I'm referring to the idea that you should start a thread on precisely that subject in the appropriate forum and I'll be happy to engage you to the necessary level of detail to actually answer the question. What I won't do, however, is take part in a derail, except to point out that even the statement you're making in the quote above is disconnected from reality.
Well, the assumptions inherent in the poll are relevant to how the results are judged, correct?
So you agree that it's difficult for the urban poor to work their way out of the lower class.
So either you disagree that the urban poor is largely black, or you agree that it's difficult for blacks to work their way out of the lower classes.
You agree that failing schools are a reason for this difficulty.
So either you disagree that discrimination plays a large part in the failing schools in inner cities, or you agree that discrimination is a major reason for the difficulty.
I think GreNME nailed it. You have a problem with reality.
There are 2 things bundled together into 1 in the poll question, that would have been better divided into 2 questions:
Generations of slavery followed by legally sanctioned and enforced racism resulted in blacks being disproportionally poor. (I hate the term lower class)
AND
It is more difficult for blacks to work their way out of poverty than poor people of other races.
Those are the 2 assumptions inherent in the question. I would agree with question #1, without doubt. Question #2 is sketchy.
My point is that
regardless of how someone became poor, there probably is not
that much difference in the difficulty of getting out of poverty, based on race. For example, coming from an intact family of two biological parents is a greater predictor of economic status later in life than race.
Maybe I was reading into it more than was there, but I saw the question as "Generations of slavery and discrimination have created conditions that make it [
especially] difficult for blacks to work their way out of the lower class. (Disagree)"
I'm not sure otherwise why they had to include both slavery and working out of poverty in the one question.
I do not think that the incredibly poor inner-city schools are due to racism. I think they are due, in part, to well-intentioned failures of the "War on Poverty" resulting in the breakdown of inner-city nuclear families, which is very strongly negatively correlated with education outcomes (and a whole host of other things).
Even during the Jim Crow era, when blacks faced entrenched and systemic racism, black schools had far better results than do the inner-city schools of today. The incredibly poor inner-city schools are also partially due to the fact that teacher's hands are tied when it comes to maintaining discipline in the classroom AND due to union rules that prevent the firing of crappy teachers. Keep in mind that almost all of these inner-city schools and school districts are run by Democrats, often black. I don't think it is racism, but incompetence based on ideological blinders and too strong of an attachment to unions (or fear of them).
As an aside, vouchers would
help, but would not solve the problem - parental direction and involvement can't be replaced by better schools. The most important thing would be to lower the out of wedlock birth rate in the inner-cities. It would have been much easier not to introduce the policy changes that created the problem than to fix it now that it has become such a problem.
ETA: change the sentence:
For example, coming from an intact family of two biological parents is a greater predictor of economic status later in life than race.
to
For example, coming from an intact family of two biological parents is a greater predictor of economic status later in life than race,
controlling for income of the parents.
In other words, poor black children from an intact family have better economic outcomes in general than poor white children with single mothers. An intact family is
a greater predictor of economic success than race. If both family status and parents income are controlled for, there is a
small difference in outcomes. I'm going to have search for the cite, because I can't remember with any specificity what my hazy memory of "small" means.