My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

I think IF there was a Jesus, (big if), he may have been some guy deluded into thinking he was god's son. He basked in the celebrity. Then one day, while they were driving nails through his feet, he slowly faced the fact that his delusion wasn't real. His last thoughts would have been "damn, betrayed" because his delusional god didn't rescue him.

This. Well said.

Because He self deluded Himself into believing He was Supernatural and when they nailed Him down He thought, "I'm really well and truly F****d now".

And this. :D
 
Devils Advocate wrote:
Your interpretation seems to makes sense, but it doesn’t. If your interpretation is correct, why would the writers of the Bible have included the passage when then know that it would be interpreted as such—which would be contradictory to the whole message the writers were trying to convey? You see?

Perhaps you attach infallibility to the writers? It might even be a legacy of the Gnostic view. Who knows what these people were thinking or even if it was all changed by the time the committee agreed on it? It wont be the first contradiction you will find nor is it the last.

What it does do is emphasise His humanity. I never understood why as the Son of God He wasnt whistling away like on the "Life of Brian". After all, He knew who he was, where He was going and it was all part of His plan. All the passages tell me is that if this episode ever occurred (and Jews were skewered in their thousands. Apart from that - What have the Romans ever done for us?) He showed Himself to be a naturally terrified and suffering man. Not what you expect from the Supreme being.

Perhaps the writers well and truly f**ked up? After all, Stephen King and J.K.Rowling have their off days too.
 
Starthinker said:
I think IF there was a Jesus, (big if), he may have been some guy deluded into thinking he was god's son. He basked in the celebrity. Then one day, while they were driving nails through his feet, he slowly faced the fact that his delusion wasn't real. His last thoughts would have been "damn, betrayed" because his delusional god didn't rescue him.
This. Well said.

Hux said:
Because He self deluded Himself into believing He was Supernatural and when they nailed Him down He thought, "I'm really well and truly F****d now".
And this. :D
Based on what we know of early Christianity, it seems unlikely that an historical Jeshua would have thought himself the son of God in the sense that Christians use it. He may have referred to himself as a son of God in the "we are God's children sense", but the idea of Jesus as divine and the idea of the trinity were not created until long after his death.
 
Devils Advocate wrote:


Perhaps you attach infallibility to the writers? It might even be a legacy of the Gnostic view. Who knows what these people were thinking or even if it was all changed by the time the committee agreed on it? It wont be the first contradiction you will find nor is it the last.

What it does do is emphasise His humanity. I never understood why as the Son of God He wasnt whistling away like on the "Life of Brian". After all, He knew who he was, where He was going and it was all part of His plan. All the passages tell me is that if this episode ever occurred (and Jews were skewered in their thousands. Apart from that - What have the Romans ever done for us?) He showed Himself to be a naturally terrified and suffering man. Not what you expect from the Supreme being.

Perhaps the writers well and truly f**ked up? After all, Stephen King and J.K.Rowling have their off days too.
You have to remember that we don't have an account of Jesus' life and death, we have multiple accounts of Jesus' life and death by different authors writing to different audiences at different times and with different messages. You need only look to the Gospel of Luke to find an account in which Jesus is very calm and serene as he goes to his death.
 
Based on what we know of early Christianity, it seems unlikely that an historical Jeshua would have thought himself the son of God in the sense that Christians use it. He may have referred to himself as a son of God in the "we are God's children sense", but the idea of Jesus as divine and the idea of the trinity were not created until long after his death.

Hmmm right. So that's why Mark has the chief priests becoming outraged by what he said at his trial about sitting at the right hand of God the Father and coming back on the clouds of heaven, and accusing him of blasphemy just before they shoved him off to Pilate? Bear in mind that at least the first gospels might well have begun to be circulated while the very people who tried him were still alive; or certainly the council of priests would still have existed and wouldn't have taken kindly to the reputation of the organisation being tarnished with lies. Of course they wouldn't have taken kindly to the truth of the matter being broadcast either; but I imagine they'd have objected to a story that was a total fabrication even more. Bear in mind this wasn't like accusing people far, far away of wanting to put your leader to death for blasphemy. The gospel writers were telling stories about people who were still alive and worked right where the headquarters of the church was.
 
You have to remember that we don't have an account of Jesus' life and death, we have multiple accounts of Jesus' life and death by different authors writing to different audiences at different times and with different messages. You need only look to the Gospel of Luke to find an account in which Jesus is very calm and serene as he goes to his death.

What, Luke, the gospel that has Jesus sweating blood as he agonised in the Garden of Gethsemane? :p
 
Bikewer said:
I've read a number of Ehrman's books and find him readable and reasonable. He seems to be well-respected in the academic community; he was part of the team
brought in by National Geographic to authenticate The Gospel Of Judas Escariot...

Really? :) What I suspect happened was that to increase the glamour of the programme and thus its appeal, they brought him in because he would be controversial.

From Wikipedia:

The Gospel of Judas is probably from no earlier than the second century, since it contains theology that is not represented before the second half of the second century, and since its introduction and epilogue assume the reader is familiar with the canonical Gospels.
 
Hmmm right. So that's why Mark has the chief priests becoming outraged by what he said at his trial about sitting at the right hand of God the Father and coming back on the clouds of heaven, and accusing him of blasphemy just before they shoved him off to Pilate? Bear in mind that at least the first gospels might well have begun to be circulated while the very people who tried him were still alive; or certainly the council of priests would still have existed and wouldn't have taken kindly to the reputation of the organisation being tarnished with lies. Of course they wouldn't have taken kindly to the truth of the matter being broadcast either; but I imagine they'd have objected to a story that was a total fabrication even more. Bear in mind this wasn't like accusing people far, far away of wanting to put your leader to death for blasphemy. The gospel writers were telling stories about people who were still alive and worked right where the headquarters of the church was.

First of all, the high priest could have seen Jesus' claim to be the messianic Son of man, as in Daniel, to be blasphemous. The Saducees, after all, weren't interested in rocking the boat and probably took a dim view of messianic pretenders, who were likely to bring down the wrath of the Roman authorities.

Second, the time elapsed from the Crucifixion (ca. 30) to the writing of the Gospel of Mark (ca. 70) was about 40 years. Assuming Annas was from 30 to 40 years old, he would have been 70 to 80 years old by the time Mark was written, assmin he was still alive. Caiahphas would have been older. In the 40 yeas that elapsed from the Crucifixion to the writing of Mark, a good deal of mythic elaboration could have taken place.

As to our disagreements regarding harmonizing the disparate Passion and Resurrection stories, it seems to me that there is nothing that you won't blithely explain away. You still haven't explained the difference in the order of post-Resurrection appearances in 1 Corinthians ans the Gospel of John, for example. I'm curious: Is there anything that might appear as a contradiction between one gospel andthe next that, hypothitically, you would find too glaring to harmonize?

The problems apologists seek to smoothe away through hamonization aren't limited to the Passion / Resurrection narratives. They are also present in the conflicting Nativities of Matthew and Luke. And here's another problem of contradiction for you. In the Synoptic Gospels, Jesus chases the money changers out of the Temple after his Palm Sunday entrance into Jerusalem and before his arrest. In fact, his creating a disturbance in the Temple precint would seem to be the proximate cause of his arrest. Yet the Gospel of John places the incident early in the ministry of Jesus, right after the wedding feast in Cana. This is a serious enough offense that it's not likely the Temple authorities would let it go unpunished. Thus it seems nearly impossible that john is referring to one incident, and the Synoptics are referring to another.
 
What, Luke, the gospel that has Jesus sweating blood as he agonised in the Garden of Gethsemane? :p

Did the author of Luke really write that?

Luke 22:43 Then an angel from heaven appeared and strengthened him. 44 He prayed more fervently, and he was in such agony of spirit that his sweat fell to the ground like great drops of blood.

There are problems concerning the authenticity of these verses being original to the author of Luke. First of all, these verses are missing from a number of our earliest and best witnesses. They also disrupt a literary device that the author seems to have been employing called a chiasmus, a style of symmetrical writing that is meant to emphasize the narrative element at its center. In this case, Jesus' prayer in which he asks that he be spared his task, but emphasis's that he wishes God's will to be done above his own.

Also of interest is the fact that nowhere else in the Gospel of Luke is Jesus portrayed as being even remotely bothered, let alone in agony. In fact, the author of Luke goes out of his way to change the portrayals of Jesus as suffering, agonizing, angry etc. as found in his source, the Gospel of Mark.
 
And then he mysteriously suggests that whereas he won't follow links...
I did follow the links.

...if I were to actually paraphrase everything in those articles and put it on the board, he'd be all-too-eager to debate me.
But why should I be expected to refute ever point of an external link? Can't you simply make an argument? BTW: I posted a link for god on trial with excellent arguments and you've ignored that. I also note that you didn't take the time to Debunk all of the arguments made in Misquoting Jesus. So I'm guessing that your argument via link only goes one way.

FWIW: If you asked me to I would itemize the arguments made from "God On Trial" But it's a powerful video and I had hoped you would watch.

Then, he goes into flat-out logical absurdity when, having just admitted that he didn't follow either of my links...
When did I say that I hadn't followed the links? I'll happily appologize if I did. Will you appologize if I didn't? I did follow the links. I found the typical dreck that I've been familiar with for years.

As for claiming that the apologetics don't stack up, the arguments are not new and as a long time follower of atheist blogs, pod casts and videos I think I can say with some confidence that to date no apologetics has ever been compelling to do anything more than give the faithful something to hold on to.

So, baby, can we have a reasonable debate? Do you even know the subject of your links? Can you reproduce a few of the arguments? I can reproduce a few or all of the arguments from "God on Trial".

I'd like to know if you even know the subject. It's easy to post links in a shot gun manner. Anyone can do that. I could send you off in a thousand directions. If I did so would you go and debunk? Really?

That I've no desire to debunk external links doesn't mean there is something untoward about me. So, let's skip the ad hom. Let's have a reasonable discussion and debate. Fair enough?
 
Last edited:
BTW, I'm still here. I'm just not willing to be drawn into an argument with Baby Nemesis.

Wise move, boy, wise move! LOL.

I'll get back to arguing on this forum later, doubtless with my usual gusto. Right now though, I have something rathre more productive and useful I want to get done, so people will have to wait in suspense.
 
and God doesn't have to answer either.
You mean your god doesn't know everything? Then you have no right calling yourself a "christian" cause you don't worship the judeo-christian god. Do you often invent a god in your own image?
 
Okay, so, I'm an Athiest, and my biblical Knowledge is a bit rusty, but as something to throw in to this Philosophical Stew...

He's Jesus. Son of God, Lamb Of god, all that love-and-kittens-and-rainbows kind of stuff. So if anyone is going to heaven when he dies, it's this guy. Directly to heavan, does not pass go, does not collect 200 bucks. But the plan is for him to get into hell and wrest souls from Satan or free the damned there or something. So the whole scourging and torture and what-not was necissary so that Jesus would doubt, and because of that doubt end up in hell to do the job.

It also puts an interesting take on his torturers, Who were now an integral part of God's plan, not just a bunch of jerks.

As I said, Not a believer, just an idea.

Trifikas
 
OK, here I am again. I'll deal with the relatively more classy arguments I need to catch up with on this board now, before getting back to dealing with the ones from the more loutish contingent.

TimCallahan said:
Specifically, Luke says that, after appearing to the two unnamed apostles on the road to Emmaus, Jesus appeared to the disciples in Jerusalem. When he appears
among them, they are frightened. He reassures them it's really him and invites them to examine his wounds as proof. This is obviously the first time he
has appeared to most of them.

In Matthew, Jesus appears to Mary Magdalene and "the other Mary" and tells them he will meet the disciples in Galilee. he does indeed meet them there,
and Mt. 28:17 that even though the disciples saw him there and worshipped him, some doubted. Again, this is obviously their first meeting with the risen
Jesus. This contradicts Luke.

Interesting observation. But I wouldn't necessarily see that as a contradiction, or that the Galilee appearance was the first, since wouldn't you have trouble taking in the idea of a resurrected person really being real, even if he had eaten something in front of you and showed you physical wound marks that corresponded to the ones he got before he died? You might doubt your sanity if nothing else. It would be an incredible thing to have to take in.

Besides, Matthew infers that even the doubters worshiped him, so the doubts can't have been on the magnitude of ones that would make them think they were going insane and frightening them.

TimCallahan said:
It's interesting that your response to my comparison of the order of post-Resurrection appearences in Gospel of John and 1 Corinthians only consists of
the quote above and an allusion to someone saying that Paul's list in 1 Corinthians wasn't meant as anything more than a credal statement. However, to answer your question above, The Gospel of John contains no instruction from Jesus for the disciples to go to Galilee. Also, they seem to have resumed their
old occupation as fishermen. If you're using the instruction in Matthew for the disciples to go to Galilee as a justification for them being there in John,
it seems a bit odd that they have already met Jesus in Jerusalem in John 20, but do not meet him in Jerusalem in Matthew.

I think you're turning up oddities all over the place where they really don't need to exist. Any slight discrepancy or omission in the text is immediately interpreted by you as an oddity or a contradiction, it seems, rather than you looking for other, possibly much more obvious explanations first, and only concluding you've found a contradiction after you've failed to think of any.

So what if the gospel writers didn't mention every single detail of Jesus' itinerary?

From that dreaded old Tektonics website again: :) The article The Resurrection Narratives Harmonized Contextually

• A second factor is the one we relate
here about precision writing in the ancient East.

Abraham Rihbany in The Syrian Christ [108ff] writes of Easterners who offer what we call "misstatements" which "are more often the result of indifference than the deliberate purpose to deceive. One of his besetting sins is his ma besay-il -- it does not matter. He sees no essential difference between nine o'clock and half after nine, or whether a conversation took place on the housetop or in the house. The main thing is to know the substance of what happened, with as many of the supporting details as can be conveniently remembered."

Why would you seek to impose exacting precision on the text before you'd consider it harmonisable?

From the article the first article links to:

The implications of this should be clear. Gospel writers who differ on minor points such as times, number of angels at a tomb, exact locations, and so on,
are signators to a semantic contract that Westerners haven't even read. Let's look at some related points that note this from a secular perspective.

Boyd and Eddy in The Jesus Legend note that sociologists aware of this phenomenon have referred to it as "relevant precision" and indeed quote a secular sociology periodical as saying much the same thing I do: That to insist on a greater level of precision that was intended for a context would be "sanctionable, pedantic, or intrusive." [433]

Similarly, Jocelyn Small in Wax Tablets of the Mind (5-7) further confirms and elucidates these points, which have special application to alleged problems in wording across the Gospels. As she puts it, "Exact wording is rarely crucial in oral societies, but often of great importance in literate ones, though this aspect took centuries to develop." As a result, "it is not the words but the story or the gist that counts." Gospel writers would not be expected to get the verba (exact words) of Jesus, but the vox (voice).

Not having the exact words would only be a problem if they were misrepresenting what he actually said. It wouldn't be a problem if, for example, one gospel said he said, "A man was walking from Jerusalem to Jericho when he was attacked by bandits who left him for dead. A priest saw him but walked by on the other side; then a Levite came across him and did the same", and the other gospel had priest and Levite spotting him in reverse order. What would matter would be the actual story. The moral message would remain intact, and since that would be the point of the story, that would be what mattered. If you can find any contradictions in the moral messages the gospels teach, then you'll have raised a point that seriously does cast the credibility of the gospels into doubt. But I can't think of one. Can you?

TimCallahan said:
As to the argument that Paul's list of who Jesus met in 1 Cor. 15:5 - 8 does indeed mention order: Jesus apperas to Cephas (Peter), then to the 12, then
to more than 500 people at one time, then to James, then to all the apostles and, finally, to Paul. This is a specific order of appearences, and it contradicts
the gospels, particularly John.

Given that stuff about indifference to minor detail like the order in which appearances might have happened - the things of key importance being what mattered, I don't see why precision-writing need be imposed on Paul.

TimCallahan said:
First of all, the high priest could have seen Jesus' claim to be the messianic Son of man, as in Daniel, to be blasphemous. The Saducees, after all, weren't
interested in rocking the boat and probably took a dim view of messianic pretenders, who were likely to bring down the wrath of the Roman authorities.

But I was saying something similar - that Jesus is in fact recorded as having said things believed to be blasphemous in the earliest gospels.

TimCallahan said:
Second, the time elapsed from the Crucifixion (ca. 30) to the writing of the Gospel of Mark (ca. 70) was about 40 years. Assuming Annas was from 30 to
40 years old, he would have been 70 to 80 years old by the time Mark was written, assmin he was still alive. Caiahphas would have been older. In the 40
yeas that elapsed from the Crucifixion to the writing of Mark, a good deal of mythic elaboration could have taken place.

There are disagreements on when the gospels were written, and Mark wasn't necessarily written anywhere near that late; but - I could have made it clearer - I meant that even if those particular priests who'd tried Jesus had died, the ones who were the religious leaders of the day would still presumably not have taken kindly to the religious establishment they were a part of being accused of doing something reputed to be so bad. If someone accused the Labour government of 1970s Britain of having an important figure put to death unjustly, we might at least expect a statement from the current Labour government refuting it, though thankfully Western governments tend not to go in for the kind of persecution that could be expected from many 1st-century authorities on being criticised, it seems. Why would the gospel writers have risked "mythic elaboration" if it meant persecution, and they would have known to expect it?

TimCallahan said:
As to our disagreements regarding harmonizing the disparate Passion and Resurrection stories, it seems to me that there is nothing that you won't blithely
explain away. You still haven't explained the difference in the order of post-Resurrection appearances in 1 Corinthians ans the Gospel of John, for example.

I have now.

TimCallahan said:
I'm curious: Is there anything that might appear as a contradiction between one gospel andthe next that, hypothitically, you would find too glaring to
harmonize?

As I said, if you can show me a contradiction in what was said about the moral teaching of Jesus, then I'll see it as casting serious doubt on the gospels' credibility. If you can show me another type of discrepancy that casts serious doubt on the credibility of the writers, such as if one said the disciples all jumped for joy the first time they saw the resurrected Jesus, and another said they were scared stiff, again, then I'd see it as casting significant doubt on their credibility. But as to the very minor details you've brought up so far, I don't see why we should immediately jump to the conclusion they're contradictions, or that they're of any significance if they're imprecise in trivial detail, because it's the story and its message that count, not the minutia.

TimCallahan said:
The problems apologists seek to smoothe away through hamonization aren't limited to the Passion / Resurrection narratives. They are also present in the
conflicting Nativities of Matthew and Luke. And here's another problem of contradiction for you. In the Synoptic Gospels, Jesus chases the money changers
out of the Temple after his Palm Sunday entrance into Jerusalem and before his arrest. In fact, his creating a disturbance in the Temple precint would
seem to be the proximate cause of his arrest. Yet the Gospel of John places the incident early in the ministry of Jesus, right after the wedding feast
in Cana. This is a serious enough offense that it's not likely the Temple authorities would let it go unpunished. Thus it seems nearly impossible that
john is referring to one incident, and the Synoptics are referring to another.

Again an interesting observation, about the likelihood of Jesus being punished if he'd done what John says he did, so early on. But the gospels say they wanted to kill him all throughout his ministry, even for things like letting his disciples pick and eat ears of grain on the Sabbath and saying it was fine, so he had to be careful about where he went in any case. The beginning of John 7 says he didn't want to go to Jerusalem because he knew his life was in danger. But having such a huge following would have protected him to some extent, as John's gospel suggests later. The reason the gospels say Jesus had to be betrayed in secret was because they were scared to arrest him publicly.

If you can find me a discrepancy you can't think of any such explanation for, then I'll view it as a possible sign that the gospels aren't as credible as they're purported to be. But even one plausible explanation mitigates any charge of contradiction.
 
. . . Interesting observation. But I wouldn't necessarily see that as a contradiction, or that the Galilee appearance was the first, since wouldn't you have trouble taking in the idea of a resurrected person really being real, even if he had eaten something in front of you and showed you physical wound marks that corresponded to the ones he got before he died? You might doubt your sanity if nothing else. It would be an incredible thing to have to take in. . . .

I think you're turning up oddities all over the place where they really don't need to exist. Any slight discrepancy or omission in the text is immediately interpreted by you as an oddity or a contradiction, it seems, rather than you looking for other, possibly much more obvious explanations first, and only concluding you've found a contradiction after you've failed to think of any.

So what if the gospel writers didn't mention every single detail of Jesus' itinerary?

Why would you seek to impose exacting precision on the text before you'd consider it harmonisable?

Given that stuff about indifference to minor detail like the order in which appearances might have happened - the things of key importance being what mattered, I don't see why precision-writing need be imposed on Paul.

I think we'll have to agree to disagree on the discrepencies of in the gospel accounts of the Resurrection and leave it at that. What you dismiss as minor among the contradictions indicates to me that we have a lot of people who weren't actual witnesses making up stories. It seems to me that a group of eyewitnesses or even a group of people who received material from eyewitnesses should have a lot more agreement in their stories than we see in these disparate accounts. It goes a great deal toward credibility that two "witnesses" can't agree on whether Jesus first met the disciples in Jerusalem or in Galilee. However, as I said, you and I will probably have to let this argument go and agree to disagree.

As to the date of the writing of Mark. In what is variously called the "Little Apocalypse" and the "Olivet Discourse" in Mark 13, Jesus tells the disciples who have marvelled at the Temple complex (Mk. 13:2), "Do you see these great buildings? There will not be one stone upon another, that will not be thrown down." This prediction - if it was a prediction - came true in the year 70, when the Romans took Jerusalem, flattened the city and utterly destroyed the Temple. So, this statement in Mk. 13:2 is either a divinely inspired prophecy or history written after the fact.

If it's divinely inspired, we would have reason to believe that the rest of Mark is also divinely inspired. However, in Mk. 8:38 - 9:1 Jesus says:

" . . . . For whoever is ashamed of me and my words in the adulterous and sinful generation, of him will the Son of man also be ashamed, when he comes in the glory of his Father with the holy angels." And he said to them, "Truly, I say to you, there are some standing here who willl not taste death before they see the kingdom of God come with power."

Since Jesus here predicts his second coming within the lifetime of people of his generation, and since that did not happen, this is a failed prophecy. Thus, Mark isn't divinely inspired, and the "prediction" of the destruction of the Temple in Mk.13:2 is history written after the fact. Ergo, Mark was written ater the year 70.

I realize Chritian apologists often argue that the "kingdom of God coming with power" refers to Pentecost. However, if we look at the parallel verses to those above, in Matthew, it is apparent that this is not the case (Mt. 16:27, 28):

". . . For the Son of man is to come with his angels in the glory of his Father, and then he will repay every man for what he has done. Truly I say to you, there are some standing here who will not taste death before they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom."

The Son of man coming with his angels to repay (Gr. apodidomi, "deliver back" or "pay out') every man for what he has done sounds like the Last Judgment, and the Son coming into his kingdom cannot be squared with the Holy Spirit descending on the disciples at Pentecost. Further, there are a number of other refernces through the New Testament to the world ending in the first century.

As to discrepencies in the moral teachings between the gospels consider what Jesus has to say aout parables in Mk. 4:11, 12:

And he said to them, "To you has been given the secret of the kingdom of God, but for those outside everything is in parables; so that they may indeed see but not perceive, and they may hear but not understand; lest they shuld turn again, and be forgiven."

In the parallel verses in Matthew, Jsus says (Mt. 13:11 - 13):

And he answered them, "To you it has veen given to know the secrets of the kngdom of heaven, but to them it has not been given. For to him who has will more be given, and he will have abundance; but from him who has not, even what he has will be taken away. This is why I speak to them in parables, becase seeing they do not see, and hearing, they do not hear, nor do they understand.

Jesus goes on in verses 14 and 15 to quote Isaiah, saying that te people's hearts have grown dull. Thus they fail to see and hear.

So, I ould say we have a serious deiscrepency here. Tell me, was Jesus deliberately excluding those outside the circle of disciples, "lest they should turn again and be forgiven," as Mark has it; or is their failure to understand their own fault, as Matthew argues?
 
So, baby, can we have a reasonable debate? Do you even know the subject of your links? Can you reproduce a few of the arguments? I can reproduce a few or all of the arguments from "God on Trial".

I'd like to know if you even know the subject. It's easy to post links in a shot gun manner. Anyone can do that. I could send you off in a thousand directions. If I did so would you go and debunk? Really?

That I've no desire to debunk external links doesn't mean there is something untoward about me. So, let's skip the ad hom. Let's have a reasonable discussion and debate. Fair enough?
I'm here also and I'd like an answer to my question.
 
TimCallahan said:
I think we'll have to agree to disagree on the discrepencies of in the gospel accounts of the Resurrection and leave it at that. What you dismiss as minor
among the contradictions indicates to me that we have a lot of people who weren't actual witnesses making up stories. It seems to me that a group of eyewitnesses
or even a group of people who received material from eyewitnesses should have a lot more agreement in their stories than we see in these disparate accounts.
It goes a great deal toward credibility that two "witnesses" can't agree on whether Jesus first met the disciples in Jerusalem or in Galilee. However,
as I said, you and I will probably have to let this argument go and agree to disagree.

Yes, we'll probably just have to agree to disagree. But I don't understand why you'd think a little discrepancy such as a difference in timing or the order in which places were visited would indicate that the entire story was made up. And the resurrection accounts wouldn't even have to mean one person thought they first met in Galilee and one thought they first met in Jerusalem. Matthew might simply have left out the Jerusalem appearances.

TimCallahan said:
As to the date of the writing of Mark. In what is variously called the "Little Apocalypse" and the "Olivet Discourse" in Mark 13, Jesus tells the disciples
who have marvelled at the Temple complex (Mk. 13:2), "Do you see these great buildings? There will not be one stone upon another, that will not be thrown
down." This prediction - if it was a prediction - came true in the year 70, when the Romans took Jerusalem, flattened the city and utterly destroyed the
Temple. So, this statement in Mk. 13:2 is either a divinely inspired prophecy or history written after the fact.

If it's divinely inspired, we would have reason to believe that the rest of Mark is also divinely inspired. However, in Mk. 8:38 - 9:1 Jesus says:

" . . . . For whoever is ashamed of me and my words in the adulterous and sinful generation, of him will the Son of man also be ashamed, when he comes
in the glory of his Father with the holy angels." And he said to them, "Truly, I say to you, there are some standing here who willl not taste death before
they see the kingdom of God come with power."

Since Jesus here predicts his second coming within the lifetime of people of his generation, and since that did not happen, this is a failed prophecy.
Thus, Mark isn't divinely inspired, and the "prediction" of the destruction of the Temple in Mk.13:2 is history written after the fact. Ergo, Mark was
written ater the year 70.

I realize Chritian apologists often argue that the "kingdom of God coming with power" refers to Pentecost. However, if we look at the parallel verses to
those above, in Matthew, it is apparent that this is not the case (Mt. 16:27, 28):

". . . For the Son of man is to come with his angels in the glory of his Father, and then he will repay every man for what he has done. Truly I say to
you, there are some standing here who will not taste death before they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom." ...

That makes sense under the partial preterist interpretation - see an article called The Olivet Discourse: Preterist Exegesis. It argues that the time Jesus was speaking of was AD 70 - designated the end of the age of the law, and the beginning of the age of the Messiah. According to this article:

• The coming and the close of the age are grammatically linked. [Keener, commentary on Matthew 563n] These are meant to be taken as simultaneous events.

• The word for "world" is not a reference to the physical world, but is the Greek aion, or "age." The question is about the end of the age a time period,
not the end of the world. Had that been the intent, the Greek word kosmos would have been used.
• That leads to point 2: What "age" is referred to here? The answer is found in knowing that the Jews divided time into two great ages: the age of law,
and the age of the Messiah. This belief is commonly reflected in the Jewish apocalyptic era [Harrington, Matthew commentary, 352]. As Wright puts it [New Testament and the People of God, 299-300]:

Code:
The present age was a time when the creator god seemed to be hiding his face; the age to come would see the renewal of the created world. The present age
was the time of Israel's misery; in the age to come she would be restored. In the present age wicked men seemed to be flourishing; in the age to come they
would receive their just reward. In the present age even Israel was not really keeping the Torah perfectly, was not really being YHWH's true humanity;
in the age to come all Israel would keep Torah from the heart.
...

It boils down to this: the "end of the age" refers back to the destruction of the Temple and the end of the covenant, and the beginning of the new covenant 40 years prior. "The age to come, the end of Israel's exile, [was seen] as the inauguration of a new covenant between Israel and her god." [NTPG, 301]

The article talks about the issue of the text suggesting judgment will happen then. It quotes Jesus' parable that said that at the end of the age, angels would gather up the evil people from among the good, just as fishermen separate fish worth keeping from fish not worth bothering with, and throw the worthless ones away. Then it says:

The verse 39 example has the same theme, only it uses the analogy of a harvest. ... This would sensibly
fit in with Matt. 24:31, a later part of the discourse ("And he shall send his angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they shall gather together his elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other.")

How could this refer to the "end of the age" in 70 AD? I think rather easily. Dispensational commentators see here a reference perhaps to the "Rapture" and/or final judgment. But neither a harvest nor a fishing expedition is such a quick event. Harvests took days to process in the age before tractors.
Fishermen stayed out fishing for extended periods (as Peter and co. stayed out all night, until Jesus leant a hand).

Basically it's arguing that the judgment would have begun in AD 70 and it's still going on.

TimCallahan said:
As to discrepencies in the moral teachings between the gospels consider what Jesus has to say aout parables in Mk. 4:11, 12:

And he said to them, "To you has been given the secret of the kingdom of God, but for those outside everything is in parables; so that they may indeed
see but not perceive, and they may hear but not understand; lest they shuld turn again, and be forgiven."

In the parallel verses in Matthew, Jsus says (Mt. 13:11 - 13):

And he answered them, "To you it has veen given to know the secrets of the kngdom of heaven, but to them it has not been given. For to him who has will
more be given, and he will have abundance; but from him who has not, even what he has will be taken away. This is why I speak to them in parables, becase
seeing they do not see, and hearing, they do not hear, nor do they understand.

Jesus goes on in verses 14 and 15 to quote Isaiah, saying that te people's hearts have grown dull. Thus they fail to see and hear.

So, I ould say we have a serious deiscrepency here. Tell me, was Jesus deliberately excluding those outside the circle of disciples, "lest they should
turn again and be forgiven," as Mark has it; or is their failure to understand their own fault, as Matthew argues?

I'm not sure I'd describe that as a moral teaching as such. I was thinking of something more along the lines of instruction to do something or not to do something.

Still, that one's struck me as a bit strange before. I wouldn't dismiss it as a contradiction though, until I'd looked at commentaries that could tell me about the sentence construction in the original language, and about other relevant information like rhetorical techniques of the day. The two might turn out not to be so contradictory as they appear.
 
You really want a genuine debate?
Absolutely.

Would what you wanted to debate on be reasonably relevant to the thread topic?
I posit that if there is a god he has frequently forsaken us and forsaken decency, justice and mercy. I posit that the accounts contained in the Bible, his alleged "word" stands as testimony to his duplicity and atrocity.

I posit that if we assume that the Bible is either correct or it is not then given the events contained therein there can only be one of two possible conclusions. There is no god or god is not good.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom