My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

But I'm not insulting you. I'm insulting the steaming pile of dog**** that is the cruelty of the Bible. God killing infants. God demanding the death of homosexuals and disobedient children. God telling Abraham to kill his son. God standing by while Jephthah murders his daughter to fulfill a promise to god. God punishing David's child for a crime committed by David to punish David. God condoning slavery. They misogyny. The genocide. The xenophobia.

The OT is in many ways offensive and the NT is also not without stain and I stand by my characterization of it. Just watch the video that I posted and tell me that the actions of the character of god in the OT are not offensive. That they don't represent the very worst of human nature much less the nature of an ostensibly merciful and just being.

Actually you weren't insulting any such thing. Leaving aside the fact that your view is a caricature, here's the system you were insulting. These were what you used foul language to describe:

What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
What The Bible Says About Honesty And The Love Of Money.
A Short Story About Tackling Prejudice, And What The Bible Says About Despising People, Judging By Appearances, And God's Mercy.
What The Bible Says About Love And Caring.
What The Bible Says About Drunkenness and Why It's Wrong.
What The Bible Says About Lies, Gossip, Quarrelling, Insulting Language And Dirty Jokes.
What The Bible Says About Sex And Marriage.
What The Bible Says About Lustful And Nasty Thoughts.

Was it really justified?
 
Actually you weren't insulting any such thing.
Actually I was.


Absolutely. Of course. None of this can erase the attrocity of the Bible and it's ostensible god.

Please note, you are in effect saying that Dennis Rader (BTK Killer) was a church going man who volunteered in his church and helped others and therefore we should look past his attrocity.

I'm sorry but I'm not going to do that.
 
I honestly thought that I had said "god of the Bible".

That said, we can first decide whether or not the Bile is correct. If not correct then there is no need to procede further for the purpose of my argument since the Bible can't be trusted as a source.

If it is correct then either the god of the Bible is not good or god does not exist.

Thanks.
I would have thought that if the Bible is correct, then only your first alternative remains, since the Bible is pretty unequivocal about the existence of God.

Really, I'm just in a nitpicking mood. Don't worry about it.
 
I would have thought that if the Bible is correct, then only your first alternative remains, since the Bible is pretty unequivocal about the existence of God.

Really, I'm just in a nitpicking mood. Don't worry about it.
Not the first time my poor construction has been called into question. Thank you. I think it is a DPDT relay error but now my head hurts.

If the Bible is correct then god is not good.
If the Bible is not correct there still could be a god and he could be good.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you didn't hear me. I said who cares!
Many of us care enough to have an intelligent discussion of the subject. You appear to be merely dodging an issue that you are not comfortable discussing.

Now you've proved that all you really want to do is be insulting, I don't want to converse with you any more. There hardly seems a point. You obviously don't want to listen, confirming my previous impression.
Now I am convinced that you are simply angered by the fact that others have the temerity to question the moral value of large parts of the Bible. Tell me, am I being insulting if I say that I find the book of Joshua to be a horrifying and immoral fantasy about the genocidal slaughter of men, women, children and even infants? Do you feel personally insulted if I state my conviction that a God who would order the slaughter of women and children is evil?

And if you provoke me some more, I will say somethingyou will regret.
I can't imagine anything that you could say that RandFan, or anyone else on this forum, might regret in the least.
 
Actually I was.


Absolutely. Of course. None of this can erase the attrocity of the Bible and it's ostensible god.

Please note, you are in effect saying that Dennis Rader (BTK Killer) was a church going man who volunteered in his church and helped others and therefore we should look past his attrocity.

I'm sorry but I'm not going to do that.

In that case you didn't even read my post properly. Why is it worth debating with you if you won't do that? What I was basically suggesting was that whether God exists or not, if Christianity is inspirational to some, why try to attack people's belief in God by bashing them with the Law of Moses? I posted those links to inspirational Bible quotes. You responded by saying Christianity is a pile of ... rule 10 breach. So now, I'll quote some of those Bible passages, and you repeat your claim that they're a load of ... rule 10 breach, or take it back.

1 Timothy chapter 6 (NLT)

11 Pursue a godly life, along with faith, love, perseverance, and gentleness.

Galatians chapter 5 (NLT)

13 For you have been called to live in freedom - not freedom to satisfy your sinful nature, but freedom to serve one another in love. 14 For the whole law
can be summed up in this one command: "Love your neighbor as yourself." 15 But if instead of showing love among yourselves you are always biting and devouring
one another, watch out! Beware of destroying one another. 16 So I advise you to live according to your new life in the Holy Spirit. Then you won't be doing
what your sinful nature craves. 17 The old sinful nature loves to do evil, which is just opposite from what the Holy Spirit wants. And the Spirit gives
us desires that are opposite from what the sinful nature desires. These two forces are constantly fighting each other, and your choices are never free
from this conflict.

19 When you follow the desires of your sinful nature, your lives will produce these evil results: sexual immorality, impure thoughts, eagerness for lustful
pleasure, 20 idolatry, participation in demonic activities, hostility, quarreling, jealousy, outbursts of anger, selfish ambition, divisions, the feeling
that everyone is wrong except those in your own little group, 21 envy, drunkenness, wild parties, and other kinds of sin. Let me tell you again, as I have
before, that anyone living that sort of life will not inherit the Kingdom of God.

22 But when the Holy Spirit controls our lives, he will produce this kind of fruit in us:
list of 9 items
• love,
• joy,
• peace,
• patience,
• kindness,
• goodness,
• faithfulness,
• 23 gentleness,
• and self-control....
list end

24 Those who belong to Christ Jesus have nailed the passions and desires of their sinful nature to his cross and crucified them there. 25 If we are living
now by the Holy Spirit, let us follow the Holy Spirit's leading in every part of our lives. 26 Let us not become conceited, or irritate one another, or
be jealous of one another.

Colossians chapter 3 (NLT)

12 Since God chose you to be the holy people whom he loves, you must clothe yourselves with tenderhearted mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience.
13 You must make allowance for each other's faults and forgive the person who offends you. Remember, the Lord forgave you, so you must forgive others.
14 And the most important piece of clothing you must wear is love. Love is what binds us all together in perfect harmony.
15 And let the peace that comes from Christ rule in your hearts. For as members of one body you are all called to live in peace. And always be thankful.

16 Let the words of Christ, in all their richness, live in your hearts and make you wise. Use his words to teach and counsel each other. Sing psalms and
hymns and spiritual songs to God with thankful hearts.

17 And whatever you do or say, let it be as a representative of the Lord Jesus, all the while giving thanks through him to God the Father.

Ephesians chapter 4 (NLT)

2 Be humble and gentle. Be patient with each other, making allowance for each other's faults because of your love. 3 Always keep yourselves united in the
Holy Spirit, and bind yourselves together with peace. 4 We are all one body, we have the same Spirit, and we have all been called to the same glorious
future.

Romans chapter 12 (TEV)

1 So then, my friends, because of God's great mercy to us I appeal to you: Offer yourselves as a living sacrifice to God, dedicated to his service and pleasing
to him. This is the true worship that you should offer. 2 Do not conform yourselves to the standards of this world, but let God transform you inwardly
by a complete change of your mind. Then you will be able to know the will of God-what is good and is pleasing to him and is perfect.

Romans chapter 13 (TEV)

8 Be under obligation to no one-the only obligation you have is to love one another. Whoever does this has obeyed the Law. 9 The commandments, "Do not commit
adultery; do not commit murder; do not steal; do not desire what belongs to someone else"-all these, and any others besides, are summed up in the one command,
"Love your neighbor as you love yourself." 10 If you love others, you will never do them wrong; to love, then, is to obey the whole Law.

11 You must do this, because you know that the time has come for you to wake up from your sleep. For the moment when we will be saved is closer now than
it was when we first believed. 12 The night is nearly over, day is almost here. Let us stop doing the things that belong to the dark, and let us take up
weapons for fighting in the light. 13 Let us conduct ourselves properly, as people who live in the light of day-no orgies or drunkenness, no immorality
or indecency, no fighting or jealousy. 14 But take up the weapons of the Lord Jesus Christ, and stop paying attention to your sinful nature and satisfying
its desires.

2 Timothy chapter 2 (NLT)

22 Run from anything that stimulates youthful lust. Follow anything that makes you want to do right. Pursue faith and love and peace, and enjoy the companionship
of those who call on the Lord with pure hearts.

Romans chapter 12 (TEV)

9 Love must be completely sincere. Hate what is evil, hold on to what is good. 10 Love one another warmly as Christians, and be eager to show respect for
one another.

11 Work hard and do not be lazy. Serve the Lord with a heart full of devotion.

12 Let your hope keep you joyful, be patient in your troubles, and pray at all times.

13 Share your belongings with your needy fellow Christians, and open your homes to strangers.

14 Ask God to bless those who persecute you-yes, ask him to bless, not to curse.

15 Be happy with those who are happy, weep with those who weep. 16 Have the same concern for everyone.

Do not be proud, but accept humble duties. Do not think of yourselves as wise.

Ephesians chapter 4 (TEV)

23 Your hearts and minds must be made completely new, 24 and you must put on the new self, which is created in God's likeness and reveals itself in the
true life that is upright and holy. 26 If you become angry, do not let your anger lead you into sin, and do not stay angry all day. 27 Don't give the Devil
a chance.

28 If you used to rob, you must stop robbing and start working, in order to earn an honest living for yourself and to be able to help the poor.

29 Do not use harmful words, but only helpful words, the kind that build up and provide what is needed, so that what you say will do good to those who hear
you.

30 And do not make God's Holy Spirit sad; for the Spirit is God's mark of ownership on you, a guarantee that the Day will come when God will set you free.

31 Get rid of all bitterness, passion, and anger. No more shouting or insults, no more hateful feelings of any sort. 32 Instead, be kind and tender-hearted
to one another, and forgive one another, as God has forgiven you through Christ.

Hebrews chapter 12 (NLT)

14 Try to live in peace with everyone, and seek to live a clean and holy life, for those who are not holy will not see the Lord.

1 Thessalonians chapter 4 (NLT)

9 I don't need to write to you about the Christian love that should be shown among God's people. For God himself has taught you to love one another. 10
Indeed, your love is already strong toward all the Christians in all of Macedonia. Even so, dear brothers and sisters, we beg you to love them more and
more.

11 This should be your ambition: to live a quiet life, minding your own business and working with your hands, just as we commanded you before. 12 As a result,
people who are not Christians will respect the way you live, and you will not need to depend on others to meet your financial needs.

Romans chapter 12 (NLT)

17 Never pay back evil for evil to anyone. Do things in such a way that everyone can see you are honorable. 18 Do your part to live in peace with everyone,
as much as possible.

1 Corinthians chapter 13 (TEV)

1 I may be able to speak the languages of human beings and even of angels, but if I have no love, my speech is no more than a noisy gong or a clanging bell.

2 I may have the gift of inspired preaching; I may have all knowledge and understand all secrets; I may have all the faith needed to move mountains-but
if I have no love, I am nothing.

3 I may give away everything I have, and even give up my body to be burned-but if I have no love, this does me no good.

4 Love is patient and kind;
it is not jealous or conceited or proud;
5 love is not ill-mannered or selfish or irritable;
love does not keep a record of wrongs;
6 love is not happy with evil, but is happy with the truth.
7 Love never gives up; and its faith, hope, and patience never fail.

8 Love is eternal.

There are lots, lots, lots more where that came from. That, whether through intention or whether through carelessness, was what you described as dog mess.

And cut the silly straw man! If a serial killer was following that stuff, he wouldn't be a serial killer, would he! Would you like me to illustrate that fact with some more quotes?
 

If a genocidal dictator slaughters millions of people but then feeds, clothes and shelters millions more, what are we to make of him? Does the good render the bad irrelevant? Anyway, the New Testament message is still "worship me and do as I say and I will make things good for you, otherwise I will destroy you".
 
Last edited:
Still, that one's struck me as a bit strange before. I wouldn't dismiss it as a contradiction though, until I'd looked at commentaries that could tell me about the sentence construction in the original language, and about other relevant information like rhetorical techniques of the day. The two might turn out not to be so contradictory as they appear.

Which original language are we speaking of, the Koine Greek the gospels were written in, or the Aramaic Jesus would have spoken? If it's the latter how do we reconstruct what Jesus actually said, particularly since the gospel writers weren't eyewitnesses?
 
Let's go back:

Ah who cares!
I care about the truth.

Can you really claim Christianity is not good when it has all this inspirational material to offer?:
This is a skeptics forum and not Positive Mental Attitude forum. Our purpose here is to expose the truth.

I'm not going to stop doing that because the truth offends some people's sensibilities. Christians believe that the Bible is the word of god. Well, what does the word of god say? There are nice things and there is the warrant for slavery, genocide, filicide, infanticide, xenophobia, etc..

I would tell those who come here and are offended not to come here.
 
Many of us care enough to have an intelligent discussion of the subject. You appear to be merely dodging an issue that you are not comfortable discussing.


Now I am convinced that you are simply angered by the fact that others have the temerity to question the moral value of large parts of the Bible. Tell me, am I being insulting if I say that I find the book of Joshua to be a horrifying and immoral fantasy about the genocidal slaughter of men, women, children and even infants? Do you feel personally insulted if I state my conviction that a God who would order the slaughter of women and children is evil?


I can't imagine anything that you could say that RandFan, or anyone else on this forum, might regret in the least.

No, you're not being insulting. What you have proved consistently over the past few days, however, is that your comprehension skills are abysmal! If you're not just trolling, then it seems obvious that you're into the most facile and frankly stupid simplifying of arguments. Can you really believe that that's what's going on in the face of the evidence? Can you really just totally miss insults, false accusations of promoting hatred, and other such things, and genuinely believe that any objection I make to what an opponent of mine says has to be something to do with not being willing to discuss some atrocity in the Book of Joshua? What a simplistic take on things! Perhaps a dustcart goes past your door every week and you mistake it for a motorbike! When you can put forward a more thoughtful argument, I'll give it a bit more respect.
 
Can you really just totally miss insults, false accusations of promoting hatred, and other such things, and genuinely believe that any objection I make to what an opponent of mine says has to be something to do with not being willing to discuss some atrocity in the Book of Joshua?
Nonsense and "some"? Just "some"? Shirley you jest. Genocide. Slavery. Infanticide. Filicide. Misogyny. Etc., etc..

Minimizing such gross attrocity is what is offensive.
 
No, you're not being insulting. What you have proved consistently over the past few days, however, is that your comprehension skills are abysmal! If you're not just trolling, then it seems obvious that you're into the most facile and frankly stupid simplifying of arguments.
I find this to be a rather disingenuous accusation given that you linked to a "refutation" of early Christian sects that contained no academic citations or reasoned arguments and amounted to nothing more than mockery of those sects based on the fact that their beliefs contradicted those of orthodox Christianity.

Can you really believe that that's what's going on in the face of the evidence? Can you really just totally miss insults, false accusations of promoting hatred, and other such things, and genuinely believe that any objection I make to what an opponent of mine says has to be something to do with not being willing to discuss some atrocity in the Book of Joshua? What a simplistic take on things! Perhaps a dustcart goes past your door every week and you mistake it for a motorbike! When you can put forward a more thoughtful argument, I'll give it a bit more respect.
You are still avoiding the issue. Your claim that the Bible is to be taken as a source of morality is complicated by the undeniable fact that the Bible also contains descriptions of utter horror that are claimed to ordered by the same God.
 
Let's go back:

I care about the truth.

This is a skeptics forum and not Positive Mental Attitude forum. Our purpose here is to expose the truth.

I'm not going to stop doing that because the truth offends some people's sensibilities. Christians believe that the Bible is the word of god. Well, what does the word of god say? There are nice things and there is the warrant for slavery, genocide, filicide, infanticide, xenophobia, etc..

I would tell those who come here and are offended not to come here.

The point is that Christianity has to do with the New Testament. Well, I don't know what they taught you in Mormon school, and maybe some sects have all kinds of horrifying Old Testament beliefs; but do you not think that the word Christian - derived from the word Christ, and Christianity, which began as a movement of people who wanted to follow his teaching and that of his followers who were believed to have his authority, would be likely to focus on ... his teachings and that of his followers? You know, a New Testament time frame? So why is what Joshua may or may not have done when he first stepped into Jericho relevant?

As for your caricature of the Bible, you would have more credibility, and thus your arguments could be respected more, if you would at least show a little willingness to delve into the cultural background of the day so you could reel off atrocities without making it look as if you're making things look worse than is warranted. For instance, that stuff about the Bible condoning slavery. The issues are actually rather more complex than you obviously suppose. The prophet Amos, for example, told the people of Israel that God was so angry with some of them for selling poor people into slavery that they were going to be severely punished. The Law of Moses said thieves should be made to serve as slaves till they'd paid back the amount of money which was the equivalent of what they stole plus a penalty. Is prison really intrinsically more humane? Can you be sure of that, knowing harsh conditions wouldn't be a given?

We have a New Testament verse from 1 Timothy that says laws are in place to put curbs on the evil activities of people like slave traders.

Also, we have factors like this. From articles called Does God condone slavery in the Bible? (Old Testament) and Does God condone slavery in the Bible? (New Testament)

... In the ANE (ancient Near East) (and OT), ... The dominant (statistically) motivation was economic relief of poverty (i.e., 'slavery' was initiated by the slave--NOT by
the owner--and the primary uses were purely domestic (except in cases of State slavery, where individuals were used for building projects).

The definitive work on ANE law today is the 2 volume work (History of Ancient Near Eastern Law). This work (by 22 scholars) surveys every legal document
from the ANE (by period) and includes sections on slavery. A smattering of quotes will indicate this for-the-poor instead of for-the-rich purpose for most
of ANE slavery: ...

"Most of the recorded cases of entry of free persons into slavery [in Emar] are by reason of debt or famine or both…A common practice was for a financier
to pay off the various creditors in return for the debtor becoming his slave." (1.664f)

"On the other hand, mention is made of free people who are sold into slavery as a result of the famine conditions and the critical economic situation of
the populations [Canaan]. Sons and daughters are sold for provisions…" (1.741)

Remember, most people assume that the slavery of the Roman Empire at the time of Paul's writings was at least as bad as New World Slavery, with all its
horrors, injustices, and atrocities. For us to be able to lodge the ethical objection of "the NT condones slavery" against the Christian worldview, we
will have to demonstrate that what the NT calls "slavery" is equivalent to what we would understand by that term, and we will have to show that NT teaching
'condones' that practice. In the case of the OT/Tanaach, we saw that the two different systems of 'slavery' were not even close enough for meaningful comparison.
We will need to compare and contrast Roman slavery and New World slavery here too, to insure that we are not committing crimes of equivocation. ...

* 1. So, our first topic concerns the question of identity--does the slavery of the NT-period Roman Empire resemble New World slavery enough for the objection
to have its customary force?
*
* The data is quite strong that the two systems are substantially different, especially in the areas most troubling to modern minds--the abuse, the oppression,
the future prospects of the slave. ...

• Slaves could litigate on their behalf (esp. in cases of assault/abuse):
"In the law of GR Egypt the slave could own property and could enter into legal transactions such as loans, leases or paramone (i.e., service) contracts...A
slave could also act on behalf of a master in his business dealings, e.g. loans, sales, issuance of receipts etc....In terms of litigation the slave was
also considered as more than n object in the law of GRE. For example, in matters of personal injury or damage of property the slave could litigate (i.e.
sue) and act on his own behalf or represent another....In this instance not only does it appear that the slave had entered into a contract with a certain
villager but also when assaulted and robbed by this same villager lodged a petition against him.""

Basically the articles are arguing that things are rather more complex than people might think. So what you need to do if you want to argue against biblical atrocities with credibility is to do a bit of research yourself into the cultural aspects/social background, and also things like the word meanings in the original language. For instance, you're convinced the Bible commands that toddlers or children not much older than that can be stoned to death if they're disobedient to their parents. You don't even have to look at the original language to see how fallacious such an idea is. It's talking about drunkards! How many drunken five-year-olds do you suppose roamed the countryside?

So do a bit of research, and you're more likely to make yourself credible enough to be taken more seriously.
 
The point is that Christianity has to do with the New Testament. Well, I don't know what they taught you in Mormon school, and maybe some sects have all kinds of horrifying Old Testament beliefs; but do you not think that the word Christian - derived from the word Christ, and Christianity, which began as a movement of people who wanted to follow his teaching and that of his followers who were believed to have his authority, would be likely to focus on ... his teachings and that of his followers? You know, a New Testament time frame? So why is what Joshua may or may not have done when he first stepped into Jericho relevant?
It's funny, but you almost sound like some of those early Christian sects that were at odds with the proto-orthodox church.

The atrocities of the book of Joshua are relevant because orthodox Christianity claims that it describes the actions of the just and loving god of the New Testament. Trying to dismiss descriptions of such terrible, capricious and malevolent cruelty as being the "old covenant" doesn't remove the problem. It is basically saying "God was evil back then, but he had a change of heart".

As for your caricature of the Bible, you would have more credibility, and thus your arguments could be respected more, if you would at least show a little willingness to delve into the cultural background of the day so you could reel off atrocities without making it look as if you're making things look worse than is warranted.
What can make the act of splitting a three year old girl's skull open with a bronze sword and then turning to plunge the blade into the belly of her pregnant mother seem warranted? I'd really like to know.

So do a bit of research, and you're more likely to make yourself credible enough to be taken more seriously.
Maybe you'd like to have a look at Joobz's Slavery and the Bible thread?
 
Last edited:
The point is that Christianity has to do with the New Testament. Well, I don't know what they taught you in Mormon school...
I was taught that "Jesus Christ is god and is the same yesterday, today and forever." --Hebrews 13:8

That the Christian god is the god of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. --Acts 3:13

...and maybe some sects have all kinds of horrifying Old Testament beliefs; but do you not think that the word Christian - derived from the word Christ, and Christianity, which began as a movement of people who wanted to follow his teaching and that of his followers who were believed to have his authority, would be likely to focus on ... his teachings and that of his followers? You know, a New Testament time frame? So why is what Joshua may or may not have done when he first stepped into Jericho relevant?
Is the Bible correct? Is it the word of god? BTW: we are not simply talking just about Joshua but of many atrocities throughout the Bible including genocide, homicide, filicide, infanticide, incest, slavery, etc., etc.

For instance, that stuff about the Bible condoning slavery. The issues are actually rather more complex than you obviously suppose. The prophet Amos, for example, told the people of Israel that God was so angry with some of them for selling poor people into slavery that they were going to be severely punished.
But god told people they could beat their slaves to almost the point of death.

The point is a simple one. If there is a god and he is omnipotent and omniscient as supposed then he would have told his "people" that slavery was wrong. If he had the time to attend to his own vanity (thou shalt not have other gods before me) then he had the time to explain that slavery is one of the most pernicious of evils.

We have a New Testament verse from 1 Timothy that says laws are in place to put curbs on the evil activities of people like slave traders.
But no prohibition of slavery... hmmm...

Basically the articles are arguing that things are rather more complex than people might think.
Please pay close attention: If you want to argue from a historical perspective that we should judge the Jews by the moral philosophy of their times then I agree. In fact, I give them great credit.

An eye for an eye is an advancement in moral philosophy in that it calls for commensurate justice. You can't kill someone just because that person takes your possessions.

The problem lies when we try and insert a just and merciful god into the mix. Then it's BS. Pure and simple. To be rational there needs be consistency.
So do a bit of research, and you're more likely to make yourself credible enough to be taken more seriously.
Oy vey.

Spare me the condescension. I've read the Bible and graduated seminary (highschool level) and I served a mission.
 
Last edited:
After all these years you skeptics/atheists still have to argue your point of view from the negative, it's like your not sure, back to the OP, it’s simply a fact that hanging on the cross for even a brief moment would be tremendously painful let alone take on all the sins of the world past, present and future.

He wanted to be done and die ... relief.
He knew when that moment had come as he stated, “into your hands I commit my spirit.”
Also the father tests our faith to the end even Jesus.
When he says why have you forsaken me, it was because he was still living, he was being tested even then.

Jesus was part of the father and so are all living beings and all that is alive, everything is part of the creator… just so happens he is called son because he excelled beyond any before or after, or any that are to come that is why he is called the son.
Jesus has become what we all truly desire.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom