Near freefal collapse speed

...Such behaviour certainly refutes any suggestion of an Event->Immediate descent type scenario...a point I have made many times...
I will vouch for the truth of that statement.
clap.gif
...(...just a pointer for others here who have a rather bizarre perspective of my purpose).
and that statement. :)

...Though not a clear creep type behaviour (more a flexure of the building) similar techniques have indicated creep type motion for WTC1 >9s prior to release...which again precludes all Event->Immediate descent type scenarios.
It sure does. And once again I note it's significance.
thumbup.gif
 
So, as an official JREF layman, I take it as: the 2 minutes prior to the EMP decent, the instability traced was probably column 79 in the process of losing its support for those several floors. The last 15 seconds was probably as it started to actually buckle. No?
 
So, as an official JREF layman, I take it as: the 2 minutes prior to the EMP decent, the instability traced was probably column 79 in the process of losing its support for those several floors. The last 15 seconds was probably as it started to actually buckle. No?
The giant leap from motion to a specific column is far beyond what can be implied by the motion data.

It may be that motion up to immediately prior to EPH release had nothing to do with column 79 at all. Perhaps ot could have been flexure enabled by the destruction of column 20.

So, IMO, no. Possibly, perhaps.

IMO it is fairly UNLIKELY that column 79 played a leading role of the very early motion.
 
In your opinion, is there anything in this which is inconsistent with structural failure due to fire? Anything which would indicate deliberate destruction by any other means, including, but not limited to, explosives?

Such behaviour certainly refutes any suggestion of an Event->Immediate descent type scenario...a point I have made many times (though not to yourself...just a pointer for others here who have a rather bizarre perspective of my purpose).

Thanx! I'm kind of a newbie here - less than 8 months!
 
So, as an official JREF layman, I take it as: the 2 minutes prior to the EMP decent, the instability traced was probably column 79 in the process of losing its support for those several floors. The last 15 seconds was probably as it started to actually buckle. No?

As an official Poe for 9/11 Twoof (for the time it takes me to write this post, that is), I say the 2 minutes is the time it took a mighty army of midgets to run in lockstep up the stairs to the area of operation within the building and start sawing, the 15 seconds is the time during which the first teams of midgets saw through the first girders, until critical damage has been achieved.
 
...

but we still see WTC being compared to CD videos.
have any truther done any work on this to show that the collapse speed can indicate a CD?


CD is gravity collapse.
There is nothing to learn by study of speed of collapse, except those doing the study are not engineers.

A few neutral want to be engineers do studies using the wrong filters, but the studies don't need to be done since the prime mover in most CD is gravity, mgh.
 
Last edited:
Yep, NIST failed to waste time and money on nonsense.
You said...
Thank goodness they [NIST] did not waste time inventing how to study one point on a building. What a waste of time.
I've simply reminded you that NIST did study one (wandering, meandering) point on the building...and then some.

NCSTAR1-9vol2 - 12.5 and the entire Appendix C.

Why did NIST not waste time on nonsense?
See above.

how did 911 truth fool so many fringe followers to say "free-fall", or the classic, "at free-fall speed"?
Partly because NIST backed them up.
 
You said...

I've simply reminded you that NIST did study one (wandering, meandering) point on the building...and then some.

NCSTAR1-9vol2 - 12.5 and the entire Appendix C.


See above.


Partly because NIST backed them up.
NIST did not back up 911 truth. ... videos labeled "demolition" do, as do failed truther papers labeled technical.

The CT free-fall nonsense is 911 truth fantasy, not from NIST. Wasn't this post in AAH? The resurrection. What is the high frequency noise you thought you removed by the SG filter you used my mistake? You failed to google the right Maybeck.
 
Last edited:
The CT free-fall nonsense is 911 truth fantasy, not from NIST.
Yawn. Where do you think the infamous "2.25s of freefall" comes from ? You already know it's from interpretation of NIST Stage 2, which was a very unwise statement to make...

203204960.png


"at gravitational acceleration" - Stupid thing to say. "AT" ?! :(

"the north face" - The entire North face ?! They only traced one region (badly) ! Stupid thing to say :(

"free fall drop" - Duh ! :(

What is the high frequency noise you thought you removed by the SG filter you used my mistake?
For a start, that doesn't even make sense beachnut. Your grammar and use of the English language is appalling.

Filtering removes...again...

a) Some low frequency signal
b) Some low frequency noise
c) Some higher frequency signal
d) ome higher frequency noise

Unavoidable.

Perhaps you could get around to suggesting an alternate appropriate filter ?

You failed to google the right Maybeck.
To which Maybeck were you referring to then ?
 
...
The CT free-fall nonsense is 911 truth fantasy, not from NIST. ...

Beachy, please.

Could you, please, put away the blinders for a moment and acknowledge that, in fact, yes, NIST did spend (waste) time and money on tracking a point on the WTC roof, and then did in fact state that "the north face descended at gravitational acceleration" and that "free fall drop continued for approximately ...[2.25 seconds]"?

a) Was that, in your opinion, a true statement?
b) Was that, in your opinion, a relevant statement?
b) Was that, in your opinion, a wise statement?

My answers to the these three questions are
a) only approximately
b) not very
c) no

This on no way touches upon any conclusions. You are correct: "NIST did not back up 911 truth". But actually, in 2013, which is the year today on my calendar, neither does femr2.
You are refering to an old video and its title.
Just disabuse yourself of that hang-up, and much becomes easier!
 
NIST did not make up the "free-fall" claims. Idiots believed the quote-mining fraud of 911 truth.

NIST did not waste time studying the "speed" of collapse. Study of the "speed" is not one of the objectives, it is like a "footnote" used for a specific purpose. Purpose? The goal free studies are nonsense. It is an obsession with a few who are still looking to break the big inside job, or other unknown reason.

NIST did not waste time on the study of this subject, they had a goal. Less than 1 percent of written work is wasted on this subject. Wasted? Not really. 0.46 waste used some in four pages of discussion in the final. Got math?

NIST did not waste time on this nonsense, they used the time it took for a purpose. A purpose which is missing in the Internet super sleuthing.

femr2 supports 911 truth with "demolition" titled videos used by 911 truther without comment from femr2, and internet technical paper library of 2 truther papers. http://femr2.ucoz.com/index/0-4 Paper which mislead people about 911. Trust in Ross, WTC is standing. Papers like these help support the crazy claims of CD related to this topic.

CDs are gravity collapses. There was nothing natural about the gravity collapse of the WTC, murder by 19 terrorists.

...
most CD's do merely start a progressive collapse that is driven by gravity.
...
The OP was correct, implying, Collapse speed is not an indication of CD.
 
NIST did not make up the "free-fall" claims.
Correct, though tfk-style context shifts will not help you here...

Thank goodness [NIST] did not waste time inventing how to study one point on a building. What a waste of time.

They did not have to, it serves no purpose...

It is silly to study one point of the collapse...

a) NIST did study one point on the building. This one in fact...
378832692.png


b) Whether you think it a waste of time or not, they performed that process, twice. Once for the draft, then again, in more detail for the final report.

c) Whether you think it silly or not, they performed that process, twice. Once for the draft, then again, in more detail for the final report.

d) As I told you earlier, NIST confirmed "freefall" during the descent of WTC7, and did so in a rather unwise fashion.

Idiots believed the quote-mining fraud of 911 truth.
Whilst I would suggest that the statements published by NIST have been latched onto literally by some, there is no "quote mining fraud" extracting the terms "at gravitational acceleration" and "freefall drop for [2.25s]" from their published report. Here is the relevant text for your delectation...
203204960.png


how did 911 truth fool so many fringe followers to say "free-fall", or the classic, "at free-fall speed"?
Partly because NIST backed them up within NCSTAR1-9 Vol 2 - 12.5.6.

NIST did not waste time studying the "speed" of collapse.
You keep quoting "speed". Do you mean "rate" ?

NIST's study of descent rates is contained within...

NCSTAR1-9vol2 - 12.5 with the entire Appendix C focussed upon sub-foot building motion utilising "made-up" methods of sub-pixel building motion detection. Many man-hours clearly went into Appendix C.

NIST did not waste time on the study of this subject, they had a goal. Less than 1 percent of written work is wasted on this subject.
LOL. Make your mind up beachnut.

Wasted? Not really. 0.46 waste used some in four pages of discussion in the final. Got math?
You're rambling again beachnut. And 0 != !0 :)

NIST did not waste time on this nonsense
What happened to your "0.46" "thingies" ? :)

they used the time it took for a purpose.
Aaaah. What was that then ?

A purpose which is missing in the Internet super sleuthing.
Again, what was that then ? :)

CDs are gravity collapses.
Clearly not. There are a few rather significant differences. Fancy having a guess as to what they are ? Don't fret, there's no "got math[ematics!]" required.

Collapse speed is not an indication of CD.
You have been provided with information, time and time again, which would enlighten you as to why your statement above is incorrect. It is a shame you are still incapable of recognising where you are going astray.

How can CD could be indicated by collapse speed since CDs use gravity to do the major destructive work.
Awful grammar and language aside...there is a useful question in there.

Again, you have been presented with information, many times, which should help you understand how "CD" can be shown to behave differently to "collapse" in terms of descent "speed"/"rate"/"motion".
 
Last edited:
Freefall doesn't mean a thing...
I think you've got it.

Gravity collapse, CD or fire/terrorist initiated, would be unique to the building, and what caused the collapse. 911 gravity collapse caused by impacts and fires. WTC design, specific damage/failure mode, "chaos" of collapse determine the profile of collapse. It is silly to study the speed/rate/etc, past the intended purpose. NIST studied the speed/rate/timing to compare to their model. Simple purpose based study.

Free-fall/CD nonsense started with idiots. NIST not needed.
Before NIST, 911 truth nuts were spreading "free-fall/CD".

http://www.assassinationscience.com/wtc.html
2002 free-fall CD nonsense, no NIST, some Zionists. Just an idiot.
http://www.twf.org/News/Y2002/0427-Mystery.html
The nuts started early. The stupid hurts.
http://www.serendipity.li/wtc5.htm
free fall and CD nonsense, no NIST required.
http://911review.org/Wget/www.the7thfire.com/Politics%20and%20History/law_of_free_fall.htm
Free-fall, and CD; no NIST
http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/WTCDEMO/wtc.html
Free-fall, CD, oh my; no NIST, just Zionists.

Free-fall and gravitational acceleration, the stuff to confuse 911 truth nuts. I feel one g, am I under gravitational acceleration now? Better check my seat for thermite.
 
Last edited:
Freefall doesn't mean a thing...
Sure - none of the members posting rational comments have suggested otherwise. AND it was taken for granted by the OP:
I see the "near freefall" collapses of the towers are still seen by some as indication for a Controlled demolition...but we still see WTC being compared to CD videos.
have any truther[sic] done any work on this to show that the collapse speed can indicate a CD?
So the topic discussion is about any truther work done to support their claim linking collapse speed to CD.

Then through the middle section of the thread we see several derails. Set those aside and see why femr2's comments entered legitimate discussion of the topic:

Addressing the topic femr2 said:
Recent feature tracing has shown that known CD can result in acceleration around g [...] Behaviour is similar to WTC7, except that WTC7 included motion long before release...Additional CD traces and additional non CD traces would be required to make any assertion.
Emphasis mine. Please note the significance of that statement in the comparison of CD versus non-CD collapses. Then note how many members fail to comprehend where it fits into this debate - and thus becomes a factor helping them to lose the plot.

femr2 has made the observation many times in the same setting of comparing CD to non-CD collapses. And, of course, it puts the lie to claims that the studies are a waste of time and related nonsense claims.

So the Original Poster - member DC - asked for more support from femr2:
have you ever compared it to other collapses, non CD collapses?
...and gets the courteous response:
Haven't had much luck finding video of non-911 non-cd collapses....
If you're aware of any video of non CD collapses which go straight(ish) down, let me know and I'll trace motion.
...so he seeks further confirmation:
so this claim that near freefall speed indicates a CD is based on no evidence at all? But still they keep comparing it in videos to CD's CD's where only the collapse initiation is done by explosives and the collapse progression is gravity driven. that is very missleading.
Which confirms that your comment "Freefall doesn't mean a thing..." was recognised by the OP from early in the thread. (several others of us on record many times on other threads. So it is not an issue for us here in this discussion - other than it being used as a distractor - principally by beachnut and those who follow his lead without giving adequate thought to any relevance to this topic.)

After some pages with several members giving multiple examples of "disparage femr2 and miss the relevance of his work specific to this thread topic" Redwood spots the key issues and femr2 responds:
So, we have indications of building instability 2 minutes before visible signs of collapse, right?
Correct
Then we have stronger evidence of instability 15 seconds before...
Correct
...In your opinion, is there anything in this which is inconsistent with structural failure due to fire? Anything which would indicate deliberate destruction by any other means, including, but not limited to, explosives?
Such behaviour certainly refutes any suggestion of an Event->Immediate descent type scenario...a point I have made many times....similar techniques have indicated creep type motion for WTC1 >9s prior to release...which again precludes all Event->Immediate descent type scenarios.
(my emphases.) And those focussed on disagreeing with femr2 at any cost once again miss those two key clams. And note the "any" and "all" claims of scope. (My DOUBLE emphasese :( )

And, in a related post, Redwood adds seismic evidence to support the key factor identified by femr2's measurements.
IIRC, seismograph readings indicate that internal collapse started ~5 seconds before the fall of the east penthouse. Then, another 5-6 seconds before the west penthouse and the outer shell begin to fall.....
So we have confirming evidence about "early motion before release" - the key 'on topic' factor of this thread. And, ironically, in a response to beachnut who lets it pass AFAICS. :o (Insert Comment about equus being brought into proximity of aqueous fluid but no forced imbibing. :rolleyes:)

So your comment:
Freefall doesn't mean a thing...
..is correct but it is not at the focus of debate. The debate is providing further proof of why free fall based claims of CD are wrong plus the bonus identified by femr2's measurements which, if comprehended, rebut one major class of claims.

...a factor which beachnut persists in disregarding despite having had it pointed out to him many times.

And, of course, the test of a technical claim is "is it right" not "you are not an engineer" or any of the other variants or lesser subsets of "All engineers are always right" and "non- engineers cannot be right" :D
 
Such behaviour certainly refutes any suggestion of an Event->Immediate descent type scenario...a point I have made many times (though not to yourself...just a pointer for others here who have a rather bizarre perspective of my purpose).

So if you don't believe that it was controlled demoltion, then why do you label your youtube videos as demolition, you disinfo agent?

Point in case, femr2 youtube videos:
- WTC Demolition - WTC1 Sauret HD http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjHIGe7XtSM

- WTC Demolition - WTC1 Hallmark http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3QW5Kf7kNU
 
Last edited:
why do you label your youtube videos as demolition
ROFL.

As I've repeated many times, back to 2010, ... in order to find stuff on this modern fangled intrawebz thing, yous gotta enter some woooords ... search keywords if you will :) Sometimes simply transcribing video title from original source. 1.4M views. Seems some folk find them useful ;)

Most of the videos on my YT channel are simply the highest quality, or processed sections, of videos available at the time...highlighting some behaviour or other. Anything you object to within the videos or simply dumb-ass objection to titling ?

You're getting as sad as beachnut :jaw-dropp

you disinfo agent
PMSL

Address the argument young man.
 
Does anybody else here have this weird feeling that the disinfo agent femr2 didn't answer my question?

That's no problem. I can repeat it:
So if you don't believe that it was controlled demoltion, then why do you label your youtube videos as demolition, you disinfo agent?

Point in case, femr2 youtube videos:
- WTC Demolition - WTC1 Sauret HD
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjHIGe7XtSM

- WTC Demolition - WTC1 Hallmark http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3QW5Kf7kNU
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom