Near freefal collapse speed

Um, that would be me doing your work for you, and as a non-specialist I wouldn't see that as being wise.
I'm not asking you to "do my work for me", I'm suggesting you highlight items on the list you think require additional info. I suggest doing so on the other thread though.
 
Ah, tfk. What a long holiday you have had. Looks like your attitude has not improved. Shame.

If, by my "attitude", you mean my lack of tolerance for arrogant, incompetent fools, you'd be right.

Funny thing, I don't see a problem with that.

tfk said:
First, you don't appear to comprehend the difference between "data" and "analysis".
Incorrect.

Nope.
The data is (in this case) principally the video collection.
The analysis is the examination & manipulation of the data to draw conclusions.

tfk said:
NIST's data is the same as (and possibly superior to) yours.
Incorrect.

Show me what video that you have that NIST does not.

tfk said:
NIST's data is ... possibly superior to ... yours.
I disagree, for many reasons as highlighted repeatedly in the appropriate thread.

Additional raw data is the construction details of the building.

Over on this thread, you're complaining that NIST "won't release data such that the simulation can be replicated, building plans, ANSYS/LS-DYNA building models, …"

Oops. Hoisted on your own petard again.

tfk said:
NIST's analysis of that data was far superior, for the simple reason that 1) they used professionals (in the case of the flight paths)
Appeal to authority.

Now you're showing that you don't know what an "appeal to authority" logical fallacy is.

It is not an AtA fallacy if the people really are authorities (they are) AND if the consensus of the experts agree with them (they do).

tfk said:
& 2) they got it done fast
Irrelevant. Slightly bizarre.

"Irrelevant" only to someone who has never managed a project or resources. Or who has never had to meet a deadline.

Speaking of "getting it done", here you are, 10 years after the event …

… and you are still flailing around, pretending that you haven't drawn any conclusions.

As well as thinking that you've put forth any sort of valid excuse for refusing to draw any conclusions.

10 years, no conclusions. That strikes me as more than slightly bizarre.

tfk said:
NIST knew that, by the time the external walls began their collapse, 80% of the building was already gone
Ew. Interesting statement to put in stone. Noted. I suggest off topic for this thread though, as is the rest of your post.

Ahhh, juvenile threats noted.

Say, aren't you the guy that was recently given a "vacation" of your own for abusing the "off topic" reporting function?

By all means have a re-read of your, er, performance on our old favorite thread.

I am perfectly happy to let both of our posting histories speak for themselves.

But, to that point, perhaps you'd like to address your performance in your reply here.

Your performance where - once again - you've focused entirely on petty semantics, and completely ignored substance.

The substance of my post concerns the issue of timing of causes & effects, and why knowledgeable engineers, when looking for causes, study the conditions leading up to an event rather than the conditions afterwards.

If you try harder next time, you "performance" may rate something better than a failing grade.
 
If, by my "attitude", you mean my lack of tolerance for arrogant, incompetent fools, you'd be right.
No, by "attitude" I mean your repeated inept attempts to appear like you know what you are talking about by utilisation of the most primitive of deliberate contextual shifts.

The data is (in this case) principally the video collection.
Incorrect. The data (in this case) by responding to my assertion that NISTs trace data was poor (and provision of a list of the issues I have identified witha that trace data) is specifically (not principally) the trace data.

Contextual shift failure tom.

Show me what video that you have that NIST does not.
As you know I have a 1Gb DV version of the Cam#3 video NIST released in the recent FOIA release, and is identical (or if not identical, almost bit perfect) to the copy they used for their traces. (proven by using their data to identify the T0 pixel).)

It is not an AtA fallacy if the people really are authorities (they are) AND if the consensus of the experts agree with them (they do).
The NIST trace data is bleedin' awful, for the many reasons listed. I can (and have) produced higher quality data.

"Irrelevant" only to someone who has never managed a project or resources. Or who has never had to meet a deadline.
ROFL. Have had to deal with many of both. What a pathetic "line of snark". Desperation creeping in ? ;)

Ahhh, juvenile threats noted.
Really ? What threats ?

I am perfectly happy to let both of our posting histories speak for themselves.
Splendid.
 
Last edited:
No, by "attitude" I mean your repeated inept attempts to appear like you know what you are talking about by utilisation of the most primitive of deliberate contextual shifts.

LMFAO…

Femr's unique, personal dictionary rears its incompetent head again.

attitude = egotistical misdirection.

Sorry, sweetheart. You are the one that changes topic every time you get cornered. You are the one who refuses to answer simple direct questions with simple direct answers. Not me.

You are the one who posts page after page after page after page after page of unmitigated crap to impress the feeble minded & credulous.

You are the one who posts clueless technobabble like the graph in this post. Only a total incompetent would state that this is a graph of "Displacement vs. Acceleration".

You are the person so clueless that you think that you can perform a competent numerical analysis without performing, or even understanding, the basics of error analysis.

And you are the one who constantly changes the definition of words. Like "frame". And *creep*.

And now "attitude".

Some of Webster pertinent definitions include::

2: a position assumed for a specific purpose <a threatening attitude>
4 a : a mental position with regard to a fact or state <a helpful attitude>
b : a feeling or emotion toward a fact or state
6: an organismic state of readiness to respond in a characteristic way to a stimulus (as an object, concept, or situation)
7 a : a negative or hostile state of mind
b : a cool, cocky, defiant, or arrogant manner

For the record, I'll admit to being a "7b".

tfk said:
The data is (in this case) principally the video collection.
Incorrect. The data (in this case) by responding to my assertion that NISTs trace data was poor (and provision of a list of the issues I have identified witha that trace data) is specifically (not principally) the trace data.

Are you drunk?

Why don't you try typing that over. This time in English, instead of gibberish.

The data is the videos. Additional data is the information about the building's construction. You know, the data that your panties are all bunched up because NIST ain't serving up to a bunch of dolts on a silver platter.

Measurements taken from raw data are not data, they are analysis.

Raw data doesn't lie.
Analyses can be competent or incompetent.

Contextual shift failure tom.

There's zero contextual shift.

The data is the video collection that was taken on 9/11. The data remains unchanging from that day to this.

There have been multitudinous analyses of that data. Some competent. Some not.

You, for example, have your "dancing acceleration gifs". Depending on which one your roulette wheel stops at, at any given instant the north wall of the towers might be accelerating downward at 1.1g, or upward at about .4g.

The data is the unchanging.
The analyses is different.

Sucks to be so clueless that you don't understand that.

tfk said:
Show me what video that you have that NIST does not.

As you know I have a 1Gb DV version of the Cam#3 video NIST released in the recent FOIA release, and is identical (or if not identical, almost bit perfect) to the copy they used for their traces. (proven by using their data to identify the T0 pixel).)

:dl:

I say, "NIST has all the same video data that you have."
You say "incorrect".
I ask, "What do you have that NIST doesn't have?"
You reply, "I have a video that is "identical, almost bit perfect" as NIST's."

:dl: :dl:

The NIST trace data is bleedin' awful, for the many reasons listed. I can (and have) produced higher quality data.

You don't produce data. You produce analyses. Most of them incompetent.

The data is the videos.

The thing that you are railing at is their analysis of that data.

Sucks to not understand the difference.

tfk said:
Getting an analysis put to bed, fast, is a sign of competence.
femr said:
Irrelevant. & slightly bizarre
tfk said:
only to someone who has never led a project.
ROFL. Have had to deal with many of both.

Sure you have. :rolleyes:

And your response to a consultant who was tasked with providing you an answer, when he's entering his second decade of dick-around with not a conclusion in sight??

"Sure thing. Take your time. Here's your check." ???

Some project manager you are...

What a pathetic "line of snark". Desperation creeping in ?

LMAO.

Recognizing the need to get things done expeditiously, provide answers & put questions to bed is "desperation"??

There's that personal dictionary again…

I'd say "desperation" is more akin to a decade with nothing to show for it but wasted time and unpleasant interactions with just about everyone.

I'd say "desperation" is the dance that you do when folks ask you simple direct questions. And your only out is to misdirect & give no answer.

That smacks of desperation to me.

tfk said:
I am perfectly happy to let both of our posting histories speak for themselves.
Splendid.

Yup. Splendid indeed.
 
Ladies, stop the handbagfight !!

:D

Yeah, you're right.

Must be like having a couple of squabbling kids in the back seat for a long, long, long, long drive.

"But... BUT ... HE STARTED IT !!!"
:o

What gets me is the impotence of it all.
"Conan the Librarian"
 
...tfk uncivil waffle snipped...

You are the one who posts clueless technobabble like the graph in this post. Only a total incompetent would state that this is a graph of "Displacement vs. Acceleration".
How bizarre. The graph...

...shows displacement, and acceleration.

RHS axis acceleration (ft/s^2), LHS axis displacement (ft)

Explain your hissy fit tfk :rolleyes:

The data is the videos.
I see you are continnuing to attempt to excuse your rambling personal attacks and hissy-fits based upon your chosen context shift. Here...
Chandler's data is very poor, but then so is NIST's...
<list of trace data issues>
Pretty poor.
...Clearly referring to trace data.

NIST's data is the same as (and possibly superior to) yours.
I disagree, for many reasons as highlighted repeatedly in the appropriate thread.
The data is (in this case) principally the video collection.

The data being discussed is the trace data. Clearly. Your petty debating tactics are transparent tfk.

There's zero contextual shift.
Incorrect.

The data is the video collection that was taken on 9/11.
Incorrect. The data being duscussed was the trace data, clearly. Context shift failure tfk.
 
Faster than free fall?

How is this possible?

Wouldn't it be possible if there was an additional downward force?

Thought I read once that it seemed like the building as a whole provided that extra force by "pulling" a single point (that was being used by truthers) down after it first started collapsing.
 
Faster than free fall?
Correct. You sound "surprised". May I suggest you check NIST's data for another portion of the building. Also over-g.

How is this possible?
All manner of possible reasons, one being the trace point not being the CoG.

I suggest you read the "femr2 video data analysis" thread if you're "new" to WTC7 over-g discussion. Here is not really the place to re-hash it again.
 
Correct. You sound "surprised". May I suggest you check NIST's data for another portion of the building. Also over-g.


All manner of possible reasons, one being the trace point not being the CoG.

I suggest you read the "femr2 video data analysis" thread if you're "new" to WTC7 over-g discussion. Here is not really the place to re-hash it again.
By CoG you mean what?

Remember, acronyms must be fully defined before any conversation can take place. We don't want any confusion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom