New Study Shows Tea Partiers more likely to be racist.

And to what degree were these people given legitimacy by the support and sponsorship of a national news networks and prominent Democratic politicians?

You're kidding, right?

Let's start with Harper's, a once-respected mainstream magazine, buying into apparently every "evil Bush" conspiracy; Michael Moore, who was the de facto guest of honor in the DNC in 2004; Dan Rather falling for the "fake but accurate" Bush AWOL memos...

...well, you get the point.

There is a recent book, United in Hate, which, while hardly objective, lists numerous other examples of prominent democrats and/or media personalities supporting the "insurgents" -- a term which is itself a form of media manipulation, since these oh-so-sensitive folks didn't want to hurt the feeling of the poor dears by calling them "terrorists" like they are -- and calling for America's defeat.
 
Well, those rationalizations are refutations in many cases, since apparently the study makers are deeply troubled by the popularity of such "racist" statements as "Blacks need to get ahead by their own efforts and without special help like other minority groups". That would make, to name one, Martin Luther King Jr. a "racist".

Not everything that doesn't fit the progressive dogma du jour is "racial resentment" -- as can be seen by the fact that same attitudes are expressed with almost the same numbers in the general American population. This either means practically all Americans are deeply "racist", or else that the definition of "racist" had become so wide as to be meaningless.

In any case, all it "proves" about the Tea Party movement is that its members are the same as Americans in general -- with the one exception of being (duh) more politically conservative. It actually gives a picture that is far closer to their own self-description as "just average Americans" than to their opponents' view of them as some racist fringe.


This only seemed to be the case regarding racial stereotyping, not "racial resentment":
Compared to middle-of-the-road whites, Tea Party supporters show far more agreement with the statement that blacks should work their way up "without special favors" the way other minorities such as Italians and Jews did, or that blacks would be as well off as whites if they worked harder.
Of course, the argument then comes down to what this means. Is it really "racial resentment" or just a natural extension of the conservative philosophy?

The problem with simply shrugging it off as the conservative mindset of self-reliance is the stark hypocrisy Tea Partiers have expressed regarding social programs from which they benefit:
The New York Times said:
But in follow-up interviews, Tea Party supporters said they did not want to cut Medicare or Social Security — the biggest domestic programs, suggesting instead a focus on “waste.”

Some defended being on Social Security while fighting big government by saying that since they had paid into the system, they deserved the benefits.

Others could not explain the contradiction.

“That’s a conundrum, isn’t it?” asked Jodine White, 62, of Rocklin, Calif. “I don’t know what to say. Maybe I don’t want smaller government. I guess I want smaller government and my Social Security."

Source.

So they don't seem to mind "special favors" from the government so long as they're the beneficiaries.

Does this mean they're racists? Not necessarily. But like I've stated before, it certainly means they're self-entitled. And self-entitled people will lash out at anyone who is not them taking what they believe is rightfully theirs. When those self-entitled people happen to be white, middle-aged conservatives, it's sometimes hard to distinguish such behavior from plain, old racism.
 
The Tea Party people are the same people who supported Pat Buchannan, Ross Perot, and Ron Paul at the polls.

A generation earlier they voted for George Wallace and cheered when the Hard Hats chased the hippies in NYC and the National Guard shot the demonstrators at Kent State.

They are the descendants of the patriots of 1776 and they want their country back.
 
This is the first time the "Tea Party" has ever protested the government in power. It must be because Obama is black! Science!

Well, why is this the first time? Do you think there was nothing to protest about under Bush I or Clinton or Bush II?

What do you think why the Ku Klux Klan appeared only after blacks were supposed to be given some rights in the South? Nothing to do with racism, either?
 
Well, why is this the first time? Do you think there was nothing to protest about under Bush I or Clinton or Bush II?

What do you think why the Ku Klux Klan appeared only after blacks were supposed to be given some rights in the South? Nothing to do with racism, either?

It couldn't possibly be that they honestly disagree with the policies and such proposed by the current people in government.

Nope, it's just cuz they hate the darkies.
 
Nope, it's just cuz they hate the darkies.

While I am reading this with a sarcastic voice in my mind, I'd just like to point out that this is a public internet forum, and it is by no means instantly apparent what tone of voice you are using.
 
Too bad you are blinded by your own dogma. If you weren't you would have seen the meaning that the sample is way too small for any meaningful results. I see you've made 2 more ludicrous assumptions. Thanks for playing.:rolleyes:

My roll-eyes was not for your politics but on your calling-out of this poll. I know that we haven't always agreed on everything, but I've often at least respected the manner in which you present your arguments.

That's why I was confused by your statement:

So nice to base all these assumptions on polling 1000 people.

Perhaps I was overly glib in my retort, but you're aware of these things as much as we are. So, to back it up a step...

... What do you believe it is about a sample size of 1006 that renders anything meaningless? They provide their error margin, post the methodology and actual results, meaning that if we wanted to do a separate analysis of the numbers, we could. That would be quite labour intensive, so please, before anyone here tries, explain what you find to be wrong with the methodology.

Or, demonstrate at least why certain results/assumptions/conclusions are too general to be drawn directly from the results.

...

ETA: For clarification

I have not read this poll, and haven't thoroughly considered the results. I'm not even sure if I will. What I was teasing you about was the "1000 isn't big enough," thing. I'm sorry, but it sounded a lot like cranky folks who act and comment as if statistical models have not been used to represent society time after time successfully. It had echoes of a head-in-the-sand type of comment, "the world doesn't operate statistically." Yet, demonstrably, it does. I actually don't know what your general positions are on polling and statistics...
 
Last edited:
It couldn't possibly be that they honestly disagree with the policies and such proposed by the current people in government.

Nope, it's just cuz they hate the darkies.

Again... why did no Tea Party appear under Bush I, Clinton or Bush II?

Exactly by what does Obama differ from these three, except by skin color and foreign-sounding name?
 
While I am reading this with a sarcastic voice in my mind, I'd just like to point out that this is a public internet forum, and it is by no means instantly apparent what tone of voice you are using.
Fair point, and it was sarcastic, yes.

Again... why did no Tea Party appear under Bush I, Clinton or Bush II?

Exactly by what does Obama differ from these three, except by skin color and foreign-sounding name?

You're deliciously narrow minded. Have you also given consideration to the times and current events? What was going on during all those presidencies? Perhaps people didn't feel sufficiently motivated to form a tea-party-esque movement in response to what they felt were incorrect government actions?

And nevermind that there were a plethora of antiwar protests during Bush II's presidency. They might have been as organized as the Tea Party groups are, just less publicized.

But no. Again, its only because Obama's black. Yep, that's it, clearly, no other possible scenario!
 
Fair point, and it was sarcastic, yes.



You're deliciously narrow minded. Have you also given consideration to the times and current events? What was going on during all those presidencies? Perhaps people didn't feel sufficiently motivated to form a tea-party-esque movement in response to what they felt were incorrect government actions?

And nevermind that there were a plethora of antiwar protests during Bush II's presidency. They might have been as organized as the Tea Party groups are, just less publicized.

But no. Again, its only because Obama's black. Yep, that's it, clearly, no other possible scenario!

Well, to be fair, its because he's black and the Teabaggers keep saying racist things. You know, as added evidence.
 
Well, to be fair, its because he's black and the Teabaggers keep saying racist things. You know, as added evidence.
All of them? Every single one? Everywhere?

FYI, calling them "teabaggers" makes you as pathetic as you view them to be.
 
You're deliciously narrow minded. Have you also given consideration to the times and current events? What was going on during all those presidencies? Perhaps people didn't feel sufficiently motivated to form a tea-party-esque movement in response to what they felt were incorrect government actions?

Perhaps. But it certainly undercuts the Tea Party's claims of fiscal conservatism when they apparently weren't "sufficiently motivated" to protest the financial irresponsibility of the previous president.

So when the motivation someone claims for doing something reveals itself to be a flagrant hypocrisy, it's only natural to assume there might be other factors involved.

And if the Tea Party doesn't like the fact that some people assume those factors are tied to the Tea Party's fringe elements, then they need to A) police themselves better, and B) come up with a platform that isn't so laughably incoherent.

And nevermind that there were a plethora of antiwar protests during Bush II's presidency. They might have been as organized as the Tea Party groups are, just less publicized.

They were not organized even remotely as well as the Tea Party for the simple fact that didn't have the sponsorship of corporations and major Republican politicians.

Let's be clear on something: Pretty much every president in the history of this nation had dissenters who protested his policies. But to equate the Tea Party with other run-of-the-mill protesters is disingenuous. They have a lot of money and power behind them, and have effectively been christened the Voice of America by the Right Wing.

If they don't like the scrutiny, then maybe they should dial it down a bit. But as along as they keep themselves in the spotlight, people are justified in taking a close, hard look at them.
 
All of them? Every single one? Everywhere?

FYI, calling them "teabaggers" makes you as pathetic as you view them to be.

They call themselves Teabaggers so I'm honoring their wishes. Of course not all of them are racist. But enough of them keep saying racist things that a rational explanation for why they have only now become upset, and are "demanding their country back", and are protesting their lower taxes by decrying their imaginary higher taxes, and why a huge percentage of them think President Obama is Kenyan, and why they keep comparing him to Hitler for no apparent reason, or why so many of them consider him to be the actual Anti-Christ, has some relation to their continued racist rhetoric.

Occam's Razor and all that stuff.
 
All of them? Every single one? Everywhere?

FYI, calling them "teabaggers" makes you as pathetic as you view them to be.

Really? Using a snarky nickname that they gave themselves before they figured out how silly it made them look makes him as pathetic as people that hold up signs saying "Dont steal from Medicare to fund socialised medicine!", "Keep your Government hands off my Medicare!" & the totally charming "If Brown cant fix it a Browning can!" as well as a bunch more racist and just plain ignorant tripe?

False equivalency doesn't come close to descibing that comment.
 
Really? Using a snarky nickname that they gave themselves before they figured out how silly it made them look makes him as pathetic as people that hold up signs saying "Dont steal from Medicare to fund socialised medicine!", "Keep your Government hands off my Medicare!" & the totally charming "If Brown cant fix it a Browning can!" as well as a bunch more racist and just plain ignorant tripe?

False equivalency doesn't come close to descibing that comment.

I've said this before. When Teabaggers stop saying "Democrat Party", "socialist", "marxist", and "communist" to describe the other side. When they stop talking about their guns and "revolution" and "the blood of tyrants", I'll entertain the idea that I need to tone down my style of discourse.

Until then, not so much.
 
I'm referring to the idea that you should start a thread on precisely that subject in the appropriate forum and I'll be happy to engage you to the necessary level of detail to actually answer the question. What I won't do, however, is take part in a derail, except to point out that even the statement you're making in the quote above is disconnected from reality.

Well, the assumptions inherent in the poll are relevant to how the results are judged, correct?

So you agree that it's difficult for the urban poor to work their way out of the lower class.

So either you disagree that the urban poor is largely black, or you agree that it's difficult for blacks to work their way out of the lower classes.

You agree that failing schools are a reason for this difficulty.

So either you disagree that discrimination plays a large part in the failing schools in inner cities, or you agree that discrimination is a major reason for the difficulty.

I think GreNME nailed it. You have a problem with reality.



There are 2 things bundled together into 1 in the poll question, that would have been better divided into 2 questions:

Generations of slavery followed by legally sanctioned and enforced racism resulted in blacks being disproportionally poor. (I hate the term lower class)

AND

It is more difficult for blacks to work their way out of poverty than poor people of other races.

Those are the 2 assumptions inherent in the question. I would agree with question #1, without doubt. Question #2 is sketchy.

My point is that regardless of how someone became poor, there probably is not that much difference in the difficulty of getting out of poverty, based on race. For example, coming from an intact family of two biological parents is a greater predictor of economic status later in life than race.

Maybe I was reading into it more than was there, but I saw the question as "Generations of slavery and discrimination have created conditions that make it [especially] difficult for blacks to work their way out of the lower class. (Disagree)"

I'm not sure otherwise why they had to include both slavery and working out of poverty in the one question.

I do not think that the incredibly poor inner-city schools are due to racism. I think they are due, in part, to well-intentioned failures of the "War on Poverty" resulting in the breakdown of inner-city nuclear families, which is very strongly negatively correlated with education outcomes (and a whole host of other things). Even during the Jim Crow era, when blacks faced entrenched and systemic racism, black schools had far better results than do the inner-city schools of today. The incredibly poor inner-city schools are also partially due to the fact that teacher's hands are tied when it comes to maintaining discipline in the classroom AND due to union rules that prevent the firing of crappy teachers. Keep in mind that almost all of these inner-city schools and school districts are run by Democrats, often black. I don't think it is racism, but incompetence based on ideological blinders and too strong of an attachment to unions (or fear of them).

As an aside, vouchers would help, but would not solve the problem - parental direction and involvement can't be replaced by better schools. The most important thing would be to lower the out of wedlock birth rate in the inner-cities. It would have been much easier not to introduce the policy changes that created the problem than to fix it now that it has become such a problem.

ETA: change the sentence:

For example, coming from an intact family of two biological parents is a greater predictor of economic status later in life than race.

to

For example, coming from an intact family of two biological parents is a greater predictor of economic status later in life than race, controlling for income of the parents.

In other words, poor black children from an intact family have better economic outcomes in general than poor white children with single mothers. An intact family is a greater predictor of economic success than race. If both family status and parents income are controlled for, there is a small difference in outcomes. I'm going to have search for the cite, because I can't remember with any specificity what my hazy memory of "small" means.
 
Last edited:
Generations of slavery followed by legally sanctioned and enforced racism resulted in blacks being disproportionally poor. (I hate the term lower class)

AND

It is more difficult for blacks to work their way out of poverty than poor people of other races.

Wait, what?

EDIT: Even if this question is problematic, it isn't like it was the only question.
 
Last edited:
Well, to be fair, its because he's black and the Teabaggers keep saying racist things. You know, as added evidence.

Well, that's true for some of them. But it was just as true -- probably more so -- that many of the "anti-war protesters" during Bush's tenure kept saying antisemitic and anti-non-Muslim things.

By the way, the USA is still in Iraq and Afghanistan. Why have the anti-war protests magically stopped?

There is ONLY ONE EXPLANATION. They HATE WHITE PEOPLE!

Who can argue with this "evidence" and "added evidence"?

(Well, it's either that, or else the anti-war protesters -- just like the Tea Party folks -- tend not to protest when their guy is in power, and have a lunatic fringe.)
 
Well, that's true for some of them. But it was just as true -- probably more so -- that many of the "anti-war protesters" during Bush's tenure kept saying antisemitic and anti-non-Muslim things.

By the way, the USA is still in Iraq and Afghanistan. Why have the anti-war protests magically stopped?

There is ONLY ONE EXPLANATION. They HATE WHITE PEOPLE!

Who can argue with this "evidence" and "added evidence"?

(Well, it's either that, or else the anti-war protesters -- just like the Tea Party folks -- tend not to protest when their guy is in power, and have a lunatic fringe.)

You there. Stop being reasonable this instant. We're in a politics forum, don't you know that?!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom