Near freefal collapse speed

That's far from a biggest problem. Chandler's data is very poor, but then so is NIST's...


Pretty poor.


Not an issue as long as the footage is "real time", not sped-up/slowed-down.


Determination of T0 is a thorny process. See linked notes in quote above.


Not relevant for either NIST or Chandler trace data. T0 for global descent is after release of the East penthouse.

Here is one of my trace data graphs for WTC7 NW Corner...

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/2/447669743.jpg[/qimg]

RHS axis is ft/s^2. Click to enlarge. You're not likely to find more accurate data anywhere.

Note maximum acceleration after a few feet of descent, with gradual general reduction in acceleration from then on.


Great work...so what is your conclusion, do you believe it to be CD or not?
 
That's far from a biggest problem. Chandler's data is very poor, but then so is NIST's...


Pretty poor.


Not an issue as long as the footage is "real time", not sped-up/slowed-down.


Determination of T0 is a thorny process. See linked notes in quote above.


Not relevant for either NIST or Chandler trace data. T0 for global descent is after release of the East penthouse.

Here is one of my trace data graphs for WTC7 NW Corner...

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/2/447669743.jpg[/qimg]

RHS axis is ft/s^2. Click to enlarge. You're not likely to find more accurate data anywhere.

Note maximum acceleration after a few feet of descent, with gradual general reduction in acceleration from then on.
Can you provide a link to those so-called NIST shortcomings?

Grazi
 
Great work...so what is your conclusion, do you believe it to be CD or not?
Using such data to make global conclusions like that is, as I said earlier in this thread, hampered by a current lack of data for separate vertical building collapses and CD's with usefully similar global behaviour.

A factor I have pointed out a number of times is that motion of the WTC7 NW corner began long before release...

(and earlier)

Such early motion indicates that release was not an instantaneous process, but rather more of a creeping motion. It would be valid imo to suggest this data refutes claims of "all structural resistance being removed instantly".
 
Using such data to make global conclusions like that is, as I said earlier in this thread, hampered by a current lack of data for separate vertical building collapses and CD's with usefully similar global behaviour.

A factor I have pointed out a number of times is that motion of the WTC7 NW corner began long before release...
[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/2/666377698.jpg[/qimg]
(and earlier)

Such early motion indicates that release was not an instantaneous process, but rather more of a creeping motion. It would be valid imo to suggest this data refutes claims of "all structural resistance being removed instantly".


Did you see the link i posted comparing verinage to the north tower?

http://911debunkers.blogspot.com/201...-are-bunk.html
 
Did you see the link i posted comparing verinage to the north tower?

Yes. I've traced verinage descents, and the velocity and acceleration profiles are indeed very different to those of WTC7 and WTC1. Given the type of building verinage is used upon, and that the WTC1 mode of destruction is highly likely to be internal ROOSD (and so initial velocity reductions would be effectively invisible, behind the perimeter wall) it's not really useful to compare them too closely imo.

Verinage is certainly much "slower" than WTC7.
 
The list contains some supporting links, but read this thread in full for more detail. Word of caution though...it's long and very noisy.
Ah, thank you. Although you might consider making it easier for a potential reader to digest by publishing it. It would certainly make your conclusions more compelling as a citation.
 
depends how long it accelerated at free fall ;)

Really?

Let's say it had an hour.


;)

You guys are easy.

Tony Szamboti claimed that, on 9-leventyleven, the columns for the WTC towers had accelerated at g for 30+ years.

My SWAG would put the towers at about .999c at that point!

tom
 
You guys are easy.

Tony Szamboti claimed that, on 9-leventyleven, the columns for the WTC towers had accelerated at g for 30+ years.

My SWAG would put the towers at about .999c at that point!

tom
You too! I could still see the towers clearly, therefor your calculations are WRONG. At that speed they would be blurry.


(It hurt even to type that.)
 
Last edited:
Anyway...the topic...

We have heard that FFA is impossible without CD...

...do truthers have any idea what speed the WTC's should have fallen to prove it isn't a CD?
 
You, tmd, (like Chandler) clearly think that an understanding of "high school physics" is sufficient to understand what is going on.


Actually I'm pretty sure a solid understanding of high school physics would be enough to understand most of the collapse. The real problem is that Chandlers does not possess even that. If he was my kids physics teacher I'd have him moved to another class..........was he competent once?, perhaps but past performance is no indicator of present or future performance or sanity:(
 
… NIST's [data is very poor] …

Bilge.

First, you don't appear to comprehend the difference between "data" and "analysis".
No big surprise there.

NIST's data is the same as (and possibly superior to) yours.

NIST's analysis of that data was far superior, for the simple reason that 1) they used professionals (in the case of the flight paths), & 2) they got it done fast, and didn't waste a ridiculous amount of time & effort chasing pointless irrelevancies (i.e., the WTC7 wall collapses).

For the collapse of the North Wall, their response was exactly the right amount of time & effort invested: The minimum required to address a dumb assertion that sent a bunch of dumb people into a tizzy.

NIST knew that their job was to discover the CAUSES of the collapse of WTC7.

NIST knew that CAUSES PRECEDE EFFECTS. (In this universe, anyway.)

NIST knew that the causes of the collapse initiation would be found in the events that happened prior to the start of collapse initiation.

NIST knew that the causes of collapse progression would be found prior to & during the (extended) progressive collapse period.

NIST knew that, by the time the external walls began their collapse, 80% of the building was already gone, & the causes of collapse & progression were a thing of the past. They knew that examining in millisecond detail the descent of the last standing shell of the building was pointless, senseless, and a waste of resources.

(For the record, the cause of the collapse initiation was the asymmetric, long-girder design of the building & the multifloor, unfought fires.

The cause of the collapse progression was principally the design of the building and, to a lesser extent, the multifloor, unfought fires.

Notice that both causes happened well before the start of the collapse of the outer walls.)

This is exactly the reason that NIST focused on events before collapse initiation for all the buildings.

An utter lack of engineering competence is why truthers are unable to address (or even understand) events or effects other than Youtube videos.

This nonsense is identical to some fools putting in 3 years of excruciatingly analysis & argumentation as to exactly which direction the dust blew after the buildings had hit the ground.

And then spent another 3 years slapping themselves on the back for the fantastically "superior to NIST" analysis that they had produced.

Excruciatingly pointless hairsplitting of irrelevant data is pointlessly irrelevant.

Excruciating, too.
 
Ah, tfk. What a long holiday you have had. Looks like your attitude has not improved. Shame.

First, you don't appear to comprehend the difference between "data" and "analysis".
Incorrect.

NIST's data is the same as ... yours.
Incorrect.

NIST's data is ... possibly superior to ... yours.
I disagree, for many reasons as highlighted repeatedly in the appropriate thread.

NIST's analysis of that data was far superior, for the simple reason that 1) they used professionals (in the case of the flight paths)
Appeal to authority. Off topic. "Flight paths" have nothing to do with "Near freefal collapse speed". Looks more like an address the arguer instance to me.

& 2) they got it done fast
Irrelevant. Slightly bizarre.

NIST knew that, by the time the external walls began their collapse, 80% of the building was already gone
Ew. Interesting statement to put in stone. Noted. I suggest off topic for this thread though, as is the rest of your post.

By all means have a re-read of your, er, performance on our old favorite thread.

Discussion of my data should be continued there if you feel the need. I don't mind wading through the thread a-gathering.
 
Ah, thank you.
No worries. The quote links to a reasonable spot in the discussion.

Although you might consider making it easier for a potential reader to digest by publishing it.
Publish ? Nah. Summarise ? Perhaps.

It would certainly make your conclusions more compelling as a citation.
I suggest a simple first step could be to embellish the point-list with additional links and references.

If items on the list are not clear, highlight them on the source thread and I'll add detail.
 
No worries. The quote links to a reasonable spot in the discussion.


Publish ? Nah. Summarise ? Perhaps.


I suggest a simple first step could be to embellish the point-list with additional links and references.

If items on the list are not clear, highlight them on the source thread and I'll add detail.
Um , that would be me doing your work for you. As a non-specialist, that wouldn't be wise, I think.
 
No worries. The quote links to a reasonable spot in the discussion.


Publish ? Nah. Summarise ? Perhaps.


I suggest a simple first step could be to embellish the point-list with additional links and references.

If items on the list are not clear, highlight them on the source thread and I'll add detail.
Um, that would be me doing your work for you, and as a non-specialist I wouldn't see that as being wise.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom