one, Martin Luther King Jr. a "racist".

Not everything that doesn't fit the progressive dogma du jour is "racial resentment" -- as can be seen by the fact that same attitudes are expressed with almost the same numbers in the general American population. This either means practically all Americans are deeply "racist", or else that the definition of "racist" had become so wide as to be meaningless.

In any case, all it "proves" about the Tea Party movement is that its members are the same as Americans in general -- with the one exception of being (duh) more politically conservative. It actually gives a picture that is far closer to their own self-description as "just average Americans" than to their opponents' view of them as some racist fringe.
 
But you're missing the much more obvious explanations:

1). They are (as the article I linked to noted) conservatives (duh), and they therefore liked Bush's policies on many issues even if they disliked his financial policies, while they don't like Obama's other policies, either;

2). As long as a Republican had a chance to be elected, they were careful not to oppose a Republican president too vocally so as to not hurt the republican candidate's chances.

And if the Tea Party presented themselves as a conservative, anti-Democrat political movement instead of a grass-roots populist movement I wouldn't have as much of a problem with them.

What race has to do with this? Nothing, that's what. People getting all pissed off when the opposing party's candidate does something when they were quiet before when their own guy did it is an American tradition.

The problem with such accusations is that they're easy to make and impossible to disprove. Remember all those who were fascinated by Obama during the election campaign? A lot of them had never felt the need to support any candidate nearly as strongly as they supported Obama. Does this waiting until the first Black serious candidate were in the running to get politically involved mean they are secretly haters of White people?

"It's hard for me to believe it's all about political activism for them". There just has to be some racist reason for their behavior!

And something important you seem to be forgetting: The numerous incidents of racism, or at least racial insensitivity, that occur in the Tea Party, often at the leadership level (some of which I cited in this post). And everytime it happens we get the same lame excuse about how the person involved doesn't represent the "real" Tea Party and that they've been immediately expunged.

Let me be clear: I don't think the Tea Party as an organization is necessarily racist. What I think they are, as indicated by the polling data, are self-entitled, reactionary white conservatives who respond with fear and ignorance to anything outside of their comfort zone.
 
You seem to have forgotten the "Bush is a murderous thug election-stealer who will make the USA into a theocratic dictatorship" folks of the last 8 years or so.

And to what degree were these people given legitimacy by the support and sponsorship of a national news networks and prominent Democratic politicians?
 
Of those, only 35% believe Blacks to be hardworking, only 45 % believe Blacks are intelligent, and only 41% think that Blacks are trustworthy. Perceptions of Latinos aren’t much different. While 54% of White Tea Party supporters believe Latinos to be hardworking, only 44% think them intelligent, and even fewer, 42% of Tea Party supporters believe Latinos to be trustworthy.
This is deeply misleading -- "lying with statistics" -- because it makes two crucial omissions.

1). The first omission is that the American population in general also thinks this way in almost exactly the same numbers about Blacks and Latinos, as the link to "Reason" magazine above shows. It is perhaps worrying that such attitudes are common, but if they are, they have nothing to do with the "Tea Party" and much to do with Americans in general.

2). The link deliberately "forgets" to notice that the "racist" Tea Party member have -- again, just like Americans in general -- positive stereotypes about other minority groups, in particular about Asians (and, IIRC, Jews as well, but I am tired and my memory playing tricks on me) -- considering them more hardworking and trustworthy than themselves.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom