My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

Pick one

Why would Jesus have said what he said? Why would the writer’s of the Bible have had Jesus say what he said?

A: Jesus, like Spock, is half-human and sometimes that side comes out.
B: It's part of a mishmash of poorly-remembered happenings that was later varnished into an allegedly internally-consistent set of instructions.
 
As Arthwollipot says, the versions of this event differ in the different gospels. Bart Ehrman discusses this at length in Misquoting Jesus, and shows how this was a matter of considerable dissent in the early Christian sects.
Some groups felt that Jesus was merely possessed by the "spirit" of God, and that this spirit left him on the cross. Thus the "forsaken" bit.
Later, this was changed to indicate a fully-godlike Christ who was in control of the whole show.


He goes into far more detail about this in Jesus Interrupted. One point that I found intriguing that Ehrman brings up in that book is the idea that there is a purpose of Jesus' death is discussed in the epistles, not in the gospels.
 
I thought this was "My Cod, why hast thou forsaken me?" I guess I've been listening to too many Newfies.
 
So the Bible says:



This is similar to:



The Psalm goes on about believing in God even though he doesn’t respond when you need him because God responds when you need him. (Doesn’t make sense to me either.)

Matthew goes on about someone giving Jesus a sponge of vinegar to drink, and how Jesus was calling for Elias to come save him and waiting to see if Elias comes to save him. Which he doesn’t. Jesus yells again and dies. A temple is split in two and the earth shakes. Zombies come out of their graves. Then a disciple comes and takes the body.

So, why was Jesus screaming about being forsaken? If he was the son of God, and God-embodied-as-man, and he died for our sins, and so forth, shouldn’t he have been all like, “Way cool! I’m dying on this cross to save everyone’s sin’s…just like I planned! This is so awesome! People should remember how great this is forever and ever…with a bunch of sculptures and necklaces and stuff showing how really great this moment is!!!”

But he didn’t. He was all like, “Wait! This is going all wrong!!!!”

Why would the writer’s of the Bible have Jesus say this? Why not have Jesus say, “I will now die so that everyone’s sins will be forgiven.” Or something plain like that. It seems clear the writer’s copied from Pslams, but why? Maybe if Matthew went on with something about how even Jesus could feel that God ignored him that you can too it would makes sense, but Matthew doesn’t do that. It just goes on to vinegar, will Elias save him, he dies, they take his body. No BIG LESSON like in Psalms.


Why would Jesus have said what he said? Why would the writer’s of the Bible have had Jesus say what he said?

Bad writers.
 
A: Jesus, like Spock, is half-human and sometimes that side comes out.
B: It's part of a mishmash of poorly-remembered happenings that was later varnished into an allegedly internally-consistent set of instructions.

Interestingly, Gnostic Christians held a "separationist" view of Jesus/Christ. They used the above mentioned passage from Matthew to support their position. By "separationist" they meant that Jesus and Christ were two distinct beings. Jesus was a righteous man who came to be indwelt by the divine Christ at the moment of his baptism. The Christ is what enables Jesus to perform his miracles. Then on the cross the Christ leaves Jesus alone to die. In the Gospel of Peter, which is probably written with a separationist view, Jesus is said to cry out "My power, O power, you have left me!". According to the Gnostics the mortal Jesus was then raised from the dead by the Christ as a reward for his service and sacrifice and taken to Heaven until the time when he returns to reign on Earth.
 
One of the explanations that sounds a little more plausible to me at least (whatever that means discussing theology) is that Jesus had to experience every step of being a mortal human being, and not having his prayers answered (I presume to take away his pain in the cross or something like that) was an important part of human experience he had to take in during his agony in the cross...

In the end, this is as futile as discuss the number of angels that can dande on a needletip, but hey.. this is an internet forum :P

haha
 
The agony in the garden of Gethsemane, the trial, the Passion and the Resurrection are all fictional invention. Since Jesus was alone in the garden, who could have reported his words and his agony? Also, why doesn't the Gospel of John report this dramatic episode? Likewise, the trial would not have been observed by any of the disciples, and there is no reason to beleive that either the high priest or Pontius Pilate would have shared the specifics of the trial with anyone. Luke even has Pilate send Jesus to Herod Antipas, and has his soldiers, rather than Pilate's, mock Jesus Ths directly contradicts the other gospels.

As to the agonized words of Jesus on the cross - "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" - Mark put these words into Jesus' mouth specifically because they were from a psalm supposedly written by King David. Since he was supposedly of the Davidic line, or was at least its successor as the Messiah, Jesus had the right to utter the words of David. Since Mark put those words in Aramaic, Matthew corrected them by rendering the words in Hebrew.

While it is possible that Jesus could have uttered all the phrases in the gospels - not only the agonized cry of Mark and Matthew, but the words of forgiveness from Luke and those of completion from John ("It is finished" can as easily be translated, "It is accomplished") - we have to ask why Mark / Matthew, Luke and John all cherry-picked certain utterances and ignored the others. The simplest answer is that, as has been well demonstrated, the gospel-writers were not eyewitnesses.

Fictional invention continues in the Resurrection accounts. Mark has no appearances of the risen Christ, only the empty tomb. Luke has Jesus meet the disciples in Jerusalem and instructs them not to leave that city, Matthew has Jesus meet the disciples on a mountain in Galilee. John, alone among the gospels, has Jesus appear first to Mary Magdalene.
 
As I have asked before (rhetorically mostly); why does God have to go through this whole silly rigmarole anyway? He is God. He can do anything. Why can he not just say he screwed up and wave His hands to fix things? :boggled:
 
Once you all see how simple the solution is, you'll beat yourselves silly with nearby objects.

Jesus was neither God nor man. He was in a state of quantum indeterminacy. What he clearly meant to say was: “Why hast thou forsaken to observe me?”

Templeton prize, here I come.
 
The agony in the garden of Gethsemane, the trial, the Passion and the Resurrection are all fictional invention. Since Jesus was alone in the garden, who could have reported his words and his agony? Also, why doesn't the Gospel of John report this dramatic episode?

In the Gospel of Luke, the verse about Jesus' agony and the sweat falling like "great drops of blood" almost certainly wasn't even in the original texts.
 
Please try to make your analyses more sophisticated and less open to easy refutation than that.
Sometimes I think you enjoy just refuting, and it doesn't matter what. :rolleyes:

I never claimed that my analysis was airtight, or that I was the most knowledgeable person in the world. I'm just calling it as I see it. :)
 
One of the explanations that sounds a little more plausible to me at least (whatever that means discussing theology) is that Jesus had to experience every step of being a mortal human being, and not having his prayers answered (I presume to take away his pain in the cross or something like that) was an important part of human experience he had to take in during his agony in the cross...

In the end, this is as futile as discuss the number of angels that can dande on a needletip, but hey.. this is an internet forum :P

haha
If you acknowledge that part of the human experience is not to have your prayers answered, even in the direst need, both Jesus and most of his followers since have been lying about prayer. I suppose that saying you won't get a stone when you pray for bread is technically true since technically you won't get doodly squat, but there's definitely a disconnect here between the events of the crucifixion and the promised personal involvement of God.

I like your explanation in part, because if it's true it provides a good reason by itself to reject any religion that does not acknowledge the uselessness of petitionary prayer and provide a reasonable explanation for why it should be so if God is represented as both all-powerful and personally caring.
 
It's just a retelling/reimagining of the age-old "scape goat" tales. What a load of old rot.

People like the idea of being able to do what they please and then dispense with the guilt. Pushing it onto another has long been the wish of many. Personally I think its better not to be a prick in the first place, but different strokes......
 
Interestingly, Gnostic Christians held a "separationist" view of Jesus/Christ. They used the above mentioned passage from Matthew to support their position. By "separationist" they meant that Jesus and Christ were two distinct beings. Jesus was a righteous man who came to be indwelt by the divine Christ at the moment of his baptism. The Christ is what enables Jesus to perform his miracles. Then on the cross the Christ leaves Jesus alone to die. In the Gospel of Peter, which is probably written with a separationist view, Jesus is said to cry out "My power, O power, you have left me!". According to the Gnostics the mortal Jesus was then raised from the dead by the Christ as a reward for his service and sacrifice and taken to Heaven until the time when he returns to reign on Earth.

What, you're advocating for New Age-type views on a skeptics' forum? Shocking! :p

Incidentally, do you think it's unfair that Gnosticism lost? Equally shocking! ;)

From an article that examines the strangeness of Gnostic teaching called Gnosticism and the Gnostic Jesus

For the Gnostics, as Gnostic scholar Pheme Perkins puts it, "most of the cosmos that we know is a carefully constructed plot to keep humanity from returning
to its true divine home."[40]

Third, Pagels and others to the contrary, the Gnostic attitude toward women was not proto-feminist. Gnostic groups did sometimes allow for women's participation
in religious activities and several of the emanational beings were seen as feminine. Nevertheless, even though Ms. Magazine gave The Gnostic Gospels a
glowing review[41], women fare far worse in Gnosticism than many think. The concluding saying from the Gospel of Thomas, for example, has less than a feminist
ring:

Code:
Simon Peter said to them, "Let Mary leave us, for women are not worthy of life." 

Jesus said, "I myself shall lead her in order to make her male, so that she too may become a living spirit resembling you males. For every woman who will
make herself male will enter the kingdom of heaven."[42]

The issue of the role of women in Gnostic theology and community cannot be adequately addressed here, but it should be noted that the Jesus of the Gospels
never spoke of making the female into the male -- no doubt because Jesus did not perceive the female to be inferior to the male. Going against social customs,
He gathered women followers, and revealed to an outcast Samaritan woman that He was the Messiah -- which scandalized His own disciples (John 4:1-39). The
Gospels also record women as the first witnesses to Jesus' resurrection (Matt. 28:1-10) -- and this in a society where women were not considered qualified
to be legal witnesses.

And for good measure: Was Paul a Gnostic?

Here's backing for the idea that it was in fact the traditional gospel writers who had the best information: Testimony of Early Church Sources.

Polycarp (AD 69-155)

Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, was personally discipled by the apostle John, and was burnt at the stake after publicly refusing to recant his faith. A letter
written to the church at Philippi (not to be confused with the NT letter written by Paul) is all that survives of his own writings: but he is important
as a source for the following writers.

Papias (AD 60-140)

Papias was bishop of Hierapolis in Phrygia, and a prolific writer. His writings survive today only in citations from other authors, such as Eusebius and
Irenaeus. Irenaus tells us he was a companion of Polycarp and had also heard John personally. Eusebius cites one passage in which Papias describes how
he would avidly question anyone he met who had first-hand knowledge of the Apostles and early church leaders. Eusebius also cites the following statement
by Papias:

Code:
'Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately everything that he remembered, without however recording in order what was said or
done by Christ. For neither did he hear the Lord, nor did he follow him; but afterwards, as I said, (attended) Peter, who adapted his instructions to the
needs (of his hearers) but had no design of giving a connected account of the Lord's oracles. So then Mark made no mistake, while he thus wrote down some
things as he remembered them; for he made it his one care not to omit anything that he heard, or to set down any false statement therein.'

Is there any evidence that any of the Gnostic writers knew Jesus, or that they knew anyone who'd known him personally?
 
Hey guys. This is my first post on this website. I stumbled upon it while looking up some topics on Google. There are some very good debates going on in this forum.

I do not think anyone has pointed out the old testement connection with Christ's words. To a person who does not have some experience with the bible reads the words, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me" (‘Eloi, Eloi, lema sabachthani?’), that person may think Christ gave up on God or feels like God has abandoned him. However, those words are directly taken from Psalm 22.

Psalm 22 begins with the person crying out to God but then follows it up with praise to God because God will vindicate him. While no actual words of vindication follow Christ's words, according to the scriptures he is vidicated because he rose from the dead.

Also note that Psalm 22 mentions how the subject's enemies "cast lots" for his cothing." (like they did for Jesus). They also taunt the man suffering telling him to have "God save him." (like they did to Jesus too). The psalm writer also says "they can count all my bones." Christian tradition says that none of Jesus bones were broken because he is the sacrificial lamb led to the slaughter during passover. The lamb used could not have any broken bones.

While I believe Christ DID rise from the dead, my purpose with this is not to convince anyone. I just want to point out WHY the gospel writers quote this saying from Jesus.

Here is Psalm 22:
1 My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?Why are you so far from helping me, from the words of my groaning?
2 O my God, I cry by day, but you do not answer;
and by night, but find no rest.
3 Yet you are holy, enthroned on the praises of Israel.
4 In you our ancestors trusted; they trusted, and you delivered them.
5 To you they cried, and were saved; in you they trusted, and were not put to shame.
6 But I am a worm, and not human; scorned by others, and despised by the people.
7 All who see me mock at me; they make mouths at me, they shake their heads;
8 “Commit your cause to the Lord; let him deliver—let him rescue the one in whom he delights!”
9 Yet it was you who took me from the womb; you kept me safe from my mother’s breast.
10 On you I was cast from my birth, and since my mother bore me you have been my God.
11 Do not be far from me, for trouble is near and there is no one to help.
12 Many bulls encircle me, strong bulls of Bã’shan surround me;
13 they open wide their mouths at me, like a ravening and roaring lion.
14 I am poured out like water, and all my bones are out of joint; my heart is like wax; it is melted within my breast;
15 my mouth is dried up like a potsherd, and my tongue sticks to my jaws; you lay me in the dust of death.
16 For dogs are all around me; a company of evildoers encircles me. My hands and feet have shriveled;
17 I can count all my bones. They stare and gloat over me;
18 they divide my clothes among themselves, and for my clothing they cast lots.
19 But you, O Lord, do not be far away! O my help, come quickly to my aid!
20 Deliver my soul from the sword, my life from the power of the dog!
21 Save me from the mouth of the lion!
From the horns of the wild oxen, you have rescued me.
22 I will tell of your name to my brothers and sisters; in the midst of the congregation I will praise you.
23 You who fear the Lord, praise him! All you offspring of Jacob, glorify him; stand in awe of him, all you offspring of Israel!
24 For he did not despise or abhor the affliction of the afflicted; he did not hide his face from me, but heard when I cried to him.
25 From you comes my praise in the great congregation; my vows I will pay before those who fear him.
26 The poor shall eat and be satisfied; those who seek him shall praise the Lord. May your hearts live forever!
27 All the ends of the earth shall remember and turn to the Lord; and all the families of the nations shall worship before him.
28 For dominion belongs to the Lord, and he rules over the nations.
29 To him, indeed, shall all who sleep in the earth bow down; before him shall bow all who go down to the dust, and I shall live for him.
30 Posterity will serve him; future generations will be told about the Lord,
31 and proclaim his deliverance to a people yet unborn, saying that he has done it.
 
The agony in the garden of Gethsemane, the trial, the Passion and the Resurrection are all fictional invention. Since Jesus was alone in the garden, who could have reported his words and his agony? Also, why doesn't the Gospel of John report this dramatic episode? Likewise, the trial would not have been observed by any of the disciples, and there is no reason to beleive that either the high priest or Pontius Pilate would have shared the specifics of the trial with anyone. Luke even has Pilate send Jesus to Herod Antipas, and has his soldiers, rather than Pilate's, mock Jesus Ths directly contradicts the other gospels.

As to the agonized words of Jesus on the cross - "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" - Mark put these words into Jesus' mouth specifically because they were from a psalm supposedly written by King David. Since he was supposedly of the Davidic line, or was at least its successor as the Messiah, Jesus had the right to utter the words of David. Since Mark put those words in Aramaic, Matthew corrected them by rendering the words in Hebrew.

While it is possible that Jesus could have uttered all the phrases in the gospels - not only the agonized cry of Mark and Matthew, but the words of forgiveness from Luke and those of completion from John ("It is finished" can as easily be translated, "It is accomplished") - we have to ask why Mark / Matthew, Luke and John all cherry-picked certain utterances and ignored the others. The simplest answer is that, as has been well demonstrated, the gospel-writers were not eyewitnesses.

Fictional invention continues in the Resurrection accounts. Mark has no appearances of the risen Christ, only the empty tomb. Luke has Jesus meet the disciples in Jerusalem and instructs them not to leave that city, Matthew has Jesus meet the disciples on a mountain in Galilee. John, alone among the gospels, has Jesus appear first to Mary Magdalene.

*Pounces* All your arguments are belong to us!

... Or at least, they belong to the man who wrote these: :D

The Authenticity of the Trial Accounts of Jesus
The Resurrection Narratives Harmonized Contextually

Your one consolation: I don't plan on throwing my weight around this religion forum for too much longer. :) In fact, God knows why I came here in the first place! Will he let me in on the secret of why if I ask him, ... or will he leave me forsaken with my query hanging in the air like a balloon on a string? I suspect the latter. :) Still, far better to have a query forsaken like a balloon left hanging on a string than to be forsaken yourself on a cross. :-7
 
It's just a retelling/reimagining of the age-old "scape goat" tales. What a load of old rot.

People like the idea of being able to do what they please and then dispense with the guilt. Pushing it onto another has long been the wish of many. Personally I think its better not to be a prick in the first place, but different strokes......

Well, anyone with the attitude you describe has seriously missed the point. Very seriously in fact, since there are lots of Bible verses about those who persist in doing nasty things not making it to heaven.

arthwollipot said:
Sometimes I think you enjoy just refuting, and it doesn't matter what.

LOL.
 
*Pounces* All your arguments are belong to us!

... Or at least, they belong to the man who wrote these: :D

The Authenticity of the Trial Accounts of Jesus
The Resurrection Narratives Harmonized Contextually

Your one consolation: I don't plan on throwing my weight around this religion forum for too much longer. :) In fact, God knows why I came here in the first place! Will he let me in on the secret of why if I ask him, ... or will he leave me forsaken with my query hanging in the air like a balloon on a string? I suspect the latter. :) Still, far better to have a query forsaken like a balloon left hanging on a string than to be forsaken yourself on a cross. :-7

It's hardly surprising that the websites of the fundamentalist Tekton ministry would support the idea of harmonization of the disparate accounts in the gospels. However, their reasoning is a bit circular. For example, the claim that the resurrected Jesus filled the desciples in on what happened at the trials and in the garden of Gethsemane means that we have to believe in the historical reality of the Resurrecction in order to accept the gospel accounts of the Passion and Resurrection stories. Yet those stories are supposed to be taken as evidence of the Resurrection.

Also, it is simply impossible to harmonize Luke's report that Pilate sent Jesus to Herod Antipas, and that his soldiers, rather than Pilate's, were the ones who mocked Jesus, with the accounts in the other gospels that it was Pilate's soldiers who mocked Jesus. How is it, in fact, that of all the gospels only Luke knows of this episode? Or how can one harmonize Matthew, were the disciples are told to go to Galilee, where they meet Jesus, with Luke, where they are specifically told to stay in Jerusalem, where they meet Jesus? It is also impossible to harmonize Mark's account of the Resurrection, where there is only an empty tomb as evidence and no post Resurrection appearances by Jesus, with the post Resurrection appearances of Jesus in the other gospels.

For that matter, how does one harmonize the account in 1 Corinthians with that of the Gospel of John?:

1 Corinthians 15:5 - 8:
1. Jesus first appeared to Peter.
2. Jesus appeared to the 12 (including Judas?).
3. Jesus appeared to more than 500 people at one time (a fact somehow missed by the gospel writers).
4. After that he appeared to James.
5. Then to all the apostles - whatever that means.
6. Last, he appeared to Paul.

Gospel of John,chapters 20 and 21:
1. Jesus first appeared to Mary Magdalene.
2. Jesus next appeared to the disciples in Jerusalem, though Thomas wasn't present.
3. Eight days later He appeared to them again, this time with Thomas present.
4. In chapter 21 Jesus again appears to the disciples, who, for some strange reason, have returned to the Sea of Tiberius (Galilee) and have resumed their occupation as fishermen.

A few discrepencies in the testimony would be reasonable, and, taking human fallibility into account, harmonization would also be reasonable. However, what we have in the gospel accounts, plus 1 Corinthians, are glaring discrepencies and out-and-out contradictions. As such, the reasoning and arguments of the Tekton ministries with regard to harmonizing the accounts of the Passion and Resurrection are specious.
 
What, you're advocating for New Age-type views on a skeptics' forum? Shocking! :p
New Age? It's nearly two thousand years old. And where do you get that I am advocating Gnostic ideas?

Incidentally, do you think it's unfair that Gnosticism lost? Equally shocking! ;)
No, I don't think that it is unfair. It is simply history.

Is there any evidence that any of the Gnostic writers knew Jesus, or that they knew anyone who'd known him personally?
Is there any evidence that any of the proto-orthodox writers knew Jesus, or that they knew anyone who'd known him personally? Only Irenaeus made the claim that Polycarp had known John and been appointed by him. Tertullian only repeats Irenaeus' claim. Ignatius makes no mention of Polycarp having been appointed by John. Irenaeus claims that Papias also knew John and was his disciple. But Papias' own writings indicate that he hadn't met the apostle John, but that he may have known another person called the Presbyter John. It seems likely that this Presbyter John could be the source of Iranaeus' confusion.

Polycarp himself makes no mention of having known John. He goes on quite a bit about Paul, but not about having known John.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom